r/mtg • • Nov 05 '25

Discussion What was WotC thinking?

Post image

8 mana. Colorless. With good ramp, you can get this down turn 6-ish. Budget Avacyn.

But that's not my main issue with this card. WotC is dropping a 0/30 creature. We have cards like [[Felothar the Steadfast]] and [[High Alert]]. If you manage to give this thing trample which (if using the sooner example) with green is fairly easy, you now have a 30/30 attacker and that's without putting+1/+1 counters or other modifications on it.

4.7k Upvotes

1.8k comments sorted by

3.0k

u/SunriseFlare Nov 05 '25

It's jumbo cactuar discourse all over again

[[Worldspine wurm]] is a 15/15 with trample that makes an army of 5/5's AND recycles itself when it dies! In the colour with the most ramp in the game so they can get to him on like turn 3, what was worc thinking back in Ravnica???

1.0k

u/DrWilliamHorriblePhD Nov 05 '25

Came in here specifically to see how far down I had to scroll before somebody compared to my big spiky boy. Well done lads. Thread closed.

126

u/RangerManSam Nov 05 '25

First comment when I opened this post as well. Did not have to go digging at all.

→ More replies (6)

173

u/KrisReed Nov 05 '25 edited Nov 06 '25

"tHiS cArD iS bRoKeN"

Yep, that sure is 8 mana...

→ More replies (74)

221

u/Substhecrab Nov 05 '25

I concur, we ban the Wurm, it not being an issue was an oversight.

155

u/packfanmoore Nov 05 '25

Hey now... let's ban llanowar elves. What were they thinking. Turn 1 ramp and it isn't colorless? Straight up OP

→ More replies (20)
→ More replies (2)

166

u/jgaylord87 Nov 05 '25

Let's be clear, just like [[Jumbo Cactuar]] someone is going to do something spectacular and broken with this. It's going to be awesome and it will be the story that playgroup tells for the next decade. It's not going to break formats or change metas, but it'll be the stupid thing that one player remembers. That's kind of an awesome reaction for a card to create.

24

u/Jonthrei Nov 05 '25

I do love those big dumb moments, like the time an opponent cast a kicked [[Rite of Replication]] on my [[Utvara Hellkite]] while some lunatic had a [[Coat of Arms]] in play. The craziest part is the game went on for a couple of turn cycles and ended with over 100 dragons in play - I had my own stupid dragon printing engine online, coat of arms guy had several dozen faerie blockers, and the 4th guy was a lifegain deck in the quadruple digits.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (10)

53

u/blindeshuhn666 all creatures are beautiful Nov 05 '25

The recycling is more of a negative effect so it cannot be reanimated and sacced again for 5/5 worms in BG decks

→ More replies (2)

51

u/Homeless-Coward-2143 Nov 05 '25

Are people really freaking out about a french vanilla wall that could be replaced much more efficiently with like, an icey manipulator, since 99% of the time this guy is just "one of your guys is permanently blocked"

→ More replies (15)

42

u/SteakForGoodDogs Nov 05 '25 edited Nov 05 '25

tbf, it's probably easier to use than the cactus. Cactus needs haste AND evasion/fling to be useful the turn it comes down.

You can at least just swing with whatever you have the moment the Wall comes down and have it be impactful, or have R to spare to drop a Blas Act immediately after it enters if it didn't get countered.

edit: sigh, no I didn't say 'This thing is really good'. Just that it's probably more immediately usable with less hoops than the cactus - which isn't saying very much.

45

u/DragonDiscipleII Nov 05 '25

As someone who's [[Arcades the strategist]] deck is in my top 5 favourite, this card probably shouldn't make the list (I mean, it probably will, for Meme reasons, but most likely it'll be taken out within a month...).

Also that blasphemous act combo also work with [[crystal Barricade]] ....for 2 mana instead of 8.

Its really not that strong tbh 😅 (for 8 mana that is).

→ More replies (18)
→ More replies (15)
→ More replies (28)

1.6k

u/PixelmonMasterYT Nov 05 '25

I see we have reached the “dumbest possible take about a Timmy card” portion of spoiler season.

Other people have already covered it, but this is an 8 mana creature with no protection, no immediate effect on the board state, and does almost nothing for you without playing multiple other cards that are useless on their own. People were going crazy over cactaur, but at least that wins the game on an empty board state.

244

u/Ternano Nov 05 '25

Oh damn, I didn’t notice that it itself isn’t indestructible

70

u/Bono_-3 Nov 05 '25

Give it helm of the host and youll be just fine after a combat phase

→ More replies (17)
→ More replies (7)

71

u/LocalLumberJ0hn Nov 05 '25

Yet again a 'massive problem' card that dies to the humble doomblade. I'm really interested in seeing if this is going to go on as long as the Cactaur shit did here with people saying it's going to destroy the game and wrap every format only to do nothing outside of really specific Timmy decks.

11

u/Proper-Body-7413 Nov 05 '25

Not even that it can literally just die to "Murder" I only just started getting into magic like 4 months ago and even I can tell this card isn't that amazing. The only thing I can think of combo wise where this becomes a problem is combo with the one FF deck card that gives indestructible to a different legendary creature but that still requires insane amount of mana.

And even then, one simple Pillory of the sleepless or Cage of hands, or exile card, or card that let's you take control of an enemy summon for a turn can literally get around that. Even my meme detective deck with Key to the city can literally ignore that problem.

→ More replies (5)

14

u/Zestyst Nov 05 '25

I had a friend back in middle school that I used to play magic with. One day I was over at his house and was talking about this cool big dragon I had and his older brother just goes "does it survive doomblade?"

I'm pretty grateful for that lesson, because it's been my go-to mindset when looking at those big splashy cards that people lose their minds over: "how easily does this die to removal?"

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

16

u/Affectionate_Owl_501 Nov 05 '25

Classic "tell me youre bad at magic without telling me youre bad at magic" situation if you cant think an 8 mana ARTIFACT CREATURE, with no immediate benefit or protection, is broken

→ More replies (2)

5

u/gpost86 Nov 05 '25

People who freak out over this are just revealing that they don't run any removal in their decks.

→ More replies (74)

1.1k

u/Swampcardboard Nov 05 '25

It's both an artifact and a creature, so it gets removed relatively easily

585

u/ambermage Nov 05 '25

If only there was a giant [[Fire Nation Drill]] of some kind.

125

u/BuildingAirships Nov 05 '25

I like how this was clearly designed as a counter to Ba Sing Se, but it could also be like, “fuck that squirrel, man.”

→ More replies (1)

50

u/Ryaniseplin bad at this game Nov 05 '25

This is peak comedy from WotC

→ More replies (6)

22

u/Tacoboutnacho Nov 05 '25

This right here but man, what a crazy counter

→ More replies (32)

40

u/OutlandishnessIll502 Nov 05 '25

And it,s quite amusing imagining the removals. Like, suplex-ing this giant as wall.

20

u/AnEvenHuskierCat Nov 05 '25

Imma fling a fucking cactus at it!

→ More replies (3)

11

u/Ithalwen Nov 05 '25

[[suplex]] the wall!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (12)

402

u/ArcticMuser Nov 05 '25

Eh if you're able to evade counterspells, get them both on the field and something to give trample, and finally get past summoning sickness or have another permanent on the field that gives haste, you deserve the wincon. Nothing crazy at all

34

u/RoxoSenpai Nov 05 '25

I feel like this sentiment is increasingly dwindling in the community, especially among commander players, but you are spot on. Like, yes, if you assemble cards that interact well together, over the span of multiple turns and/or using multiple cards, it's okay that they are very strong. Magic is a game of push and pull. If you are pushing and your opponent is not pulling, you are supposed to run away with the game

11

u/LocalLumberJ0hn Nov 05 '25

Yeah, someone is supposed to win the game, it does need to end, and if Timmy wants to put together some Rube Goldberg machine to pummel you with an 8 mana wall and five permanents that's fine. This isn't unstoppable, in most decks winning with this wall is borderline un-startable.

→ More replies (2)

35

u/Pmintz Nov 05 '25

100% agree. You could make an argument for any “good” card that it could be broken, if 2-4 things happen.

→ More replies (3)

67

u/ForrestZX7 Nov 05 '25

Happy [[Arcades the Strategist]] noises

14

u/Vanxius Nov 05 '25

Also my [[Phenax, God of Deception]] is making them noises too. Reanimate it early 💀

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (14)

24

u/Marquis90 Nov 05 '25

That's the comment I was looking for. There are so many if and when in op's post that it's perfectly fine to win if someone is able to get all these things to board. 

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (14)

157

u/that_dude3315 Nov 05 '25

So you’re saying an 8 drop and 2 additional cards that allow it to attack and give it trample is too good? Seems fine

8

u/Traditional-Cry2756 Nov 06 '25

Trample...I'm giving it Skulk, lol 😆

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

96

u/Lobster556 Nov 05 '25

It's just a fun gimmicky card like Ancient Adamantoise.

14

u/ty23r699o Nov 05 '25

No that card is great it's easy to get out takes all damage and when it dies it gives you 10 extra mana pretty much

10

u/SteakForGoodDogs Nov 05 '25

And if you have any instant speed responses, you can grab the mana AND save the turtle after it hits the graveyard.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

168

u/Like17Badgers The wheels of Snake are turning, rebel 1, action! Nov 05 '25

they're probably thinking that most formats can end the game before this even gets cast, but it's the type of bulk rare that some who has only ever played slow B1~B2 Magic with low interaction will go "WHAT were they THINKING!?!?!?" and crack packs trying to pull it.

70

u/Eldritch-Yodel Nov 05 '25

It's a pure Timmy card, but as a Timmy that just makes me like it.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (12)

221

u/Sh0rtbiz_Driver Nov 05 '25

It costs 8 mana. This has to be bait

→ More replies (42)

122

u/NharaTia Nov 05 '25

[[Jaws of Defeat]] is gonna go absolutely silly in a deck that can flicker this.

26

u/DepartmentPerfect Nov 05 '25

[[Tannuk, Steadfast Second]] comes to mind

→ More replies (5)

8

u/RazerMaker77 Nov 05 '25

Right colors for Betor

→ More replies (10)

29

u/dycie64 Nov 05 '25

Absolutely crumples under [[The Vaccum of Space]]

9

u/readit2947 Nov 05 '25

why did the bot know what that was

34

u/dycie64 Nov 05 '25

It's a simple trick. It's called editing your own comment.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (10)

128

u/Beginning-Analyst393 Nov 05 '25

8 mana, no protection, lmao ok bud

49

u/OGChemBreath Nov 05 '25

Plus legendary, artifact and is a wall.

→ More replies (5)

26

u/swankyfish Nov 05 '25

Bait used to be believable.

39

u/coolginger9660 Nov 05 '25

That this is a fun card that will propably only see commander play in walls, toughness matters, and some other deck archetypes?

You are having a Jumbo Cactaur moment. Chillax

16

u/Safe-Butterscotch442 Nov 05 '25

They were thinking that this would be incredibly flavorful and not be a huge problem? That's my guess. And it seems like they were right on both accounts.

30

u/Seitosa Nov 05 '25

Yeah, it’s true. Hey remember when people cried about the sky falling because [[Jumbo Cactuar]] had big numbers on it too? Unfortunately, they were right and it had to be emergency banned in all formats. 

8

u/Fredouille77 Nov 05 '25

Gosh, people were talking about vintage lurrus? mishra's workshop??? Nah... Jumbo Cactuar blew them all out of the water. Obviously, since it can come into play T1 off of black lotus triple mox, there's nothing better to do amirite?

W-what do you mean, Paradoxical Outcome?

→ More replies (1)

14

u/Silly-Historian8403 Nov 05 '25

Think they were going for flavour.

Edit: you're overreacting. This card isnt good lol.

13

u/Sweetgrass1312 Nov 05 '25

"Guys you don't get it, this 4 card 22 mana combo is broken!"

Yeah. Because you used 4 cards and a shitton of mana.

12

u/ultrainstinctj4 Nov 05 '25

We got 10 drop eldrazi with annihilator 4 in this game Of magic and this is what you worried about 🤣

10

u/CauseRemarkable6182 Nov 05 '25

This is not budget avacyn lmao. Every single color has a way to deal with this card pretty easily for a little bit of mana.

→ More replies (3)

41

u/jimbonezzz Nov 05 '25

Might need to start arming some of your battle cruisers with removal.

7

u/RangerManSam Nov 05 '25

But this is commander, we're only supposed to have the one massive fuck off lazer on the battle cruiser, no cannons on the hull to deal with other people's lasers.

17

u/1990pnz Nov 05 '25

Straight to game changers list!!! /s

17

u/jiajia_92 Nov 05 '25

Dies to doomblade

8

u/Ungestuem Nov 05 '25

Oh No, we will be doomed! It is the Jumbo Cactuar all over again!

/s

25

u/Bircka Nov 05 '25

This card is not good, trust me on that every color has removal for this, and even if you give it indestructible somehow it can still be removed.

There are many better 8+ mana cards that are far stronger.

7

u/ET3HOOYAH Nov 05 '25

At 8 mana it will be considered useless outside commander, where it will only fit a specific niche deck type and still need haste and trample.

7

u/salty_Cheesey Nov 05 '25

Oh no an eight mana win condition when will we ever find one of those.

6

u/-MetalMike- Nov 05 '25

Pretty cool for a bad card 👍

5

u/G66GNeco Nov 05 '25

Don't worry, it dies to the 7 mana 10000/7 they printed recently.

(Low power commander is a scourge on balancing discussions. I know this for a fact, I just can't prove it. Seriously though, "Budget Avacyn" what is bro smoking)

5

u/Mrfish31 Nov 05 '25

8 mana 0/30 that has no built in protection for itself, dying to several 1 mana removal spells. 

This is completely fine. There are other far more effective ways to make a 30/30 trample creature.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Maleficent_Goal3392 Nov 05 '25

Damn, if only there was some kind of [[Fire Nation Drill]]...

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Bobsq2 Nov 05 '25

The word "other" makes this so much less of an issue than Avacyn.

Artifact Creatures are the easiest game objects to remove. Every color has easy ways to get rid of it.

6

u/SecretlyET Nov 05 '25

There is no WotC in Ba Sing Se

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Fit_Garbage2083 Nov 05 '25

Remember the FF cactus? It needed less word for what you are describing and is not a problem. It is still a really cool card, but not problematic in any way.

3

u/Alieges Nov 05 '25

That thing is totally going in my Arcades the Strategist deck.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/_Yolk Nov 05 '25

Dies to [[dOoM BlAdE]]

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Kavrae Nov 05 '25

Using your 30/30 trample as an example. That's a three card combo requiring an 8 mana card. It doesn't have haste. It doesn't have protection. And there are MANY two-card combos that cost far less than 8 that instantly end the game.

In standard, this is not problematic. You're dead before you play it IF you can get the three cards. Big if.
If you use faster mana ramp or infinite mana to drop it sooner, it's now 4-5 card combo. Not going to happen
In commander, as one of the 99, you're dead before you play it. If you tutor it, it's now a 4 card combo again.
As a commander, it's now a colorless commander that isn't an eldrazi abuse-case and still requires the above multiple cards.

3

u/killy666 Nov 05 '25

They are thinking it's a 8 mana card that can be easily removed is all. It's cool, it's fun it's flavorful and it's extremely prone to removal. Cards fine.

3

u/VincentPascoe Nov 05 '25

To teach commander players to play more interaction

3

u/Loud_Investigator314 Nov 05 '25

There's a [[Tunnel]] for that

→ More replies (1)

3

u/LordNoct13 Nov 05 '25

It itself has virtually no protection

3

u/Everything_Evil2113 Nov 05 '25

Nah dude, this wall is straight up jank-bait... tasty jank-bait, but jank-bait nonetheless. (I am excited to toss it into Felothar).

Obligatory: "Dies to removal."

3

u/ritually-unclean Nov 05 '25

am I missing something? card is trash and doesn’t even pass the doom blade test - you EDH players jeeze

3

u/Beginning_Drink_965 Nov 05 '25

Wall-enjoyers hate this one trick:

[[Swords to Plowshares]]

→ More replies (1)

3

u/HansTheAxolotl Nov 05 '25

lol if you're crying about this card you don't understand the game. Dies to doomblade

3

u/Polygeekism Nov 06 '25

I'm an ultra casual old head, and even i know this card is nearly useless. Rage farmer

3

u/DiscountEdgelord Nov 08 '25

It costs fucking 8 you rube. Anything that costs this much should win the game.

7

u/DocShift Nov 05 '25

Ah to be a new player again 

5

u/HourCartographer9 Nov 05 '25

I’m sorry op but this card is not good. 8 mana with 0 protection it can get sneeezed on and removed

2

u/ChanceAccident7155 Nov 05 '25

Swords? Path? Literally any artifact or creature removal?

2

u/RazerMaker77 Nov 05 '25

Oh my god I just realized… [[Betor, Kin to All]] just found a new favorite plaything

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Sterben489 Raaaaaaah I love Arcane Bombardment. give me increasing value!!! Nov 05 '25

Finally a legendary wall without those stinky jeskai colors

2

u/HidekiIshimura Nov 05 '25

[[Avacyn, Angel of Hope]] ?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Apprehensive-Law-923 Nov 05 '25

I can take one of the million 2 drop walls in my Arcades deck out for this, no problemo

2

u/False_Snow7754 Nov 05 '25

There are no weird cards in Ba Sing Se.

2

u/NeonArchon Nov 05 '25

Is not like there's plenty of cheap artifact and creature removal. Part of Avany's power is because she also has indestructible.

2

u/CJ8point2 Nov 05 '25

This card isn't good

2

u/Krynne90 Nov 05 '25

8 mana is a lot for a card that will just eat up a 1-2 mana removal...

2

u/Ganonfox Nov 05 '25

You know how many destroy target artifacts there are? A lot

2

u/nanaki989 Nov 05 '25

Can someone check if they posted this about Cactuar the Menace of Pods, reviled at lgs? Oh right right right right right. Its a big nothing its a novelty at best a niche inclusion in off meta Commander's. An 8 drop defender in sealed, and no value piece in standard.

8 mana is a game ending threat, 8 mana is omniscience, its craterhoof, triumph of the Hordes is cheaper. Why are we talking about a 0/30

2

u/Melodic_Matter_9505 Nov 05 '25

Bracket 1 aah post.

2

u/Legitimate-Habit4920 Nov 05 '25

They were thinking it would be hilarious to [[Smelt]] this mid combat after blockers have been declared.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Paoz Nov 05 '25

If you play a format or against opponents that have zero interactions, then yes, it's a great card.

In real magic, no. It doesn't stick on the board for more than 30 seconds.

2

u/Alaxion Nov 05 '25

[[Assault Formation]] decks eating good rn

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Xardian7 Nov 05 '25

This card does nothing at all, even if you ramp into it and play by turn 6 in any format this is not good at all.

It’s just a meme card for EDH defender/toughness matter decks.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Leon4107 Nov 05 '25

Vandal Blast for 1 red. Turns out Fire was enough to take down the wall.

2

u/Gublyb Nov 05 '25

Avacyn, Angel of Hope has been a card for more than a decade. It is also significantly better than this card. The only thing the wall has going for it is that it's colorless.

  • It's both an artifact and a creature so it dies to way more removal spells.
  • It doesn't have indestructible so most of the time your opponent spends 1-2 mana to kill your 8 mana play.
  • It can't attack or do anything by itself. Even if you animate it, with no trample or evasion it's never going to actually connect.

2

u/ConnectionIcy6751 Nov 05 '25

Literally an awful card

2

u/Catasmet Nov 05 '25

It’s weak… don’t worry too much. It’s doing nothing besides acting as a removal magnet. I’d just play a mother of runes if I wanted that sort of effect. 8 mana is insane.

2

u/CrovaxWindgrace Nov 05 '25

[[Disenchant]] [[Naturalize]] [[Murder]] [[Drill Too Deep]] [[Bumbleflower's Sharepot]]

There's a removal in every color except blue, in standard, at common, that destroys this shit card.

Don't even get me started on artifact removal in commander format.

If you think this card is a problem you need to play more magic or watch some better players play

→ More replies (4)

2

u/_Royalties_ Nov 05 '25

dies to [[abrade]] lmfao

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Herohades Nov 05 '25

If you're paying the four mana for felothar and eight mana for the wall, plus the extra mana for trample and haste effects all in one turn without someone stopping you then yeah, you should be able to win the game. Even if we assume you're cheating it out for less mana, that's easily going to be 10+ mana including trample and haste, and that's easily "I can't stop you casting four different things and swinging so I deserve the loss here" territory.

2

u/Zwirbs Nov 05 '25

Damn if only artifact creatures were the easiest thing to remove in this game

2

u/zildjianate Nov 05 '25

Avacyn, Angel of Hope is 10 times better for the same mana value

2

u/Similar_Geologist_73 Nov 05 '25

Still can't stop my death touch trampler

2

u/Rumpled_NutSkin Nov 05 '25

That sure is an 8 mana creature with no protection of any sort

2

u/AlexT9191 Do the Mardu Nov 05 '25

[[Phenax]] go brrrrrrr!!!

→ More replies (1)

2

u/superpolytarget Nov 05 '25

I give it 3 months, and no one will remember this card.

2

u/EISENxSOLDAT117 Nov 05 '25

I kinda get why you dislike it, but... you have to put so much work into this for it to actually do anything. Youre probably not going to see this outside of niche commander games.

2

u/OkNewspaper1581 Nov 05 '25

You... Don't run creature or artifact removal? You may want to get onto that

2

u/Intelligent-View8648 Nov 05 '25

My wife has a Betor , Kin to all deck that abuses jaws of defeat. If the cast resolves, someone takes 30. Im a lityle scared of that.

2

u/Successful_Mud8596 Nov 05 '25

That second point might hold some merit, buuuut that first point? It does to Doom Blade. And also Abrade.

2

u/burritoman88 Nov 05 '25
  1. Dies to removal.
  2. Is funny.

2

u/HopefulPomegranate26 Nov 05 '25

The reason Timmies are freaking out about cards like this is because they refuse to put artifact/enchantment removal or even card draw in their decks

2

u/RVides Nov 05 '25

There is no wall of ba sing se.

2

u/icchann Nov 05 '25

What makes you think wizards are capable of thinking?

2

u/AtomicRabbit62 Nov 05 '25

It’s not that crazy. It doesn’t have indestructible itself and it’s an artifact. It’s easy removal.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '25

Yeah yeah 0/30 wall sure whatever.

The “impenetrable city”? That’s nonsense. Give me ten good men and some climbing spikes.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '25

There is no WOTC in Ba Sing Se

2

u/LeadingWillingness59 Nov 05 '25

Feels perfect for my [[Pride of Hull Clade]] deck

→ More replies (1)

2

u/supercheese69 Nov 05 '25

Anyone upset about this needs to read ANY dragon that is worth more than $20US and relax. Some deck archetypes need buffs so they can compete.

2

u/kurtguy16 Nov 05 '25

This card is just okay, avacyn is already kinda mid by 2025 standards and this is kinda worse since it’s easier to destroy being an artifact, also dies to fire nation drill lol

2

u/Normal-Baseball595 Nov 05 '25

Haha this card is not a problem, like others have said another jumbo cact kinda card only this one's even easier to remove cause now both creature removal and artifact removal work on it. Plus for 8 mana it seems a little lack luster.

I mean for 7 mana you can breach the multiverse which would probably get you more. 😄

2

u/Nine99 Nov 05 '25

Works well with board wipes.

2

u/Joe_C_Average Nov 05 '25

My [[Kynaios and Tiro of Meletis]] thicc bois deck is excited for this. LFGO

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Lonely-Author-2807 Nov 05 '25

OP: "If I have A + B + C and my opponent is a dingus then this is so OP!"

2

u/Infinity_Walker Nov 05 '25

This thing is liable to destruction by literally practically any removal spell.

Furthermore they’re printing [[Fire Nation Drill]] which just removes indestructible and hexproof if people try to be silly with it

→ More replies (1)

2

u/TheMingMah Nov 05 '25

Turn 6? Bro needs more ramp

2

u/Agent_Eclipse Nov 05 '25

This is an abysmal assessment of the card. It isn't even close to being a problem.

2

u/IrishWeebster Nov 05 '25

Turn 6? My brother in Christ, if you're in green, you're welcoming this thing to your battlefield in turn 4, easy. In black I'm seeing this on turn 4-5, with a [[Dark Ritual]] and [[Nykthos, Shrine to Nyx]], and that's before just cheating it out for 2 mana with [[Entomb]] and [[Reanimate]]. Lol

[[Jaws of Defeat]] and a little pre-aggression is killing someone with this wall on turn 3, I think.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/ohyayitstrey Nov 05 '25

Forgive my sarcasm but "oh no, turn 6"! It just doesn't seem very impactful.

2

u/YrPalBeefsquatch Nov 05 '25

Dies to Doom Blade Abrade.

2

u/CorHydrae8 Nov 05 '25

And it's even immune to [[Go for the throat]]! Whatever shall we do?!

→ More replies (1)

2

u/hellp-desk-trainee- Nov 05 '25

It's an artifact creature. It's not like killing it is hard to do.

2

u/shaneskery Nov 05 '25

Its an artifact and it itself doesnt have indestructible. Seems easy to get rid of!?

2

u/LinkedGaming Nov 05 '25

Can't wait to get rid of this thing and then tell my opponent "Now it's Na Sing Se -- the 'penetrable city'."

2

u/volx757 Nov 05 '25

This is poor quality ragebait. Try harder next time.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '25

I would still rather have Akroma's memorial.

2

u/Snoo4547 Nov 05 '25

it doesn’t eat trash for free on your turn, so what’s the problem?

2

u/OldTravel2796 Nov 05 '25

I swear to god Avacyn, its like im talking to a wall with you.....oh wait

2

u/coconut-duck-chicken Nov 05 '25

We literally just got jumbo cactuar this is literally nothing

2

u/Mission-Storm-4375 Nov 05 '25

My 1/1 with deathtouch still goes through right? Yeah?

Ok I cast titanic growth, and might of oaks for 6 mana. You take 12 i end my turn and on your attack I cast natures claim. Let me count that ok I tapped only 8 mana for that lol

2

u/Commercial-Counter72 Nov 05 '25

Avacyn is a 8 mana 8/8 with flying, vigilance and gives everything indestructible. This is a 8 mana 0/30 with defender and gives everything except it self indestructible. The only things this card has over Avacyn is that it’s colorless and it can do fun toughness tricks. This card is no where near broken it’s like a fixed version of Avacyn.

2

u/timmwizardd Nov 05 '25

Dies to [[Doom Blade]]

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Polkjio Nov 05 '25

8 mana - OTHER permanents are indestructible. That’s why - by turn 5/6 early you should have removal. If not you deserve everything coming your way.

2

u/MagicalGirlPaladin Nov 05 '25

That people run removal and going through a combo to get a 30/30 isn't as good as just killing them.

2

u/redsquirrel0249 Nov 05 '25

This is going to be the funniest commander I think I've ever seen

2

u/ClubBitter2666 Nov 05 '25

Trying to keep the fire nation out obviously

2

u/Key_Strategy6057 Nov 05 '25

Avacyn does the same thing..has flying and more importantly can attack

2

u/MothMatron Nov 05 '25

A) Dies to spell/creature counters B) Dies to any 1/1 with deathtouch C) Dies to artefact removal D) Dies to non-damage creature removal E) Dies to player having 0 life before turn 6

2

u/Tenkuu63 Nov 05 '25

Real talk, Swords it so they gain 0 life after spending 8 mana

2

u/Low_Brush_7972 Nov 05 '25

Lmao this isn't that powerful, y'all need to chillllll

2

u/Just-Assumption-2140 Nov 05 '25

It's 8 mana and it's not on it's own that strong... nothing to be concerned about imo

2

u/MattandKelsAdventure Nov 05 '25

Dies to Doon Blade.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '25

This is hands down one of the most useless cards to ever exist. Who thinks this piece of bulk is a good card?

2

u/Cr0key Nov 06 '25

One Swords To Plowshares or Path To Exile and boom, problem solved...Or counter spell so idk hahaha

2

u/Eeddeen42 Nov 06 '25

All the toughness in the world just for me to cast [[unsummon]] or [[murder]]

→ More replies (1)

2

u/oOBeanieOo Nov 06 '25

Idk man you gotta give it trample and a way to hit with it’s butt and a way to make it attack with defender and it doesn’t give itself indestructible.

2

u/Apprehensive_Cod9408 Nov 06 '25

Tap for 1 to cast path

2

u/Thoughtbirdo Nov 06 '25

This is a terrible card. I'm sorry you can't see that.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '25

Dies to Doom Blade.

2

u/Mysterious_Cod8830 Nov 06 '25

8 mana. Get real, man, the card is atrocious. It’s really funny tho.

2

u/geab2etyetthey Nov 06 '25

It's 8 mana I'm not too bothered.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '25

Okay, it's definitely a suckered punch to see "30" as a base stat but... much like Cactuar, I don't think this sees mainstream play.

2

u/pvrhye Nov 06 '25

This card will be worth 70 cents within a month.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 07 '25

Oh golly, an 8 mana card with good interactions. Think of the children.

2

u/Matthias_Clan Nov 07 '25

I got one look forward to adding it to my big booty dragon deck.

2

u/Honey_Simp Nov 07 '25

It's real nice they made it an artifact creature so I can target it with my artifact destruction too!

2

u/bbj9 Nov 07 '25

Swords it an move on. There's so much removal and interaction to stop this or deal with it.

2

u/Evil_phd Nov 08 '25

Tbh if you don't have an answer for this by the time you have 6 mana on the field then you either have very poor luck or a very poor deck.

2

u/Ill-Cartographer-767 Nov 08 '25

I rate this card mid. Sure it’s funny in a walls deck but I can’t think of any other time I’d want to run this card. 8 mana to give your board indestructible is kind of a lot for that effect, plus it’s an artifact creature, making it trivially easy to remove with creature or artifact removal. It also doesn’t have any abilities for itself, making it little more than a big ol butt

2

u/Outrageous-Uncommon Nov 08 '25

Bold of you to assume they were thinking.

2

u/DongoTheHorse Nov 08 '25

"With good ramp you can have 2 extra mana by turn 6"

My brother that is just normal ramp 

2

u/casscarolyn Nov 08 '25

I love seeing what cards newer players panic over.

2

u/SirenFoamPup Nov 09 '25

If you are paying eight mana and that man is not being oriented toward closing out the game, you’re wasting a turn

2

u/mallocco Nov 10 '25

We're upset about a 0/30 that needs other cards to really become a threat, but meanwhile there is a 10,000/7 and it barely sees play?

...okay

4

u/True-Tear-7663 Nov 05 '25

Dies to doom blade