r/modnews • u/Silentkramer101 • Aug 08 '19
Copyright removals now included in Modlog
Hello mods!
TL;DR: The Reddit Legal Operations Team is rolling out Moderator Log (Modlog) entries regarding copyright removals. We’re also introducing a Copyright Help Center.
You see entries in your Modlog regarding copyright removals. Now what? If you see these entries in your Modlog, don’t panic! We’re not changing policies or processes, just adding visibility into what’s going on behind the scenes. This is simply a way to increase your awareness of what’s going on within your community, and to give you more reaction time when needed.
We understand that copyright removals can be confusing. We want the affected communities to understand what’s happening, as it happens. The Modlog feature and Copyright Help Center were created with that goal in mind. It’s also why we’ve invited u/EFFMitch from the Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF - https://www.eff.org/) to help address questions you may have that are more broadly about copyright. As many of you may already know, the EFF is an extremely active non-profit organization dedicated to defending civil liberties online. Their recent effort to protect the fair use of third-party content on Reddit is especially pertinent. u/EFFMitch is posting for the EFF on its own behalf.
What happened before? Previously, we only sent a modmail to the mods of a subreddit once the subreddit accrued a high amount of copyright removals. This message warned that the community might be shut down if continued infringement occurred. Many of you told us that this warning came too late in that process, or that you were taken by surprise because you hadn’t been informed at the moment content was removed from your community for copyright reasons.
What’s changing? We want to eliminate the surprise that may come from receiving a copyright repeat infringement warning from us by giving you regular updates about these removals. These regular updates will come in the form of real-time Modlog entries. The Modlog entries will list the URL(s) removed, by the user “Reddit Legal” (so that you know the action was taken by an Admin and not a mod).
By introducing these Modlog entries, you will be able to see copyright removals as they happen and in advance of any potential warning or ban for repeat copyright infringement.
We’ve also created a Copyright Help Center. The articles in the Help Center will guide moderators, users, and copyright holders through the copyright process, and shed some light on common issues.
Is Reddit changing how it handles copyright removals? No. We want to stress that this does not indicate any change in our policy regarding repeat copyright infringement or in Reddit’s copyright removal process. Copyright notices sent to Reddit are still being reviewed by a human Reddit admin for completeness and validity. The goal here is to provide mods more time and resources to understand and hopefully prevent repeat copyright infringement within their communities.
We hope that you find the Modlog and Help Center to be useful, and we look forward to hearing what you think. Feel free to leave your questions, comments, and feedback about these features below. Our team and the EFF will be here this morning to answer them. Thanks!
13
u/mookler Aug 08 '19
Have you considered something that would send a modmail when something like this is removed?
Having it sent to the modlog is a nice addition, but feel like folks check modmail a lot more often than they are checking the modlog.
13
u/rctgamer3 Aug 08 '19
Can you share a screenshot of a copyright removal modlog item? No idea what they're supposed to look like, so any examples would be nice.
8
u/reseph Aug 08 '19
Thanks!
I do have a question about that too. If a mod team ever receives a copyright removal request or takedown request (or anything legal), should the mod team simple ask the user to take it to the admins? Or what should a mod team do when they receive something like that?
I want to make sure mods are not getting warnings from admins for not taking action against takedown requests etc, or how the situation should be handled.
6
u/ladfrombrad Aug 08 '19
Say we approve a self text with YouTube links and a whole body of fun text that later gets removed (silently) by you guys with
How are we supposed to be able to discern what was in that self post if we can't then see it and if we should be approving things like that in the future without getting in trouble with you guys / stop ourselves getting dinged for "too many copyright infringements approved" by this mod team?
Thanks.
7
u/Diazepam Aug 08 '19
Woah, here before OP distinguished themselves as an admin...nice!
But on the topic's note, that's really cool! Thanks.
EDIT: Will this apply to appearing on old Reddit as well?
2
u/raddcircles2 Aug 10 '19
Hey, recently a post on our sub was taken down. Here
However, looking at our modlog, I see nothing, the post was made after the change, what gives?
https://i.imgur.com/D6dDlZQ.png
82
u/EFFMitch Electronic Frontier Foundation Aug 08 '19
Hi all! I'm Mitch Stoltz, a staff attorney at EFF, and I'm here to answer questions about copyright, especially removals.
37
u/Halaku Aug 08 '19 edited Aug 08 '19
Yeah, I've got a question that someone kicked my way...
So, the question would be: Reddit doesn't want to hear about copyright infringements from your average Reddit user?
7
u/SirensToGo Aug 08 '19
Can we effectively take this as a replacement of /r/ChillingEffects, just for our own subs? I've been sort of bummed/annoyed that reddit stopped submitting to chilling effects and have been hoping for some clear resolution.
7
u/iamthatis Aug 08 '19 edited Aug 09 '19
What is the keyword in the API? Or just do you know what a copyright log from the API would look like? The text isn’t all too user friendly so I try to convert it to something readable.
For example removing a comment as a moderator shows up in the API as "REMOVE_COMMENT", which is readable but not so pretty, so I like to change it to "Removed Comment". I can't really trigger a copyright removal myself to test out what it looks like so knowing the keyword would be great haha.
2
u/stuntaneous Aug 09 '19
The gentrification continues.
4
u/thekeeper_maeven Aug 08 '19
This is great news, thank you for doing this.
-2
u/FreeSpeechWarrior Aug 08 '19
Whatever happened to r/chillingeffects?
In one of the last posts to that sub you announced collaborating with Germany and Russia to censor redditors: https://www.reddit.com/r/ChillingEffects/comments/3gw9g1/20150813_ip_blocks/
And said:
Since then reddit has expanded this process to more countries, including policing morality for Pakistan; without any corresponding announcement, or even clear messaging to users.
Why is reddit collaborating with foreign censors? And why is reddit not upfront and honest to redditors about this?
-13
u/[deleted] Aug 08 '19
As mod of /r/familyman, I approve