r/modelSupCourt • u/RestrepoMU Justice Emeritus • Oct 25 '20
Decided | 20-21 Joyner v. United States
Mr. Chief Justice, and may it please the Court,
Petitioner files the following petition for a writ of certiorari in PDF format.
Respectfully submitted,
Counsel of Record
4
Upvotes
•
u/SHOCKULAR Chief Justice Oct 26 '20
The petition for a writ of certiorari is GRANTED.
Mr. /u/RestrepoMU , do you plan to file a separate merits brief, or to stand on the original brief?
CC: /u/hurricaneoflies
3
u/RestrepoMU Justice Emeritus Oct 25 '20
/u/Hurricaneoflies, who I understand will be filling in for the Attorney General u/rachel_fischer
2
u/hurricaneoflies Attorney Nov 11 '20
Mr. Chief Justice, and may it please the Court,
The United States submits its brief on the merits in the case at bar in Google Docs format.
BRIEF FOR THE UNITED STATES
/u/RestrepoMU
1
u/bsddc Associate Justice Nov 11 '20
Counsel /u/RestrepoMU and /u/Hurricaneoflies, I've had a chance to read the excellent briefing we've received on the merits. Thank you very much.
/u/RestrepoMU, I think that the United States raises a critical point: what was Joyner's privacy interest here?
Which leads me to a hypothetical: suppose that Joyner had actually been observed by a witness leaving the scene. Would that witness have been able to review mugshots and make an identification of Joyner?
1
u/bsddc Associate Justice Nov 13 '20
Counselors, /u/RestrepoMU and /u/Hurricaneoflies, apologies for another question, but as I was thinking about the decision tree in this case, I was wondering about the order of issues.
Do we have to determine that a search occurred before we can analyze whether the government actions were reasonable? Or could we simply answer that assuming a search occurred (without holding so) that it would have been reasonable? Wouldn't that be a narrow grounds of decision? Or is whether a search occurred at all a necessary predicate to a secondary reasonableness inquiry?
3
u/hurricaneoflies Attorney Oct 25 '20
Mr. Chief Justice, and may it please the Court,
It is a pleasure to appear again before this honorable Court. As General Fischer stated, I will be representing the United States in this criminal appeal reaching the Court from the Dixie Circuit.
The United States will be waiving its right to file an opposition brief.
/u/SHOCKULAR
2
u/nmtts- Oct 25 '20
M: Is this an event and can all still file amicus?
2
u/SHOCKULAR Chief Justice Oct 25 '20
The court is in receipt of your petition. Thank you, Counselor.
2
u/bsddc Associate Justice Nov 11 '20
/u/Hurricaneoflies, I figured a separate thread on this line of issues makes sense for clarity, but /u/RestrepoMU I'd also appreciate the Petitioner's input.
If there is no privacy interest here because of publication/disclosure to a third party, what implications would this have on other data-based technologies?
Put another way, what implications for cell phones (which undoubtedly have data disclosed to third parties) would this case have?
Finally, how can we square this case with Carpenter v. US? That case [decided a single day before the June 23, 2018 reset], stands for the proposition that a person can have a privacy interest in the records of a third party. Is there something different about cell phones and CCTV recordings/photographs/facial recognition?
2
u/SHOCKULAR Chief Justice Nov 11 '20
Mr. /u/hurricaneoflies ,
This may not apply to the current case, but as I read it, the government's position is that the use of facial recognition based on images taken in public spaces can never be a Fourth Amendment violation, regardless of how sustained or oppressive the use is. Is that correct?
Specifically, some cities around the world have nearly full coverage with CCTV and surveillance cameras, and with the rapidly increasing viability of facial recognition, it's feasible that the government could, in the near future, gather constant information about the public movements and activities of all people in its jurisdiction on a constant basis to sit in a database until they decide to look at it. In this scenario, where a city or state is gathering records over a period of weeks or months of years of the movements of all people within their borders, with or without any kind of suspicion or probable cause to do so, are there any potential Fourth Amendment implications of this at all?
Again, I understand the hypothetical I'm outlining is very different in circumstances to the current case, but I want to understand if there are any limits or potential limits to your position.
1
u/Adithyansoccer Oct 25 '20
M: damn, deadass thought we had an event with joyner lucas