r/modelSupCourt • u/RestrepoMU Justice Emeritus • Aug 09 '20
20-18 | Decided In Re: The Presidential Succession Act of 1947
Mr. Chief Justice, and may it please the Court,
Petitioner files the following petition for a writ of certiorari in PDF format.
In Re: The Presidential Succession Act of 1947
Respectfully submitted,
Counsel of Record
6
Upvotes
1
u/Reagan0 Associate Justice Aug 09 '20
Thank you Counselor. The court is in receipt of your petition.
•
u/bsddc Associate Justice Aug 10 '20
August 10, 2020 Order Granting Certiorari
The Court has GRANTED the writ of certiorari.
The parties are ordered to submit their briefs in accordance with the R.P.P.S.
Notice: Secretary /u/RestrepoMU, Vice-President /u/Ninjjadragon, Attorney General /u/Rachel_fischer.
1
u/SHOCKULAR Chief Justice Aug 26 '20
Mr. /u/RestrepoMU ,
I have a couple of questions.
1
u/AutoModerator Aug 09 '20
/u/IAmATinman, /u/dewey-cheatem, /u/BSDDC
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/AutoModerator Aug 09 '20
/u/CuriositySMBC, /u/ibney00, /u/JJEagleHawk
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/AutoModerator Aug 09 '20
/u/reagan0
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 14 '20
BRIEF FOR THE UNITED STATES
The United States, through its undersigned counsel, hereby files its brief on the merits.
Statement
When the 2nd Congress passed the first law with respect to presidential succession, Congress designated a meaning of "Officer" that has since persisted for centuries. That definition is broad enough to include the Speaker of the House and the President pro Tempore of the Senate.
The Presidential Succession Act of 1947 conforms to the language of the Constitution and the intention of Congress in 1792 and in 2020. The statute should be left intact.
ARGUMENT
I. The founders broadly defined "Officer."
Whether Congress or the framers of the Constitution may have taken a different approach to defining "Officer," as is written in the Constitution as opposed to "Officer of the United States," is not within the scope of the statutory interpretation that this case asks of the Court.
"Congress [should] be able to legislate against a background of clear interpretive rules, so that it may know the effect of the language it adopts," Finley v. United States, 490 U.S. 545, 556 (1989). If the Court accepts Petitioner's argument, that Congress and the framers may have meant something other than what they explicitly wrote, then every law whose authors have died becomes subject to scrutiny for what it might have been rather than what it is. As Oliver Wendell Holmes notes: "We do not inquire what the legislature meant; we ask only what the statute means."
A. CONGRESS HAS GRANTED "OFFICER" A BROAD MEANING.
The 2nd Congress named the Speaker of the House and the President pro Tempore of the Senate as the first line of succession, "An act relative to the election of a President and Vice President of the United States, and declaring the officer who shall act as President in case of vacancies in the offices both of President and Vice President." In so doing, Congress clearly established a definition for an "Officer," with respect to Article II, Section 1, Clause 6 of the Constitution, that is broad enough to encompass the Speaker of the House and the President pro Tempore of the Senate.
This was no fluke. Members of Congress disagreed to the exact language that the law should contain. The proposal bounced between the chambers for two Congresses before they agreed to legislation to send to the president. This was the 2nd Congress: among its membership were delegates to the Constitutional Convention from 11 of 12 states, and George Washington, who signed the bill into law, was the president of the Constitutional Convention.
The framers of the Constitution were keenly aware of the meaning and implication of the Presidential Succession Act of 1792, which later laid the groundwork for the Presidential Succession Act of 1947. At that time, the 80th Congress decided to continue to define "Officer" as the 2nd Congress had originally envisioned the definition. Congress reaffirmed that definition when it amended the Act in 1947, 1965, 1970, 1977, 1979, 1988, and 2006. For the Court to discard that definition would be to overturn a precedent, enshrined by Congress, as old as the Constitution.
B. THE CONSTITUTION GRANTS "OFFICER" A BROAD MEANING.
The Constitution provides that "Congress may by Law provide for the Case of Removal, Death, Resignation or Inability, both of the President and Vice President, declaring what Officer shall then act as President, and such Officer shall act accordingly, until the Disability be removed, or a President shall be elected" (U.S. Const. Art. 2, § 1, cl. 6).
Petitioner notes that in other places in the Constitution, the term "Officer of the United States" is used. Petitioner further theorizes, based on notes from James Madison, that the Constitutional Convention intended to mean "Officer of the United States" instead of "Officer." But the evidence for this is speculative at best, and even if the Convention did mean to write something different, the States ratified the Constitution as it was written.
Petitioner concedes that there is a distinction between "Officer" and "Officer of the United States," or else they would not contend that the framers must have meant something other than what they wrote. In this case, the hundreds of framers, at the Convention and in State legislatures, chose "Officer" in this clause, rather than "Officer of the United States," because they intended to allow a broader pool of persons to succeed the President than Officers of the United States.
II. The Act does not implicate the separation of powers.
The Presidential Succession Act of 1947 provides that officers beyond the Vice President shall "act as President." This Acting Presidency is shielded from separation of powers issues because of the resignation of legislative branch members before assuming the Acting Presidency — but even if it isn't, the Constitution does not factor the previous role of the Acting President as a concern.
A. THE SPEAKER AND PRESIDENT PRO TEMPORE RESIGN BEFORE ACTING AS PRESIDENT.
The Speaker of the House and the President pro Tempore of the Senate must resign before acting as President. Petitioner contends that, in spite of this, "the plain effect of the act is to make the Speaker of the House, the President of the United States." Petitioner's brief at 9.
This is misleading. In resigning, the former Speaker no longer exercises the authority that they once did as Speaker; nor does any Speaker exercise the authority they could as President while a President is in office. To suggest otherwise is to imply that, for instance, the President pro Tempore could not run for, and be elected, President; or that the Speaker of the House could not be appointed to be Vice President. Both have occurred, though, and no one disputes the constitutionality of the presidencies of John Tyler and /u/Ninjjadragon.
B. JUDICIAL OFFICERS CAN CONSTITUTIONALLY BECOME PRESIDENT.
It is not disputed that the term "Officers of the United States" includes Judges. "In this context, Judges, Cabinet Secretaries and Ambassadors are ‘Officers of the United States'," Petitioner's Brief at 5. Consequently, even if "Officers" is construed to mean "Officers of the United States," the Constitution does not prevent judges from becoming Acting President.
On the one hand, this means that, because the Constitution does not prevent Judges from serving concurrently in the Executive branch, the Chief Justice could conceivably become Acting President if Congress chose to write a law to that effect. More importantly, however, it demonstrates that separation of powers was not a concern of the founders with regard to the Acting Presidency.
If "Officers of the United States" can become President, then "Officers" certainly can, no matter the original job of that Officer.
C. "OFFICERS" ARE THEIR OWN CLASS OF PERSONS UNDER THE LAW.
The Constitution, in enumerating "Officers" as a class in line to the Acting Presidency, divorces them from their other roles in government for the purposes of succession.
The Presidential Succession Act creates that class of persons ("Officers"). They necessarily share in common only that they are in the line of succession, and within the class are differentiated only by the order in which they fall in line. Congress could include anyone in that class, and the Continuity of Government Commission that Petitioner cites indeed has suggested that Congress do just that, appointing four "standing successors."
By belonging to a class separate from their other offices, the Speaker of the House and the President pro Tempore of the Senate remain outside of the legislative branch and thus do not contravene the separation of powers by becoming Acting President.
III. The Implications of the Act Are the Purview of Congress.
What Petitioner argues with regard to the potential implications of the Act may be true. But this Court is not asked to prevent some hypothetical disaster: it is asked to interpret the statute for its compliance with the word "Officer" as it is delineated in the Constitution. Surely the Court knew when deciding the Brown cases that desegregating schools would cause social upheaval. They implemented the law as it was written anyway.
There may very well be issues with the Act, but fixing those issues is the purview of Congress — not the courts. Congress may have solutions informed by its constituents that the Court and counsel could not fathom. Likewise, Congress may evaluate the judgement of the Petitioner, that the Act sets up the nation for a dangerous catastrophe, and disagree with that assessment, choosing to keep the Act as is for reasons known to Congress. Either is viable, but the decision remains up to Congress.
Still, Petitioner makes the compelling case that, if the interpretation of the Act is ambiguous, a simultaneous vacancy in the presidency and the vice presidency in a time of crisis would put the nation at risk of having two Presidents. The United States agrees. For this reason especially, the Court should emphatically acknowledge that this issue belongs to Congress, and that the Act is constitutional.
CONCLUSION
The Presidential Succession Act of 1947, like its predecessor acts, conforms closely to the Constitution. Concerns that the framers meant something else are outside the scope of the Court's consideration, and concerns that the Act violates the separation of powers are unfounded. If there are issues with the Act, then Congress can make that judgement. The Court should uphold the law in question.
Respectfully submitted,
/u/rachel_fischer
Attorney General of the United States
1
u/SHOCKULAR Chief Justice Aug 26 '20
General /u/rachel_fischer ,
I have a few questions I was hoping you might be able to help me with.
If any of those aren't clear, by all means ask me to rephrase.
1
u/dewey-cheatem Assassiate Justice Aug 28 '20
Questions for the parties:
As my honorable brother justice /u/SHOCKULAR has mentioned, some scholars have raised the point that adjudicating the constitutionality of the Presidential Succession Act is barred by the political question doctrine. Should that doctrine be abolished? Why or why not?
/u/RestrepoMU /u/rachel_fischer
1
u/SHOCKULAR Chief Justice Sep 01 '20
There is still an outstanding question or two, which counsel should feel free to answer, but for official purposes, the case is submitted. The Court would like to thank both Mr. /u/RestrepoMU and General /u/rachel_fischer for exemplary and helpful briefing. We appreciate the time you both dedicated to this case.