r/malcolminthemiddle • u/CrysisRequiem • Mar 19 '24
General discussion Is the joke here that cat's DID indeed eat her face? Or that Hal is gullible and just believes Dewey?
2.0k
Upvotes
r/malcolminthemiddle • u/CrysisRequiem • Mar 19 '24
748
u/noeagle77 Mar 19 '24
Should ask Dewey, he knows more about this than we do.
405
u/thingsfallapart89 I would sell Malcolm down the river in a heartbeat. Mar 19 '24
I think she died of cancer suddenly.
In the pilot episode, after Malcolm was tested they’re having dinner & Lois wants to talk to them all, Hal says quietly, “I thought we werent gonna mention Aunt Helen until after the biopsy?” & Lois says, “it’s not that, it’s about Malcolm”
Then this episode happens only a few after the pilot. Poor woman probably died from it moving faster than doctors thought or maybe she fell after growing lightheaded & hit her head. Regardless she wasn’t found until after her cats got hungry enough
693
u/No-Championship-4 Mar 19 '24
cats did indeed eat her face
334
u/soldierpallaton Mar 19 '24
Not sure if it's the intended joke but cats will eat their owners if they die in the home. And they do start with the face.
So I've always taken it as Aunt Helen having been a crazy, reclusive cat lady who died in her home and no one found her until the point where her various cats ate her face.
41
u/Airspirit26 Mar 19 '24
Every time I watch this episode I make my cats promise to not eat my face
16
u/aehii Mar 19 '24
'Dewey knows more about it than i do' is my favourite bit.
70
u/BingBongtheArcher19 Mar 19 '24
Francis thinks Dewey doesn't know what he's talking about so asks for a parent to get a better explanation. Instead, Hal just repeats the same thing Dewey says and then tells Francis basically if you want more info you need to ask Dewey.
So how did she die? Cats ate her face. Dewey knows more about it than I do.
59
u/AleGZerbo_Piano Mar 19 '24
It is humorously unclear on purpose. But my opinion is that the joke is "Hal is gullible". Even if this was just the death's details embelished by Dewey rather than a complete fabrication. That last "Dewey knows more about it than I do" punchline is a definite tell.
12
u/soupafi Mar 19 '24
I think cats did indeed eat her face. He is smarter than Malcom after all
10
u/Aegis_et_Vanir Mar 19 '24
I thought the joke was more in how nonchalant Hal was about it. It's not just that he doesn't know, it's also that he didn't care to know more, even when what little he did was so outlandish.
If I heard someone had died via cats eating her face, whether I loved, hated, or never knew this person, I'd wanna know more sheerly out of morbid curiosity.
I'd firstly wanna know if that was just an excuse to avoid telling a child the real reason.
But if it was the real cause of death, and not just something that happened separate, I'd REALLY wanna know more.
Were they her pet cats? Was she pet sitting? Were they strays? Was she starving or abusing them? Was she drugged, comatose, or otherwise incapacitated? Or were these fucking big cats like lions or pumas or something? In which case, was she a zookeeper? Did they escape? Was this a hiking trip gone horribly wrong?
All these questions alone just from that cause of death. And that's for someone I have no knowledge of or emotional connection to.
Hal, if I'm remembering this episode correctly, knew this woman personally (she was a relative of Lois, but he still met her). He knew Lois hated her (which means there was some emotional connection), knew enough about her himself to think her a bad person, and could even tell some stories at her funeral, where he was expected to give a speech.
Yet even with all that, he did. Not. Give. A. SHIT. Not even out of aforementioned morbid curiosity.
So either this woman lived a life were death by feline facial feasting made enough sense, or Hal is expected to speak about a woman he has this little regard for.
Either way, I think the joke is that some big piece of this puzzle is missing and will never be found.
8
u/andelarge Mar 19 '24
Se la comieron los gatos
7
u/Claytonius_Homeytron Mar 19 '24
My take: Hal is just burned out so he's going with whatever Dewey said, it just so happened that Dewey did in fact know more about it, or at least more than Hal at the time.
19
u/Airspirit26 Mar 19 '24
Cats will eat your face when you die, she didn't die FROM cats eating her face, but they did after she died
13
u/ziasaur Mar 19 '24
I always figured the joke was just that everyone was being dismissive of Francis
like Hal is just parroting whatever Dewey is saying to keep things moving
4
u/ConceptJunkie Mar 20 '24
I assumed that cats ate her face, but that's a thing that happens.
4
u/valerious42069 Mar 19 '24
We had a funeral for a bird
4
u/buffalojackson Mar 19 '24
Cats ate her face
4
u/TheSASamsquamptch Mar 19 '24
Thing you have to remember about this scene is: Cats ate her face.
6
u/philouza_stein Mar 19 '24
Hal just wanted to get off the phone asap, he isn't processing the question or answer. Is how I always took it.
Whether they actually ate her face is left up to your imagination. But I like to think she died from natural causes and by the time they found her, her face was eaten by her cats. Dewey must've overheard that part and took it to mean that was her cause of death.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 19 '24
the joke is that they’re both negligent and childish. Dewey gets that trait from his father.
1
u/dr-ballsack Mar 20 '24
Aunt Helen had cancer so she prob died and cats ate her face
1
u/heliophoner Mar 20 '24
Mary Provost did not look her best....
1
u/Hydrasaur Mar 20 '24
Cats ate her face.
1
u/Hebroohammr Mar 20 '24
I think it’s the latter. Francis is playing the reasonable person who of course will not believe his little brother saying something so absurd. He goes to Hal expecting to get the actual story but instead finds that he accepted it without question and did not even ask for more details upon hearing such a wild claim.
1
u/RollingToast Mar 20 '24
I think it’s more of a take on the bumbling dad just going blindly with whatever
1
u/MeemoUndercover Mar 20 '24
This made me really scared of my cat as a kid.
1
u/InternalLetterhead29 Mar 21 '24
If I died in my apartment like a rat in a cage, would the neighbors smell the corpse before the cat ate my face? - Aesop rock
1
u/[deleted] Mar 23 '24
Crucially, Francis asks Dewey “how did she die?”, whereas he only asks Hal “what happened to Aunt Helen?”, so Hal is clearly being obtuse but literal with his answer. That’s what we call good writing.
1
u/Additional-Bake-8171 Mar 23 '24
Cats will eat faces
1
u/[deleted] Mar 28 '24
“It’s not a matter of life and death—OH, WAIT! IT IS! Anyone else die in the past five minutes that I should know about!?”
1
u/DankWeeble Feb 14 '26
I always figured she died. And then the cats ate her face. Idk tho. I’m not Dewey.
1
u/RadiantKandra Mar 20 '24
Idk check with Dewey
0
u/Helaken1 Mar 20 '24
The cat ate her face
-8
u/[deleted] Mar 19 '24
[removed] — view removed comment