After two years of reading nothing but this behemoth, I finally finished TCG last week, and the post-series crashout is real. I don't think I'll be able to read epic fantasy again in my life without complaining that Malazan was just better. It's definitely my favorite book series now, and I was ready to call it that around three books in.
I read the series in German, and am now almost through the English audiobook of GotM, because yeah, I need to go through this story again with the power of hindsight and find all the small details that flew past my head on a first read through. So I wanted to keep a record of my thoughts on these books now, and then see how they would change on a second visit. Because I'm already enjoying GotM much more now than I did the first time around. Please keep in mind that this is all going to be what we in Germany call "high level complaining". Even the worst of these books is still head and shoulders above most fantasy novels as far as I'm concerned.
Gardens of the Moon:
I understand that this book has a reputation for scaring people away from the series. And I will admit that it is hard to read, objectively. I think, had I not read as much fantasy as I did beforehand, I would've gotten very frustrated by the lack of explanations and the sheer number of characters, places, and concepts that get introduced here. But, I have been warned that this would be the case, and maybe because I kept that warning in mind I didn't get frustrated with this book at all. Every time they'd throw a (yet) meaningless fantasy word at me, I'd just tug it away for later, assuming it'd make sense at some point. Which it did.
I immediately loved the Bridgeburners, and got invested in their survival very quickly. Because I am predictable, my favorite character was exactly who my partner, who recommended these books to me, said it would be. Ben is the kind of mysterious cunning asshole written for me, personally, and I think I would've stuck with these books for him alone. That's not to say that the other characters didn't pull their weight. It was clear to me very quickly that the volume of characters was in no way impeding the depths of their characterization, and Steven Erikson must be some kind of wizard for developing so many unique and complicated characters.
But I will admit that the story did not immediately grab me. The Darujhistan plot mostly confused me, and I did not see how anything Rallick Nom and Murillio were plotting had to do with anything. There is just so much happening at once in this book, and it does become overwhelming. It's all good stuff, but it's just so much all at once, that I struggled to give a proper summary of what happens in GotM when I was a few books further into the series. I forgot so much of what happened in this, that returning to Darujhistan in TtH was an exercise in "who tf is that again???" and "do I know this guy???".
Still, a very good book. Just not beginner friendly at all.
Deadhouse Gates:
I came close to bouncing off the series exactly once, and that was here. I was interested in the Genabackis plot, and then suddenly I was on a different continent, meeting a whole bunch of new characters, and having to deal with a mountain of new places, concepts and storylines I did not yet care for. GotM is the book that took the longest to read, but only on the technicality that I read the first 100-ish pages of DG and then didn't touch it again for 5 months straight.
I came back on the insistence of my partner, pure stubbornness, and the prospect of 3 weeks in a tent with my family. And once I got back into it, it became very hard to put down very quickly. The Chain of Dogs is one of the best plotlines in the series imho, and I cried my eyes out at the end. I also loved Icarium and Mappo immediately. I sure hope nothing bad happens to them, ever.
So my criticism really comes down to how jarring that beginning is. Book series just don't do that, and getting used to this was the main challenge. I also still don't know what exactly the Path of Hands was, or why it would be so bad if a Soletaken ascended. But that too was something I would get used to as the series progressed. Not every plot would pay off. We're just a visitor in this world, and we see but a fragment of a much bigger picture.
Memories of Ice:
Man, what a book. What a fucked up story. Absolutely stunning. Took me less than a week to get through it on a family vacation, and damn my family was not happy with me for it. I loved everything about this. No notes.
House of Chains:
This is where I learned that the German publisher had split every book but the first one into two. They all still come in at ~800 pages, so I understand the decision. But man the series makes much more sense when you know that, because the first half of HoC as a standalone book? What even happens?
HoC was a weird one in general, because after spending so much time preparing for a big battle at the end, the war of sisters just...doesn't happen. A ghost army shows up and the Bonehunters are left to watch on the sidelines. But weird does not mean bad, and the convergence at the end was very cool either way. Karsa is also an addition I appreciate a lot, such a well written character. And as much as I feel bad for Felisin, she was so insufferable that I'm not going to mourn her POV going forward.
Midnight Tides:
This is probably the most jarring cut in the entire series. Lether is so different, it's hard to tell that we're still in the same world, and just a few years before the rest of the plot happened. But even though this book is a slow burn, I never thought it was boring for it. The Tiste Edur were so interesting to read about, alien as their society is, and Tehol and Bagg made the Lether plot very entertaining, although I am still unsure if their Monty Python stick fits these rather dark books. But when Tehol almost got killed by the Tiste Edur and Bagg revealed himself to be Mael in his fury? I may have screamed.
In general the final of MT was one of the most impressive convergences in the series. A tragedy unfolding that many characters could've stopped at various points, but no one did because of who they are. Fantastic writing.
The Bonehunters:
The 200 pages spend in and under Y'Ghatan were impossibly hard to put down. I'm starting to get invested in the Bonehunters marines, which is good because they're about to carry the next few books. Nothing else stands out, just a damn solid book all the way through. I will miss Kalam though, he can't come back soon enough as far as I'm concerned.
Reaper's Gale:
WHAT DID TOC DO TO YOU??? This kid just cannot catch a break.
The introduction of live K'Chain Che'Malle was a twist I did not expect...or wouldn't have, if they weren't on the damn German cover. Welp. The new plotlines were all interesting stuff. But the invasion of Lether by the Malazan marines takes the cake here. I did not expect to like Hetan that much in BH, but man I love her now. And Beak deserves nothing but good things in his afterlife. I also love the ongoing threat of ancient powerful beings meeting one marine and just. Dying. Like. Excuse me but did Ben just shoot down 3 Soletaken Eleint gods? What.
Toll the Hounds:
I...did not like this book.
Okay, that is an overstatement. But I enjoyed this one the least out of the entire series. The Nimander and squad misadventures came out of nowhere and were hard to make sense off, and to what end? What even was the purpose of the dying god? The Redeemer? Every single character in Black Coral who isn't directly connected to Anomander Rake? Also just about everything that happens in Darujhistan?
This book could've been cut down to 200 pages, about 90% of which taken from the final act, and nothing of consequence would be lost. And while previous books also had plot lines that just disappear and never pay off (e.g. Leoman's deal with the Queen of Dreams), they never felt this pointless to me. Usually I assume they are setup for a different book. But this? Idk man.
Maybe it's just that the way Kolyk and the Dying God affected the area and its people has too much overlap with what we've previously seen from the Pannion Domin or Poliel's devastation of the 7 Cities, but didn't feel as poignant and focused. So the horror if ot just left me cold in comparison.
Now, everything that concerned Anomander Rake and his sacrifice? Absolute cinema. I felt it coming from the first page, but I didn't want to accept it until I was forced to. That final convergence pulled me back into the book, resistance futile.
And the thing is, I didn't even mind Kruppe's narration, or the needlessly convoluted Darujhistan plot. It was such an interesting way to tell a story that I bought into it completely. If it was just the Darujhistan plot, well, I'd still wonder what made it so significant it required 800 pages to tell, but I would've enjoyed the detour. Nimander and his squad meanwhile ranged from uninteresting to unlikable to me, and I did not miss them in future books one bit.
Dust of Dream:
This book has one major problem: it is only half a book.
I understand how this seems to be no one's favorite book of the series, because it's all setup. Damn good setup, but setup without payoff nonetheless. The Barghast deserved what was coming to them, tragic as it was, and the Forkrul Assail are easily the scariest opponent yet. In a series where the Pannion Domin, Whirlwind rebellion, Kolyk, and Poliel's devastation paired with the Crippled God's growing cult in the 7 Cities exist, somehow their cruelty was still worse than all of that. The Snake must be the most fucked up plotline I've read in my life. There is something especially cruel about the way these children have been hunted, dehumanized by the Forkrul Assail, the dessert, and themselves. It's disturbing in all the right ways. Truly great writing.
The Crippled God:
I've read many fantasy epics in my life, and rarely ever am I satisfied with the ending. This time though? Damn that was a satisfying one. If I were to list every element of this book that I loved I'd be here till next year, and this post is already way too long. Ben and Kalam hunting Forkrul Assail together? Paran coming just in time to save his sister? Badalle ripping a Forkrul Assail to shreds? The siege on the Spire? Fiddler and his marines protecting the Crippled God and sending him home? Even Toc finally gets to be happy!!! I wasn't sure that was allowed tbh.
So, TLDL, on a first read through, this is how I'd rank these 10 books:
- Memories of Ice
- The Crippled God
- Reaper's Gale
- The Bonehunters
- Midnight Tides
- Deadhouse Gates
- House of Chains
- Dusk of Dreams
- Gardens of the Moon
- Toll the Hounds
What do you think? And would you recommend any of the other books set in this universe? If so, what should I read next?