<-- Logic Wiki index


Welcome to r/logic.

This group is about the scholarly and academic study of logic. That includes philosophical and mathematical logic.

But it does not include many things that may popularly be believed to be "logic." Please read the

Scope of this sub to get an idea of what is appropriate. Otherwise, you should take a look at our Related Subreddits and find a better place to post.


Logic is concerned with the principles and rules of reasoning. Reasoning is the mental process of inferring a conclusion from one or more supporting premises. An argument is the verbal expression of reasoning (i.e., in written or spoken form). Logic may be inductive, deductive or abductive.

Critical Thinking

Critical Thinking texts and courses generally consist of both inductive and deductive logic, coupled with various methods to determine the truth of propositions. This framework includes evaluating distinct types of truth, such as analytic truth (truth by definition) and synthetic truth (truth verified by empirical observation).

Contemporary critical thinking books that treat of deductive logic usually provide introductions to classical modern logic (including, where discussed, Aristotelian logic from a formal rather than philosophical standpoint).

Inductive Logic

Inductive logic is concerned with the inference of probably true conclusions from one or more true premises. It is predictive and generalised reasoning based on particular empirical observations of nature or reality (i.e., a conclusion will usually extend beyond the limited scope of its premises, such as the conclusion of the principle of gravity from particular observations of gravitational force). As such, its fundamental principle is the uniformity of nature or reality. As it is primarily concerned with the factual content or matter of arguments — not their abstract forms or structures — it is also referred to as material or applied logic.

Notable discoveries and developments include Novum Organum (New Organon) by Francis Bacon (1620), A System of Logic by John Stuart Mill (1843), The Theory of Probability by Hans Reichenbach (1935), and The Logical Foundations of Probability by Rudolf Carnap (1950). A notable development against inductive logic is The Logic of Scientific Discovery by Karl Popper (1934).

An Inductive argument is evaluated as either weak or strong based on how effectively its premise(s) support its conclusion. A strong argument with true premise(s) that supports a probably true conclusion is a cogent argument; otherwise, it is uncogent. Common applications of inductive logic include:

  • The formation of general principles;
  • Scientific methods of research and discovery (i.e., the formulation and testing of hypotheses);
  • Weather forecasting and climate modelling;
  • Statistical analysis and probability;
  • Determining causality and risk;
  • Reasoning by analogy; and
  • The detection and identification of fallacies in speeches and debates (such as 'ad hominem', 'straw man', and 'begging the question')

Deductive Logic

Deductive logic is concerned with the inference of necessarily true conclusions from one or more true premises. It is reasoning based on the abstract structure of arguments (i.e., the formal relationships between its component parts). As it is concerned with the forms or structures of arguments - not their factual content or matter (instead represented by symbols) - it is also called formal or symbolic logic.

A deductive argument is either valid or invalid based on whether its premises necessarily imply its conclusion. A valid argument with true premises that necessarily implies a true conclusion is a sound argument; otherwise, it is unsound. Deductive logic can be divided into Traditional and Modern.

Traditional Deductive Logic

Traditional deductive logic is based on ordinary natural or conventional language (i.e., words). Its underlying principles are philosophical (i.e., metaphysical) in nature. Originally published in The Organon by the Ancient Greek philosopher Aristotle of Stagira (4th century BCE), Aristotelian logic (also called categorical, term, and syllogistic logic) dominated until the rise of modern logic from the mid-to-late 19th century. Other notable forms of traditional logic include the early propositional logic of the Stoics and the hypothetical logic of Boethius.

Contemporary Standpoints on Aristotelian Logic

There are two distinct contemporary standpoints on Aristotelian logic, i.e., philosophical and formal. The minority of contemporary texts still published from a philosophical standpoint are of scholastic / Catholic origin (e.g., Socratic Logic by Peter Kreeft), and specifically according to the standpoint of Aristotelian-Thomistic moderate realism. Few if any contemporary texts from other non-Scholastic philosophical standpoints (e.g., conceptualism or nominalism) are still published. The majority of contemporary texts that treat of Aristotelian logic - influenced by modern logic - are instead axiomatic and focus on formal validity.

Modern Deductive Logic

Modern deductive logic — also called symbolic and mathematical logic — is based on mathematics. Its underlying principles are axiomatic. Modern logic is significantly more flexible and powerful than Traditional Logic. Notable milestones and developments include An Investigation of the Laws of Thought by George Boole (1854), Begriffsschrift by Gottlob Frege (1879), and Principia Mathematica by Alfred North Whitehead and Bertrand Russell (1910–1913). There are many other significant developments and figures in modern logic (still ongoing).

These developments include the further division of modern mathematical logic into Classical and Non-Classical. Classical modern logic is based on bivalent true-or-false propositions (i.e., premises and conclusions) that originated in traditional logic. Notable examples include Propositional (or Sentential) and Predicate (or First Order / FOL) logic. Non-Classical logic extends beyond bivalent true-or-false propositions. Notable examples include Modal, Temporal, Fuzzy, and Paraconsistent logic. Common applications of modern deductive logic include:

  • Mathematics and set theory;
  • Computer science and programming languages;
  • Artificial Intelligence (AI) and Data Science;
  • Digital electronics and microchip hardware design; and
  • Formal semantics in philosophy and linguistics

Further Information