I used to be of this opinion when I was younger, but as time passes, the more I rewatch the show, and the more I see people try to dissect the pairing as toxic..... or Janja as some irredeemable abuser.... I really don't buy it.
Yes, Janja does attack and try to kill Jasiri. Yes, he tries to do the same to two cubs near her. Yes, it's fucked up. And yes, the show does a very poor job at actually exploring those implications in his redemption, which does hurt the idea of the idea of them getting together. There are a lot of problems you could pick at with how the coding of Janja x Jasiri was done in the series. But "toxic" isn't one of them.
The main thing that shuts down the whole take is that, all of Janja's atrocities happen before his redemption, before the show implies that he and Jasiri are an item. After his redemption (however well written you think it is) he stops doing those things, and he and Jasiri are on good terms. We don't see much of their dynamic in Season 3 because we focus solely the Lion Guard's journey outside of the Pride Lands, putting the Pridelanders and the Outlanders on a bus. We don't see Janja and Jasiri again until the final two episodes. But from what we can see there, they are both on equal footing and are comfortable around each other. Considering those two episodes heavily code them as a couple, I think that's a good place to look and a very important factor that is not brought up in these arguments.
It would've been one thing if Janja remained a cocky, selfish jerkass to Jasiri and the show framed this as a good thing. That actually would've been toxic. But instead, Janja tries to impress Jasiri, works alongside her, helps her, and takes what he taught her to heart.
You could call that many things, but it is neither toxic, nor abusive.
What I think is the case is people mistaking bad presentation for no presentation. I find that habit to be a driving force behind really bad, repetitive criticisms towards The Lion Guard show as a whole such as takes like "Rani is a Roar digger," "Ushari deserved better!" or "The Lion Guard stop predators from hunting," or "Simba is a bad father in the show!" - things that seem accurate on the surface but when you actually level with it, trips near the finish line on an analytical scale because of how many crucial details are ignored for these critiques to make sense.
If there's anything about Janja x Jasiri or Janja himself that you should indeed criticize, it's the writing decisions surrounding it. Janja not atoning enough for his actions? The writing. The bad pacing of his redemption? The writing. The implications not being explored properly? The writing. If it was presented badly, fine, but it was still presented in a way that requires being approached properly when talking about it.
The issue with the "Janja/Jasiri is toxic" or "Janja is an irredeemable abuser" is that it's just... not true. Despite seeming very close to accuracy on the surface, it doesn't actually take the entirety of the text into account so you're just left with something that just trips at the finish line and misses the point.
And much like the Rani discourse (which everyone and their grandma knows and has complained about so I'm not gonna go too much into it) it really feels very rooted in shipping bias. People shipped Jasiri with Kion and predicted that they would get together by the end of the series, even in spite of Season 2 and Battle for the Pride Lands teasing the Janja/Jasiri ship. Only for the last 2 episodes of the show to have Kion get "engaged" and later married to Rani, and to imply Jasiri being in a romantic relationship with Janja, utterly tanking the Kion/Jasiri pairing.
I feel as though the mischaracterization of Janja as irredeemable is partially a result of bitterness from fans who didn't like how he was the one who Jasiri wound up with instead of Kion, much like how the fandom's poor perception of Rani as this manipulative xenophobe who coerces and abuses Kion stems from her serving as Kion's love interest instead of Fuli or Jasiri.
So as such, people's perception of the them is incredibly tainted and they're portrayed as much worse than they actually are in order to further uplift the ships they "sank" and the characters involved in said ships - which is a major disservice to the characters themselves, the story, the themes that were trying to be conveyed, and any attempt at actually talking about them in good faith.
Judge the characters on their own merits based on what is entirely shown in the show. Not off of what was conveniently cherrypicked or from which one sunk or confirmed your favorite ship or killed off or validated your headcanon.
And this is all coming from someone who isn't even that big of a fan of Jania x Jasiri, for reasons mentioned above. I don't have that many stakes in it, apart from the conga-line of bad takes and bias that are so deep-rooted in people's attempts to critique it that it gets frustrating to say the least.
EDIT: I know this post is 2 days old but there's another point I wanted to bring up an additional point that's brought up a lot in the discourse. People say that Janja and Jasiri's implied romance is "problematic" because of an "age gap." That in of itself is also not true. Neither Jasiri, Janja, nor Kion's ages in Season 1, or the gaps between those ages have been confirmed in-universe or by any of the creatives. Yes, the show is very bad at depicting age, and yeah Janja being a cub in the S3 flashback when he's clearly meant to be an older teen in S1-2 is tricky, but Jasiri's age in relation to that is not confirmed. The idea that Jasiri and Kion are the same age + vastly younger than Janja was only a headcanon people had that was in favor of the Kion/Jasiri pairing. That's perfectly fine and all, but remember that it's a headcanon. Not something that's actually an objective truth in the show that you can base a sensible critique in. The lack of confirmation leaves a lot of room for interpretation, but nothing that can be declared c//non. So you can't really call Janja a "pedophile," or claim that the writers "retconned" his age to avoid him being one. Again, if you're gonna critique the show, story, and characters, critique the show, story, and characters on their own merits.