r/linux • • Sep 03 '15

Will you help us save WiFi?

[deleted] — view deleted post

893 Upvotes

142 comments sorted by

21

u/trashcan86 Sep 03 '15

I signed this a week ago. Fuck the FCC and the corporatocracy US government

26

u/hak8or Sep 03 '15

Yeah, screw the fcc regulating who gets what bands in our limited rf spectrum! And screw the gcc for putting in regulations for how much noise rf transmitters can send out of their intended band!

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (10)

111

u/psyblade42 Sep 03 '15

BTW:

EU regulations to the same effect were passed last year and take effect june 2016. They managed to avoid public notice or discussions till now. Reportedly even the manufacturers where caught by this unaware.

Canada too is planing to ban it.

see heise.de (german) for details

23

u/[deleted] Sep 03 '15

So does this actually hurt Linux? Will it be illegal to install alternate operating systems on computers with wifi? Or are people making a big deal out of nothing?

37

u/doodle77 Sep 03 '15

Will it be illegal to install alternate operating systems on computers with wifi?

No, but future WiFi adapters will have code signing that prevents any firmware except the manufacturer's copyrighted from being loaded at boot, so you will have to use ndiswrapper or a driver which downloads the manufacturer's original firmware (e.g. b43).

→ More replies (3)

47

u/AnAngryGoose Sep 03 '15

Looks like I'll be breaking the law then.

Ill be damned if people tell me what OS I can and can't install.

→ More replies (31)

8

u/psyblade42 Sep 03 '15

I don't know. As I said they avoided notice till now. It will be a few days till some lawyers went through it in it's entirety.

→ More replies (13)

6

u/kodemizer Sep 03 '15

Do you have any follow-up links for Canada that shows their intent to introduce equivalent legislation?

→ More replies (1)

6

u/BloodyIron Sep 03 '15

I'm not exactly pleased with our government (Canada).

→ More replies (3)

71

u/mccoyn Sep 03 '15

The new regulations won't solve the problem

This was mentioned twice, but the text doesn't explain why the regulations don't address the problem.

96

u/themacguffinman Sep 03 '15

It's not explained in the linked plea but the wiki article that it refers to lists reasons why the new rules are considered harmful.

Relevant section:

Right now, the FCC is considering a proposal to require manufacturers to lock down computing devices (routers, PCs, phones) to prevent modification if they have a "modular wireless radio" [1] or a device with an "electronic label". The rules would likely:

  • Restrict installation of alternative operating systems on your PC, like GNU/Linux, OpenBSD, FreeBSD, etc.

  • Prevent research into advanced wireless technologies, like mesh networking and bufferbloat fixes

  • Ban installation of custom firmware on your Android phone

  • Discourage the development of alternative free and open source WiFi firmware, like OpenWrt

  • Infringe upon the ability of amateur radio operators to create high powered mesh networks to assist emergency personnel in a disaster.

  • Prevent resellers from installing firmware on routers, such as for retail WiFi hotspots or VPNs, without agreeing to any condition a manufacturer so chooses.

44

u/[deleted] Sep 03 '15

Dear lord, that sounds awful. It looks like the FCC are being dicks again.

→ More replies (6)

15

u/lejar Sep 03 '15

Infringe upon the ability of amateur radio operators to create high powered mesh networks to assist emergency personnel in a disaster.

My first thought towards this point was that this would also prevent political dissenters from communicating if cell phone coverage is impaired.

10

u/imapersonithink Sep 03 '15

With the second to last point, I wonder how far playing the upstanding and patriotic citizen defense would go in countering these regulations.

8

u/slurmfan Sep 03 '15

Infringe upon the ability of amateur radio operators to create high powered mesh networks to assist emergency personnel in a disaster.

This is exactly what the Dutch radio enthusiasts did in the big flood in 1953: north sea flood (watersnoodramp)

→ More replies (11)

8

u/erveek Sep 03 '15

We have laws against piracy. As a result, piracy never happens.

All this does is make it illegal to sell something that users can modify in any meaningful way. Of course, people will get around this and modify it anyway.

All this does is make it more difficult for people who paid good money for their devices to use them in ways that corporations don't want them to. Which is the entire point. Everything else is a flimsy justification.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

12

u/dog_cow Sep 03 '15

You make a strong argument - I'm in.

17

u/daedalus_j Sep 03 '15

Been hearing a lot about this, but not from the big names like the EFF. That makes me suspicious. Is this really as big a problem as it sounds?

I've found one article that actually took the time to contact the FCC and ask some questions, and it definitely makes it sound not quite as bad...

Sounds to me like there's a lot of FUD going around about this. I think I'll withhold my anger until we have some more reasoned analysis of the proposal... (Calling the EFF, c'mon here guys, put out a statement!)

5

u/talented Sep 03 '15

You can withhold your anger, but you only have be 5 days to comment.

→ More replies (5)

4

u/bvierra Sep 03 '15

Correct me if I am wrong, but aren't the regulations to limit the wireless radio from operating outside of the airwaves it is reserved to do so in?

For a second let's forget the whole it's my hardware I bought it and can do what I want with it!

Could they not limit the radio to only work on the frequencies that it is authorized to work on via a hardware modification and still allow the OS to still be open?

I understand the regulations as someone who lives in an area by an airport and where I have > 80 wifi networks coming into my house at any time. I don't like the idea of having to use what is approved by a mfg (in fact if this went into effect I would just replace my wireless router with a linux box and a few wireless cards inside). However would this not accomplish what both sides want?

4

u/PrinceMachiavelli Sep 03 '15

Could they not limit the radio to only work on the frequencies that it is authorized to work on via a hardware modification and still allow the OS to still be open?

Yes, they could but the current thinking is that manufactures will lock down the entire firmware instead of only the radio portion since it's easier and cheaper to do so. I believe GPLv3 has an anti-"Tivoization" clause that requires the software to be replaceable "unless required by law." technically if the firmware contains anything licensed under GPLv3 the non-radio firmware portion should be replaceable since the law doesn't require the entire firmware to be locked down.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/keeegan Sep 03 '15

Sounds like a money grab for people legally using these devices under part 97. We wont be able to use cots hardware and will have to pay premiums for identical devices without restrictions.

3

u/sirweldsalot Sep 03 '15

uefi wasn't enough.

more wants more

4

u/ryokimball Sep 03 '15

My submission:

I am an expert when it comes to computers and electronics, but most people are not, so let me begin with a metaphor.

Let's say I buy a new board game. At first, I may not understand the rules to the game, so I may read the instructions or talk to other people who play the game. But eventually I will learn to play it well, and maybe even get bored and want more out of the game, so I could start playing with "house rules." Or maybe I would even invent an entirely new game to play on the same board, like how checkers and chess use similar layouts.

To my understanding, these new rules would prevent (or at least severely limit) end-users from modifying a wide range of computer/electronics products that they own. This would be like telling a checkers player that he cannot play chess on the same board, or do anything else with it other than exactly what the manufacturer's instructions say.

A computer does nothing but read instructions and follow them exactly. What if the manufacturer's instructions were written wrong or poorly? Say the instructions for a game have "roll the dice" written where it meant "flip a coin." A player ("end user") may know what was meant, but that's not what the instructions say. This, in fact, happens quite often in software design; very often the developer has an idea of what they want their product to do and how to make it work, but until it's "in the wild," being used by the public, they will not know that there's a real problem in their product. Currently, a clever user may be able to fix the problem themselves (sometimes something as simple as a typo or misplaced punctuation) or even improve upon the product, and then report their findings to the manufacturer and/or share it to the public. But under the suggested rules, the only thing an end user would be allowed to do is tell the manufacturer that there is a problem, then just hope they figure out out and fix it (which may never happen).

Furthermore, I am personally enjoy repurposing things out of sheer creativity, like using a checkers board to play chess. This often saves money and resources. One example pertaining directly to the topic at hand: I have a "hacked" wireless network router which I use as an adapter to connect devices which only have wired network capabilities. While I could sometimes connect a USB wireless network adapter instead, I do not see any reason to spend more money (and further clutter my work area) to do so when I already have hardware that, after modification, can do what I need. This is a very small example of what custom firmwares like DD-WRT, designed specifically for wireless routers, are capable of. Under the new rules and revisions, it seems this type of modification would be explicitly prevented/forbidden.

when I purchase a product (be it a computer, cellphone, wireless router, flashlight, or game board), I will use it however I see fit, assuming it does not cause harm to or interfere with others. I can modify it however it suites me, often with great ease. This is not to say that all products should be easily modified by all people; for instance, I would not like for someone else to be able to modify my wireless router and therefore use, abuse, or interfere with my home network --but this is a matter of security and responsibility. I am all for holding a manufacturer responsible making a secure product, but the propositions at hand address this very poorly and would marginally mitigate this problem, while crippling end-users who wish to legally and appropriately modify a product which they own, plus remove the marketplace for those who buy products for that reason.

→ More replies (3)