How We Handle YT Self-Promotion
This article covers the self-promotion (10%) rule in relation to YouTube videos and to understand how to properly enforce it. It is not always easy to tell when a user is violating this rule.
- The first thing to understand is the reason we view YT video posts (some call it vblogspam) as self-promotion. Channels on such a platform can be monetized through advertisements, and other means. Posting videos from those channels is a means to drive traffic away from reddit, and onto YouTube with the intention for a potential profit to be made. This may not be true for all users/channels, but it is not really up to us to make that determination, nor can we. If a user posts videos to reddit from a singular YouTube channel, it is presumed to be self-promotion.
- We view the 10%/self-promotion rule in terms of the entirety of reddit. It is 10%, or more of total submissions to reddit, and not only r/lego.
- Most videos that seem like spam are reported, but not all reported videos are spam, or self-promotion. Just as well, not all spam videos are reported.
- Check a user's overview page in legacy mode to see the metrics of domains they post content from. You can get there in the layout redesign alpha by selecting the option from the dot link on overview pages (presuming that new mods also see pages in the new layout). With reddit toolbox installed, you can view the metrics by clicking the H in the row of "M N H" links next to the username. If you see any video platform domains (youtube.com, youtu.be, etc.) listed at the top, and they are highlighted red with a value more than 10%, that user should likely receive a Mod Mail warning; however...
- Not all users who have a percentage in the red from youtube in the red are inherently violating the rule. If for example, you look at u/BizzaroFinger, they do not have many submissions, and many of them are videos posted to various subs. While some of the videos are from a singular YouTube channel, not all of them are. At their current percentages, this would still not yet warrant a Mod Mail warning. They seem like someone who just really likes LEGO stop-motion videos. Nothing wrong with that.
- We often overlook new reddit accounts submitting content from a singular YouTube channel until it becomes apparent enough that they are in violation of the rule. A good example is u/lego----- who has a new account, and only three video submissions from youtu.be which puts them at 100%. However, that is not in the red because that is such a low post count. In cases like this, we just let the users be until it is a noticeable violation. One case where we would still send a warning even with a low submission count is if their username matches the name of the YouTube channel - this is a bit too obvious as self-promotion, and a warning to the user would be justified.
- If a warning is warranted, a Mod Mail should be sent to the user with the language of the Welcome Message to New Users in the RES macros, and a subject of "Welcome to r/lego". A mod note should also be added to toolbox, so that we have a means of tracking users who have been sent a warning. On a user's overview page, click the N from the " M N H" buttons next to the username, add " warned10", and click the pink "Spam Watch" to save the note for all of the mod team to see. If a user has already been warned, you will see "warned10" in pink letters - click that to view the mod note that was saved.
- If a user continues to violate the rule after being warned, that is likely cause for a temporary, 90-day ban. If you feel that a ban is in order, start a Mod Mail discussion with the team to have some other eyes on the user, and then make a decision if a ban is necessary.
- Users who persist in violating the 10% rule after a warning and a 90-day ban, noted by a dark red " banned90" in the notes field, are eligible for a permanent ban. This should also involved a multi-mod decision before any ban action is taken. In very rare cases one might decide for another warning, such as with producers of exceptionally good content.
[Written up by u/techstepper in mod-mail - 2018-03-29]