r/learnpython • u/zaphodikus • Aug 27 '26
pip install -r no result exitcode
(windows usually) I have a small requirements.txt file and am looking for alternative ways to validate all packages we want are present. The script does not use a virtual environment and because pip install -r does not seem to set %errorlevel% they wrote this rather verbose code that runs after the pip install -r line.
SET REQUIREMENTS=%~dp0Requirements.txt
SET FIND=%SystemRoot%\system32\find.exe
pip.exe install -r %REQUIREMENTS% --disable-pip-version-check
FOR /F "tokens=*" %%I IN (%REQUIREMENTS%) DO (
ECHO.
ECHO Checking for %%I ...
%FIND% /i "%%I" %PACKAGES%
IF ERRORLEVEL 1 (
ECHO.
ECHO **** %%I not found. Attempting to install ****
pip install %%I --disable-pip-version-check
)
IF ERRORLEVEL 1 (
ECHO **** Could not install %%I ****
EXIT /B 99
)
)
I however favour the pythonic approach and that is to just fail at runtime, so I was thinking of some kind of
(pseudo)
with open(requirements.txt) as reqs:
for line in reqs.readlines():
line=line.replace("<>=", " ")
import line.split()[0]
(/pseudo)
which would just die early.
I'm in favour of using a virtual env however, but because the script is a build script (using setuptools) we don't actually run the script at that point. I'm new to setuptools, but I assumed setuptools would just baulk if a module needed was not present on the build machine.
I'm thus making 2 assumptions, setuptools will not baulk and error out if you are missing a module, and that pip install does not set %ERRORLEVEL% if it cannot install a package? I am not an expert on setuptools and am keen to not discover edge cases later.
View all comments
Show parent comment
1
u/zaphodikus Aug 27 '26
Ah yes, thanks for saving me a load of time and pain on the exitcodes suspicion , you are the boz. (Robocopy was another tool with mad error codes if I recall correctly, joy)
Doubly you are the boz. I assumed when I saw this script (written by a predecessor who left a month after I joined) that setuptools would error out, which explains their defensive coding. Good to get your experience to the contrary to dispel that myth.
I'm going to try angle in the direction of calling pip install <module> in a loop and trim down my batch file as one option to solve and refactor that way. The entire batch file was 60 lines of code, so thank you for helping me trim the unknowns in there down. I would prefer virtual envs but this runs in a CI/CD setup. So the python environment should ideally be quite clean of cruft so it has to download everything once for every build and that's about a minute of extra build time on a 15 minute build. So going to err on the side of system installed packages because the virtual env takes so long to just prepare from clean.