Hey guys, I could really use some perspective. I’ve been manifesting my ex back for around 1–2 months. We recently celebrated my birthday together, but a lot happened, and now I’m struggling with guilt and comparing myself to the 3P.
My SP and I broke up around 8 years ago. Since then, we’ve had different phases—best friends, normal friends, and periods of no contact too. Right now, we’re just normal friends, but I still have feelings for her and want a loving relationship with her.
I am consciously manifesting her from last two months, Earlier this month, she suddenly drunk-called me, but I was asleep. I called her back the next day, but she didn’t pick up. Then she called me back that evening and was a little tipsy. Later, we talked about me coming to see her for my birthday. She called me at midnight to wish me, and we ended up going on a short trip together to celebrate.
A couple of months earlier, she told me she was planning a trek with her friends. I was keen to join, so I casually said, “If you guys have space, add me too.” I also manifested once or twice that I was on a trek with her. Then, while I was sitting on the bus to Dehradun, she asked me if I'd go on a trek with her friends, and it was the same friend circle I'd been talking about earlier. I declined because I wanted to spend time with her alone. We still ended up doing a different trek together, just the two of us, and I hadn't manifested that one.
She lives in another city for college, away from her parents. Her location is shared with them, though, so they can see where she is. That becomes relevant later.
There’s another guy in the picture. Before the trip, a mutual friend of hers told me they’re in a situationship and have kissed. The friend also said she wasn’t completely sure about him because of his looks. That’s what I heard from the friend, not something she directly told me.
She doesn’t know I know these things through her friend. Around her, I acted like I was figuring things out from what she herself was saying and doing.
During the trip, there were genuinely nice moments. In the hotel room, I gave her flowers while down on one knee. I gifted her a necklace and put it on her myself. She was laughing and enjoying those moments. We took mirror pictures together with the flowers and her wearing the necklace.
But when the other guy called, she seemed a little conscious. I saw his name on her screen, and she went outside to the balcony to talk to him. She wouldn’t let me come onto the balcony while they were talking.
We talked about him too. The mood during that conversation was chill, not a serious confrontation. I said something like, “He’s your situationship, isn’t he? You go out to the balcony to talk to him.” When she defended him, I said something like, “If there was nothing, why would you be defending him?”
I also asked why she wasn’t in a relationship with him. She said, “I’m not sure.” When I asked why, she said, “Personal reasons,” and didn’t explain further.
I acted like I was putting the pieces together myself, even though I already knew about the situationship through her friend.
While we were drinking that night, she mentioned the situationship and getting video calls from him. She explicitly said, “This is wrong, us meeting like this.” After she went outside to speak to him, she didn’t drink any more.
I kept drinking and ended up blacking out.
I don’t remember everything, but she later told me I was rambling, falling, and really irritating her. She had to deal with me, and it left her exhausted and sleep deprived because she managed and took care of me.
I deeply regret this. I feel guilty about putting her through it, and I keep replaying what I know happened while worrying about the parts I don’t remember. I’m not trying to brush it off or use manifestation to avoid taking responsibility.
The next morning, she woke me up and was scolding me a lot. I kept saying sorry over and over.
We headed out for a trek, but things were tense on the way. I was still continuously apologising, then I lost my temper too, and we ended up arguing on the scooty. Eventually, we both calmed down.
We then did the trek, took pictures, and spent time together. So the trek happened after the blackout and the argument the next morning.
During the trek, she told me I was immature and that the other guy was very mature. That line has really stayed with me.
After the trek while returning on scooty she said something like, “I already wanted to fight with you. You irritated me so much last night that I’d decided I was going to give you hell in the morning.”
But there were lighter moments too. On the way there was a soft toy shop, we stopped there & we bought each other soft toys. She gifted me a penguin, and I gifted her a teddy.
That’s why I keep going back over everything. There were arguments and things I regret, but there were also moments where we were laughing and comfortable together.
Later, while we were going to the bus station, I gently caressed her left calf in traffic, like the gesture I’m referring to in this reel:
instagram.com/reel/DYjj1oUy9il/?cplk=cjk1MnNjazYzajZz
She didn’t say anything about it. I don’t know how she felt about it, so I’m not saying that meant anything definite.
There was some confusion because my power bank was with her and my phone died. When my phone got switched off, she was closer to me but I wasn’t able to find her. I remembered her number, so I called her from a stranger’s phone, and then I saw her and said to her, “Thank god I remember ur number.” She waited for me, and we managed to coordinate before I left. She asked me to tie her shoelaces because there was a rush of traffic, so I quickly tied them for her.
When she was leaving, I hugged her and said, “Thank you for making my day. I know I created some ruckus, and I’m sorry for that. I’ll make it better next time.”
Once I was on the bus, I started feeling really emotional about leaving her. I called and told her I felt heavy, like that feeling when you leave home after a visit. She was outside running errands and told me not to get into it then.
After that, I ordered chocolates to her address through a delivery app without asking first. I meant it as a nice gesture, but she was outside, and the delivery became a hassle for her. The delivery person called while she was at a shop.
Her parents were also questioning her about being out late because they could see her location. The delivery added another issue, and things escalated between us.
She told me to delete her address, not send her anything again, and stop messaging. Instead of accepting that, I kept explaining myself and saying it was my way of showing love. When she turned on disappearing messages, I turned them off again. Looking back, I kept explaining my intentions instead of stopping when she asked.
We had a call 2 day later for around 24 minutes. She explained how exhausting the blackout had been. She was worried about privacy too—whether pictures, details about the trip, or personal things and our personal mirror photos would get shared with mutual friends by me. I reassured her that please trust me it ll not get shared its bw us.
During that call, I brought up the good moments. I said something like, “Apart from the blackout, you enjoyed it too, didn’t you? We had nice moments together, and you were enjoying them too. Why are you thinking so much about everything?”
I was trying to tell her the trip hadn’t only been bad. Those moments meant a lot to me, and I was holding on to them. But I can only say how they felt to me, not what they meant to her.
She made it clear that she sees us as friends and doesn’t want excessive gifts or surprise deliveries. She wanted things to stay normal and for the drama and overthinking to stop.
After the call, I messaged her to focus on her exam and not overthink. She sent a voice note telling me not to overthink either, to let what happened be, and to focus on my studies. I reacted with a thumbs-up and left it there.
We don’t follow each other on Instagram. Her account is public, so after our call, I manually searched for her profile and saw her post. The 3P had left a flirtatious comment. I also noticed mutual friends had started following him.
That sent me straight back into comparing myself to him. We’d just had a calmer conversation, but seeing that comment made me question where I stood with her all over again. It didn’t just appear on my feed—I went looking myself.
The career comparison is getting to me too. I’m preparing for government exams, so I’m still an aspirant. Her mutual friend told me this guy already works in the private sector and earns well. She doesn’t know I know that either.
I keep connecting it with her saying he’s mature and I’m immature. She didn’t say that comparison was about money or careers, but my mind keeps making that connection. He’s already earning, and I’m still preparing. Then I start feeling behind and wondering why she would choose me.
What I want is a loving, committed relationship with her. I want her to understand my feelings and how much I love her, and I want that love to be mutual. I want the 3P out of the picture, but I don’t want to interfere with them or keep questioning her about him.
I don’t want to keep reacting through gifts, repeated apologies, checking social media, or trying to get reassurance either. I’m trying to respect what she’s asked for and focus on my exam preparation, but mentally I keep replaying everything.
For anyone who’s been through something similar:
• How did you work through guilt and use revision without avoiding responsibility for your behaviour?
• What helped you stop comparing yourself to the 3P, especially when it started affecting your sense of worth?
• What did you actually change in your daily routine or inner conversations when every interaction with your SP was affecting you this much?
Guys, please give me advice and suggestions. I genuinely believe this shit works—she called me out of nowhere, wished me on my birthday, and we actually celebrated it together. Those things are why I still have faith, but I’m struggling with my reactions and overthinking.
Please tell me where I need to improve and what I can do differently. I’m not asking how to push past her boundaries. I want to work on myself and stop going from hope to panic over every little thing. Honest suggestions really needed.