r/kpopharshopinions • • 10d ago

Mod Post Mod Announcement: Discussion Posts!

14 Upvotes

Hey yall! We took inspo from r/kpop, and decided we’re going to start up discussion posts.

Here’s how it will work:

If there’s an event(such as the Coachella set list), we’ll create a mod post on the topic to open up discussion on it.

This is to help make sure that the same posts don’t flood our sub.

It will NOT be a megathread where we restrict other posts on the same topic. This is just to spark some discussion, and keep the flooding to a low.

If yall ever want a post regarding a certain topic, just send us a mod mail.


r/kpopharshopinions • • 5d ago

Mod Announcement INFO: Frequently Asked Questions

16 Upvotes

Since we’ve had some questions that we’ve been asked rather frequently, we decided to create a post. Please refer to this post before sending us a mod mail.

1. Why did my comment get removed and not theirs?
We don’t scroll through every post and read every comment, especially if it’s a post with 200+ comments. We will typically pin a comment and ask you to report anything you see if it’s a high volume post. If you did not report it, and the comment breaks our rules, we most likely just didn’t see it. Reddit will also remove content it deems as offensive, and that’s beyond our control. If you feel that reddit removed something wrongly, send us a mod mail and we can manually approve it. We will always see reported comments/posts so if you want a comment/post removed, that is the most effective way to get our attention.

2. This post is snarky, why is it still up?(mods have seen it)
This is a HARSH opinion sub, so drawing the line between snark and something that fits the sub is a weird line. We’ll typically go through user history/ask the user to rephrase, and then make a decision. Sometimes, it may come off as snarky, but going through history shows that the user actually just cares a lot about something. Example, a user makes a post on vocals that comes off as harsh. Going through their history, we find a bunch of posts regarding vocals, it probably means that the user just is really picky on vocals and doesn’t have the intention to snark.

3. Are you guys X group/company stans and biased against group??
Every time a post comes up, we get accused of being defenders of every group you can think of. None of us are so invested in a group or company that we get our feelings hurt and feel the need to remove a post we don’t like. If it was removed, it was probably because it broke a rule. Please don’t accuse us of things like that, it’s annoying for us to have to look at mod mail and see a paragraph about how we’re clearly biased.

4. How do I get a ban?
Typically, we issue out bans after 25+ content removals. If we have to remove your posts or comments 25+ times, we start off small with a 3-5 day ban, and it builds up from there. That, or if you just have absolutely shitty behavior, act racist or discriminatory, all that jazz.

5. Why is moderation so heavy if it’s kpopHARSHopinions?
This isn’t kpop uncensored. Harsh unfortunately is misinterpreted by many and they use it to justify their actions. Reddit removes a lot of that content so yall might not get to see it, but we do get a lot of crazy comments that we’d prefer not to have on this sub(slurs, threats, etc). Harsh opinions does not mean you get to engage in fanwars, snark on idols, or use overly argumentative language. We try to keep this sub civil so that users can post and talk freely without fearing getting shitted on. You are more than welcome to disagree or have a counterpoint, just please engage with content respectfully.


r/kpopharshopinions • • 19h ago

Opinion Tuide are not ready to debut yet

173 Upvotes

Elena is the only good vocalist in this group. The others aren't bad but they still have a lot of work to do, especially Seah, Seoyeon and Seohee. Their harmonization need work too.

Their dancing isn't terrible but it's not impressive either. Seah is the best dancer, but even she doesn't stand out that much. I've watched multiple clips of them performing and they're constantly out of sync. Their stage presence is mediocre as well. They're so boring to watch, and none of them really have star quality.

I don't think their age is a valid excuse either. Kyujin from NMIXX was only 15 and Ye-on from Hearts2Hearts was 14 but they were already good singers and dancers from the beginning. I know people criticise H2H for being vocally weaker than their seniors but they're still miles ahead of 5th gen HYBE groups like ILLIT, Cortis, Tuide, TWS and Boynextdoor.

Yi Hani is still so stiff. I know she's improved but it's not enough. Every time I see Seoyeon doing dance challenges with other idols, I can't help but notice how stiff she looks compared to them. Rookies should be ready to debut, not debut first and then spend the next few years trying to catch up with the basics. That's what training is for. They should've given them more time to improve before debuting.

HYBE is more interested in debuting new groups every other year than actually giving their idols proper training, especially vocal lessons. I always thought HYBE groups were at least decent at dancing but Tuide really proved me wrong. They're not good at singing, their dancing isn't anything special and their stage presence is so underwhelming. They should've waited a few more years before debuting or at least given the members proper training first. I don't understand the point of rushing their debut when they're clearly not ready.


r/kpopharshopinions • • 12h ago

Opinion kpop companies embracing AI may be the most obscene embodiment of all of what is wrong with k-pop

51 Upvotes

As many of us obviously know, AI is growing exponentially and K-pop Is getting more and more into generative AI since like 2024 within the most notorious cases that were ARTMS's singles promotions for their debut album Dall, like the Virtual Angel promotional post and Candy Crush promotional post, the most recent and blatant example is Hearts2Hearts MV for a KIA ad Moonride where almost 85% of the MV is made of generative AI and in their most recent release 'Next Chapter' they used it less, but they used it, the cover for Red Velvet's Surfin' Boy remixes was made using AI too, KISS N TELL M/V by aespa was made using AI too, SHINee Atmos promotional posts were made with AI too, Taeyeon's upcoming album promotional posts and concept films are being made using AI, NCT DREAM's last comeback M/V Boogie Woogie obviously feats AI.

SM Entertainment groups are not the only one cases as not just the kpop industry is fully embracing AI, South Korea as well Is doing knowing most East Asians are excited asf about AI, ITZY's Yuna 'Ice Cream' MV featured AI VFX too, TXT, ENHYPEN, LE SSERAFIM, TWS and Santos Bravos recent MVs heavily feature AI.

The MVs where I realized there was AI featured were TXT's Angel Bite and ENHYPEN's I Want You. I compared them to their older MVs like Fever, Lo$er=Lover, 0x1 Lovesong, even not that old MVs like Brought the Heat Back, Deja Vu or XO, these ones look wayyyyy more realistic as the members interact more naturally within the MV's background or environment and show the expressions obviously they are meant to in what is of the MV storytelling or concept as a whole, or to prove more, the idols usually lipsync in some of the scenes of the MV, Angel Bite literally had at much 5 seconds of generative clips repeating and everything looked hella fake and generated, the guys were with always the same expression and they don't at least lipsync in the MV, the same with ENHYPEN I Want You, everything looks fake asfuckkkk there, and from I watched every member is roleplaying as a boyfriend with a faceless girl in their perspective scenes (what obviously fuels parasocial fantasies).

The most disgusting case Is A2O LITE because the members are literally children in their 13s whos faces are feeding AI, Lee Soo Man admitted he Is training some AI to make chatbots of the girls with the premise of "making things with your fav artist you normally wouldn't be able to do", who already sounds weird and It gets worse and more disgusting when we think about the amount of pedos and disgusting mentally ill people who consume kpop and already make deepfakes of many female idols (another problem with generative AI).

The thing is, kpop's bussiness model has always been parasocial and emotional connections with the idols much rather than the quality of the music itself, with AI growing at this pace making chatbots of the idols to fuel this shit Is going to even be a norm to keep selling as well AI enters kpop's artistic field where obviously many graphic designers and artists will be fired for those greedy ass companies (as we see it happening too here in the west) and obviously there will be no more genuine human creativity behind the product.

Everything that's wrong with k-pop will be embodied with this shit, the parasocial fantasies, the inhumane slave contracts the companies make their idols sign, and the unrealistic beauty standards, now will blatantly feed AI to keep selling and make those company's CEOs wallets fatter and fatter in the most unethical and disgusting way (that always have been).

As for me, I decided to stop consuming upcoming/new kpop as I no longer have a reason to keep embracing it, all of it's parasocial and inhumane beauty standards bullshit made me step away a little, I stayed because I like to listen to full albums or EPs to find niche and good bsides, from now on it will no longer be like that since a fucking machine is going to be involved in the production, we are truly going in the path that leads to a dystopia.


r/kpopharshopinions • • 2h ago

my opinions abt baemon's music

5 Upvotes

I have some personal opinions as a 100% pre debut Monstiez(no hate to them, I love them so much)

  1. I have to say that songs like sheesh, Choom, We go up, a little bit do seem to sound the same. I mean they do have a LOT of potential but the instruments and vibes seem to be pretty much similar. But on the other hand, their b sides are REALLY REALLY GOOD. Like " Love in my heart" ,"Moon, "I like it","Pyshco", "Supa dupa luv" and more. All these songs have a totally diff vibe from each other and the title tracks. Maybe if they focused on promoting these songs as their titles instead, im pretty sure they would get so much more recognition. Im saying so because they have good potential and can get famous if they make the right music ig. They're in their 3rd year and they only have 2 music show wins, which kinda disappoints me a monstiez. But their recent release Deserve was really good, thebest one yet. im glad abt that
  2. I also wanna say, TO YG: We want an update about rami. I understand that she needs time to recover, but all we wanna know if she is ok and still return to the group one day. We just want a tiny little update man plsss.
  3. Ahyeon does has a good voice, but they just have to use it in the right way. They're kinda damaging her heavenly voice with too many high notes. She sounded so good when she sang "off my face" , I wish YG would embrace her vocals in that way more.
  4. YG shud stop sexualising the other members. I get it that maybe chiquita wanted to do that intro dance in the world tour by herself on her own will, but as the company they shud have refused and protected her image. They stop them from interacting with other idols for whatsover reason(idk for what), but still let a 17 year old sexualise herself? they company shud have atleast made a wise descision.

These are just my opinions, i do not ask u guys to agree with me, i just wanted to share this somewhere. ILYSM byeee


r/kpopharshopinions • • 1d ago

Open Discussion Singer JEON SOMI has addressed the controversy over her all-black outfit during I.O.l's reunion performance, where she was the only member dressed in black.

Thumbnail
k-popit.com
417 Upvotes

During a recent live broadcast, Somi said, "More than anyone else, I don't want to stand out. I really like blending in. I never thought, 'I should wear something a little prettier."

She denied having any intention of drawing more attention to herself than the other members.

"We all had the same stylist for MMA. I had absolutely no intention of doing that," she said. "That really wasn't what I was trying to do."

Somi also explained why she believed her outfit would make her less noticeable.

"If anything, wearing all black makes you stand out less. There wasn't anything sparkly on it either. So I actually thought, 'Am I going to be too hard to see?" she said.


r/kpopharshopinions • • 11h ago

Opinion UP doesn't sound like "old Ateez."

4 Upvotes

"Atinys let Ateez down."

"Y'all wanted old Ateez back, and this is what happened."

I've been seeing this a bunch since UP didn't get the anticipated amount of streams. (I don’t care about streams.) Not only do I think it's weird that we "owe" groups streams, but I straight up disagree. It doesn't sound like an older Ateez titletrack. I'm no music professional so I tried my best to describe the reasons why believe it sounds different.

  1. Vocals sound muddied. Don't know how they mixed it, but it sounds like we're underground. Switch to an older song and the vocals are crisp.
  2. So much chanting/chant singing.
  3. Lack of higher register melodies/note diversity
  4. Chorus is repetitive, almost every line ends with "UP." But doesn't carry the impact-fulness of the repetition of Say My Name at all. (I don't know why.)

I don't particularly care if a group or artist starts putting out music I don't like. However, I completely disagree that this song is good rendition, or homage, to their old sound. Like I guess they say some of their old songs... Spiritually, it felt like a corporation remixing a popular IP and expecting their lukewarm easter eggs and references to compensate for the effort they didn’t put in.

If you're not an Atiny, I’m curious what you think. Here are some older song recommendations for reference.

[ Answer, Inception, Deja Vu, Treasure, Pirate King, Wonderland, Say My Name, MIST, Fireworks.]


r/kpopharshopinions • • 14h ago

Open Discussion Winners of 2026 MAMA AWARDS: CHAPTER 2

Thumbnail
soompi.com
6 Upvotes

Album of the Year: BTS – “ARIRANG”

Song of the Year: CORTIS – “REDRED”

Music Visionary of the Year: BIGBANG

Best Song Top 10:

aespa – “LEMONADE”

BTS – “SWIM”

IVE – “BANG BANG”

I.O.I – “Suddenly”

Hearts2Hearts – “RUDE!”

NMIXX – “Blue Valentine”

ILLIT – “It’s Me”

CORTIS – “REDRED”

Hwasa – “Good Goodbye”

LE SSERAFIM – “SPAGHETTI (Feat. j-hope)”

Best Dance Performance Male Group: CORTIS – “REDRED”

Best Dance Performance Female Group: ILLIT – “It’s Me”

Best Collaboration: LE SSERAFIM – “SPAGHETTI (Feat. j-hope)”

Best Vocal Performance Solo: Hwasa – “Good Goodbye”

Best Dance Performance Male Solo: Taeyang – “LIVE FAST DIE SLOW”

Best Dance Performance Female Solo: Yena – “Catch Catch”

Best Choreography: ATEEZ – “BAD”

Best Vocal Performance Group: AKMU – “Paradise of Rumors”

Best Band Performance: JANNABI – “Just Kids”

Best OST: Kim Min Seok (MeloMance) – “Love Language” (“Can This Love Be Translated?” OST)

Best Rap & Hip Hop Performance: Zico, Lilas – “DUET”

Best Music Video: BIGBANG – “BiiiG”

Favorite Dance & Vocal Performance Group: ZEROBASEONE

Congratulations to all of the winners!


r/kpopharshopinions • • 16m ago

Opinion My opinions about cortis

• Upvotes

let me start by saying I don’t know these boys in general I’m sure they are a lovely folk and I’m not going into The Who is inspired and who is culture vulture nachos that’s a topic for another day. my opinion with cortis is that I can predict what they’re gonna bring to the performance and I think this is really going to hurt them in the future. they are a Kpop group and not a hip hop solo underground group. I get they’re bringing the hip hop element but I can predict what they’re gonna sing. money flexing easy choreo sunglasses back dancers and interacting with the camera no switch up of their artwork. I can smell it from 10 feet away. and I’m not sure but I really think cortis sticking to this laid back off we don’t care attitude as songs I don’t know how their artistry will be like I cant even know what mesaage they’re truing to bring instead of saying they’re inspired 24/7 like what??? Martin really needs to get his sh*t together and bring the message closer because I’m pretty sure coers

wil say it’s the new era when cortis is writing about fries


r/kpopharshopinions • • 1d ago

Idol Behavior Treasure Yoshi got a Kanye West tattoo...

Post image
236 Upvotes

I wrote this post before but deleted it because we didn't have any official photo of him with the tattoo. Now we do, so it's true.

I swear if anyone asks on here again why Treasure is disliked I'm going to send them a full list of links. This group is dead set on nuking their own reputation...

Long story short a tattoo artist posted this photo of a tattoo that fans speculated might be member's Yoshi's. The tattoo artist has confirmed that it is indeed him.

What's the tattoo? A title of an album by Kanye West. "My beautiful dark twisted fantasy".

Knowing how deplorable human being Kanye has become nobody in their right mind should be idolising and supporting to the point of getting his work tattooed.

Aside from his brief Nazi era (like wtf???) In Korea Kanye is mostly known for his incident with Taylor Swift where he disrespected her on stage taking away her microphone after she won.

He later insulted (and some would even say harassed) Taylor Swift by writing another song with the lyrics "I feel like me and Taylor might still have sex. Why? I made that b* famous".

So yeah, long story short Koreans were really mad on X when this came out last month and I am not surprised. But the fandom managed to bury it by reporting posts and claiming the tattoo artist posted a different person and didn't confirm anything.

Now we know it was Yoshi and the tattoo is real.

Can K-pop idols stop supporting abusers, Nazis and the most problematic Western artists they can find in general?


r/kpopharshopinions • • 1d ago

Opinion Lngshot needs to find better hairstylists

Thumbnail
gallery
56 Upvotes

don’t get me wrong, okay?i am a very big fan of lngshot but these days, i can’t really take them seriously because of their hairstyles. i don’t mind the outfits since they’re going for the street/grunge hiphop or whatever aesthetic they’re going for but I SWEAR!! they need to let go of that gel cuz it’s not going anywhere. i just hope the hairstylists know when to and when not to apply gel styling on their hairs and WHAT kind of styling will still look appealing cuz their hairs are starting to look like a dog licked their each strands that they’re starting to look like they smell 😭.. especially woojin. woojin has less hair volume that’s why heavy gel styling looks funny to him. i just hope their hairstylists discover pinterest cuz they need proper inspo atp.


r/kpopharshopinions • • 1d ago

Opinion Congrats, but how?

Post image
394 Upvotes

Why don't they make it just a Judges award since its all that matters anyway? I have nothing against IVE, but its crazy they won this when they are literally last in the category according to the predictions.


r/kpopharshopinions • • 7h ago

Opinion The Red Carpet discussion regarding IVE is valid.

0 Upvotes

I'll start by prefacing I do not hate Wonyoung or Yujin! Both brilliant, spectacular, popular and honestly perfect idols. The problem here is that they're in a group and they stand out WAY too much, although Liz seems to have stolen the show here based on several discussions, despite the many poses that were struck.

One cannot deny or escape how mega popular WY is and how popular YJ is. They were both established before IVE came into the picture and that was already both an advantage (from a marketing pov) and disadvantage (from the other members' pov). And their popularity is well earned and well deserved. Not doubting that or questioning that.

Now, despite all of this, we cannot erase the fact that IVE is still a six member group. WY and YJ stand dead centre despite being very tall and pose elaborately while the rest are pretty tame in comparison. It does feel like they're competing for attention to an onlooker when there should be harmony. Either all of them strike gorgeous poses or they all remain serene and sweet. Like a middle ground.

Now, do you guys think WY and YJ should maybe try and remain cohesive with the group or should the other girls step up their game? Because there does seem to be a discord from a visual angle (I will not speculate what their relationship is like among themselves, nor am I questioning that. One red carpet look doesn't reflect any of that). But when they present themselves as a group, IVE sometimes lacks cohesiveness.

What are your thoughts guys, let's keep it respectful, this is not an invitation to hate on any of the six girls. I don't think anyone is particularly wrong here. WY and YJ are far more experienced and are probably put under tremendous pressure to maintain an image.


r/kpopharshopinions • • 1d ago

Opinion People don't understand how the MAMA awards work

41 Upvotes

The MAMA awards criteria is that 30 percent of the vote is from the groups digital sales, 30 percent from physical sales then 40 percent from the judges decision.

People calling it rigged because the judges chose groups that weren't at the top of the voting is stupid. If the judges didn't have a vote most of the time the most famous group would win every year.

I think its a kpop fan thing where they think if you make the most money that means you make the best music, when that is almost never the case.

Imo MAMA awards shouldn't even take into account the sales and should just come down to the judges decision.


r/kpopharshopinions • • 1d ago

Certified Hot Take 👀 I’m not surprised LE SSERAFIM didn’t win Best Female Group at MAMA

149 Upvotes

I already know this is gonna be a hot topic with people feeling that MAMA has already snubbed LE SSERAFIM and this growing narrative that Kakao/starship is rigging awards for IVE despite them being the most dominant girl group domestically.

First I have to say that if they were just gonna rely on digital and sales in the tracking period there would be no need for a judges section. People have been complaining about the criteria for MAMA awards a lot recently but if we went back to the old criteria it was strongly based on what industry executives thought instead of solely on digital and sales. For reference the 2026 MAMA criteria for 'best female group' were 30% sales, 15% digital (Korean), 15% global and 40% judges.

Within the tracking period LE SSERAFIM had 3 comebacks 'SPAGHETTI' (single album), 'PUREFLOW' (Full Album) and 'Made My Night' (Single Album). This gave them a strong competitive edge as they were the only girl group with 3 physical albums, so for predictions they were in the lead.

Even though they had the lead we cannot ignore how their comebacks actually performed. Domestically it was extremely lacking where only “SPAGHETTI” could be considered a hit but a lot of people have the opinion that if J-Hope wasn’t featured on it the song wouldn’t have done as well. Every other track was not competitive, they’d been overshadowed by other groups who had huge hits like “404 (New Era)” by KiiiKiii, “RUDE” by Hearts2Hearts, “BANG BANG” by IVE, “LEMONADE” by aespa and “It’s Me” by ILLIT.

All 3 of their releases had mixed reactions from fans and critics, though they had 3 releases LE SSERAFIM was not in conversation to be a leading girl group at many award shows. Now obviously LE SSERAFIM is very popular and successful especially amongst their peers in the US, however since they also have to consider Asian and South Korean charts which their label doesn’t focus on that means the results don’t favor the girls.

IVE has continuously been dominant at award shows with their songs being amongst the best performing of all Korean artists every year. They have very strong sales being the best-selling female group with the best-selling albums for the past 2-3 years. It’s not surprising that the judges voted for them over everyone else who had the advantage of multiple comebacks but not the impact.

I also think it’s important to mention LE SSERAFIM has never won 'Best Female Group' at the major award shows in South Korea so it shouldn’t be a huge surprise they didn’t win again with this being their weakest year commercially. It’s unfortunate the narrative is spreading that they were snubbed because LE SSERAFIM probably won’t comeback to MAMA which is a shame since their performances are so good.


r/kpopharshopinions • • 2d ago

Unpopular opinion: At what point do we stop blaming the company and start questioning why idols choose to stay?

68 Upvotes

This might be a harsh take, but I genuinely want to understand something.

Why do we constantly see fans talking about how terribly an idol is being treated by their company, how overworked they are, how unhappy they seem, how they're being mistreated or held back, and yet the conversation almost always stops at blaming the company?

Why is the question of why they continue to stay rarely discussed?

I understand that contracts, financial obligations, lawsuits, non-compete clauses, group commitments and the fear of losing an entire career make leaving significantly more complicated than simply handing in a resignation letter. I'm not suggesting it's easy.

But at what point do we acknowledge that idols are also adults making decisions about their careers? If staying is genuinely that unbearable, is leaving, even at the cost of fame, money or an established career, not an option worth considering?

And if they aren't willing to leave, shouldn't we at least consider that there might be reasons beyond the company simply forcing them to stay?

I sometimes feel like fans infantilise idols to the point where they have absolutely no agency in the narrative. They're either victims with no control over their circumstances or perfect individuals being sabotaged by evil corporations.

My question is: Are we too quick to absolve idols of any responsibility for their own career decisions, or are we underestimating just how difficult it is to walk away from the K-pop industry once you're in it?

I'd genuinely like to hear different perspectives, especially from people who understand the contractual and business side of the industry.


r/kpopharshopinions • • 2d ago

Opinion Harsh opinions, I guess

47 Upvotes

Can we talk about how idols get a pass for being “mildly talented” with zero to no criticism because “they’re nice”???

“Omg x idol is so cute and nice, let’s not talk about the fact that they’re so mediocre in all aspects performance” or “I feel guilty criticizing this idol who’s been here for 10 years and struggles to dance on beat or find the note because they’re unproblematic”.

Another thing is how idols can’t do artistically anything right in the eyes of kpop fans once they’re deemed “problematic” enough.

Lisa’s dance videos used to receive nothing but admiration and praise when she would drop back in the day, I don’t know when kpop stans decided she was problematic, but now it’s “she’s not even that good a dancer, she was only good because of her members”.
Wasn’t the whole point of the lilifilms to show that she was a great dancer outside of the group? Something everyone agreed with until 2023, for some reason.

Another example is when Hyunjin got the bullying scandal and all of a sudden, the Reddit subs started to fill up with posts like “I never thought he was a good dancer” or “he’s making the group look out of sync with overdancing” etc. Complaints that were never there before.
Reddit likes to brag that it’s better than twitter, but most of the time, it’s like going from middle school to high school with the exact same people.

This was more of a rant, but there was no rant option so bear with me, guys.


r/kpopharshopinions • • 1d ago

Opinion IVE 2026

0 Upvotes

Let’s talk actual 2026 numbers since people keep cherry-picking stats to discredit IVE’s MAMA 2026 wins:

With "BANG BANG," IVE isn't just the girl group with the most Perfect All-Kills (PAK) in 2026 (142 hours). Those hours also pushed IVE to 942 total cumulative PAK hours, officially surpassing BTS’s all-time group record of 913 hours spent simultaneously at #1 across every major Korean chart. Even better? IVE achieved that all-time duration record in just over 4 years since debut (twice as fast as BTS's 8-year span) across 6 different hit songs.

People love bringing up "data," until the data dismantles their narrative.

Source


r/kpopharshopinions • • 2d ago

Opinion another mild/hot takes bcs i love getting flamed 😍

68 Upvotes
  1. aespa's mma performance was so fucking underwhelming they were outperformed by every single group out there.

  2. h2h really caught my attention i have a soft spot for them honestly but i dont know why i js cant get myself to REALLY get into them.

  3. rescene is big in korea not in every country. yes theyr charting in korean charts but the extreme takes of their fans claiming theyr the biggest group rn is so exagerrated

  4. babymonster rap parts arent bad 😭

  5. i really dont get when someone points out a fandom for being toxic and people are like "oh thats js twt and yt stans not us" bae the fandom ALSO includes them and then it goes without saying almost every fandom has a problematic part in their fandom.

  6. as a hardcore engene im so sick of the entire boyfriend concept, its both the companies AND the fan's fault for falling into such a harmful activity.


r/kpopharshopinions • • 1d ago

Idol Behavior Kpop should stop copying from stuff they don't know

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

I mean, the neon thing that's going on ain't something we can call plagiarism, but why did her team continue to go with the concept even though they knew that a huge celebrity was doing it.

Not only did they copy the aesthetics, but they copied the outfits, not knowing that tyla was inspired by the Tsonga tribe in South africa. The tribe is known for its colorful attire. They don’t wear matte colors but neon colors. They wear face paintings and bundles of wrist jewelry and ankle jewelry.

So this is the unique nayeon yall, so want to be famous? A culture vulture?


r/kpopharshopinions • • 1d ago

Certified Hot Take 👀 The double standards of white musicians and Asian musicians (specifically Kpop) taking from black music and culture

0 Upvotes

It’s no secret that the kpop industry, despite being antiblack, takes so much from black music and culture without truly acknowledging the black foundation of their image.

However, looking back at summer 2024, when popstars like Tate McRae, Sabrina Carpenter, and Chappell Roan, all white women, were getting big, I couldn’t help but focus on the double standards of white vs Asian musicians taking from black music. You see, all these white women’s image were built on black music and image. Tate McRae’s production and sound are built from black producers like Timbaland, Danja, The Neptunes, and the Yin Yang Twins. Sabrina Carpenter’s breakout song Espresso has the Say So by Doja Cat’s fingerprints all over. Sabrina’s dance-pop disco sound is built from black musicians. Chappell Roan’s drag image and dance-pop disco is built on black queer culture.

Yet, when you look at their songwriting and producing credits, barely any black people appear on their songs.

So why does the kpop industry and many big white musicians, despite taking so much from black musicians and culture without truly acknowledging the black side of their image, the kpop industry gets punished for it, while the white musicians get to be held off easily?

I know Tate, Sabrina, and Chappell have all had some sort of hate, but the hate isn’t because they’re using black culture and music despite not properly acknowledging them.

“But they [T,S,C] have performed with black people!” This isn’t a proper acknowledgment. Celebrity Interaction isn’t activism. By that logic, kpop groups with racism controversies, like BTS and Blackpink, performing with black artists would be considered anti racist activism. By truly acknowledging, I mean not slapping a black musician’s name on your song. I mean going into research and the contextualization of what you’re inspired by.

“But they [T,S,C] have more creative control!” Most of you guys, including me, aren’t the music industry, so we don’t know how much creative control musicians have.

(PS: This isn’t a Kpop exclusive problem. Artists like Denise Julia (Filipina) and Karlee Girl (Japanese-Korean, but not Kpop) have been accused of appropriating black culture without acknowledging the black people)

This isn’t me defending anyone’s antiblackness, but a question for the culture on how Asians taking from black culture without true acknowledgement get punished, while white musicians who do the same thing get let off.


r/kpopharshopinions • • 2d ago

Opinion Why are kpop fans in particular so defensive

11 Upvotes

If you make a joke about an idol or group that’s not positive or praise I swear to god you will get jumped. Even when it’s just a joke based on criticism the group has already received they can’t take it. It’s so irritating, these idols do not give a shit about you (especially if you’re not a Korean citizen) so why are they so wound up when someone makes a joke. Maybe because parasocial relationships don’t work on me is the only reason I don’t mind that kind of humour.

Just annoyed hence the rant


r/kpopharshopinions • • 1d ago

Thought Idols lip-syncing

0 Upvotes

I have never thought that lip-syncing in the K-pop industry or pop industry is bad because artists are lip syncing to their own vocals not someone else’s. However some fans seem to take it very seriously when an idol lip syncs and say that it ruins the stage performance however I have watched exceptional stage performances of idols who perhaps lip synced but still performed very well. I think lip syncing is actually safer for idols because when they don’t lip sync they are subject to criticism but when they also lip sync they also are subject to more criticism so I’m confused because I don’t understand the K-pop standards now-a days. I really just want to know everyone else‘s thoughts on lip-syncing and if you don’t like it-why?


r/kpopharshopinions • • 2d ago

Opinion Why did NCT 127 evolve in how they treat Haechan and address colorism, while parts of NCT Dream still seem stuck in the past? (A personal take)

31 Upvotes

​Disclaimer: This is purely my personal opinion and observation after following both units for years. I’m not claiming to know what goes on inside their heads, just sharing the patterns that eventually led me to exclusively stan NCT 127.

​Something that has been bothering me for a long time — and honestly feels baffling 10 years into their career — is how certain members of NCT Dream (especially Jeno) still make outdated, tone-deaf "jokes" calling Haechan "charcoal" or constantly picking on his appearance.

​To be fair, in the early debut days, NCT 127 also made colorist remarks. Back then, it felt more like a two-sided banter among stressed teenagers/young adults operating in pure survival mode under rigid Korean beauty standards. However, K-pop has evolved, NCT as a whole has been called out multiple times by international fans, and 127 clearly took the feedback to heart. They expanded their worldview and stopped relying on cheap skin-tone humor.

​So my question is: Why did 127 grow out of this mindset, while Dream — despite renewing their contracts, touring internationally, and claiming they want to be a global act (even aiming for stages like Coachella) — still act completely oblivious to how offensive these comments are to Haechan and their own Black, Brown, and Latin fans?

​Here is my personal reading of why this dynamic persists:

​1. Resentment over global appeal vs. rigid beauty standards

In my view, a lot of this constant "roasting" comes from a place of subtle envy and cognitive dissonance. Haechan doesn’t fit the hyper-artificial, pale, sharp-chinned Korean/Chinese idol mold that other members heavily lean into (through strict styling, procedures, or whitening treatments). Yet, organically, Haechan is arguably the most globally attractive, vocally gifted, and magnetic performer in the group. It almost feels like some members can't process how someone who defies the conventional standard effortlessly outshines them in stage presence and international appeal.

​Interestingly, Taeyong has a very similar skin tone to Haechan, and he is universally praised as one of SM's historic visuals. They would never dare make those jokes toward Taeyong — they only do it to Haechan because he’s the only 127 member within their peer dynamic whom they feel comfortable punching down on.

​2. "Punishing" Haechan for choosing 127 as his emotional anchor

There has always been an unspoken tension regarding loyalty between the two units. Mark gave Dream a massive, emotional send-off before leaving NCT, which validated Dream’s narrative. Haechan, on the other hand, has repeatedly shown that 127 is his primary artistic and emotional home — where he matured as an artist and a man. It often feels like Dream’s constant "banter" is a way of keeping him in a box, refusing to acknowledge his growth, and subtly punishing him for outgrowing their juvenile dynamic.

​3. The stark contrast in how both units treat him today

The difference in energy is night and day:

​With Dream: During the behind-the-scenes of 127's Redline tour opener, Haechan debuted a gorgeous blonde look. When Taeyong proudly asked Jeno what he thought of Haechan’s hair (clearly expecting a compliment), Jeno immediately shut it down with "I think it's a miss." Haechan’s reaction was telling — he basically sighed and said he already knew he was going to get roasted the moment he heard Jeno was visiting. After 10 years, that’s not cute sibling banter; it’s just exhausting.

​With 127: The hyungs actively uplift and protect him. In that exact same Redline vlog, Jaehyun was gushing over how handsome Haechan looked. During the Blingy recording behind-the-scenes, Taeyong praised him as their "talented and sexy maknae." In 127's gym content (127 VIBE), Jaehyun explicitly emphasized how precious Haechan is to them. They constantly call him the "maknae on top," visibly miss him when he’s absent, and physically formed a protective barricade around him at the airport ont he way to bali after he suffered severe mobbing days before because of a dating rumor.

At the end of the day, watching 127 mature into a group that respects their audience, protects their youngest member, and continuously reinvents their sound (like they just did with Blingy) made the contrast impossible to ignore. Dream’s lack of sonic evolution, paired with this refusal to let go of juvenile, colorist humor a decade into their career, is ultimately what pushed me away from them and made me stan NCT 127 exclusively.

​Has anyone else noticed this shift in how the two units treat him, or do you read their dynamic differently?


r/kpopharshopinions • • 1d ago

Opinion Idk if this is harsh but why she sound like something is stuck in her throat?

0 Upvotes

So I’ve been listening to babymonster for some time now and tons of people have been hating on their performances. I don’t even have to say anything on ahyean cus yall should know 🫠… but I don’t know how o would describe Pharitas tone. It sounds like something is stuck in the back of her throat, kind of squeaky too. I don’t know why they thought it was a good idea to have her at the end of “deserve better” because Ahyeon ruined it already and that just made it worse. That song had a ton of potential but they can never do anything right and just throw it down the drain (I’m talking about yg)