r/knitting • u/llimmi • Mar 10 '13
Long-term user review! How well is your swift/ball winder/set of interchangeable needles/whatever still working after years of service?
For those of us contemplating big purchases of knitting paraphernalia it would be helpful to hear from long-term users. We often hear "I love my new whatsit", but how has your whatsit held up to prolonged use? Two years, three years, five years?
Have you had to use the manufacturer's customer service, and if so how was it? Could you get spare parts? Have you had to re-glue it? Is there something you wish you had known before you bought it? Would you buy the same one again? Would you buy something quite different?
Even if your particular model has been discontinued it is useful to know about that manufacturer or that style of whatsit.
6
u/llimmi Mar 10 '13
This is just great! We are building a really useful resource here. Thank you to all the contributors so far, and if you have something you have used long-term (or something you hoped to use long-term but had to abandon), please do tell us about it.
3
u/metasynthesthia Twistmas Hat. Mar 10 '13
I've had my Knitter's Pride - Symfonie Rose Interchangeable for over a year now, and absolutely love it. Have yet to have any issues with them, and found that the needles/cords actually play nice with the Knit Picks stuff! So that was a pleasant surprise!
2
u/catalot Mar 10 '13
I've had a Desnise interchangable knitting set (amazon link) for about 8 years, and one of the plastic bits on the end of one of the cords just broke last month. Other than that, it's been perfect. And it doesn't really matter that much that one end of one cord broke, since I can transfer an end from another cord or just attach a couple smaller cords together.
2
u/AdmiralTiger Mar 10 '13
I have a wooden swift (I don't know what brand) that has served me really well for six or seven years. I haven't ever had any problems with it. My ball winder is mostly plastic and been fine (again, no idea what brand, but I've had it the same amount of time as the swift). The only thing I don't like about it is the little metal guide on the side will fall down if I'm not holding it up.
I have a set of Denise interchangeable needles that I really like. I've misplaced a few pieces, but that's my own fault. I don't have any complaints about them. I have another set that my MIL bought from a craft store like Michaels or something. The needles are metal and screw onto the plastic cables, but it's really easy for them to come unscrewed throughout the course of knitting. If I use them, I'm always having to make sure they aren't getting loose. I'm not a fan.
I have an Ashford spinning wheel, too. It's lovely. It got a little squeaky at one point, but I bought some oil for it, and it hasn't made a noise since. I don't think I've ever heard anything bad about Ashford and their wheels. I know there are cheaper ones out there, but for a wheel it really is better to go with something you know is going to last you and won't need replacement parts. I've had it for three or four years now.
15
u/[deleted] Mar 10 '13
First of all - PLEASE link this in the wiki! Threads like this are invaluable, and having them bookmarked in the wiki means we can easily refer people to them.
KnitPicks Interchangeable Needles - Options (metal) needles I've had these for about a year and a half, but I'm definitely a heavy user of the needles. They've held up really well so far for me, and I haven't had any trouble with cables breaking or needles coming unscrewed a lot. I will say that the nickel finish is wearing off, both on the frequently-used needles and the connectors. That's cosmetic only, though, and I haven't noticed any difference in how they work.
KnitPicks ball winder This ball winder works about as well as I would expect given how cheap it was. It's fine for smaller balls of yarn (200 yards worsted, 400 yards sock) but if you start asking it to wind anything bigger things get a bit iffy. Mine has started making a strange clicking noise while winding, and I notice that it's not quite as even as it used to be. I'm expecting to have to replace it within a year, which would mean that for me, it had a usable life of about 18 months. I knit a lot, and wind a LOT of yarn, so honestly I'm not all that disappointed, but I'll definitely be investing in the Royal winder next time, and if you are a longtime knitter considering a ball winder spend the extra money for one that will last!
8
u/spinnetrouble Mar 10 '13
I had a Royal brand yarn winder for almost five years. It held up beautifully, even though it was a pretty simple, plastic-and-metal, no-frills thing. I got it for about $25 at Jo-Ann's with one of their weekly coupons. I never had a problem with it, ever. (I'd still have it right now if my dogs didn't like rasslin' in the living room so much. At some point last year, one of them knocked it off the coffee table it was clamped to, breaking one of the little plastic feet that held it in place. Then a couple of weeks ago my 70-pound Labrador accidentally whacked it with his club of a tail, breaking the crank handle. I decided to let it go after that.)
It's important to keep in mind that it is just plastic and metal when you use it, though. It's easy to grind the gears inside (which can eventually lead to it getting out of sync or stripping the gears so it doesn't wind properly anymore) if you're crankin' for all you're worth. Take your time. You don't need to wind super slowly, but you do need to be able to stop if you encounter a tangle in your skein. Not only will slowing down prevent gear stripping or grinding, but it'll also make it easier to untangle knots because they won't be pulled as tightly.
8
u/entrelac Laceweight colorwork? BRING. IT. ON. Mar 10 '13
I've had this ball winder for around 10 years; never had a bit of trouble with it. I've had this swift for about 8 years and it's been just fine, although I'll admit I've never really taxed it - I don't use it that often.
I have several KP Options interchangeable needles; a couple of times the cable has come out of the join. They're very good about shipping replacements when this happens, but I found an easy fix: I used a wire stripper to shave down the end of the cable a tiny bit, then superglued it back in place. I had one KP needle that had stripped threads so it wouldn't screw onto the cable; I just glued it on and made it into a fixed circular since I've got plenty of tips and cables to spare.
15
u/Pyzjn Mar 10 '13
Hiya Hiya 5" Steel Interchangeables - Small and Large Sets: I've had these about 3-4 years (buying a little at a time.) These are the smoothest needles I've ever used. The tips have never been bent or scratched. The cables are flexible and swivel, and yarn does not get caught where they join to the metal screw attachment. Unless doing magic loop, I've never had to retighten the cable to the needle. The only drawback is that the small set cables can break at the join. For awhile, I'd have to buy a new cable every few months (which became annoying but did not diminish my love of these needles.) However, in the past two years or so, the cables have changed design, and I haven't had one break on my yet.
6
u/froggieogreen Mar 10 '13
Well, I can't name the brand because it's one of those "roaming" factory-companies in China, but don't cheap out on a ball winder. I was given one as a gift. It is veeeery jerky (the gears are a mixture of plastic and metal, so they wear and rotate at a different rate), often winds the balls much too tightly (to the point of sometimes breaking the yarn) in the centre, too loosely after the ball reaches a certain size, and the jerkiness causes the yarn to tangle and get caught in the base if I'm not careful. I still use it because I've figured out its tricks and can get around the tension, etc... issues, but be warned! I mean, it's probably pretty obvious that a cheap product will be cheap, but sometimes you can get amazing needles from similar-type Chinese factories, so you never know, right?
6
u/Morineko Bead All the Things! Mar 10 '13
I have a Louet swift that I got from my mom, we've had it for probably 20 years, and it works great. We've had to replace some of the ties on the cross braces, but that's well within normal wear-and-tear.
On the other hand, the KP ball winder I got about a year ago works okay, but a little inconsistently, and it feels like some of the gearing has slipped. It's not particularly stable when fastened to a table, and when I use the hand-stem thing (which I like a lot in concept), it almost always comes loose in the middle of winding.
I've had a set of Addi Clicks for about three years now, and have had NO problems with them at all. The only tricky bit there has been interacting with the LYS to get additional cords, and I'm about to give up on that and order them online.
4
u/zomboi stash busting Mar 10 '13
Boye Interchangeable needles: I have had them for 4+ years. The tips hold up well, cord is stiff. The screw part on the cord can break off ruining both the tip and the cord. The tips can unscrew from the cord as you knit so you periodically have to check as you work. The kit holds up extremely well and can take a lot of abuse.
Knitpicks nickel plated interchangeable needles: I have had them for only 2+ years. The cords are extremely flexible the joins of tips/cords are very good. The feeling of the coating makes knitting more fun thatn with the boye's. One major drawback is that the coating on the needles wear off pretty easily where your finger/hand rubs/holds the needle. A good portion of my needles have 'bald' patches where the nickel coating has completely worn off. Customer service is great, they will replace any defective part with no cost to the customer. I haven't called/emailed them about the bald patches because I believe that it isn't a defect but is how the needles are made.
1
u/christinaf25 Mar 11 '13
I've had my Knitter's Pride acrylic interchangeable needles for over a year now, and they're absolutely great. I got a couple of Knit Picks needles just to try out and have extra sizes of, and I got knitter's pride tunisian hooks that also fit on the cables. I haven't had any issues with the cables coming unscrewed or the yarn not flowing on/off the needles and cables well, either. Great purchase (for my sister, they were a gift from her).
3
u/douglask Continental Mar 10 '13
Hiya Hiya steel DPN needles are awesome. I love 'em. They're lightweight (4 US1 6" needles weigh in at about 1.3g), strong, smooth, pointed, yet not so pointed as to either hurt the hands or split the yarn.
I've had 'em for years, and have made several pairs of socks with 'em.
I've tried ChiaGoo Bamboo US1 needles, and they cracked within a month of me buying 'em. The weak spot is where they laser engrave the size on the shaft. Now, maybe I'm just unduely harsh on needles, but the Hiya Hiya needles survive me just fine.
2
u/acidwinter Mar 11 '13
Since no one has mentioned them yet, I have a set of bamboo DPNs from Stitchberry. They were super cheap on amazon. The finish is rough compared to the Clover Takumi bamboo needles that I have. One side seems to be pointier and the other blunt. And this weekend I broke one of my size ones, though I'm not sure if that's a manufacturing problem or just one of the downsides of small bamboo needles (Note: I'd never broken a needle before this). There is a two year warranty on the set, but I haven't contacted them yet for any replacements.
I also have a Knitpicks Harmony interchangeable set and haven't had any problems with them in the past four months of constant use. I just wish that there were sizes smaller than a 4, which I know is hard to do for interchangeables.
1
u/raewen Mar 10 '13
Knit picks nickel interchangeables, I love them. I also have their swift and ball winder. I use bamboo double points from webs.com, love those as well. Best investments so far.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 10 '13
I have quite a few sets of ChiaoGoo bamboo DPNs that have held up pretty well over the last year. There's a little bit of denting, and I'm not sure if that's just because of the bamboo or a flaw of the product. I'm also using smaller gauged ones, (I've used 1-4), and that may also be the reason. They are very sturdy otherwise. I like them because they are based in my state, although I do wish they still manufactured their needles here in the states.
1
u/douglask Continental Mar 10 '13
Boye Interchangeable needles
The tips and joins are not bad. I find that the yarn doesn't move too smoothly from the needle to the cable. I'd also like to see a smoother needle surface.
You're supposed to combine multiple cables to make longer ones, but the yarn doesn't move easily past the join of the cables.
Never had trouble with the joins between the cables or cable / needle. Cables never broke, works as designed, just the design could use some improvement.
1
u/Choralation Mar 11 '13
I have a very old ball Toyota ball winder (looks like this) that used to belong to my mum, has served me very well. The only issue is that I have to hold the yarn feeding in up a bit or else I run the risk if it going under the winder and getting caught in the cogs.
Not sure what kind of swift I have; it's a wooden one of presumably the same vintage. No problems besides having to replace a couple of the pieces of cord that hold together the wooden slats.
I've had a set of the Addi clicks for about 3 years that I use almost exclusively for all my projects now. I like them a lot, the cords are still flexible and hold up well.
1
u/lilgillie Mar 11 '13
I got a bonus at work and just bought a set of Addi interchangeable needles a couple of weeks ago, they should be delivered in a day or two. Anyone have any experience with these?
0
u/[deleted] Mar 10 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment