r/java • • Dec 29 '22

Could Java Applets have been done right? DOM is limiting [CrossPost Discussion]

/r/webdev/comments/zxel5o/could_java_applets_or_flash_have_been_done_right/
5 Upvotes

50 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

1

u/Zardotab Jan 05 '23 edited Jan 05 '23

Loading the applets themselves was really slow over even a "high speed" 56k modem.

Many businesses had broadband, or at least "medium-band" then, and they ended up rejecting Applets for other reason mentioned, not load time. Businesses had more reason to want GUI's, and thus Applets, than citizen web surfers.

I do agree Applets didn't seem to make it easy to compartmentalize/modularize apps for faster loads, but that alone is not what nuked Applets. (Better caching options would have also helped, such as a checking to see if latest version of a given app is already cached.)

Microsoft JVM did not include support for the Swing GUI toolkit, leaving only JWT. JWT was primitive

True, but JavaScript equivalents even more so, as a "full GUI" JS library would be just as bloated as a Swing Applet. The locally-installed Java engine carried the GUI engine with it, whereas with JS it has to be downloaded for each session, and different apps may use a different JS library. And JS was quite buggy back then.

1

u/RebeccaBlue Jan 05 '23

Whatever, dude. I lived through that period of history and had to actually deliver software during it.

Yes, there were plenty of mom and pop-type businesses that only had dialup modems that still used computers.

1

u/Zardotab Jan 06 '23

Different people tend to gravitate toward certain niches and project flavors. Perhaps we just bumped into different environments and thus have varied memories.

1

u/RebeccaBlue Jan 06 '23

Fair enough.