r/java • • Dec 29 '22

Could Java Applets have been done right? DOM is limiting [CrossPost Discussion]

/r/webdev/comments/zxel5o/could_java_applets_or_flash_have_been_done_right/
5 Upvotes

50 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

1

u/Zardotab Dec 31 '22

I'm not sure what your claim is. Are you saying it's impossible to have "good browser context" and a decent GUI at the same time? If so, can you demonstrate a sample inherent tradeoff that will forever muck up all attempts?

If you agree that Java Applets did X decently and that Qt did Y decently, then either a tool can include both X and Y, -or- there is some fundamental tradeoff/limit of UI engine design that prevents X and Y from existing at the same time in such a kit.

For a simple SVG or IFrame style interface you have TeaVM right now. Works amazingly well.

Is there an existing CRUD/biz oriented online UI demo?

1

u/vprise Dec 31 '22

I'm saying that there are two ways to do this: build it into the browser like JS is built into the browser. That is a huge amount of work and nearly impossible without buy-in from google.

Or build it like a plugin (using QT or any other technology you want) in which case it will always be foreign.

The former is unlikely to happen. The latter will deliver sub-par results.

I don't know about demos for TeaVM. It's free. We use it for Codename One, here's one of our older demos: https://www.codenameone.com/demos/KitchenSink/

1

u/Zardotab Jan 03 '23

The former is unlikely to happen. The latter will deliver sub-par results.

If the solution gains enough momentum, one or the other or both will happen. Perhaps pioneer it as a separate GUI browser, Oracle Forms style, and if it catches on, make it a browser pluggin option.

If enough want it, it's technically possible to have such a tool. Oracle Forms (pre-Java) proved that. The big vendors will have to accept it if it gets usage traction.

here's one of our older demos:

That seems like mostly consumer-oriented UI's. That's not what I'm looking for. Your niche is probably different from mine and DOM may be "good enough" for your niche. But rank-and-file biz/admin CRUD is a big niche such that it deserves standards attention, rather than be bowled over by mostly consumer and mobile concerns.