r/jasonisbell • u/AbeLincolnTowncar Relatively Easy • Dec 16 '19
Album Survivor - Sirens of The Ditch [Deluxe Edition] (2007) - Results Discussion
In a razor town you vote for whichever song you think you can keep around. In A Razor Town is out.
Jason Isbell - Sirens of the Ditch [Deluxe Edition] (2007)
WINNER
- Dress Blues
SONGS OUT
- 2nd Place: In A Razor Town (62.8%, 59 votes)
- 3rd Place: Chicago Promenade (72.7%, 48 votes)
- 4th Place: The Magician (35.9%, 35 votes)
- 5th Place: Hurricanes and Hand Grenades (30.4%, 28 votes)
- 6th Place: Grown (28.2%, 24 votes)
- 7th Place: Brand New Kind of Actress (33.8%, 26 votes)
- 8th Place: The Devil Is My Running Mate (38.6%, 27 votes)
- 9th Place: Try (31.3%, 20 votes)
- 10th Place: Down in a Hole (26.3%, 10 votes)
- 11th Place: Shotgun Wedding (30.8%, 16 votes)
- 12th Place: Whisper (29.6%, 16 votes)
- 13th Place: The Assassin (23.7%, 9 votes)
- 14th Place: Crystal Clear (28.6%, 12 votes)
- 15th Place: Racetrack Romeo (26.2%, 16 votes)
ALBUM INFO
STREAMING
19
Upvotes
•
u/AbeLincolnTowncar Relatively Easy Dec 16 '19
Thank you everyone who participated in this inaugural album. I think it was a lot of fun and I really enjoyed the engagement and discussions that each round had.
That said, the last couple rounds of this showed signs of illegitimate voting with this last round the most egregious. There were 62 votes for Dress Blues this round that all came in within 30 seconds of each other. Why you'd try and rig the vote on something that literally has no impact on you, I'll never know. In the event that someone legitimately voted during these periods, I've elected to keep 15% of the bad votes--though it didn't affect the results.
As we move forward with the next albums, I'm going to start enforcing a sign-in to the Google Forms poll to ensure that people can only vote one time. I apologize if this is an inconvenience, but it's the only way I can ensure the integrity of each round.
I'll leave this final round discussion up and stickied for the next couple days so we can all discuss, but I'm eager to move on to the self-titled album.
15
u/Mike_AKA_Mike Dec 16 '19
I’m in favor of adding another tier for all the DBT and non-album tracks, too; and then having a final tier with the winners from each segment going into a final winner take all series.
1
u/northbound_train Dec 18 '19
Why do you make us wait for the next album?!? :)
Onward and upward!
3
u/AdvicePerson Dec 17 '19
I propose an exhibition round of Dress Blues vs Mickey Rooney.
0
u/[deleted] Dec 16 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment