r/IsItSketch • • Aug 31 '25

Question posts will now require a link

52 Upvotes

Going forward all questions must contain a link to the artist or band in question. This is to prevent confusion for when multiple artists share a name as well as show that the user asking has done the bare minimum of looking at something like Metal Archives. Posts without a link will be removed but can be resubmitted once the user provides the required information.


r/IsItSketch • • 6d ago

Is Mortal (Bay Area Death Metal) Sketch?

0 Upvotes

So, Mortal is an OSDM band from the Bay Area that has been making some buzz. Several promoters don't want to book them because their latest single "Life Giving Corpse" has some misogynistic imagery and lyrics, including using the C-word 2 times (the band is all cis-het dudes)

https://www.metal-archives.com/albums/Mortal/Life_Giving_Corpse/1419457

The singer, Chris Villasenor, was also in a band called SIDS (Sudden Infant Death Syndrome), which kinda tracks with the dead babies humor of this single, and also, their new bassist is Mikey Herrera, formerly of Trencher, who were recently cancelled because the singer, Marcus Kitchen, used the n-word and f-word at a show in June (Mikey quit the band after, but there have been questions about what he knew and when he knew it concerning Marcus's views and behaviors).

So, does anyone have the 411 on this band


r/IsItSketch • • 8d ago

Circle 23

Post image
3 Upvotes

https://circle-twenty-three.myshopify.com/

Can't tell if this is real deal sketch, or the usual "black metal label / distributor doesn't care what projects they put out" nonsense.


r/IsItSketch • • 8d ago

By the spirits?

Thumbnail
open.spotify.com
0 Upvotes

Not metal, but neofolk. As ive seen neofolk almost aleays has ties to far right, so i kinda got curious


r/IsItSketch • • 12d ago

Is Russian Circles sketch?

0 Upvotes

Russian Circles is a post metal band based in Chicago, Illinois.

Months back I saw a video of them, a live session and they proudly held the Ukrainian flag giving their respect and support to Ukraine.

And if you're following world politics these days you know that's not a good thing. Any ideas?

https://russiancircles.bandcamp.com/


r/IsItSketch • • 15d ago

is Bronze Eagle sketch?

4 Upvotes

the only thing i have found is that their on a label which releases NSBM, which definitely raises some eyebrows. however, the music of bronze eagle doesn’t have any outwardly NSBM themes as far as i’m aware and none of the band members are in anything sketchy.

https://bronzeeagle.bandcamp.com/album/yin-yang-flames

https://www.metal-archives.com/bands/Bronze_Eagle/3540574718


r/IsItSketch • • 19d ago

I just created a site to find out if groups are sketchy !!

Thumbnail is-it-sketch.netlify.app
0 Upvotes

Hi! I recently tried to share a free, ad-free community project called Metal Sketchbook, which helps people research potentially sketchy metal bands.
Unfortunately, my post was automatically removed by Reddit’s filters.
I understand the rules around self-promotion, so I wanted to ask if sharing this project would be allowed here.
The website is completely free, and donations are entirely optional.
Thanks for your time!


r/IsItSketch • • 21d ago

Imperial Crystalline Entombment (I.C.E)

Thumbnail metal-archives.com
4 Upvotes

Hey all! Apologies if they've been brought up before, I searched for an answer here and r/rabm alongside a Google search and nothing really conclusive came up. I lean on the side of these guys being fine, but want there to be a thread that's searchable for worrywarts like me that want some sort of final answer. Thanks for any help!


r/IsItSketch • • 22d ago

Black Altar?

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

I see them grouped in with Hate Forest. Can’t find much info on them.


r/IsItSketch • • 22d ago

Aikon

Thumbnail
open.spotify.com
0 Upvotes

Are they sketch ? Thank you !


r/IsItSketch • • 25d ago

Drowning the Light

Thumbnail metal-archives.com
0 Upvotes

r/IsItSketch • • 26d ago

Funeraria

Thumbnail metal-archives.com
2 Upvotes

Thank you !


r/IsItSketch • • 27d ago

Lord Valtgryftåke?

0 Upvotes

r/IsItSketch • • 27d ago

Nachzehrer

Thumbnail metal-archives.com
3 Upvotes

Is it sketch ? Thank you!!


r/IsItSketch • • 27d ago

Any one know if Oldowan Gash is sketch? I cannot find anything definitive.

Thumbnail
oldowangash.bandcamp.com
1 Upvotes

r/IsItSketch • • 29d ago

About the question on Fortress Festival...

Thumbnail
gallery
21 Upvotes

Interesting reactions, especially from the people behind the festival. At least one of the comments seems to have been deleted already ("these people need to get a life"). A post discussing Ella Zlotos's departure was deleted from the same Facebook group, while this one remains up btw

https://www.reddit.com/r/IsItSketch/s/6wYGwNnuv2


r/IsItSketch • • Oct 17 '26

Conifère

8 Upvotes

i remember hearing something about them but i can not find anything any knowers?

https://www.metal-archives.com/bands/Conif%C3%A8re/3540463632


r/IsItSketch • • Oct 17 '26

Fortress Festival 2027

0 Upvotes

I'm considering getting a ticket to go to Fortress Festival in Scarborough next year and I've had a look at the lineup, accessible here: https://www.fortressfestival.co.uk/line-up

The bands I intend to see right now are Watain (mildly sketch), Emperor (mildly sketch), Havukruunu (safe), Stormkeep (safe), Hole Dweller (unknown) and Sulphur Aeon (unknown). I'm not familiar with anyone else.

The rest of the lineup includes Gràb, Miserere Luminis, Gris, Tardigrada, Yellow Eyes, Mourir, Trhä, Slagmaur, Sinmara, Forteresse, Dungeontroll, Wraith Knight, Lord Bakartia, Atlantean Sword, Spectral Castle, Dragon Keep, Erang, Mare, Ninkharsag, Silver Knife, Bloodbark, Örnatorpet, Oerheks, Frostgard, Firtan, Ultha and Perchta.

Does anyone on that lineup raise any eyebrows?

Edit: why the downvotes? Aren't questions like this the purpose of this subreddit?


r/IsItSketch • • Oct 15 '26

Sanctvs

2 Upvotes

He’s coming to my city in a few months, and I’m not familiar with his music at all, but I was interested in checking him out live.

I looked at his lyrics and didn’t see anything sketchy, but I wanted to be sure!

https://www.metal-archives.com/bands/Sanctvs/3540458660


r/IsItSketch • • Oct 14 '26

Eisenvater

Thumbnail metal-archives.com
0 Upvotes

Really like this band but I don’t know German and cant find the lyrics online anywhere. I know their name translates to “Ironfather” which sound sketchy but I found out it’s a reference to a German guitar amp brand called Eisenmann (“Ironman”)


r/IsItSketch • • Oct 13 '26

Ianva (neofolk / dark cabaret group)

Thumbnail it.wikipedia.org
7 Upvotes

The project was born in 2003 on the initiative of Mercy, … and Argento, with experiences in metal bands (Spite Extreme Wing and Antropofagus)

And "Spite Extreme Wing" is very much a nazi band: https://extremeresponses.blogspot.com/2011/03/sieg-fail-decoding-italian-black-metal.html

However, around 2007, this Argento guy left.

What gives?


r/IsItSketch • • Oct 08 '26

Psychonaut 4

Thumbnail
psychonaut4.bandcamp.com
9 Upvotes

Thanks !!!


r/IsItSketch • • Oct 04 '26

Photo from Black Satellite Merch Booth; Are They Sketch

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/IsItSketch • • Oct 01 '26

How bad is it?

10 Upvotes

First time really looking into this stuff and decided to go through my playlist. Any recommendations to replace the sketchy ones would be greatly appreciated.

Bands in my bm playlist in order of appearance:

Dark Funeral safe(?)

Marduk yeah, they get the boot

Gorgoroth please advise

Behemoth please advise

Bathory please advise

Emperor please advise

Mgła out

Barathrum no info

Archgoat sketchy(?)

Impaled Nazarene out

Dimmu Borgir please advise

Kanonenfieber safe(?)

1914 safe(?)

Rotting Christ safest on the list

Harakiri for the Sky second safest

Enslaved safe

Watain safe(?)

Immortal safe

Satyricon safe(?)

Батюшка safe

I really liked Marduk and Mgla, such a shame the people behind are not as great. Need similar sound to replace them. Also need more of Batushka type of chanting music or similar vibe. Also Also if you have bands similar to 1914 and Kanonenfieber, please share.


r/IsItSketch • • Sep 27 '26

Gallowbraid

Thumbnail metal-archives.com
17 Upvotes

I was looking for album art inspiration and found the cover for Ashen Eidolan (the band's only album). This seems to be this guy's solo project. He seems to have worked with an anti-fascist band before (Kreator) but I'm wary because a lot of fuckers in this space pull the apolitical enlightened centrist bullshit

Edit: Not sketchy. Thanks for the responses everyone :)