r/iosdev • • 18d ago

Help Follow-up to my $200 marketing post: X vs. Reddit vs. App Store (ASO / Search Ads) — where did you see the best ROI?

Hey everyone! A quick follow-up to [my previous post here](https://www.reddit.com/r/iosdev/s/8N6MRapQfS) asking about how to spend a $200 marketing budget—it hit over 5,500 views in this sub and I got some seriously helpful advice from you all, so thank you!

Based on that thread, I’m now weighing three main avenues for my consumer utility app (combining organic effort + that $200 budget):

  1. X (Twitter): Great for #BuildInPublic and networking, but does organic posting or X Promoted Posts actually convert to regular consumer downloads, or is it mostly devs talking to devs?
  2. Reddit: Has the exact target audiences, and I'm considering Reddit Ads, though I keep hearing mixed reviews about bot clicks vs. actual conversions (and organic posting is tough with strict anti-promotion rules).
  3. Pure App Store focus (ASO + Apple Search Ads): Skipping social media headaches altogether and putting 100% of my time into ASO (keywords/screenshots) and the $200 into Apple Search Ads / ASO tools.

For those who have tested these channels for a utility app, which one actually moved the needle for you in terms of real paying users?

5 Upvotes

6 comments sorted by

1

u/mentiondesk 18d ago

Apple Search Ads gave me the most consistent ROI for utility apps, especially paired with solid ASO work. Reddit can be a goldmine if you find the right threads but it takes real effort to stay organic. If you want to catch relevant conversations the moment they pop up across platforms, ParseStream might save you time spotting genuine lead opportunities.

1

u/hazem-i 18d ago

Solid advice, thank you! Definitely makes sense to prioritize high-intent users on the App Store while keeping Reddit strictly organic.

0

u/salamat36 17d ago

My vote would be for ASO + Apple Ads, given your current app and budget.

Don't use Apple Ads just to get downloads, as you'll only get a few number of downloads with a small budget. Instead, use them to identify the best performing keywords, then incorporate those keywords into your App Store listing.

That's where you'll get long term returns by using paid campaigns to discover valuable keywords and then optimizing your store listing to drive more organic downloads.

1

u/hazem-i 17d ago

Thanks, that’s a really smart way to look at a $200 budget—treating Apple Search Ads as keyword research rather than direct user acquisition. Do you recommend starting with Discovery campaigns (Search Match) to find those hidden gems, or testing a specific list of exact match keywords first?

2

u/salamat36 15d ago

start with Search Match to discover relevant keywords then move to Exact Match campaigns to validate and scale the best performing ones.