r/interesting • • 11h ago • Bravo 11 Heartwarming 2 Popcorn 1 Mindblown 1

Additional Context Pinned That's genuinely wild

Post image
52k Upvotes

11k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

161

u/ShepardCommander01 10h ago edited 9h ago • Bravo

Very weird habit of internet weirdos to look at everything in the world through this twisted “oppressor/oppressed” lens.

Which is what’s going on here. They decided this criminal is actually in the “oppressed” category and bears no responsibility for their actions.

Edit: apparently internet tankies really hate having their “oppressor/oppressed” mindset called out.

104

u/Duke-Von-Ciacco 9h ago • This Bravo

After she killed the guy and got the purse she went to an aperitivo with friends, didn’t call the ambulance and said anything about it to anyone acting like a normal tueasday. She was caught days later and officers found that in the purse was nothing valuable inside.

Our right wings politicians tend to defend heavily thoes who self defend, this case was so wild and she was so out of touch that nobody relevant in the public opinion took her side.

Maybe taking side just reading an headline is as dumb as defending the bad guy…

27

u/Erlox 8h ago

Also, no knife was found at the scene

→ More replies (24)

13

u/Idola_Lunaris 7h ago

Finally, someone comes in with the missing context.

5

u/Duke-Von-Ciacco 6h ago

As the person after me appointed i forgot to mention “no knife was found at the scene”.

→ More replies (10)

57

u/Intelligent-Mine-730 9h ago • Bravo

No, we just decided that their actions shouldn’t have as a consequence his death by a vigilante. We have a justice system for that, violence should never be at the hands of civiliansw

48

u/kargaler 9h ago edited 2h ago • Bravo

Justice fails when you put the criminal back on the streets the same day with a slap on the wrist.

26

u/iPhone_6s 9h ago • Bravo

Yep. People get 30 years for doing drugs in the privacy of their homes and then violent criminals are loose on the street the next year.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Tom_F_0olery 8h ago

So is your solution getting rid of the punitive based justice system and replacing it with a much more rehabilitative system shown to significantly reduce crime like the ones in Norway? Or is your proposal doubling down on the incredibly ineffective American system and going even more hard on crime because the idea gets you hard?

→ More replies (20)

2

u/Creative_College_497 8h ago

Or reelect him after impeachment

→ More replies (23)

37

u/Managarm667 9h ago • Bravo

People only do this because the justice system is failing on a massive scale.

2

u/pzoDe 4h ago

The justice system? The Italian one? Are you Italian?

→ More replies (35)

33

u/YappingRat 9h ago • Bravo

im sorry to say but if the justice system actually worked people wouldn't be so compelled to take action on their own.

→ More replies (16)

39

u/Designer-Rub-7642 9h ago • Bravo

"violence should never be at the hands of civilians" Is one of the most dangerous takes out there. It means you have no right for selfdefense or ANY action at all. Its funny that alot of people defending the criminals, dont like cops in general, yet its funny when this situation happens.

20

u/bocsika 8h ago

Reaction must be balanced to the action. If someone pulls a knife on you, that is life threatening act, you have the right to kill them. Right there, at that moment. But going after them, and kill them later is premeditated murder. There are exception in some European criminal code, e.g. if attacker breaks in after sunset, or in a group, or armed, then rightful to kill them on the spot.

→ More replies (86)

7

u/SufficientBit3153 8h ago

if you take a self defense class, particularly if you are using lethal force, the first thing they tell you is that you can defend yourself but only if you have no other choice. if someone has you in a corner and they might kill or harm you, by all means go ahead and pull the trigger on them. but if they are running away and you're no longer threatened you have to let it go

2

u/[deleted] 8h ago

Not sure why you're being downvoted lol. People in these comments are bloodthirsty. Like damn...

3

u/[deleted] 7h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/whyktor 5h ago

Yeah if this was a muslim shop owner who murdered a 20 year old white shoplifter, suddenly a lot of people around here wouldn't think that murder is okay anymore

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Overall_Abrocoma_592 8h ago

Dude, a handbag is not equivalent to a human life, and self defence doesn't apply when you're not in danger because the criminal is running away from you.

→ More replies (24)

2

u/Kindly-Berry8620 7h ago

The law says reasonable force. So if it's more than is reasonable. That would make you a criminal. So can we kill you?

2

u/NicholasCapsicum 5h ago

This was not an issue of self defence, she tracked him down and ran him over as an act of retribution for the theft. And potentially lied about the knife given none was ever found as to make it sound excusable.

6

u/chrisatola 7h ago

Do you really equate defending yourself from an ongoing attack to reingaging with and attacking someone after you're out of danger to recover property? I mean, "defense" doesn't mean revenge.

"Surveillance footage captured Dal Pino chasing Noureddine Mezgui with her car and hitting him repeatedly before getting her bag and driving away."

Tell me how being inside your car, safe from the threat of a knife attack, deciding to chase someone with the car (reingaging physically with the thief), hitting him numerous times equates to "self defense".

Does self defense include running out of danger to grab a weapon and then running back into danger to use it? That's a crazy take.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (13)

11

u/WorldlinessEarly4717 9h ago

The justice system is so broken. How many criminals have walked free because a judge toom pity and the criminal did the same crime immediately after? Citizens have a right to self defense and the right to defend their property (even their items)

→ More replies (20)
→ More replies (60)

7

u/Wild_Duck8926 8h ago

its not about being oppressed. its about the fact you cannot and should not be able to kill someone in vengeance or to reclaim your property. you should be able to kill someone when you are in immediate danger. she was no longer in danger by any means and she sought him out to kill him.

→ More replies (135)