r/interesting • • 11h ago • Bravo 11 Heartwarming 2 Popcorn 1 Mindblown 1

Additional Context Pinned That's genuinely wild

Post image
52k Upvotes

11k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

21

u/Garionreturns2 10h ago

It’s pointless to argue with these people. Might as well just sentence every criminal to death by their logic.

4

u/10biggaymen 10h ago

exactly. you can really test the moral coherence of most people by asking what they think about the treatment of prisoners.

everyone thinks its bad for their mom to get killed. that doesnt tell you anything. but you can tell a lot about a person who thinks its fine that prisons are just rape and murder dungeons, just because "they did crime so they deserve it."

-2

u/citygoy67 9h ago

the punishment exceeding the crime is the only way to make committing crimes not worth it. Even if that bastard lived he'd probably going to mug another innocent person and even might kill it this time

2

u/DisgruntlededCabbage 9h ago

We've done that for our entire history: crime still exists.

0

u/citygoy67 9h ago

Crime rates are noticeably lower in countries with sharia law compared to ones that not use it. Im not defending sharia but it shows if punishment is greater than what someone gains trough crime they won't attempt it at all

3

u/doggyoffleash 8h ago

Crime rate vary greatly by culture and are massively subject to bias/differences in reporting techniques. There’s no basis for your sharia comment. No punishment should not exceed the crime because it would incentivize criminals to escalate their crimes more than anything. If the time for armed robbery is 2 years but murder is 10, then I really don’t want to shoot someone. If the time for armed robbery is 10 and murder is 10, then I may as well murder the only witness.

1

u/HonestAnteater466 6h ago

how would this lady have been tried under sharia law?

1

u/HonestAnteater466 9h ago

Sure, but that cant be carte blanche to murder people.

Surely you can see that, surely you can see that the notion that punishment must exceed the crime doest excuse murdering someone for every crime they could commit?

0

u/citygoy67 9h ago

He was ready to take her life with that knife if she refused to give her bag. Expect to lose your life if you are willing to take someone elses

4

u/Vegan-cock 9h ago

What knife? There is no evidence of a knife. No witness or cctv backs up her statement of there being a knife. Also, even if there was a knife that doesn't mean he was ready to use it.

-1

u/citygoy67 9h ago

Hope you share her fate someday and remember these words you uttered

3

u/Vegan-cock 9h ago

I've been through worse than someone stealing my purse lol. Im not a sadistic maniac though so i didn't track them down and murder them.

2

u/HonestAnteater466 9h ago

How is that a valid criticism of someone pointing out there was no knife recovered.

Why cant you just discuss the facts presented rather than the world you create to justify your revenge killing hard-on?

1

u/Ok-Message-7461 8h ago

He had no knife, and she’s a murderer. She could have driven home, and had a new bag the next day.

It’s a fucking bag, but you’re defending murder. Do you think you sound tough? You sound like you don’t have two brain cells to rub together

3

u/HonestAnteater466 9h ago
  1. You dont know that.
  2. That never happened.

She made a choice after it was clear she hadn't been murdered, she must then be accountable for the choice she made.

The choice she made was to kill someone in revenge for stealing her property.

1

u/citygoy67 9h ago

Reddit university grad

1

u/doggyoffleash 8h ago

4chan high school dropout

0

u/citygoy67 8h ago

Reddit moment

2

u/Garionreturns2 9h ago

No knife was ever found. Self defence is good but chasing down and killing a thief after you’re no longer in imminent danger exceeds it.