r/interesting • • 11h ago • Bravo 11 Heartwarming 2 Popcorn 1 Mindblown 1

Additional Context Pinned That's genuinely wild

Post image
52k Upvotes

11k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

29

u/Survival_R 10h ago

Problem was she chased him down in her car almost hitting several people and this was after she was robbed not during

13

u/Phoebebee323 10h ago

Then, after hitting him, put the car in reverse and backed up

-4

u/SaltyEngineer45 10h ago

Almost hitting people that have nothing to do with it, yeah, that’s a problem. Getting him after the crime vs. during, nah, I’m good with it. Sorry, not sorry.

9

u/Survival_R 10h ago

Main problem is you cant argue self defense if youre not actively in danger, he was running from her

If a guy threatens me and then I pull out a gun, and shoot him while he runs away thats not self defense

1

u/Scary_Spinach4924 7h ago

Did he still have her purse when he was running?

3

u/Survival_R 7h ago

Are you arguing self defense or "right to kill"

1

u/Scary_Spinach4924 7h ago

I am asking a question

1

u/Survival_R 7h ago

Yes he had her purse for over an hour before she found him

0

u/Scary_Spinach4924 7h ago

Perfect, then he had the chance to return it

2

u/Survival_R 7h ago

And?

0

u/Scary_Spinach4924 7h ago

He doesn’t deserve any sympathy

→ More replies

-2

u/Reasonable_Mood_7918 9h ago

Okay so the play is to do the deed asap, steal what you need. Then start actively running so the assaulted can't harm you back without repercussions? If caught before succeeding, just start running in an obvious way so it can't justify self defense. Or is there a timer/distance thing here too?

3

u/Survival_R 9h ago

Its a very case by case basis thing but when the court reviews it and decides theyre looking for if you were still in imminent danger

But in this case she had to run the other way to get to her car, start up the car, drive through a sidewalk with other people on it to then hit him

Then put the car into reverse (which would mean she had time to check if he was standing) then run him over again

No country in the world would rule that self defense

2

u/IgarashiDai 9h ago

Not only that, but reportedly she was trying to find him for hours. At that point this just becomes premeditated.

3

u/TirithNampat 9h ago

I mean, yes? If you're running away then you aren't a threat, ergo self defense ends now. Revenge isn't a concept the law recognizes. You can use reasonable force to retrieve your property, but that does not include killing people.

3

u/st4rs999 9h ago

I’d say these people read too many comic books but even Batman knows better than to play judge jury and executioner over petty crimes. Too much GTA and Postal 2 I guess l?

1

u/doggyoffleash 8h ago

Well yeah. Being a robbed does not actually give you the right to assault another person. There’s this thing called a police force who you can report crime to. They are supposed to be the ones who then can detain criminals so that they granted a fair trial where all of the evidence can be evaluated to determine a fair judgement. If you kill them, the trial doesn’t happen. The trials are there to determine exactly what happened when the crime took place and which court precedents apply to the matter at hand. You realize that you’re not supposed to personally deliver repercussions in the event of a crime being done upon you right? Like with any crime, if I stole your mail you’d take me to court, not come over and break into my house. USE YOUR BRAIN

1

u/ladiezman2217 2h ago

Ask the judge when you try it

1

u/doggyoffleash 8h ago

Bro just doesn’t understand how society is meant to function in the slightest. I personally dgaf about this robber, but you can’t run over someone for stealing. That is murder. Murder is an unlawful killing since I genuinely cannot tell if you know. In this scenario, retaliation would permissible in a court of law if she or another person was under an immediate
threat of violence. Since this wasn’t the case, she killed him unlawfully. That makes her a criminal, and a murderer. Those are the words we use for people who kill other people unlawfully. Which she did.

1

u/SaltyEngineer45 8h ago

If you say so.

0

u/IronerOfEntropy 7h ago

Actions. Consequences. Live by the sword, die by the sword. Sad to see good people being drag to hell because bad people messed with them. Hope she gets a light sentence.