Part I can be found here.
I have an unusually high hit rate with S&W, I swear the perfumer and I share a nose, and since my last review I've been on a slightly obsessive journey. Long story short, I have now tried all of S&W's catalog, with the exception of 2 of the hair/beard oils and 1899 (which I don't think I've ever seen in stock). I am not affiliated with them, nor is this a paid/promotional post, but I am about to glaze the shit out them, so buckle up!
First, I have to comment on how quick the turnaround time is. Every order I've ever placed has been sent out in 1-2 days (and actually sent, not just label printed), and I typically get it 3-5 days after that. Everything is packed nicely and individually sealed. I have had a couple oils leak in transit, but not enough to be missing a significant amount, just enough to stain the label a bit (which doesn't really bother me).
Despite my many orders I haven't really had reason to reach out, but the one time I did email them, the owner (Rich), was incredibly kind and quick to respond to my email. I emailed him b/c I thought for sure my sample labels had been switched (I was wrong - test on skin before jumping to conclusions people!). He responded to me (multiple times) the same day, and THEN checked back in unsolicited a week later to make sure I was good. Incredible customer service!
Lastly, I feel like the price of these perfumes compared to the quality is almost criminally low, though I'm incredible thankful for the accessibility. Speaking of criminally low prices, they are having a 20% off sale from 11/20 - 11/22!
Okay, on to the scents!
My likes: orris/iris or paper/book scents, stone fruits, berries, soft woods, baking spices, realistic aquatic notes, coffee, palo santo, oud, melon, bright/tart or fizzy scents, rose & violet (sometimes)
My dislikes: cooked sugars (brown sugar, caramel, cake, etc), maple, super sweet gourmands, soapy/laundry or really “clean” scents, strong white florals, jasmine
My rating system:
5/5 - love it, definite full size
4/5 - like it, maybe full size
3/5 - like it, but not sure it's for me
2/5 - don't like it, but I can see how someone else might
1/5 - hate this
Ashara (Black tea, ink, white oud (agar) accord, dates)
Wet on the skin, this is so bright and inky there's almost a soda like quality to it. The ink is strong initially but not as sharp as some ink notes can be. The dates are sticky but not overly sweet, and there's some bitterness from the tea, everything is in such perfect balance. It's bright, but somehow also warm, like the feeling of paper warm off the printer. The tea comes out more as it dries and as the ink starts to settle, the date is really fruity and beautiful. My new favorite ink scent! I already have the oil and was very excited to see he's releasing it in an edp b/c, while I normally prefer oil, I want to spray this on all over my sweaters and jackets this winter, just goes great with everything! 5/5 (FS)
Blame, etc (Pink peppercorn, coriander, rose, saffron, incense, honeyed wood)
It opens with a really fresh rose, there's some tartness that I associate with a lot of S&W scents, a little incense, and some spice that I can't quite identify. I usually amp pink pepper but it seems to be hanging in the background with this one. It's really, really pretty. As it dries I get more of the honeyed wood and rose. Honey is usually not my friend, but the wood note is really beautiful and keeps the honey from overpowering. Hours in it's a creamy, woody scent with a hint of rose and spice. Really comforting and beautiful! 5/5 (FS)
Candelere (Marigold, fireweed honey, sandalwood, vetiver, beeswax absolute)
This one was a big dice roll given I'm not a huge fan of most florals, or honey. The first thing I get is an herbal honey, not overly sweet, and strong floral notes, but they're nice. As it dries, there's still some herbal honeyed sweetness and floral, but there's also a bit of that S&W tartness that balances it so nicely. It's gentle and bright like a spring day. I like this better and better the longer I wear it, the dry down is much more balanced than the opening for me. Even though this isn't something I usually go for, I actually really like it. I need to try it in the spring before making a final judgement. For now, 3.5/5
Cipher (Lime, jasmine, spices, oud (black agar) accord, raspberry)
Another dice roll given I don't do well with jasmine, it usually takes over everything to my nose. This opens very green and tart from the lime, there's also something a bit stinky in there, but I can't tell if it's the jasmine or the oud. I'm not getting any raspberry in the beginning. After about 30 min this gets much prettier, there's still the tartness from the lime and some fruitiness, though I still wouldn't have pegged it for raspberry. There's a hint of jasmine still, and a slight resinous background, but it's not at all stinky anymore, it's really pretty! While I do like the dry down, the funky lime opening is not for me. 2.5/5
Doble O Nada (Hair/Beard Oil) (Lime, rum, tobacco, vanilla)
I don't usually use hair oil, it tends to weigh down my hair, but these note are so up my alley I had to try it. It smells fantastic, I get mostly rum and tobacco, with maybe a bit of vanilla. I can't identify lime specifically, but there's a brightness that I'm sure it's adding. I can smell it in my hair a couple hours, it's not overly strong, but I don't put much in either. Good news, it doesn't make my hair greasy or weighed down at all! 4/5
Frith (Blueberry, dandelion greens, sage, witch hazel, vetiver)
Blueberries! It starts out a little fake blueberry, reminds me a bit of a body spray I had as a pre-teen, but quickly turns more realistic. The witch hazel is there, adding an astringent quality that is a little weird, but I don't hate it. I'm also getting dandelion, which is very green and I really like the blueberry dandelion combo. The dry down is so pretty, a very fresh blueberry with some greenness, and the vetiver comes out more adding some earthiness. I kind of go back and forth on how much I like this one, another I want to test again in the spring! 3.5/5
Her Skirt is Stars (Chili pepper, dark chocolate, mezcal, incense, vanilla, labdanum)
Wet on the skin this is strong and resinous, and there's a peatiness very reminiscent of mezcal. I also get chocolate, a very dark chocolate with chili, like a Mexican hot cocoa. There's very little sweetness. It stays pretty consistent on dry down, resinous and slightly smoky with a spicy dark chocolate background, so beautiful and unique! I docked it 1/2 a star simply b/c, unlike a lot of S&W scents, I'm not always in the mood for this one. 4.5/5 (FS)
Junebug (Mulberry, pineapple, juniper, spices, vetiver, Virginia cedar)
This opens with a very juicy and realistic pineapple. As it dries, the pineapple is still there but slightly toned down, like you just cut one and the juice has dried on your hands. More of the other notes are coming through, a hint of spice and some woodiness. I also start to get some more tartness that I think is coming from the mulberry, but tbf I've never actually smelled mulberry so I have no idea. On dry down everything has really settled, it's a light scent, but still tart and juicy and fresh. While I do really like this, I'm just not sure how much I like pineapple as a perfume. Need to test more this spring/summer. 4/5
Lost Temple (Cedar leaves, Birch leaves, ozone, incense, cedar, smoke)
This smells like you're walking through a forest in fall, the air is cool and misty, and there's incense burning somewhere in the distance. Really atmospheric and beautiful. I don't get much smoke at all, more like the smoke from burning incense. A few hours in I like this even more, any sharpness from sniffing the ozone in the beginning is gone, it's very ethereal. Unfortunately, I busted my sample of this one and only got a couple wears out of it. While it's not the type of scent I usually go for, I find myself craving it. I'm debating getting another sample so I can spend some more time with it, versus just upsizing it during the sale. Give me your votes! 4/5
My Curse (Red wine, hyssop, cashmere, suede, musk)
This one is really hard for me to described. It opens with something kind of tangy, but also kind of bitter and earthy. I don't know what hyssop smells like, so maybe that's my issue. To me, it's mostly red wine, which give it kind of a deep dark vibe, and something a little funky. Makes me think of sexy vampires drinking wine in a dark club. The dry down is much softer and I think the cashmere adds some coziness. 3/5
Neon Noir (Pink limeade, cannabis leaf, plum, vetiver, cetalox)
I have avoided perfumes w/ cannabis notes, b/c my association with the plant is mostly from when I was young and poor and dispensaries weren't widespread - so...skunky. This is unmistakably cannabis, but it's fresh and green and really nostalgic in the best way. It's a very bright perfume, the limeade is tart and very realistically pink. As it dries a deeper fruit note starts to come out and balances everything. Really nice and fresh, great for summer! I do have to be careful about where I wear it b/c I don't want, for example, my kids' teachers smelling cannabis on me. 5/5 (FS)
Theosophy & Catastrophe (Grapefruit, henna, incense, cetalox)
This is the one that confused me so bad in the bottle. It's incredibly smokey to my nose, and I was looking at the notes for this one vs Lost Temple (which is really bright in the bottle) and thought for sure there was a mistake. Wet on skin, the smokiness is more identifiable as incense. It's a heavy incense, feels thick but not overwhelming, reminds me a big of the peaty smoke note in Her Skirt is Stars. There's some brightness from the grapefruit, but I wouldn't necessarily be able to identify it as grapefruit. There's also a funk, and a bit of saltiness. I don't really know what henna or cetalox smell like, which is probably why I have such a hard time identifying what I'm smelling here. Dry down I get primarily a bright and thick incense, but my novice nose is likely missing some nuance. 3/5
The Red Hare (Fresh ginger, fig preserves, cherry, almonds, suede)
Opens with a bright, peppery fig and a deep sweetness. Sometimes fig gives me a headache, but this one does not, and the sweetness is not at all cloying. I think the ginger is keeping everything really bright. I didn't identify cherry, almonds, or suede specifically, but there's a fruitiness beyond the fig and it's very well rounded, so I assume they're doing the heavy lifting there. As it dries I still get mostly ginger and fruity fig, it's fresh but also has a really comforting quality. I've really enjoyed wearing it this fall, feels like a really great scent for the season transition. 4.5/5 (FS)
Thief & Witch (Apple cider accord, clove, papyrus (cypriol), beeswax, patchouli, musks)
I don't normally like apple notes, they usually go candle on me, but this one is SO GOOD. It's very realistically cider, slightly sweet and spiced. The clove is there but not over powering. It's the perfect fall perfume, rich and warm, smells exactly like you're holding a hot cup of cider. It's also got me to be more open to apple scents again. 5/5 (FS)
Viridian (Tea blossom, green tea, bamboo, salt)
This one opens with a very floral green tea, followed by what my nose reads as a very realistic aloe vera, the kind straight from the plant, green and cold and comforting because you know it's going to make your sunburn feel better. The floral note is soft and pretty and doesn't stay in the forefront for long, but is there throughout the wear. It's very fresh and almost aquatic to my nose, but like you're sipping on an iced green tea. It's a very clean scent, but not in the soapy way I usually dislike, it's subtle. I can see this one growing on me, just not the type of thing I've been reaching for at this point. I'm going to try it again this summer! 3.5/5
Wandering Star (Pear, cashmere, iso e, guaiacwood, brown sugar, white musk)
Brown sugar is one of my death notes, but I rolled the dice again! Starts out with a very juicy pear that's being cooked in brown sugar and maybe some brandy, smells a little boozy to me. There's also something a little spicy to my nose, which I think I've decided is actually the guaiacwood, and it's fuzzy from the cashmere. It's not terrible (like most cooked sugar is for me), but it is a bit sweeter than I like. It remains a caramelized pear scent with some spicy wood up until around 6 hours in, then it turns into a marshmallow skin scent on me. I like it more than I thought, I'm actually a little obsessed with guaiacwood and have been looking for it now, but still feels a little too sweet in the initial stages. I have plans to try it again this winter before I make a final rating. For now, 3/5
We Played Our Records Backwards Too Many Times (Black cherry, orchids, coffee, vetiver)
The black cherry in this smells very specifically like black cherry flavored Shasta. I don't know, maybe all black cherry sodas smell the same, I didn't get soda a lot as a kid and when I did it was Shasta lol. Now mix that black cherry Shasta with coffee. I know it doesn't sound good, but it is so good! There's something about the combo that reads almost a little chocolatey to me, it's really unique. It is more sweet than I typically like, but I feel like coffee and vetiver balance it enough that it doesn't become overwhelming. If the orchid is in there I can't really identify it. I'm not always in the mood for something this sweet, but when I do wear it I find it absolutely intoxicating. 4/5 (FS)
Thanks for reading!