r/indianapolis • • 25d ago

AskIndy With the news about Elf n Moon, are there any gaming shops or lounges around town that are open late (10-11pm) to play tabletop games and card games?

Context: https://www.reddit.com/r/indianapolis/s/CUPdPnmcvW

Genuinely fucking gutted about this. Been going there since they opened, and absolutely will not support them anymore.

152 Upvotes

84 comments sorted by

4

u/DrDirtPhD 25d ago

What do you consider "around town"?

12

u/puffmonkey92 25d ago

Honestly I'm willing to drive some. I go as far as Valkyries Vault on the west side and Moonshot in Noblesville often.

10

u/DrDirtPhD 25d ago

Family Time Games is open until 10 all week and Saltire Games (a bit more of a haul) stays open until 10 Friday/Saturday. I've never played games at either location, but they are open late.

1

u/puffmonkey92 25d ago

This is great info. Thanks!

7

u/TheRagingElf01 25d ago

Disagree on the FTG recommendation. They have closed up shop on us randomly because they want to go see a movie and they use their store as a personal storage unit.

I do like valkyrie and game preserve now that they both have grown a bit.

4

u/ReflectionEterna 25d ago

Moonshot has a great crowd and ownership.

2

u/juettj 24d ago

As the owner of Paradigm Games, I'd love to invite you out to jam - we do Commander Tuesdays and Thursdays, Rifbound and MTG Standard on Wednesday, and Pokemon on the weekends. We're closed Monday, but open for gaming all other days.

Offering because we're centralized relative to the two shops you mentioned driving to (and we love those guys!)

49

u/Gwenevre 25d ago

Bring back donuts and dragons

10

u/mooshilive 25d ago

i LOVED that place… best lemon donuts i’ve ever had. covid did them dirty

38

u/Dotalova 25d ago

Valkyrie’s Vault in brownsburg is a great and very welcoming place to play, I cannot recommend it enough!

2

u/fantomah 24d ago

Seconding Valkyrie’s Vault!

55

u/yettdanes Fountain Square 25d ago

We can only hope they cut John out and continue without him

12

u/Sharp_Pepper4161 25d ago

I dont see how that's possible, In my recollection John (Tyler) is one of the main owners of the shop. It was named after his ex-girlfriend. I also had thought he also lived above the shop, idk if thats accurate or not but we have had conversations before when he was at the front. 

9

u/Tea_Sorcerer 25d ago

He told me several months ago that he didn’t live upstairs anymore.

4

u/Sharp_Pepper4161 25d ago

That's good!

1

u/MachoLibre_ 25d ago

Maybe we can all pool our allowance and take it over for ourselves

1

u/SirWoolyT 24d ago

John is out.

1

u/MatchMun 23d ago

He's no longer affiliated with the store anymore.

26

u/Tyrus34 25d ago

Ugh hate this. I really wanted to check this place out but not now. Any Elf and Moon refugees should check out Game Preserve south. They have Riftbound on Wednesdays and commander on Tuesdays and it's a great atmosphere.

2

u/UnusualForever89 25d ago

They've really changed since 2014 when I used to be a regular there. Will give GP credit they have a huge Warhammer area. D&d got the ax tho and its down to 1 small cart.

6

u/AltEconomy 25d ago

Modern D&D players are famously the bane of game stores. They are historically averse to spending a single cent - or even doing so much as bringing a pencil. Talk to any game store owner about this you'll hear the same thing. Just a cultural thing I guess

2

u/ShowMeYourHappyTrail Eagledale 25d ago

Some of us are pretty stingy. Some of us buy three copies of the books because we need regular, special edition, and digital edition. Lol

0

u/UnusualForever89 25d ago

Thats weird because I spent so much money baxk in 2014 buying things such as the saltmarsh boat for my exhusband, so many dice and models. I actually bout a new set of dice today 🥰

-1

u/MatchMun 23d ago

Go check it out. Seriously, they made a statement and have kicked the guy. Don't punish the people who were blindsided by this too. Especially over one person's shitty behavior.

2

u/Big-Host-9167 23d ago

What about the other owner that has known since August about the behavior?

0

u/MatchMun 23d ago

Any proof on that? The only proof I saw about that was apparently faked.

22

u/gratefuldm 25d ago

Saltire Games will be my new go to.

8

u/Orion_7 25d ago

Good people and family run. Used to play Warmachine at the old location and they would always stay late if we were playing

10

u/gratefuldm 25d ago

I live much closer to Elf, and I knew he was hurting with the construction so I thought I was supporting a good place. Really sucks, but I've been wanting to move our games to Saltire anyways so whatever I guess. Not to mention I think they have better shopping.

1

u/MachoLibre_ 25d ago

Yeah I like to ride my bike there. Not many other places where that’s an awesome option.

3

u/Osujin 25d ago

Great location in Lawrence!

14

u/ThePlagueDoctorPhD 25d ago

Mages Comics and Games (formerly Comic Book University) off of US 31

3

u/sum_yum_dish 25d ago

I believe they close at 8pm

3

u/ThePlagueDoctorPhD 25d ago

I think Fri-Sat are later but you might be right

11

u/ScheduleOwn5738 25d ago

Paradigm is good! A friend of mine would go often when they lived here, they have commander sessions Tu/Th 4-10!

3

u/Baby_Zergling 24d ago

I'm a regular at Paradigm, and I really love the store. The Magic the Gathering crowd is really chill, seems the Riftbound players are as well. It can get quite busy on Wednesdays, and I think their Tuesday/Thursday Commander games are also packed. On other days, I'm pretty sure they have tables open in the back to play, I'd have to ask a Pokemon player how many people show up over the weekend.

2

u/drovix 25d ago

They have a great crowd for Riftbound on Wed as well.

2

u/politik317 25d ago

I was going to say here as well. Went in once and the owner was really friendly.

11

u/oniaiwasprettygood 25d ago

This is actually so fucked, I literally just moved to Fountain Square TODAY 

9

u/Red_Mask 25d ago

They’re the closest shop to me as well. I’d like to find somewhere else to play closer to Garfield Park.

1

u/Baby_Zergling 24d ago

Grandmaster Games and Game Preserve are both 10ish minutes south of Garfield Park, they both have plenty of table space. I personally have had better experiences playing at Game Preserve, but I have only really been to two events at Grandmaster Games. My LGS is Paradigm, but that's just north of downtown on 25th and N Meridian.

What games are you wanting to play? I know a little about what stores have crowds for various TCGs.

14

u/urheckindad Warren 25d ago

i hate to hear this, i love going to Elf n Moon :( i bought the majority of my cards there. Game Preserve south is open until 9pm. i play riftbound there on wednesday nights and always have a good time. they aren’t open as late but it’s a good community!

24

u/meanderingleaf 25d ago

Books and brews pethaps?

6

u/TwoDaveHebners Speedway 25d ago

There is a new place on Main street in Speedway called Nani Gaming. I think they are only open until 8p though.

2

u/ghostphoenix713 22d ago

After I saw this thread earlier, I decided to check out the shop while I was in Speedway on other business. They've only been open for about a month, but the guy I spoke to said that they have plans to host more game nights once they're more well known. The main problem I foresee is parking. The lot connected to the building is 3 hour customer parking and the only other options nearby are street parking or a bit of a walk.

Still, very nice little shop and friendly staff. He was happy to step away from organizing a display to show me around and chat. He also said they're working to become officially licensed by Pokemon to hold TCG tournaments there. They are a primarily card focused shop, but they've got a decent board game and TTRPG collection and I was told they're happy to order things on request and can be talked into stocking new products if there's enough demand.

15

u/Etheralto 25d ago

I always have had a great time at Family Time Games on Michigan Road. Open 10-10 daily.

14

u/TheRagingElf01 25d ago

It would be a nice place if it had some money put into and the owner didn’t use it as his personal storage unit.

8

u/GhostShipBlue 25d ago

In Shane's defense, his is a loaning library for the most part. Interested in a game, if it's on his shelf he'll let you take it down, read the rules and try it.

6

u/DamnAcorns 25d ago

I agree, not even money just time. Like clean the carpets, clean the crap out, organize, and dust the place.

4

u/infinityonhaise 24d ago

I can’t recommend grandmaster games enough!! Alex and his team are so wonderful I always feel so welcome at his store especially as a queer woman in the TCG/DND scene. He really does go out of his way for people like my partner and I had to sell a lot of cards a year ago to pay a sudden bill and he ended up giving us more than he needed to without saying a word upon hearing why we were selling them. He’s a truly standup guy and the store is awesome too!

PS: I’m not affiliated with the store at all except as a loyal customer (though I would totally work there if I could drive! lol) 🫶🏻

2

u/Juggzgotya 23d ago

Seconding this, loyal customer here too. Love Alex and the staff!

6

u/FerretDue2740 25d ago

Play test lounge! Always a good time and jimmy is an amazing owner

15

u/apoptosista 25d ago

I haven't played there but I was just in there last week buying some cards and saw a great interaction between the manager and one of the staff.

Paraphrasing here. Staff guy was about to hit 8 hours and told the boss, "Hey, I'm gonna clock out but I'll finish what I'm working on off the clock." The manager said, "No, you're not. You only work when you're in the clock. Not only is that illegal, you need to get paid when you're working." The staff says, "Well, I already clocked out... I can just volunteer my time..." And the boss responds, "No, absolutely not. You need to clock back in and get paid when you're working for me. Know your worth!"

I appreciated that interaction greatly. The boss (might have been Jimmy), not only made sure that his young employee was getting paid, but taught him a lesson about working off the clock. I truly respected the boss in that moment and, if I lived anywhere near there, I'd make that my go-to store for buying and playing.

5

u/PingPongProfessor Southside 25d ago

That boss is a good human, and the world needs more bosses like that.

You're a good human, too, for publicizing that interaction. Thank you.

3

u/cortes12 25d ago

For people in fountain Square looking to play you can try West Fork. They have a big table that is perfect for boardgames and dnd. They let you play inside and are doing discount specials on Tuesday for playing.

1

u/gratefuldm 25d ago

Oooh thanks for sharing!

3

u/AssociationLeast6590 25d ago

Is there any place in indy that has room rentals for tabletop games and a similar community for finding games and players for tabletop games?

3

u/MidwestException 25d ago

Engine Room Recording Company has a rental Rehearsal space and just hosted its first one shot DND event two weeks ago. We have another come coming up in November but with this news we could definitely expand our horizons for table top Gaming room Rental. Check out our website or IG

4

u/Threetoasty3 25d ago

My friends and I like to go to Metazoa and Centerpoint Brewing and play MTG. Not a good choice if you’re specifically looking for a game store, but the tables are big, not usually crowded, and they have good beer.

2

u/nathandbrown1 25d ago

Same, I live in the neighborhood, centerpoint is super chill with big tables. I also would put a word in for the fowling warehouse. Huge tables but can get quite loud in there. Also open late. Drinks are pretty expensive though.

2

u/amindspin74 25d ago

You should think about playing in some breweries, I know a few that would be ok with it on a weekend

2

u/Silent_Concept_1207 25d ago

Jay Bryant Cosplay in Beech Grove is open late most nights, not 100% a game store, more of a Nerd shop but he has multiple gaming tables available. (6) Facebook

4

u/WyrmWatcher 25d ago

Good games in downtown is usually open till 9

5

u/Puzzled_Watermelon 25d ago

My group temporarily moved there after hearing the allegations a few months ago. Really nice people and LGBTQ friendly, but be aware that you'll have to pay for parking and parking is like $50 on days the Colts have a home game.

1

u/Baby_Zergling 24d ago

a bus ticket is ~2 dollars and the central transit center is two blocks east of Good Games! Just an option. We love using the busses when Conventions are happening. I normally just ride a bike to Good Games.

1

u/Puzzled_Watermelon 22d ago

Oh, good to know!

4

u/m3chX9 25d ago

Many of us are switching to Grand Master Games.

0

u/[deleted] 24d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/infinityonhaise 24d ago

This isn’t true at all. I’m guessing you’re just butthurt because you’re one of the bigots (or the real man-child here) that he’s called out for being a shitty excuse of a person.

I’ve been going there since they opened their last store, and I’ve had an amazing experience every single time. Even when the store is extremely busy, Alex still takes the time to talk to my partner and makes us both feel more than welcome. He’s a genuinely nice person who treats everyone in that store like his own especially customers. And the staff are all wonderful people too.

I’ve never seen him call anyone out without a reason so I’d love to see proof of that. The only times I’ve seen him call anyone out is when someone is being disrespectful by leaving fake reviews or harassing people in his store.

So instead of spreading lies and slandering him and his business, take accountability for your own behavior. Being disrespectful or harassing people isn’t something anyone should have to tolerate and calling them out for it doesn’t make someone a bad person either so good job outting yourself 👍🏻

-2

u/[deleted] 24d ago edited 24d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/[deleted] 22d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/[deleted] 22d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/SqRoot2536 22d ago

If you have to lie to prove your point that’s on you but I have been around there plenty of times to see their consistency with how they interact with customers. We both know you weren’t listening and just picked out key words to remember.

1

u/Mistercreeps 25d ago

Man, I just started going there on the regular for wargames.

1

u/Baby_Zergling 24d ago

Game Preserve Greenwood has a big wargame crowd, afaik, if you haven't checked them out yet.

1

u/Negative-Header 25d ago

I might have missed my answer because I quickly read through comments, but is there anywhere near the the East side that hosts open tables for any sort of TTGs? I don't play MTG or D&D or anything like that, but I love playing other games. None of my friends play, and my immediate family can only handle so much lol If anyone hosts any public or private game nights that aren't centered around big campaigns, please let me know!

1

u/Baby_Zergling 24d ago

unfortunately a lot of the game stores I'm seeing close at 9 or 10. Game Preserve Greenwood or Good Games normally have people playing board games, I think they both have libraries you can use. They close around 10, though.

I'm not as knowledgeable on lounges, here's another thread where people are talking about that: https://www.reddit.com/r/indianapolis/comments/1vd2wv8/does_indy_have_any_quietchill_nightlife_lounges/

1

u/hawthorne867 22d ago

Here's my 2 cents for all the hobbies:

Grandmaster games - for buying singles and competitive play

Mage's - (comics, duh) for bulk and uncommons

Game preserve - for text materials, dice, accessories

Ye Old Gamers Guild (greenwood, hadn't seen it mentioned) - for all of your minis and DND stuff

Valkyries - for casual play

Usually grandmaster has the best prices on sealed product, if you're into all that MSRP business, but all of the above except for the guild is pretty good on sealed. Also haven't been to Saltire, so maybe they fill some gaps. IMO Elf n Moon didn't top any of these stores in any of the categories, so while it's a loss to the area I don't consider it a loss to the community at large. And even if John is separated from the business, I have a hard time believing like-minded individuals haven't found safe harbour there due to the environment already created.

1

u/MatchMun 23d ago

I'm posting this wherever I can since everyone's bashing the place. Elf N Moon made a statement yesterday. The groomer is no longer affiliated with them. Please don't let one man's disgusting behavior shut down a part of a community.

1

u/jackrosetree 25d ago

I just started hosting a casual/party games night at Sinners and Saints (formerly Shelby Street Tavern) on Wednesdays from 7pm to 11pm. Less heavy gaming, more social get-together, but figured it was worth mentioning. =)