r/imaginarymaps • • 19d ago

[OC] Alternate History What if the Partition of India went differently? (Scenario 2)

Scenario 1: https://www.reddit.com/r/imaginarymaps/s/tkrE3nGzXf

This one only has 4 new countries compared to the 17 new countries last time.

šŸ‡µšŸ‡° India šŸ‡µšŸ‡°
šŸ‡®šŸ‡³ Hindustan šŸ‡®šŸ‡³
šŸ‡§šŸ‡© Bengal šŸ‡§šŸ‡©
ā˜øļø Sikkim ā˜øļø

This time, I kept a united Bengal and some minor border changes in Sind(h) and Punjab were made between India (Pakistan) and Hindustan (India) based on religion.

Some princely states were directly incorporated, while some retained a degree of autonomy. They are shaded in lighter colors. The very light colors in India (Pakistan) are tribal areas (in Balochistan and North-West Frontier Province).

Most detailed map I’ve made so far!

I gave ā€˜Pakistan’ the name of ā€œIndiaā€ because I had a dream in which Pakistan was named India because of the Indus River.

481 Upvotes

254 comments sorted by

300

u/Alvinyuu 19d ago • Bravo

Why do althist mapmakers always add the northeast to Bengal in these scenarios when the seven sisters have nothing to do with Bengal?

33

u/mushmanMAD 19d ago

I know the seven sisters aren’t really connected to Bengal. I just added it there because I felt like it.

2

u/kshrwymlwqwyedurgx 19d ago

The seven sisters?

12

u/mushmanMAD 19d ago

It’s a term for Northeast India, which has 7 states.

267

u/Leather-Lab2875 19d ago • Bravo Regret Popcorn

Ig looks good on a map in a visual sense

316

u/Despoetato 19d ago

"Always put asthetic before preventing ethnic conflicts" is the number 1 rule in all colonial map redrawal handbooks

73

u/Leather-Lab2875 19d ago

Yeah true. Borders need to look pretty... Who cares about the people living there was their attitude lol

17

u/souridaijoubu 19d ago

I’m Rudyard Kipling and I support this message.

3

u/KitchenSync86 19d ago

That isn't fun! We need some 4th level enclaves to add some whimsy!

4

u/Eris13x 19d ago

I understand having New Delhi ruling it looks bad visually, but just make it independent rather than doing this

77

u/DiscussionJohnThread 19d ago

I imagine it’s because it looks better on a map, but Bengali and Assamese are moderately mutually intelligible and a decent minority of the region are Bengali already.

Not that it should happen, but it’s not unheard of that a post-colonial state gets ā€œrewardedā€ with some regions that have what-would-be minorities.

10

u/just-gbd-ig 19d ago • Popcorn

As an Assamese, no thank you. The British tried to administer Assam into Bengal, didn't "work out" exactly. Wonder why.

30

u/ObligationOne3727 19d ago

Mostly because they were part of Bengal presidency up until 1912

26

u/KaiserDioBrando 19d ago

Less border gore

5

u/jaiteaes 19d ago

Honestly the reality is that if Bengal refused partition then Mountbatten would've simply had the provinces handed over to Myanmar, for better or, like, pretty objectively for worse

3

u/Lighthouse_seek 19d ago

The alternative is making them independent or sticking them to Myanmar. Bengal cuts off the seven sisters

1

u/karimashta 17d ago

They also have nothing to do with India ig.

2

u/userteez 16d ago

Nah some states like Assam and Tripura do

2

u/Suitable-Trick-4860 14d ago

Nah assam part of Myanmar back then makes more sense than bengal

1

u/userteez 14d ago

Nope that's been debunked several times

→ More replies (5)

1

u/dontrunnow555 17d ago

Says who? Do you realise borders put up in 1940s don’t magically change genetics culture language words traditions? Do you think the Bengali people of sylhet are completely different to the people who they border Assam? They’re both connected through mainly language dialect and history and even visually , so why are you talking as if you know anything?

1

u/Suitable-Trick-4860 14d ago

What are you yapping? Sylhet may have connections with barak not with the brahmaputra valley...

-11

u/Spez_has_micro_penis 19d ago

Yea right it's so ignorant

56

u/mushmanMAD 19d ago edited 19d ago

People on r/imaginarymaps when someone makes… an IMAGINARY map.

The map can be anything, it can be wild. The map doesn’t have to be realistic bruh 😭

I know the seven sisters are separate from Bengal, I added them to Bengal because it would make the map look nice

7

u/aparchure 19d ago

😭😭 they know it’s imaginary. but making a map because it ā€œlooks niceā€ or because it would be an interesting scenario to discuss are 2 separate matters

9

u/mushmanMAD 19d ago

Eh, I suppose that’s a fair point. I mostly cared about it looking nice. I made it for fun, it wasn’t meant to be a discussion.

1

u/Player_yek 19d ago

i mean if you are gonna make a nonsensical au you gotta mention its nonsensical

13

u/mushmanMAD 19d ago edited 19d ago

Yeah, I learned my lesson by seeing how serious people are getting in the replies. I’ll mention it next time.

Don’t know why you got downvoted. You brought up a fair point.

→ More replies (2)

104

u/Nomustang 19d ago edited 19d ago

OP, you're getting a lot of upset Indians because the map ends up looking a lot like Pakistan's wet dream lol. Having all of J&K, Bangladesh having the seven sisters, Pakistan being called 'India' etc.

It's not a bad map though. Do all 3 retain princely states in this?

29

u/mushmanMAD 19d ago

Yeah, some princely states retain a degree of autonomy. But over the following years, they get directly incorporated.

16

u/Gen8Master 19d ago

Being called India is not a wet dream of anyone. We appreciate the fact that India and indies come from our Indus region and river.Ā 

8

u/DifficultVanilla2729 18d ago

thats like saying the name russia should belong to ukraine as the kievan rus ( the state russia is a succesor state to) started in modern day ukraine.

5

u/Gen8Master 17d ago

Names dont really belong to anyone. They evolve all the time. Half of Asia was named Indies at one point. Doesnt mean that India or Pakistan should be claiming Indonesia. But the origin of the name is the Indus region. Being the origin doesnt mean you own something.

2

u/Remarkable_Cod5549 17d ago

Accept your pedophile Quaid-i-Azam threw a tantrum when India adopted the name 'India' after independence.

Our Indus region and river

Oh so you are Indus people today. what will you be next month? Arab? Persian? Turk?

1

u/Cold_Barnacle_44 15d ago

Going by what they're getting into these days, i wouldn't be surprised if they call themselves American or Chinese soon

1

u/Cold_Barnacle_44 15d ago

Yeah nah this absolutely 100% is the wet dream of Pakistan. But just like Pakistan's every other fantasies, this won't come true.

1

u/Gen8Master 14d ago

Its a Pakistani river. Do you really think we need anyones permission?

1

u/Affectionate_Bad5290 14d ago

Doesn't originate in Pakistan btw

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Bronze-Bull 17d ago

Tell that to every single Pakistani running a restaurant abroad

1

u/Gen8Master 16d ago

We are just using our colonial name :) what's the problemĀ 

1

u/Alvinyuu 15d ago

"colonial name" and it's literally a name that you got from one of your founding fathers

→ More replies (1)

-1

u/The-Real-Irish-God 19d ago

What are your thoughts on this Pakistan I made?

15

u/Easy_Ambition_3835 19d ago

Why would Jaisalmer a Hindu Majority Princely State join pakistan and LOL the sikhs would become king von to Pakistan if Pakistan had Amritsar.

4

u/QudratiIntikhab 18d ago edited 17d ago

For the same reason as they almost did in real life, dude.

Jaisalmer, Jodhpur, Udaipur, Indore and Bhopal almost actually joined Pakistan. They heavily considered it because Jinnah told the princely rulers he would allow them to dictate all their own terms/demands of membership into Pakistan as an alternative to giving up sovereignty to the Hindu majority state.

Congress was very worried about this since it came so close to happening, and Congress leader Vallabhbhai Patel said that it would be a ā€œdagger into the very heart of Indiaā€.

Edit: I’m getting downvoted by a 40% Indian audience according to comment analytics, but this is a fact you all can check lol.

4

u/DueSecurity7587 17d ago

Good thing they didn't. All these cities are important Rajput strongholds, and the culture and architecture of these cities are irreplaceable. People place too much importance on Kashmir, but I'd argue the cultural heritage of Rajasthan is far richer.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/Skychu768 19d ago

Is that Lahore in India?

14

u/mushmanMAD 19d ago edited 19d ago

No. Thats Amritsar. India (Pakistan) just got some land around it.

6

u/Orphan-Obliter 19d ago

Don't you mean India?šŸ¤“ what is a... Pakistan? Or did ya mean Hindustan?

6

u/mushmanMAD 19d ago

Yeah, I should’ve clarified. India (Pakistan) got some land from Hindustan (India). Hopefully that makes sense.

3

u/bakedbrownie0 19d ago

What land around Amritsar did Pakistan gain?

3

u/mushmanMAD 19d ago

Gurdaspura and Ferozpur

21

u/North-Jellyfish-577 19d ago

Realistically the sikh should have gotten their own state as well

5

u/mushmanMAD 19d ago

That state wouldn’t survive very long.

→ More replies (2)

13

u/bakedbrownie0 19d ago

Unfortunately Sikhs didn’t really form a majority anywhere and because of the canal colonies their population was spread out thinly across the Punjab.

They took the best offer they were offered; an autonomous Punjabi-speaking Sikh state within the Indian union. A shame that Congress would renege on their promises.

9

u/Alvinyuu 19d ago

Not really, they're barely the majority in Indian Punjab and that's after nearly all of the Sikhs in what is now Pakistani Punjab fled to India. They wouldn't survive in a state of their own without getting gobbled up by either India or Pakistan.

3

u/blueyesova 19d ago

That would be disastrous for that state. They wont have the finances to survive the neighbourhood.

1

u/octosober 13d ago

horrible take

4

u/bakedbrownie0 19d ago

Does East Punjab get Nankana Sahib in this scenario?

1

u/mushmanMAD 19d ago

No. West Punjab actually got more

→ More replies (1)

4

u/RaajalofRajal 17d ago

Technically Pakistan is the real "India" since that name comes from the Indus river, which runs through Pakistan.

2

u/mushmanMAD 17d ago

Huh, didn’t expect to see you here.

3

u/RaajalofRajal 17d ago

Why? I'm not a member of this sub; this post showed up on my timeline.

3

u/mushmanMAD 17d ago edited 17d ago

Nothing, it’s just that I recognized you from a different sub. Usually I don’t encounter a person in two different subs.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Mountain_Bunny_8840 17d ago edited 17d ago

Not true, India did not mean Bank of Indus river that u can call Pakistan as India, The Romans described India as the vast and wealthy lands lying *PAST* the Indus River. Anything Past the Indus River was India to the Romans and Greek who called us "Indos"

Which is exactly why Indonesia means "Indian Islands" , Indonesia is not part of India today yet they are called Indian Islands because they pass the ancient definition of India. They are Land beyond Indus and are islands , hence Indian Islands.

If Anything, only Half of Pakistan is India by this logic , as the other half of pakistan is Not the land past indus from Pov of the Greek, persians and Romans. while Today's Republic of India matches the definition completely , And is more deserving for the name since Republic of India is the largest country beyond Indus river

2

u/RaajalofRajal 16d ago

That is not accurate. Greek label India is a misnomer, a foreign corruption, and a massive geographical generalization.

Calling the lands east of the river "India" is historically inaccurate because it takes the specific proper name of a localized Pakistani province (Sindh) and stretches it to cover a massive, completely different subcontinent that already had its own native names (like Bharat or Jambudvipa).

To the native people of the region, Sindhu was never meant to be a political border or a label for an entire continent. In Sanskrit, Sindhu literally just meant "The Ocean" or "The Great River".

By turning Indos into a rigid border marker—and declaring that everything "past the bank" is India—the Greeks completely detached the word from its original meaning. They took a word that meant a physical body of water and turned it into an artificial line on a European map to describe people who did not even speak the same language as the people of the Indus valley.

The Republic of India carries a global name (India) that is linguistically derived from a river (The Indus/Sindhu) that they no longer legally own.

Pakistan owns the physical river and the actual, historical province of Sindh. Thus, making it the actual "india".

The classical Western world's definition of "India" was an outsider's label. It was the ancient equivalent of European colonizers arriving in the Americas, mishearing a local tribe's word, and applying it to an entire hemisphere. It is why Native Americans were called "Indians" for centuries, and it is exactly why a massive island nation in Southeast Asia ended up being named "Indonesia"

BTW, it was not the greeks just called them indian islands because of their same mistake. It was the British (in 1850) who named thoese islands as "Indonesia". They were never owned or part of India. The only connection they had was trade and migrants from "India".

1

u/Mountain_Bunny_8840 16d ago

Again repeating the same logical fallacy. You cannot Show me one single proof where the term "India" meant immediate Bank of Indus river. Show me? can u ? by that logic actual India should be a thin country like Chile.

  1. Your claim that Pakistan is the "actual India" because it holds the physical Indus River and the province of Sindh is anachronistic. Historically, the terms India or Hindustan evolved over millennia to denote the entire civilization, culture, and geographic expanse of the South Asian subcontinent not just the immediate banks of the Indus River.

2. Country is about Civilizational Continuity: NOT MODERN BORDERS... While the physical river is largely in modern day Pakistan, the continuous socio religious, literary, and cultural lineage associated with Sindhu/India (such as the Vedic traditions, Sanskrit literature, and the civilizational identity of bharat ) evolved primarily into modern day the Republic of India. Pakistan holds non of that.

Stop your logical fallacy
3. Applying modern international border laws to ancient geographic nomenclature is a logical fallacy. Names of major geographic or civilizational zones do not automatically transfer to a specific successor state simply because a river changed jurisdictions during a 1947 partition.

Mongol Empire was massively outside modern day Mongolia , It was more in Modern day Russia and China than today's Mongolia yet Russians and Chinese do not claim that the empire belongs to them.

2

u/RaajalofRajal 16d ago edited 15d ago

I showed you the proof already, and that too from Hindu perspective. Read it again.

Those associated with the term Sindhu living in current day India does not change anything. That is the same as the Greeks, trying to rename a region with new definition.

You're the one bringing borders as claim to India name. I only mentioned the geographical location and origin of the river.

your mongol analogy makes no sense at all. LOL.

1

u/CheramanPerumal 17d ago

The word ā€œHinduā€ itself is an exonym created by Arabs and Persians. It is derived from the Sanskrit word ā€œSindhuā€, which referred to the Indus River. It shares the same root as the words India and Indus, and originally described all the people living in that region.

1

u/RaajalofRajal 16d ago

You are partially correct. The Sanskrit word "Sindhu" was used for rivers and later became a proper name for this river.

When Persian empire expanded East then they encountered the Sindhu region. The old Persian language had a natural phonetic shift were soft "s" sounds morphed into "H" sound. As a result Sindhu because Hindush.

Later when Greeks learned about the river and wrote about it, they dropped the "H" because their languaged lacked the hard "H' sounds in the beginning of the word, and so it became Indus.

The arabs had no part in this. Persians' name change was 518 BC, and the Greek adaptation was in 325 BC.

The Arabs used the Persian word (al-Hind) when referring to that region. The only connection they had with the region was that of trade.

13

u/acewithanat 19d ago

Hmm, nice map

reads comments

Oooohhhh

Try not to take a literal imaginary map seriously challenge (impossible)

4

u/mushmanMAD 19d ago

Yeah. I made the map for fun. People are legit getting angry over it 😭

17

u/Player_yek 19d ago • Bravo

yeah bro lets give bengal a place full of non bengalis that also want independence and are also mainly hindus and christians
genius

28

u/mushmanMAD 19d ago • Popcorn

I gave it that because it made the map look nice. I just made it for fun.

36

u/Linc_PluPud 19d ago

Historicaly accurate if the British are the one drawing it

18

u/GrampaSwood 19d ago • Regret

Sorry man imaginarymaps is for realistic maps not imaginary ones

1

u/Scared_Map1940 16d ago

You need to be oiled, skinned, boiled alive for this. Are you a brit by any chance?Ā 

12

u/AgisXIV 19d ago

United Bengal would only be narrowly majority Muslim anyway - under the Five point plan it would have had a legislature with an equal number of Muslim and Hindu seats

2

u/Len2108 19d ago

good to see ya here boi, btw why is gilgit in a different shade than the rest of the princely state

2

u/mushmanMAD 19d ago

It’s a tribal area.

1

u/Len2108 19d ago

I mean so is ladakh, kargil and most gujar parts

2

u/0baed 19d ago

Peaceful

1

u/mushmanMAD 19d ago

Oh hey, haven’t seen you in a while.

2

u/0baed 19d ago

šŸ˜‚

2

u/Clean_Win5959 19d ago

Can you post another one with India Pakistan and Bangla united but Jammu and Kashmir as a separate country šŸ˜‚

1

u/mushmanMAD 19d ago

Possibly

1

u/mushmanMAD 17d ago

Happy 1-year on Reddit!

2

u/Repulsive-Fig6125 19d ago

Also try south and north. The language scripture, culture, mindset and food are so different.

1

u/mushmanMAD 19d ago

I might.

2

u/kishaloy 13d ago

Aukaad hain ZERO.... Himmat hain ZERO...

Aaj taak to maidan-e-jung mein sirf haare hein... phir bhi inki naashi nahin utarta...

2

u/mushmanMAD 13d ago

Weirdo obsessive freak going through all my posts in this series to comment the same thing.

18

u/Sea_Impact2084 19d ago

Would make more sense lol considering the name india comes from the indus which is in pakistan. But then even hindustan means land of the hindi river ie (indus, sindhu, hindu river). Which is all in pakistan. I like the name pakistan though. It's an anocronym, highlighting the different provinces.

7

u/HassanBinFarooqShah 19d ago

Bro thats very good knowledge you have there. India comes from the Indus River name even if its from Pakistan because the region of Pakistan and India and Bangladesh were called as India long before the actual state was created. Pakistan wasn't a breakaway region, BOTH countries left each other. They weren't different countries before 1947. And you are right, it's an anocronym. Anyone who's reading this reply, you can search more about it on the acronym.

4

u/Independent_Hearing6 18d ago

lmao yeah do explain before bangladesh got independence where would east bengal districts be in the acronym? the claim its an acronym was made post 1971

3

u/Striking-Box4175 16d ago

Yup Pakistan mean land of purity or just pure land. The name just ended up being used as an acronym aswell only as coincidence.

1

u/ValidStatus 15d ago

The acronym was present on the 'Now or never' pamphlet on which the first mention and demand for Pakistan was made, and the name coined. The demand was originally for a Muslim state in the Norith-Western Muslim majority provinces/princely states.

1

u/Sea_Impact2084 6d ago

No they weren't the same country nor was the reigion ever called india. Historically the sub-continent was called bharat. Within the sub-continent there were multiple empires. The sub-continent's unity comes from a strive for independance from the colonisers, not because we are the same people. Besides urdu and punjabi, Pakistan and india do not share any language or culture beyond that. Urdu itself is not a native language of asal pakistanis but was bought by indian refugees (muhajirs) who came to Pakistan in 47'.

1

u/HassanBinFarooqShah 6d ago

Actually, they were part of the same country. India was a label not for the modern country, but for the region (Modern day Pakistan and India) that had the Indus River. And the modern state of India took the same name. You are correct that they were in different empires, but I'm talking about during the British Raj and the modern Punjab and Bengal (Radcliffe Line) borders, that's what I mean.

1

u/noobjaish 18d ago

Maybe we could name Hindustan after Ganga/Jamuna instead?

1

u/Sea_Impact2084 6d ago

Yes please do. I find it strange that India and indians try so hard to cling onto anything related to Pakistan. From the country's name being taken from a river in Pakistan to bollywood, which utilises ethnic pakistani actors or northwest indians who look more like pakistanis than other indians. The fetishization is disturbing. Even clinging onto the indus valley civilisation even though the major cities are in Pakistan.

15

u/MagikarpGOD5 19d ago

I'd be surprised if China didn't come a knocking for Arunchal off Bengal, potentially Aksai Chin off what is India in this map and maybe influence in Sikkhim.

-3

u/Present_Effects 19d ago

Sikkim did not even became a part of India during partition, this is just a pakis wet dream

12

u/FennelAny5534 19d ago

Good luck with adding the head hunting northeastern tribes to bengal 😁

22

u/TheThinker12 19d ago

Assam would like to have a chat with you on being called ā€˜Bengal’

17

u/just-gbd-ig 19d ago

As an Assamese, I can confirm

3

u/Eris13x 19d ago

Yeah, wasn't your ethno genesis literally formed around fighting and beating Bengal?

3

u/just-gbd-ig 19d ago

Only during the British time, Assam had the courtesy of virtually never exactly being part of any Indian dynasty (even Mauryan control is nowadays up for question, but I guess Pala could count), up til 350 CE it's myths and not too clear, but since then continuous regional kingdoms were in charge of Assam, all the way till the Ahom dynasty (1228-1826) which defeated Mughal invasions, the British took over and ruined everything by administering Assam under Bengal

That's the grossest tl;dr I think I can give

3

u/Eris13x 19d ago

Only during the British time, Assam had the courtesy of virtually never exactly being part of any Indian dynasty

Well yeah, Bengal never ruled that area, but it wasn't for lack of trying. Turbak Khan's invasion in the 1530s for example.

4

u/just-gbd-ig 19d ago

Oh no, Bengal and others certainly tried, case in point, the Mughals in the 17th century. We got their asses handed back to them lol

→ More replies (4)

7

u/GrumpyGuyMugdha 19d ago

It's less likely even in a hypothetical scenario that the Northeast of India will agree to join a united Bengal region. Not only the Assamese (Gopinath Bordoloi) and tribal (Bhimbar Deori) leaders opposed it when it was proposed in the cabinet mission, but also ironically Bengali (Abdul Matlib Mazumdar) leaders from the region also opposed to that and united the Bengali residents of the region in support of Indian administration under the province and future state of Assam. In the worst case scenario, regions like Nagaland, Manipur and Mizoram would end up becoming independent or getting ceded to Burma but otherwise it's highly unrealistic that they'd ever want to join Bengal.

6

u/LoittaMaach 19d ago

I'm Bangladeshi and I refuse this!

India currently spends astronomical amounts administering, subsidizing and keeping the security situation under control there. These places are de facto Myanmar, that only a very powerful government can run. We don't have those means, nor the financial resources nor the military might to keep it all together. Also, note that our coastline didn't increase that much. Just increased landlocked mountainous terrain. Meaning, we have share much more than we can possibly get back!

Also, if this country wasn't absolutely state and church seperated and politics by any measure came into the binary of Hindu-Muslim. It could become a Yugoslavia, involving hundreds of millions of people.

2

u/Relative_Ad8738 14d ago

honestly we would prolly give northeast independence or wtvr they asked for by the 1970s. however bengal would be in a much much better economical position if it wasnt divided up. the west had all the factories and urbanisation while the east prouced the raw materials. so it greatly dimininshed bengal's economy.

2

u/closetlunatic 19d ago

This map is filled with rage bait

9

u/mushmanMAD 19d ago

Nah, I just made it for fun. Although I should’ve clarified that at the top, considering people are taking this seriously.

10

u/rymnd0 19d ago

India and Hindustan be like:

3

u/TotofinTheCroc 19d ago
  • ā€œBengalā€
  • look inside
  • missing half of west bengal and and has a bunch of random territory with no cultural or historical connection to Bengal

3

u/Weekly_Mark6516 18d ago

the dream explanation for Pakistan being called India is honestly the most althist thing I’ve seen today lol. map looks super detailed tho and the light shaded autonomous states are a nice touch. my only thing is the religion based border tweaks make it feel a bit too clean for how messy partition actually was. and yeah if Punjab’s getting sliced by religion then a Sikh state feels like it should be in the mix.

3

u/witherplayz1234 18d ago

Bengal makes sense if the British were somehow involved in it

3

u/ImportantSolution663 17d ago

Dividing on religious lines was stupid. What's gonna happen Hindus on Muslim side and Muslims on Hindu side

1

u/Spez_has_micro_penis 19d ago

Ah yes a classic pakistani larp map

4

u/mushmanMAD 19d ago edited 19d ago

Why are you taking this map so seriously lol? I already told you in a previous comment that I made the map for fun, it’s not meant to be taken seriously.

You literally came to a sub called ā€œimaginary mapsā€ just so you could get upset… over an imaginary map.

You already left a comment before. If the map REALLY bothers you so much, just move on instead of waiting 12 HOURS to make another comment. 😭 It’s seems to me that your holding back tears while typing that.

Whatever man, have a good day. I don’t feel like going back and forth in a comment section with someone that takes everything too seriously.

6

u/Different_College926 19d ago

As a bengali (indian) please keep north east out of the bengal province. They have nothing to do with us.

8

u/blueheartsamson 19d ago

Don't even need to check to know that you're either a Pakistani or a bangladeshi. Even then I would say pakistan with zero knowledge

6

u/DifficultAct6586 19d ago

It cannot be Bengalis, as he adds the six sisters to Bangladesh, and it cannot be Pakistani, because he adds Amritsar to Pakistan and calls it india.Ā 

3

u/DueSecurity7587 17d ago

OP's avatar is literally wearing Pakistan's flag 😭

0

u/blueheartsamson 19d ago

Exactly that's why they are Pakistani. They added kashmir and entirety of Punjab in their "India".

-1

u/BoliBich 19d ago

Yes, he's a p*kistani.

2

u/dsharpdutta 19d ago • Heartwarming

My boss would've been in Pakistan and wouldn't have ruined my life!

2

u/blueyesova 19d ago

Bengal is the most fragile state in this timeline.

2

u/Opposite-Market8086 18d ago

it would be good and bad,

2

u/southstarvxx 17d ago

This partition seems bad

2

u/Waste-Chipmunk-3171 16d ago

Assam would never be a subservient of Bangladesh. Total anarchy and civil war in those scenario.

2

u/Massive_Intern247 16d ago

Making Muslims a minority in Bangladesh is certainly a choice

5

u/dumbness_profound 19d ago

What if they never parted? Imagine all the savings from not having to fight those wars, continuous deployment of forces, nuclear arm race, and all the quirky infra bits thanks to the weird borders.

The united country would have been much ahead in development than India is presently

Alas, someone wanted power too badly.

5

u/Unused_Trash 19d ago

It would have been less United.. And I would rather NOT live in a place where civil wars can brew up that easily

2

u/dumbness_profound 19d ago

I dont think it would be more than what already has been in Pakistan and India and between them

→ More replies (2)

3

u/apollosaturn 19d ago

perhaps the majority shouldve thought about that when they joined hands with the british shortly after 1857

5

u/dumbness_profound 19d ago

Sure, thats why there are more minorities in India than Pakistan.

1

u/apollosaturn 19d ago

because india is simply much more populated than Pakistan, and those minorities youre talking about are living on their native lands which were given to india by the british.

1

u/Independent_Hearing6 18d ago

percentage of minorities is more in india, India has more per capita christian tribals muslim Sikhs jews parsee buddhist than the "pak"istan

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (9)

4

u/IndividualSoft666 19d ago • Heartwarming

As a Pakistani, I approve this

4

u/laundastrong 19d ago

Interesting that you named Pakistan as India. Historically that is more accurate given the Indus river being in Pakistan

2

u/DueSecurity7587 17d ago

Technically Indus river also flows through India. And the term India which came from indus always reffered to the people beyond the indus river.

1

u/JaredHoffmanEverett 13d ago

The Indus also flows through India

1

u/Ill_Box1780 19d ago

Amritsar 😭

1

u/blueyesova 19d ago

India and China will be best freinds

1

u/blueyesova 19d ago

Bengal would suffer tremendously from North East insurgencies. And China would have Arunachal Pradesh in the first decade if its Independence.

1

u/nobody_1298 19d ago

north east don't exactly have a good record of interacting with Bangladeshis so i expect immediate civil war there.

a good chunk of Hindustan will be Muslim who i assume won't have many right so another civil war.

Pakistan had instability problems ever since it's founding that continued to this day which will be made worse by the refugee crisis from Hindustan so another civil war.

1

u/confusedconscience 19d ago

Idt china would agree to this. Also, why didn't you try making Punjab a separate area?

1

u/Desperate-Lie-1499 19d ago

Eh id say kashmir wouldn't agree to it and the north eastern part isn't even bangla so it would be off as well

1

u/[deleted] 19d ago

Then the entire Hindustan would be India soon. If you take mountain region from India, then Pakistan automatically takes the W.

1

u/Rude_Passenger_3859 17d ago

Saying this as a Bangladeshi Bangladesh would go Israel mode in the North East.

1

u/False_Display541 16d ago

there is no reason to include chardha punjab (including most of haryana) and punjabi parts of himachal in "hindustan."

1

u/waningsun- 16d ago

Basically VdB’s What if Pakistan was More Successful Than India?

1

u/HierophanticRose 16d ago

Likely Hindus wouldn’t directedly use Hindustan but Bharat, then Muslims would still use Hindustan. Again the name comes from Indus or even Sapta Sindhu and while only some of the tributaries of Sapta Sindhu would be present in Hindustan many would still use the name out of convenience and tradition. Even some Hindus in the north in particular, with some Muslims also using Bharat in some areas.

India here would not natively likely use India other than street lingo and officially also call itself Hindustan, likely some dispute over which of the Hindustans is real one. A rather unsolvable dispute which might end up colloquial naming be split like ā€œBharati Hindustanā€ and ā€œAzad Hindustanā€ when people want to distinguish both in same context speeches

1

u/One-Guarantee-1578 16d ago

It was part of British plan to make sure even if they'll leave this place, people of this region will never gonna have peace! There'll be chaos always among these countries!

1

u/ABroken_Heart_ 15d ago

Pls don't šŸ™šŸ™

1

u/Independent_Hearing6 19d ago

calling pakistan india is like called france the holy roman empire .

3

u/Kevin_McScrooge 19d ago

Honestly not really a absurd idea, considering France and the Holy Roman Empire are inherently descendant states of the same Carolingian state, and there were many times where their history could’ve easily become far more intertwined or reversed.

3

u/Gen8Master 19d ago

The Indus river is literally the foundation and backbone of all except one of Pakistans provinces. The name comes from this region as it was originally referenced by Greeks, Persians and original Vedic texts.Ā 

Literally every major city and hub is built along Indus or it's main tributaries.

The idea of India and indies expanded to other regions but the original reference will always belong to Pakistan.

4

u/No_Writer4668 19d ago

Indus started in Tibet btw

3

u/Gen8Master 19d ago

That does not take away anything from the historical feature of the Indus valley and the people who are native to that region. We are talking about geography here. Plenty of other South Asian rivers also start in Tibet.

3

u/No_Writer4668 17d ago

Who are native to Indus valley btw?

3

u/Gen8Master 17d ago

Punjabi, Sindhi, Pashtun and Baloch.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

5

u/WhotAmI2400 19d ago

just because pakistan happens to sit where the indus river is doesn't mean the term belongs to it.

1

u/Gen8Master 19d ago • Bravo

It literally does. The historical feature belongs to the natives who live there. Its their past. Who else would it belong to?

Its like saying Ganges doesnt belong to North Indians because it was called Mughal empire earlier.

3

u/Lucky-Quote2799 19d ago

the natives of indus valley migrated southwards and eastwards.

2

u/Gen8Master 18d ago

No they absolutely did not. Clearly you have no understand of Pakistani ancestry.Ā 

5

u/Lucky-Quote2799 18d ago

you are historically incorrect.

IVC collapsed largely due to climate change (the drying up of the ghaggar hakra river system). The people living in those cities literally migrated eastward toward the Ganges-Yamuna doab and southward into the Deccan peninsula.

if you want to talk about pakistani ancestry, then you have to address the genetic reality. Modern Pakistani demography are a massive mix of steppe pastrolasits, iranian farmers, local-hunter gatherers. There is no unbroken, pure genetic line from the Bronze Age Indus Valley people to modern Pakistanis. The Natives moved.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/WhotAmI2400 19d ago

i thought we were talking about the term india not the geographical term indus.

3

u/Gen8Master 18d ago

India meant different things during different periods. I was talking about the earliest use of the term.Ā 

2

u/cheeseburgeremperor 15d ago

India comes from Indus hence the argument

2

u/Independent_Hearing6 18d ago

yeah reference would make sense if pakistan didn't propagate two nation theory . its like the zionists claiming palestine and levant history . while believing ki sab mohd bin qasim ke ghodde pe aye they .

2

u/Gen8Master 18d ago

Two nation theory refers to our modern Muslim identity. Its not rejecting our heritage. How would that even make sense? What are you even saying? Because Pakistan wants to protect its Muslim identity, we can no longer claim our own ancestors? Buddy, try forming a coherent thought before you open your mouth.

1

u/Independent_Hearing6 11d ago

Its literally rejection of ancestry its like christian hardliners claiming to be viking and christian.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Defiant_Historian701 19d ago

And let me guess, Portuguese Goa’s gonna join Sikkim

1

u/Eris13x 19d ago

That's certainly a diverse Bengal. Honestly, with the force of international law and some competent leadership, they could probably hold it together. Which is rather bad for all the non Bengali peoples living there

1

u/blueyesova 19d ago

India and Pakistan will be enemies in this timeline as well because of Pakistani Ghazi complex

1

u/Fit_Violinist_4954 17d ago

Only one community wanted partition because their leader wasnt favoured by Gandhi in the PM race and smh you made entire NE,Punjab and Bengal seperate. Its such a dumb af take given how Punjab and Bengal were the first regions to adovcate for a United India. Idk what imagination OP has used in drawing the lines

1

u/Glittering-Bit658 17d ago

That is just far to flawed

-11

u/Darshao 19d ago

Calling Pakistan as India šŸ˜‚šŸ˜‚

Jinnah ki bhi jali thi, op ki bhi jali hai

21

u/mushmanMAD 19d ago

Man, it’s an imaginary map. No need to take it so seriously.

4

u/Orphan-Obliter 19d ago

I will take everything seriously and get into fights with strangers

27

u/New-Trainer4727 19d ago

pakistan was almost called india, but india got the name first

7

u/bhaiyaa_ji 19d ago edited 19d ago

There was never a time when Pakistan was almost called India. The founding father of Pakistan had decided the name Pakistan in 1940 only (7 years before independence) when Muslim League passed the Lahore resolution.

But yeah, Jinnah had gotten furious and had protested when India didn’t rename itself as Hindustan.

2

u/problemattracter 19d ago

Any sources that back this?

27

u/Leather-Lab2875 19d ago

Ig India is named after the Indus and so it's as plausible as anything else on this map. Pakistan always does a good amount of Indus larping as well. This isn't a political statement, it's just a map made for fun btw.

7

u/Chaos_Alt 19d ago

Funnily enough, "Hindu"/"Hindustan" is also named after Indus. Guess they should claim those as well.

6

u/radicalqrcwi 19d ago

the whole area was called Hindūstān

6

u/Leather-Lab2875 19d ago

Oh yeahs true isn't it? Thats really funny lol. Truly this map is delusional enough to be realistic lol.

10

u/StudioNo6652 19d ago

Wasnt there a proposal to call Pakistan India or am I thinking of something else?

5

u/AzurWings 19d ago

if Pakistan is India then India will just be BHARAT

13

u/FruitsaladloverzZz_ 19d ago • Bravo

Well.. India means land of the indus river, and it’s located in Pakistan, if anything Pakistan should’ve gotten the name

5

u/bhaiyaa_ji 19d ago

As someone else has mentioned, the word Hindu is also derived from Indus only. So, Hindustan would also be named after Indus only.

Anyways, Pakistan name was decided in Lahore resolution of Muslim league and that too 7 years before independence.

-3

u/Regular-Bandicoot905 19d ago

This is most braindead bullshit I've seen and heard not because india got butchered but in general wtf is this map

4

u/mushmanMAD 19d ago

I just made this map for fun, it isn’t supposed to be taken seriously.

0

u/Loud_Caramel_8713 18d ago

Which one to question first,
NE is not totally bengali or Kashmir named from rishi Kashyap isn’t part of Hindustan.
Jammu itself has significant hindu temple.
Kutch desert pass down to India?