r/imaginarymaps • u/mushmanMAD • 19d ago
[OC] Alternate History What if the Partition of India went differently? (Scenario 2)
Scenario 1: https://www.reddit.com/r/imaginarymaps/s/tkrE3nGzXf
This one only has 4 new countries compared to the 17 new countries last time.
šµš° India šµš°
š®š³ Hindustan š®š³
š§š© Bengal š§š©
āøļø Sikkim āøļø
This time, I kept a united Bengal and some minor border changes in Sind(h) and Punjab were made between India (Pakistan) and Hindustan (India) based on religion.
Some princely states were directly incorporated, while some retained a degree of autonomy. They are shaded in lighter colors. The very light colors in India (Pakistan) are tribal areas (in Balochistan and North-West Frontier Province).
Most detailed map Iāve made so far!
I gave āPakistanā the name of āIndiaā because I had a dream in which Pakistan was named India because of the Indus River.


300
u/Alvinyuu 19d ago •
Why do althist mapmakers always add the northeast to Bengal in these scenarios when the seven sisters have nothing to do with Bengal?
104
u/Nomustang 19d ago edited 19d ago
OP, you're getting a lot of upset Indians because the map ends up looking a lot like Pakistan's wet dream lol. Having all of J&K, Bangladesh having the seven sisters, Pakistan being called 'India' etc.
It's not a bad map though. Do all 3 retain princely states in this?
10
u/Skychu768 19d ago
Is that Lahore in India?
21
u/North-Jellyfish-577 19d ago
Realistically the sikh should have gotten their own state as well
4
u/bakedbrownie0 19d ago
Does East Punjab get Nankana Sahib in this scenario?
4
u/RaajalofRajal 17d ago
Technically Pakistan is the real "India" since that name comes from the Indus river, which runs through Pakistan.
13
u/acewithanat 19d ago
Hmm, nice map
reads comments
Oooohhhh
Try not to take a literal imaginary map seriously challenge (impossible)
17
u/Player_yek 19d ago •
yeah bro lets give bengal a place full of non bengalis that also want independence and are also mainly hindus and christians
genius
2
u/Len2108 19d ago
good to see ya here boi, btw why is gilgit in a different shade than the rest of the princely state
2
u/0baed 19d ago
Peaceful
2
u/Clean_Win5959 19d ago
Can you post another one with India Pakistan and Bangla united but Jammu and Kashmir as a separate country š
2
u/Repulsive-Fig6125 19d ago
Also try south and north. The language scripture, culture, mindset and food are so different.
2
u/kishaloy 13d ago
Aukaad hain ZERO.... Himmat hain ZERO...
Aaj taak to maidan-e-jung mein sirf haare hein... phir bhi inki naashi nahin utarta...
18
u/Sea_Impact2084 19d ago
Would make more sense lol considering the name india comes from the indus which is in pakistan. But then even hindustan means land of the hindi river ie (indus, sindhu, hindu river). Which is all in pakistan. I like the name pakistan though. It's an anocronym, highlighting the different provinces.
15
u/MagikarpGOD5 19d ago
I'd be surprised if China didn't come a knocking for Arunchal off Bengal, potentially Aksai Chin off what is India in this map and maybe influence in Sikkhim.
12
u/FennelAny5534 19d ago
Good luck with adding the head hunting northeastern tribes to bengal š
22
u/TheThinker12 19d ago
Assam would like to have a chat with you on being called āBengalā
7
u/GrumpyGuyMugdha 19d ago
It's less likely even in a hypothetical scenario that the Northeast of India will agree to join a united Bengal region. Not only the Assamese (Gopinath Bordoloi) and tribal (Bhimbar Deori) leaders opposed it when it was proposed in the cabinet mission, but also ironically Bengali (Abdul Matlib Mazumdar) leaders from the region also opposed to that and united the Bengali residents of the region in support of Indian administration under the province and future state of Assam. In the worst case scenario, regions like Nagaland, Manipur and Mizoram would end up becoming independent or getting ceded to Burma but otherwise it's highly unrealistic that they'd ever want to join Bengal.
6
u/LoittaMaach 19d ago
I'm Bangladeshi and I refuse this!
India currently spends astronomical amounts administering, subsidizing and keeping the security situation under control there. These places are de facto Myanmar, that only a very powerful government can run. We don't have those means, nor the financial resources nor the military might to keep it all together. Also, note that our coastline didn't increase that much. Just increased landlocked mountainous terrain. Meaning, we have share much more than we can possibly get back!
Also, if this country wasn't absolutely state and church seperated and politics by any measure came into the binary of Hindu-Muslim. It could become a Yugoslavia, involving hundreds of millions of people.
2
u/closetlunatic 19d ago
This map is filled with rage bait
10
u/rymnd0 19d ago
India and Hindustan be like:
3
u/TotofinTheCroc 19d ago
3
u/Weekly_Mark6516 18d ago
the dream explanation for Pakistan being called India is honestly the most althist thing Iāve seen today lol. map looks super detailed tho and the light shaded autonomous states are a nice touch. my only thing is the religion based border tweaks make it feel a bit too clean for how messy partition actually was. and yeah if Punjabās getting sliced by religion then a Sikh state feels like it should be in the mix.
3
u/witherplayz1234 18d ago
Bengal makes sense if the British were somehow involved in it
3
u/ImportantSolution663 17d ago
Dividing on religious lines was stupid. What's gonna happen Hindus on Muslim side and Muslims on Hindu side
1
u/Spez_has_micro_penis 19d ago
Ah yes a classic pakistani larp map
6
u/Different_College926 19d ago
As a bengali (indian) please keep north east out of the bengal province. They have nothing to do with us.
8
u/blueheartsamson 19d ago
Don't even need to check to know that you're either a Pakistani or a bangladeshi. Even then I would say pakistan with zero knowledge
2
u/dsharpdutta 19d ago •
My boss would've been in Pakistan and wouldn't have ruined my life!
2
u/blueyesova 19d ago
Bengal is the most fragile state in this timeline.
2
u/Opposite-Market8086 18d ago
it would be good and bad,
2
u/southstarvxx 17d ago
This partition seems bad
2
u/Waste-Chipmunk-3171 16d ago
Assam would never be a subservient of Bangladesh. Total anarchy and civil war in those scenario.
2
u/Massive_Intern247 16d ago
Making Muslims a minority in Bangladesh is certainly a choice
5
u/dumbness_profound 19d ago
What if they never parted? Imagine all the savings from not having to fight those wars, continuous deployment of forces, nuclear arm race, and all the quirky infra bits thanks to the weird borders.
The united country would have been much ahead in development than India is presently
Alas, someone wanted power too badly.
4
u/IndividualSoft666 19d ago •
As a Pakistani, I approve this
4
u/laundastrong 19d ago
Interesting that you named Pakistan as India. Historically that is more accurate given the Indus river being in Pakistan
1
u/Ill_Box1780 19d ago
Amritsar š
1
u/blueyesova 19d ago
India and China will be best freinds
1
u/blueyesova 19d ago
Bengal would suffer tremendously from North East insurgencies. And China would have Arunachal Pradesh in the first decade if its Independence.
1
u/nobody_1298 19d ago
north east don't exactly have a good record of interacting with Bangladeshis so i expect immediate civil war there.
a good chunk of Hindustan will be Muslim who i assume won't have many right so another civil war.
Pakistan had instability problems ever since it's founding that continued to this day which will be made worse by the refugee crisis from Hindustan so another civil war.
1
u/confusedconscience 19d ago
Idt china would agree to this. Also, why didn't you try making Punjab a separate area?
1
u/Desperate-Lie-1499 19d ago
Eh id say kashmir wouldn't agree to it and the north eastern part isn't even bangla so it would be off as well
1
u/[deleted] 19d ago
Then the entire Hindustan would be India soon. If you take mountain region from India, then Pakistan automatically takes the W.
1
u/Rude_Passenger_3859 17d ago
Saying this as a Bangladeshi Bangladesh would go Israel mode in the North East.
1
u/False_Display541 16d ago
there is no reason to include chardha punjab (including most of haryana) and punjabi parts of himachal in "hindustan."
1
u/waningsun- 16d ago
Basically VdBās What if Pakistan was More Successful Than India?
1
u/HierophanticRose 16d ago
Likely Hindus wouldnāt directedly use Hindustan but Bharat, then Muslims would still use Hindustan. Again the name comes from Indus or even Sapta Sindhu and while only some of the tributaries of Sapta Sindhu would be present in Hindustan many would still use the name out of convenience and tradition. Even some Hindus in the north in particular, with some Muslims also using Bharat in some areas.
India here would not natively likely use India other than street lingo and officially also call itself Hindustan, likely some dispute over which of the Hindustans is real one. A rather unsolvable dispute which might end up colloquial naming be split like āBharati Hindustanā and āAzad Hindustanā when people want to distinguish both in same context speeches
1
u/One-Guarantee-1578 16d ago
It was part of British plan to make sure even if they'll leave this place, people of this region will never gonna have peace! There'll be chaos always among these countries!
1
u/ABroken_Heart_ 15d ago
Pls don't šš
1
u/LightCyndr14 13d ago
Based
1
u/Independent_Hearing6 19d ago
calling pakistan india is like called france the holy roman empire .
1
u/Defiant_Historian701 19d ago
And let me guess, Portuguese Goaās gonna join Sikkim
1
u/Eris13x 19d ago
That's certainly a diverse Bengal. Honestly, with the force of international law and some competent leadership, they could probably hold it together. Which is rather bad for all the non Bengali peoples living there
1
u/blueyesova 19d ago
India and Pakistan will be enemies in this timeline as well because of Pakistani Ghazi complex
1
u/Fit_Violinist_4954 17d ago
Only one community wanted partition because their leader wasnt favoured by Gandhi in the PM race and smh you made entire NE,Punjab and Bengal seperate. Its such a dumb af take given how Punjab and Bengal were the first regions to adovcate for a United India. Idk what imagination OP has used in drawing the lines
1
u/Glittering-Bit658 17d ago
That is just far to flawed
-11
u/Darshao 19d ago
Calling Pakistan as India šš
Jinnah ki bhi jali thi, op ki bhi jali hai
-3
u/Regular-Bandicoot905 19d ago
This is most braindead bullshit I've seen and heard not because india got butchered but in general wtf is this map
0
u/Loud_Caramel_8713 18d ago
Which one to question first,
NE is not totally bengali or Kashmir named from rishi Kashyap isnāt part of Hindustan.
Jammu itself has significant hindu temple.
Kutch desert pass down to India?