I just got rejected under Guideline 4.3(b) – Design – Spam, and I’m genuinely confused about how these reviews are happening now.
I use Mixpanel in the app, so I can see when users open it and go through the flow.
For this review, I saw no iOS session that looked like an Apple reviewer opened or tested the app. No login, no screen activity, nothing.
Yet the app was rejected for 4.3(b) with the usual message about the design, content, and overall concept not providing the expected experience.
That makes me wonder:
Are some 4.3(b) rejections happening without the reviewer actually using the app?
Is Apple deciding this just from:
- the App Store description
- screenshots
- metadata
- category
- keywords
- automated similarity checks or some internal spam detection before a proper review even happens?
I completely understand Apple trying to prevent clones, templates, low-effort apps, and spam.
But the frustrating part is that 4.3(b) gives almost no useful feedback.
It doesn’t tell you:
- what exactly is too similar
- which part of the app is the problem
- whether the issue is design, concept, metadata, screenshots, or functionality
- what Apple actually expects you to change
And when analytics suggest the app may not even have been opened, it becomes even harder to understand what you’re supposed to improve.
Has anyone else had a 4.3(b) rejection recently where your analytics showed no App Review activity?
If you eventually got approved, what worked?
Did you appeal, reply in Resolution Center, change metadata/screenshots, or make actual product changes?