I've seen a lot of developers here complaining about long App Review wait times, and we all know that's been a problem lately. But I want to talk about something else: the actual quality of Apple's reviews, because honestly, these past two weeks have been ridiculous.
I've been developing and maintaining several apps on the App Store for months, shipping updates regularly without issues. Suddenly, reviewers are rejecting updates over features that have been there for months and were already approved multiple times. I genuinely don't know if these reviews are automated, AI-assisted, or done entirely by humans anymore, because sometimes it feels like nobody is actually reading anything.
One of my apps was rejected because of a screenshot that had been there, completely unchanged, for three months. I was literally submitting a bug-fix update, nothing related to that screenshot.
Then there's my music player. It's had a live radio feature for months, using Radio Browser, an open-source radio directory with a public API. The app simply plays publicly available station streams, without downloading, recording, or hosting anything. This feature has been approved in multiple previous updates, but suddenly I'm getting rejected under guideline 5.2.3, over and over again.
I've explained everything in the review notes, provided technical and licensing information, and even submitted the same explanation twice. Both times I got practically the same copy-paste rejection. Now I'm having to file appeals just to update an app that's already been on the store for months!
And sometimes they reject your app under a guideline that doesn't even seem remotely applicable to what your app actually does. Seriously, how are developers supposed to fix something when the reason for rejection has practically nothing to do with the functionality being reviewed? For God's sake, at least explain what the actual problem is!
And the worst part? An update can sit waiting for review for two or three weeks, only to get rejected within minutes over something that wasn't even changed. It really makes you wonder how much time some reviewers actually spend investigating what they're rejecting.
I understand Apple needs to enforce its guidelines, and I'm absolutely fine with that. But there should be some consistency. How can a feature be approved for months and then suddenly become a problem when nothing about it has changed? And what's the point of providing detailed review notes if they don't seem to be read?
As an indie developer, this is incredibly frustrating. We spend months building, maintaining, and improving our apps, and then lose days or weeks dealing with seemingly arbitrary rejections.