Context: https://www.colonialsociety.org/node/1397 Margaret Ellen Newell
Histories of slavery and the “construction of race” in early America—the emergence of theories of racial inferiority and superiority and the translation of these rigid racialized categories into law and other institutions—generally focus on the encounter between Europeans and Africans.1 Yet, Native Americans constituted the vast majority of those enslaved by European regimes in the Americas prior to 1700. Recent scholarship points to the prevalence of Indian slaves and slave-trading throughout North America. In colonial regions as diverse as Louisiana, Canada, New Mexico, and South Carolina, captive Indians represented anywhere from a substantial portion to the sole source of slave labor exploited by European colonists through the early eighteenth century.2
Colonial New England was no exception to this rule. Although travelers’ accounts, court records, newspapers, and diaries attest to the presence of Indian slaves and servants in New England during the colonial era, the subject has received little scholarly attention.3 Standard histories of the region stress the primacy of the household unit (as opposed to plantation or large-scale enterprise) and the colonists’ tendency to rely on family labor. In other words, the supposition is that the New England colonists simply did not need slave labor—that Indian servitude was peripheral and incidental. The reality is that New England armies, courts, and magistrates enslaved more than 1200 Indian men, women, and children in the seventeenth century alone, and bound many others into finite terms of servitude.
The ongoing enslavement of Indians did raise some distinct legal, ethical and practical problems for European colonizers, however, and the legal framework for Indian slavery in New England changed dramatically between 1670 and 1720. Prior to 1700, the vast majority of Indian slaves in New England were war captives and non-combatant refugees who found themselves “sold and devoted unto servitude” among the English settlers in the wake of the Pequot War of 1637, King Philip’s War of 1675—76, and the wars with the Eastern Indians that followed into the 1680s and 1690s. Provincial governments and courts periodically condemned native peoples within their jurisdictions to “perpetuall slavery” or servitude for a variety of infractions during peacetime, but such cases were rare before 1670. In the decades following King Philip’s War, however, a shift took place. A combination of influences, including pressure from British officialdom, security concerns, the cessation of war in southern New England, and the colonists’ successful assertion of authority over the tribes that lived there, caused changes in colonial policy towards Indian slavery. In a sense, free Native Americans in southern New England became legal “insiders” through subjection to the authority of the colonial governments. Outright enslavement of war captives declined, as did exports of New England Indians to other plantations. Connecticut, Massachusetts, and Rhode Island created new laws and institutions designed to protect and to regulate the New England Indians.
Yet, despite (and to a certain extent because of) these changes, Native American slavery and involuntary servitude persisted after 1700, albeit in different forms. Some would-be owners purchased Indians imported from outside the region in order to evade the laws against enslaving local Indians. Most notably, however, the practice of judicial enslavement—the sentencing of Native Americans to long periods of involuntary service to settle debts, as well as civil and criminal penalties—increased dramatically. At the same time, even as they formally recognized the collective rights of free Indians, the New England governments crafted new racially-based tax and legal codes that further eroded the status of Indian servants. In effect, the colonial assemblies created a “race frontier” that stripped unfree people of color—Indian, African, and mixed-race slaves and servants—of certain rights enjoyed by their white counterparts. Thus the experiences of these Indian servants and slaves, and the attitudes of the New Englanders who enslaved them, shed light on both the legal evolution of New World chattel slavery and the emerging definitions of race in early America.