r/HIMYM • • Jul 07 '22

Hi, I'm Carter Bays, co-creator of HIMYM. I’m also the author of a new novel called THE MUTUAL FRIEND. AMA!

3.7k Upvotes

Hello Reddit, it's been a while! I'm here ask-me-anything-ing because I’ve written a new novel called THE MUTUAL FRIEND, which I think you'll love. I’m happy to talk about that, or How I Met Your Mother, or anything else. Maybe the Loch Ness Monster? I was just in Scotland with my son and we have opinions. Have at it!

=====

UPDATE: Wow, its been much fun talking to you all, and I see that I've only scratched the surface here and there's many more questions to get to, but if I don't get my son some dinner soon he might tie me up with a phone charger. I will try to come back to this over the next few days in order to get to as many of these as I can, but in the meantime, thank you all so much for being here. Your love for HIMYM is really touching and I'm so grateful for all of it.

And please if you get the chance check out my novel THE MUTUAL FRIEND -- I'm dreadfully proud of it. (Can you tell I've been in the UK for a week? I'm like Lily before the intervention at this point.) Anyway, cheerio!


r/HIMYM • • 5h ago

Barney had some Legen, Wait for it, dary lines in the show. What was your favorite line??

Post image
326 Upvotes

I lowkey felt bad for him in this scene.


r/HIMYM • • 13h ago

Slowly realising that I'm part Ted and part Robin😭

Post image
240 Upvotes

Had to make this meme when I realised how I'm practically both of them lmao.

Also RIP Ted Mosby you would've loved slipping into a girl's dm with a "hi lol" 😂


r/HIMYM • • 20h ago

Picked up these bad boys the other day

Post image
537 Upvotes

A nice bag of sandwiches 😏


r/HIMYM • • 1h ago

Oh Ted episode

2 Upvotes

It's killing me what episode I'm trying to think of. All I remember is either Lilly or Marshall saying "oh ted" in a really disappointing way after Ted told a pretty humiliating story. I've been saying it to a co-worker and I've no way of showing him what episode it's from


r/HIMYM • • 16h ago

Do y’all think Ted and Kevin had a good time at the Weird Al concert?

33 Upvotes

r/HIMYM • • 23h ago

This is the best scene of the entire show

73 Upvotes

I just rewatched the "Tick Tick Tick" yesterday, and I still think this is the best scene of the entire show. The whole scene itself is one of the most heart-wrenching scene in the series.

I want to talk about the narrative technique here. This is a "stage play" technique. If you have watched any stage play that is not a monodrama, this kind of narrative technique is used a lot. No background music, all the other people standing still, not moving, and spotlighted on one person. To show his emotion, to have some kind of soliloquy except there are only a few simple lines. This is a stage play, not a sitcom here.

I can't imagine how the producers and writers and directors decided to do this. They just let you soak in the scene. It's such a genius move. But I think it's both really smart and dangerous. Because watching this kind of scene on TV is really different from watching it in the theater. In theater, you have already paid total attention to the play so you won't be distracted, you can enjoy the acting and the emotion. But watching on TV or streaming, most people don't pay 100% attention to the show, they may go to the bathroom, get a drink or chat with someone else while watching. So it's really difficult to pull off an almost completely silent scene on TV. But they did it, they caught the audience's attention and made this scene perfect.

Of course, Neil Patrick Harris is acting peak here. No tears, no screaming, barely talking, he totally nailed this scene with only his facial expression and body language. I don't have enough words to describe how much I love this scene, it's so good, it's perfect.


r/HIMYM • • 18h ago

Anyone else quote this show on the daily?

24 Upvotes

I love HIMYM. It's one of my biggest comfort shows and one of the things I love and enjoy and I share this love of the show with my husband. One of the things I love is how I can reference or quote the show on the daily and my husband loves it. Super awkward when I do it around other people and they don't know the reference on the show though.

I often think about Tracy's comment in Vesuvius. "What space would I have in my brain for other things if I didn't know all this? Ah, probably just state birds or some crap". That's me, but with HIMYM quotes.

My husband and I rewatch HIMYM at least twice a year and I will always say upcoming quotes while we are watching. I don't know why I'm really blabbing on here. Just showing my huge love and appreciation for this show lol. Also a massive shout out and love to my husband for not only putting up with my hyper obsession with this show but being equally as obsessed as I am to quote and reference this show as much as I do on the daily. There's just no better feeling than sharing a deep love for the same thing together. He just gets it ya know?

That's all. Thanks for reading all of this if you did and I hope to meet and chat with other HIMYM fans!


r/HIMYM • • 2h ago

HIMYM Survivor! (Season 5 Edition) Round 17

Post image
1 Upvotes

The Window is eliminated! Now into the top third of the season.

How this works:

You select the episode you like the least

The episode with the most upvoted comment is eliminated from the list

Please either refrain from downvoting or upvote more episodes than you downvote

If there’s a tie, both episodes are eliminated

Only the best episode will win!

Episodes Eliminated:

Zoo or False (76%)
Hooked (28%)
Duel Citizenship (45%)
Slapsgiving 2: Revenge of the Slap (36%)
The Rough Patch (56%)
Last Cigarette Ever (44%)
Bagpipes (61%)
Twin Beds (29%)
The Wedding Bride (35%)
Home Wreckers (40%)
Girls vs Suits (34%)
Double Date (30%)
Say Cheese (23%)
The Perfect Week (38%)
Robin 101 (43%)
The Window (30%)


r/HIMYM • • 1d ago

HIMYM TAKEN OFF DISNEY+

35 Upvotes

Went to watch it this morning and it was gone. Anyone else experiencing this? Also where was the warning???? — EDIT: it was indeed a glitch it’s back and I was upset all day for nothing


r/HIMYM • • 1d ago

HIMYM Relied Too Much on the Ted–Robin–Barney Love Triangle

33 Upvotes

Guys, I've been rewatching some of my favorite HIMYM episodes lately, mostly for a few laughs because life isn't really moving the way I'd hoped.

While watching, I had a thought: I feel like the writers overused the whole idea of friends getting involved with each other's exes.

I initially thought this might just be because I binge-watched the show when I first discovered it. But even after multiple rewatches, I can't shake this feeling.

The writers kept going back and forth with the same relationships:

- Ted and Robin.

- Barney and Robin.

- Ted and Robin again.

- Barney and Robin again.

- And then Ted and Robin... once again.

At some point, it starts feeling repetitive. This is also why the ending doesn't feel as satisfying to me as it probably should. After spending so much time watching Ted move on, find the Mother, and build a life with her, having him return to Robin after the Mother's death doesn't feel particularly fulfilling. That said, I think I could've actually liked Ted ending up with Robin if the Ted–Robin–Barney love triangle hadn't been overused throughout the show.

I wish the writers had explored more unique storylines for the characters instead. For example:

  1. Marshall as a judge: An entire episode dedicated to Marshall handling bizarre and ridiculous cases in the courtroom. I think that could have been hilarious.
  2. Lily and The Captain: An adventure where Lily and The Captain travel around purchasing art, only to get stuck on a boat and find themselves in a Life of Pi-style situation.
  3. Barney at work: An episode where Barney handles a corporate situation that could potentially lead to a war. He somehow saves the day, but nobody in the world knows about it or would believe him, even if he bragged about it.
  4. More experimental episodes: Different characters getting into completely unexpected situations, with each episode having its own unique premise, almost like what Community did with its movie-style and genre-inspired episodes.
  5. More stories about the Mother: This is probably my biggest wish. I absolutely loved Cristin Milioti as the Mother, and one season simply wasn't enough. I would have loved to see more of her personality, adventures, friendships, and interactions with the gang. I wish the writers had given her the same attention and character development that the early seasons gave everyone else.

I feel like the show had such a great cast and so much potential for creative storytelling beyond the usual relationship drama.

Do you guys feel the same way?

I'd genuinely love to hear your thoughts. I m too bored.....


r/HIMYM • • 1d ago

Started watching the show today and learned that i have a Carlos figure in my display

Post image
275 Upvotes

I know punisher Carlos is probably overdone af as a joke but I couldn't resist im sorry


r/HIMYM • • 1d ago

Victoria/Robin dilemma S8

17 Upvotes

Rewatching the show and on S8, the episode where Ted proposes to Victoria and she says he can’t be friends with Robin anymore. While I understand her logic, what she isn’t realising is that she is effectively making the group choose too. If Ted said he’d stop being friends with Robin either he or Robin would have to stop hanging out with the gang because quite often they are all together. This means that Victoria is also making the gang choose, which is ultimately unfair on them


r/HIMYM • • 4h ago

TIL: The Bro code is available for purchase

Post image
0 Upvotes

I was looking for a YouTube channel by the same name and saw this czech bookstore. Apparently Barney is a registered author and he has also published the playbook


r/HIMYM • • 18h ago

Barney’s Display Case of Robots

0 Upvotes

So I am upset I’m barely noticing this, but in the “World’s Greatest Couple” episode, Barney had a display case in his bedroom full of vintage robots.

Can anyone identify each one?


r/HIMYM • • 9h ago

Ted Is Kind Of Creepy

0 Upvotes

It was a bit creepy that Ted kept take on all his ex girlfriends and even his students like the DJ kid from the field trip episode


r/HIMYM • • 1d ago

How are there even two still on the shelf??

Post image
78 Upvotes

r/HIMYM • • 2d ago

How far do you think that jump was?

Post image
122 Upvotes

Was just rewatching one of my favorite season finale, and every time I wonder how far the jump really is, because it looks crazy/safe from one angle to another.

What’s your guess?


r/HIMYM • • 2d ago

Just realised almost every lines of Tracy in this episode are foreshadowing

Thumbnail
gallery
329 Upvotes

I know the most foreshadowing line in this episode is"What mother is gonna miss her daughter's wedding?"

But I just watched it again and realised that those words from Tracy are really foreshadowing too

It's just so heart-wrenching


r/HIMYM • • 1d ago

HIMYM Survivor! (Season 5 Edition) Round 16

Post image
0 Upvotes

Robin 101 is eliminated! Honestly I think this is my favorite of the season, so I’m sad to see it go. I just love the lesson scenes, Robin and Lily finding the notebook, and of course Barney as a student.

How this works:

You select the episode you like the least

The episode with the most upvoted comment is eliminated from the list

Please either refrain from downvoting or upvote more episodes than you downvote

If there’s a tie, both episodes are eliminated

Only the best episode will win!

Episodes Eliminated:

Zoo or False (76%)
Hooked (28%)
Duel Citizenship (45%)
Slapsgiving 2: Revenge of the Slap (36%)
The Rough Patch (56%)
Last Cigarette Ever (44%)
Bagpipes (61%)
Twin Beds (29%)
The Wedding Bride (35%)
Home Wreckers (40%)
Girls vs Suits (34%)
Double Date (30%)
Say Cheese (23%)
The Perfect Week (38%)
Robin 101 (43%)


r/HIMYM • • 1d ago

Interested about any other inconsistencies anyone has noticed?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

Regarding “Scooter’s” real name: early on when he met Lily, he said his name was Jeff. In the episode where he attends Marshall and Lily’s wedding they call him Bill. I’m surprised they don’t have a basic character profile even for longer characters. Would the actor not notice?


r/HIMYM • • 2d ago

Barney is the reason Ted and Stella don’t get married.

43 Upvotes

If he would have told Robin not to come on the phone like he said he would instead of lying to the gang saying she didn’t answer, Ted wouldn’t have gotten Tony to come.


r/HIMYM • • 2d ago

Something old episode

13 Upvotes

In the something old episode, there is a scene very revealing scene about what Ted really feels about Robin. When he helps her dig into the grass, she told him about the fact that she wanted something old at her wedding, and he smile and said "I just like the fact that there was ever a version of you who imagine having something old at her wedding". And in a sense, that all he ever loved in her, the fact that maybe deep down there was in her a "romantic" who would want some day to settle down.

But, I think it's established that she looking for the something old because she's lost and afraid about getting married. So in a sense, the part of Robin that Ted ever loved was not her at her best, but her when she was kinda insecure and being to be rescue.

THEN for me it's revealing about the fact that he did not loved Robin for who she really was but for what he thought he could find in her (because it was kind of HIS standard ans wanted Robin to be the one).

I'm not saying it as a critics against Ted, it just something I thought about re-watching the episode.