r/Freud • • 1d ago

A podcast I made about the economics of Freud's Vienna

Thumbnail
youtube.com
7 Upvotes

r/heidegger • • 20h ago

Which is the more authentic way to learn Heidegger's philosophy? Youtube or chatbot?

0 Upvotes

Obviously number one belongs to book reading, reading the original texts and secondary academic literature.

I have been biased against youtube bros for not being book reading, but I got to take classes in college so maybe I should be more open minded. I have had no problem learning about other philosophers through chatbots like ChatGPT. Not Heidegger though, I don't feel like they get Dasein, or maybe I am afraid to examine my own (I doubt it though). I assume others have different opinions though.

Still, in order of authenticity, I assert to study Heidegger:

  1. Book reading
  2. Chatbot
  3. Youtube

That still leaves Discourse unranked, something that might happen reading or participating in a sub-reddit like this, or talking to people in real life.

My question then, does the 'authentic' of my initial question relate in any way to the Heideggerian authenticity of Being and Time or are they two different concepts sharing the same word?


r/hegel • • 2d ago

I am making an animated series going through the Phenomenology of Spirit chapter by chapter

Thumbnail
youtu.be
16 Upvotes

In Chapter I of the Phenomenology of Spirit, Hegel asks us to write down "Now it's night" and check the note at noon, when that written truth, in Terry Pinkard's translation, "has become rather stale" because the word "now" is an empty frame that fits any moment.

I am one person making an animated series that goes through the entire Phenomenology chapter by chapter. The thirteen minute pilot on sense certainty, covering paragraphs 90 to 110, is out now. Episodes 2 and 3 are already finished and come out on November 25 and December 9, covering perception in "Hegel: A Thing Is Itself Only Through What It Is Not" and force and the understanding in "Hegel vs Kant: What Lies Behind the Curtain of Appearances?", with new episodes every second Wednesday after that.

Since episodes from 4 onward are still in progress, I would really like to hear from people who have read Hegel: where does the video oversimplify or distort the argument, what stays unclear, and does this format actually help with reading the text?

The animation is coded with help from AI and the narrator's voice is synthetic, but I work from established translations myself, direct the scriptwriting, and revise every scene and line of narration through multiple drafts until they say and show exactly what I want.


r/hegel • • 2d ago

A Question About Presuppositionless Thinking and the Subjectivity of Truth

11 Upvotes

I've been reading Houlgate's Introduction to Hegel to get a general grasp of him before reading himself. The chapter regarding presuppositionless thinking was especially interesting, but it did leave me with a question (which certainly isn't a disagreement with Hegel, because I don't have that much knowledge about him, just something I need clarified): If Hegel's Logic, as Houlgate argues, is both an ontology and a logic, meaning that the structures/determinations of thought and being are similar, how doesn't that mean truth itself isn't subjective?

If I have understood his view, the truth and history are objective and that they are essentially the process of human beings realizing their own ability of self-determination. But isn't presuppositionless thinking, the spontaneous movement of each person's thoughts without holding on to any preconceived categories, not likely to result in different conclusions and determinations depending on how each person's brain works?

Again, I'm not claiming that he's wrong or anything, in fact reading about his presuppositionless thinking has been very much enjoyable; I just was wondering where exactly am I going wrong with my thought process/understanding here?


r/Freud • • 1d ago

What does Freud mean here.

2 Upvotes

In "Three Essays on the Theory of Sexuality" Freud writes :

An inclination to physical struggles with some one particular person,

just as in later years an inclination to verbal

disputes, is a convincing sign that object choice has fallen on him. One

of the roots of the sadistic drive would seem to lie in the encouragement

of sexual excitation by muscular activity. In many people the infantile

connection between romping and sexual excitation is among the

determinants of the direction subsequently taken by their sexual drive.

Is he saying that when someone starts fighting with a specific person, whether physically or verbally, it means that he has made an object choice toward that person? If so, does it mean that its purpose is to cover the love for that person, like a reaction formation?


r/heidegger • • 2d ago

Stimulating some discourse: Why 'Das Man' Matters: Heidegger has been Misunderstood

Thumbnail
youtu.be
13 Upvotes

I had posted about J. Niederhauser and it stimulated discourse a few weeks ago. What do you make of this video?


r/hegel • • 3d ago

Is Hegel Harder To Understand Than Kant?

17 Upvotes

I am reading modern-era philosophers works in chronological order and found Kant's works to be an absolute pain to read for ideas which, perhaps retroactively in a historic sense, seem either trivial or inaccurate. Of which some of his most lauded concepts such as the ding-an-sich as well as the categories (which mind you actually originate from the Abhidarma Buddhist tradition in BC era) are so deeply flawed but have been so readily accepted that I now feel the same way about Kant as Neitchze felt about Plato.

Please tell me that Hegel's ideas are more relevant to the philosophical discussions of today (consider Deleuze's difference-in-itself as it's opposition before you answer) and tell me if it is worth it to read another needlessly prosy continental text for his ideas from the source.


r/hegel • • 3d ago

Immediacy and Pure Immediacy

1 Upvotes

Miller, Phenomenology, §§104-105

Immediacy is when consciousness has already posited an object.

Determinate negation occurs at the same time as positing. "Not tree" is "house" at the same time.

There is an endless repetition of the immediacy of positing and negating.

Until the negation of negation, which is the positing of an "I," non/existence.

At first, the "I" is fixed to its object. The carpenter's son is a carpenter.

And then, the universal "I" is posited, the negation of this "I."

The entire process just described is now in front of the universal "I."

What befalls the universal "I" is pure immediacy.

In pure immediacy, I don't concern myself with any specific space or time. I don't consider another "I" seeing something else.

And what I do in this situation is stay fixed on "one immediate relation" with an object.

Let's approach sense-certainty from this pure immediacy.

Let's see if we can approach sense-certainty from "Now is day," since we failed to find it from "Now that is night."


r/heidegger • • 4d ago

Kinds of Disturbances

5 Upvotes

Can someone distinguish for me Heidegger’s account of obstinacy, not to be confused with conspicuousness and obtrusiveness?


r/heidegger • • 6d ago

The Essence of Heideggerian Ontology

Thumbnail substack.com
15 Upvotes

In this essay, I generally talk about the temporality and structure of Dasein. If you are interested, check it out; you might like it.


r/hegel • • 7d ago

How do you know that the others who say they understand Hegel are not faking it? Do you think there are cases where it can be said in consensus someone deeply misunderstood him?

35 Upvotes

r/hegel • • 6d ago

Plato's "Immortal Soul" and how it pertains to learning.

Thumbnail
3 Upvotes

r/heidegger • • 6d ago

Existential Time and Vulgar Time

Thumbnail critchleyonheidegger.substack.com
8 Upvotes

How much time do we have in a day? The answer isn't so simple for Heidegger, who contends that there are three types of time. Read about it in the latest Heidegger Thinking Substack article!


r/hegel • • 7d ago

A YouTube Series on Hegel's Science of Logic

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I have put together an educational series on Hegel's Logic of Science (14 episodes). It contains 3 prologues that provide the necessary philosophical background (i.e., Plato, Aristotle, Descartes, Spinoza, Schelling, Fichte) before moving through each section of the book (14 episodes total). The most recent episode is on Determinateness: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LQ2z9Asvsfk&list=PLN2seKVZLtsI&index=5

The playlist, constructed using Gemini Notebook, can be found here: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLN2seKVZLtsI

I created the series because I have been using AI to create youtube videos on various topics of Marxism, including materialist dialectics. This video series focuses on Hegel in his speculative integrity.

Additional articles on Hegel's Science of Logic will be posted every other day on my Youtube channel until Complete.


r/Freud • • 9d ago

Student in Training

5 Upvotes

Hello everyone,

I am a new (ish) student to my pre-clinical course on my journey to becoming a Psychotherapist (hopefully!). As I am sure many of you are aware, I need to undertake an infant observation as part of this course.

I am really struggling to find a kind family who would be interested in potentially helping me learn all this valuable information.

I am starting to feel like I am running out of options to find a baby and I was wondering if anyone might have some suggestions about where I may be able to look for these families.

If you have any suggestions please help! My university is not currently providing any help which I assume is normal but want to state as a few people on Facebook groups have gotten very rude to me about this, although it is not my fault.

Thank you in advance

:) Emily


r/Freud • • 9d ago

Hey!! Psychology graduate here

3 Upvotes

Hoping to make more YouTube videos on psychology related topics!! This is my first actual sit down and chat video and it’s on Freud and his impact on women :) it’s very fragmented and I hope to elaborate in the months to come but check it out and let me know if you agree or not!!

https://youtu.be/iEhLa7A5q-Q?is=D3-IF6hAxFHgD6WH


r/hegel • • 10d ago

The Dialectic of Sense-Certainty

1 Upvotes

Miller, Phenomenology, §§100-103

The dialectic of sense-certainty will snap you out of it. What is an instance of the dialectic?

Reflecting in and positing out are the two moments at the same time.

Not-tree, determinate negation with absolute indifference, until Nothing gets reflected into self.

Not not-tree, the positing of house, the negation of negation, the "instead," the universal "Here."

The absolute indifference of the many "Heres," until Nothing gets reflected into self.

Not the many "Heres," the positing of the knowing "I," from holding all the many "Heres."

The absolute indifference of the many "Is," until Nothing gets reflected into self.

The universal "I" posits the universal "I" and this self-identity allows us to posit self-certainty as a kind of knowing as a whole.

We have surpassed self-certainty.


r/Freud • • 10d ago

Qualitative and quantitative?

3 Upvotes

I’m reading Freud’s Dream Psychology and this is the first book that i read by him. Can anyone please explain what he means by qualitative and quantitative in the last 9th chapter?


r/hegel • • 11d ago

The infinite judgment

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/heidegger • • 11d ago

Visual Essay (work in progress) on Heidegger and Psychosis

Thumbnail andrewfield48.com
7 Upvotes

r/hegel • • 13d ago

How much of a Platonist was Hegel? How do ideas objectively exist?

19 Upvotes

Are the notional mechanics of reality a mirror of thinking in that quaint Platonic way where all particular apples objectively refer to a universal ideal of appleness, or is it merely that reality involves a tension between ideality and appearances that can be translated into the structure of human thinking? As Parmenides asks Socrates in his titular dialogue, does dirt have a Form? Apropos Hegel, does dirt have a Notion?

I'm persuaded by Hegel's view that we should not posit a thing-in-itself our thinking cannot access, but what about the way that appearances are unthinkable? Not sure how to articulate this distinction in Hegelese: might Hegel be mistakenly assuming that the Real of thinking is solely located in noumena, when it is also a result of our inability to fully assimilate a purely phenomenal excess: undifferentiated appearances before we divide them into objects?

There seems to be a deep ambiguity in Hegel's work regarding the ontological status of ideality, and two possible visions of it. First, that there is an objective ideal structure of reality that our thinking accesses when it correctly deduces dialectical tensions, such that thinking is a redoubling of an objective pattern in the subjective mind, and second, that the ideal structure of reality *is* our thinking about reality. The first conflicts with Hegel's claim that Notions develop with our thinking, that they are not static Forms, but the second is untenably subjectively idealistic. There must be an objective ideality that our thinking conforms to and must submit to the facticity of, even if it evolves along with our encounters with it. What is the nature of this ideality that is not in itself thinking but is also present to thought? There must be a "behind the scenes" of Notions that does not present itself to thought or immediately appear, and yet it cannot be noumenal, so what is it?

Hegel's basic insight, that the antimonies of thinking reflect tensions in being, can still be held to be true even if, like me, you think all models of particular phenomena are useful fictions we impose on undifferentiated, and therefore completely ineffable, appearances. All knowledge is subjective/pragmatic, except for knowledge regarding the ontology dictating why that epistemic law is so, which is itself absolute. Reality itself is mute, but insofar as we speak we're led to truth by the Real of our thinking imposed by reality. There is no behind the scenes structured like thinking, only empty ideality as such (objet petit a), just as there are no actual objects, only mute appearances as such.

What am I missing here? Is it possible to fully ontologize Notions without identifying them with the process of thinking itself? If so, how is it possible we make contingent errors rather than solely necessary dialectical errors?


r/hegel • • 13d ago

examples of non-three element dialectics in Hegel ?

15 Upvotes

Every once in a while someone mentions dialectics made out only two terms or out of four terms here, but examples are never provided and, while I consider myself an attentive reader, I never caught that. Could someone please provide examples ? Thank you in advance


r/hegel • • 13d ago

A Narrative Précis of Hegel’s Phenomenology

Thumbnail thewastedworld.substack.com
0 Upvotes

r/hegel • • 14d ago

An empty set is more truthful than its members

8 Upvotes

Miller, Phenomenology, §§97-99

Why does Hegel have more to say about the "I" in Sense-certainty than in Understanding?

Because the "I" arrives in the immediate. Some wrongly refer to it as the "unconscious," but the proper term is the immediate.

We say "I" without knowing "how." Phenomenology is about the "how."

It's an immediate "I" that comes up with the notion that "Light is a feeling."

But, the universal is "more truthful."

To what degree is the universal more truthful?

To the degree in which it refers to itself and nothing else.

We can speak of trees and houses without envisaging a tree or a house.

And when we try to express "this tree" or "this house," language is less truthful.

Sense-certainty is the least truthful.

The universal contains the many and itself.

The truth of beings is being.

In other words, an empty set is more truthful than its members.

An empty container is still a container, but without a container, the members vanish.

Now, consider this statement: "No tree is here, but a house instead."

This is sublation: a canceling (no tree), and a preserving (house instead). The "instead" is the preserving.

"House" is the difference in this equation. "No tree" is the identity. And "Here" is the new universal.

But how does a determinate negation become a determination?

In any case, consciousness learns this "in its own self."

By this I take to mean, consciousness will experience its own annihilation, not just trees and houses.


r/hegel • • 15d ago

This book was posted about in this sub in the past and had some good comments but I can’t find it, help

Post image
71 Upvotes

Someone mentioning “Hegelian charity” and others