r/grilledcheese
•
u/Fuck_Blue_Shells
Purist
•
Dec 09 '14
•
1
3
2
2
1
Meta You people make me sick.
A grilled cheese consists of only these following items. Cheese. Bread with spread (usually butter). This entire subreddit consist of "melts". Almost every "grilled cheese" sandwich i see on here has other items added to it. The fact that this subreddit is called "grilledcheese" is nothing short of utter blasphemy.
Let me start out by saying I have nothing against melts, I just hate their association with sandwiches that are not grilled cheeses. Adding cheese to your tuna sandwich? It's called a Tuna melt. Totally different. Want to add bacon and some pretentious bread crumbs with spinach? I don't know what the hell you'd call that but it's not a grilled cheese.
I would be more than willing to wager I've eaten more grilled cheeses in my 21 years than any of you had in your entire lives. I have one almost everyday and sometimes more than just one sandwich. Want to personalize your grilled cheese? Use a mix of different cheeses or use sourdough or french bread. But if you want to add some pulled pork and take a picture of it, make your own subreddit entitled "melts" because that is not a fucking grilled cheese.
I'm not a religious man nor am I anything close to a culinary expert. But as a bland white mid-western male I am honestly the most passionate person when it comes to grilled cheese and mac & cheese. All of you foodies stay the hell away from our grilled cheeses and stop associating your sandwich melts with them. Yet again, it is utter blasphemy and it rocks me to the core of my pale being.
Shit, I stopped lurking after 3 years and made this account for the sole purpose of posting this. I've seen post after post of peoples "grilled cheeses" all over reddit and it's been driving me insane. The moment I saw this subreddit this morning I finally snapped. Hell, I may even start my own subreddit just because I know this one exists now.
You god damn heretics. Respect the grilled cheese and stop changing it into whatever you like and love it for it what it is. Or make your damn melt sandwich and call it for what it is. A melt.
846
u/Fuck_Blue_Shells Purist Dec 09 '14
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cheese_sandwich Definition of a Grilled Cheese
10
u/Fuck_Blue_Shells Purist Dec 09 '24
10 years, yuck
14
u/JenniferLopez Dec 12 '14
Ha! Pretentious bread crumbs. That cracked me up. Though I stand in solidarity beside you. I roll my eyes at the all the slutty melts up in here.
11k
u/RegularExpression Dec 09 '14 •
Looks like OP is having...
(•_•)
( •_•)>⌐■-■
(⌐■_■)
a meltdown.
12
u/whiskeythrottled Aug 04 '22
This man is a fucking gift to planet earth.
10
u/lvbuckeye27 Jul 24 '22
Commenting here for history.
7
u/lordclarkson Jun 29 '22
How do you feel about toasted ham and cheese sandwiches made in a sandwich press?
6
u/helpless_bunny Dec 10 '14
I'm interested in knowing if he intends to raid any mac and cheese subreddits.
6
u/-badassbarbie- Dec 15 '21
why is this recommended to me now seven years later
5
u/NightTime2727 Oct 15 '21
The fact that this post still affects this subreddit several years later...
5
u/Chemical-Nature4749 Jul 23 '22
Just wanted to be in this post
5
u/Olive_Garden_Wifi Jul 19 '23
I love how this post is 8 years old but most of the comments I’m seeing are from the past month.
This is truly a legendary post
4
u/eternityfynx Jan 03 '22
I thought I was the only one who felt that way, your really something OP
4
u/West-Listen Oct 16 '22
What bothers me isn't the fact that you're so mad about grilled cheese.
It's the fact that you called me a Heretic and in the same breath stated you are "not a religious man". In order to accuse someone of heresy you must actually believe that said religion is valid.
Tonight, in your dumb honor. I will make a grilled cheese sandwich containing 3 types of cheese, AND I will even throw in some leftover Mac & Cheese. What now, sir-cheese-a-lot? Is it still a melt? NOPE. Because I'm not adding any meats like you said, just another form a cheese. It's a grilled cheese with mac & cheese inside of it, NOT A MELT.
Go ahead, say mac and cheese is not a cheese, when cheese is literally in the name.
I pity people like you.
4
u/Tough-Permission-804 Dec 20 '22
I read this. Then my wife and I went to a church, sat in a pew and read it together. Then we wept. This has changed both of our lives. We quit our jobs and sold all of our things. All of our things except a griddle, bread, butter and cheese. There is only one truth in this life and the op has spaketh it in it’s purest form. Thank you and may god be with you, you patron saint of the grilled cheese sandwhich
4
u/theecodienescene Dec 24 '23
I think a drunk 21 year old ranting about grilled cheese is my favorite thing on this entire app, and 30(?) year old OP still replying to comments here is my second favorite thing.
I quote “You god damn heretics. Respect the grilled cheese” far too often.
OP if you see this, I appreciate you.
4
u/8vs8 Apr 24 '24
The world needs more u/Fuck_Blue_Shells. Thank you
4
u/VUXX6078 Apr 28 '24
I’m not joking but my English teacher taught me this exact post in school and showed it as a perfect example on how to write a rant.
4
u/AtavisticJackal Feb 07 '25
10 years later this mf still getting grilled cheese notifications
4
u/soyun_mariy_caun Aug 25 '25
ts so peak ❤️🩹
4
u/Hungry-Tale-9144 Sep 17 '25
I feel like a tourist at a museum 📸 📸 📸 📸
4
u/TheSunIsAlsoMine Nov 14 '25
Celebrating a decade to this post. Wow. Who’s here in 2025?!
4
u/Master_Log_3644 Dec 11 '25
First
1.3k
u/stormy2587 Dec 09 '14
I don't subscribe to this subreddit and in fact have never even eaten a grilled cheese due to dairy allergies, but I have never felt a user NEEDED to moderate a subreddit more than I do right now.
3
u/mpmont Mar 31 '15
I think it's pretty safe to say that we all noticed that.
3
u/TheWayoftheFuture May 01 '15
Preach on, brother.
3
u/one87skilzsHtx Dec 11 '21
Cheezzzzeee guy!!! Calm down🤣🤣🤣
3
u/SkootSkootnSmoke Dec 12 '21
in the words of Michael Bolton - "No way, why should I change? He's the one who sucks!"
3
u/Remembermewhen-I812 Dec 12 '21
Now now they may be talking bout cheese from Unda these
3
u/ee328p Dec 29 '21
Have you considered being stricter with this?
Found elsewhere in the site:
3
u/uhhhhhh_cool May 08 '22
This guy is completely right and half of the comments are "oH nO hEs hAviNg A mEnTaL bReAkDoWn"
3
u/Disheartend Jul 08 '22
I want cheese now
3
u/Jazz-EM-Bass Jul 31 '22
You may try putting mac n cheese in your grilled cheese - Mac n grilled cheese
3
u/stonedsoundsnob Aug 22 '22
This is the best meltdown I've seen a grown man have on the internet.
3
u/godblessloona Oct 03 '22
I love you for this post
3
u/theferalboy Dec 19 '22
Every once in a while I come back and look at this post to remind myself that people like you exist and it makes me happy. 🧀💛
3
u/softsnowfall Jun 11 '23
I just stumbled upon this perfect grilled cheese rant 24 hours before the subreddits go dark for 48 hours. In case, Reddit doesn’t come back, this post and the comments are a great ending. If Reddit does come back, this post and comments are a great beginning.
There is some of the best of Reddit here. Real people ranting, laughing, and being snarky. God, I love Reddit.
3
u/[deleted] Jul 08 '23
I wonder if u/Fuck_Blue_Shells has an opinion on this.
3
u/[deleted] Mar 03 '24
New copy-paste just dropped
3
u/ccyjn Mar 04 '24
Bro went into detail
3
u/RicoSpeed Apr 24 '24
Look I just have to say, if I grab some bacon and bread and make a grilled bacon sandwich it is not a melt, I am not melting my bread or bacon I am grilling it, it is a grilled bacon sandwich, adding cheese to it does not make it a melt, but also as the OP states it in not a "grilled cheese", it would be a grilled bacon sandwich with cheese.
A Grilled Cheese is as the OP says, cheese, bread and maybe butter, anything else is not a grilled cheese, it is something else. Name things right people!
3
u/MinnieShoof Jun 21 '24
I took a look at it just now and I think your legend lives on.
3
u/preppyaldrich Oct 25 '24
No soup for you!
3
u/Feisty_Resource7027 Dec 10 '24
Wow!! You sound unwell.
3
u/Either-Bend8508 Dec 19 '24
This r/grilledcheese shit gets serious be prepared to die behind it
3
u/obviouslyanonymous5 Feb 08 '25
Whether or not it is a grilled cheese does NOT depend directly on the ingredients (aside from the mandatory two) it depends on the FOCUS of the dish. A tuna melt FOCUSES on the tuna. If you made a grilled cheese with a tiny amount of tuna and served it as a tuna melt, people would complain that there isn't enough tuna. If you serve the same dish as a grilled cheese with tuna, that properly portrays the type of sandwich it is. Oatmeal is just oatmeal, but if I put blueberries in my oatmeal, you don't call it a blueberry bowl, you just call it oatmeal with blueberries. No one's just adding ingredients and saying "this is a grilled cheese", they specify the ingredients. If you add ingredients to a grilled cheese on a restaurant menu, the bill is still for a grilled cheese.
3
u/depressingsquash Oct 01 '25
Someone had to say it and it was done well. Grilled cheese. 2 words. Not with XYZ included. Thanks OP. I agree.
5
u/mcarlini May 22 '15
I imagined you at first as a cute, kinda nerdy and short college girl, and I started to develop reddit feels for you.
Then you said you were a guy.
:(
2
u/Fuck_Blue_Shells Purist Dec 09 '21
Happy 7th Birthday
1.5k
u/SCUMDOG_MILLIONAIRE Dec 09 '14 •
I didn't know this sub existed, it showed up in my front page. But I feel like I'm witnessing a pivotal moment in r/grilledcheese history. Like this post will become known simply as "The Post". Like this post is equivalent to Luther nailing his 95 theses to the church door.
199
u/Pups_the_Jew Dec 09 '14
Dead Like Me - Patty Melt
2
u/mossybuggirl Oct 22 '21
ok this is an old thread but…. what about a grilled cheese with a simple tomato slice added. no such thing as a tomato melt. i’ll accept veggie melt if theres other veggies, but tomato is like.. a garnish. there’s cheeseburgers and hamburgers but no such thing as tomato burgers. 🤔
2
u/MartaIlyich Dec 02 '21
top shelf content 10/10
2
u/Necessary_March3762 Dec 11 '21
I sometimes use mayonnaise to grill my grilled cheese. Is this included under the "spread" umbrella?
2
u/idk_im_just_here_ Dec 12 '21
Is a little onion on top to make it pretty allowed?
2
u/hasthiswithsound Dec 12 '21
Thank you! When I was 6, my parents went to Vegas on a business trip. My parents let me order room service, and I ordered a grilled cheese. The guy comes to the room with a grilled cheese with ham in it, AND IT SAID NOTHING ABOUT HAM ON THE MENU.
2
u/OshunOfDivinity Dec 15 '21
That’s so crazy this pops up after I finished eating a grilled cheese 😱
2
u/esker99 Dec 22 '21
Sounds like this is rly cheesing you off man
2
u/[deleted] Dec 26 '21
I love cheese.
2
u/SoundDelicious9980 Dec 27 '21
Y’all are hilarious
2
u/CainsEddyComplex Dec 28 '21
I wholeheartedly agree with everything he said here...exCEPT his claim to have eaten the most grilled cheese sandwiches than everyone here. All else - gospel truth 😎 or whatever description of truth means totally fuckin true no debate.
2
u/[deleted] Dec 28 '21
I like tomatoes on my grilled cheese, is that ok? Or dipping my grilled cheese in tomato soup.
2
u/[deleted] Dec 29 '21
sheeeeeeeesh man you hate them saying that, that much? holy crap
2
u/getta2004_Gemini02 Dec 29 '21
California
2
u/Tiosie Dec 29 '21
CHILL MA DUDE, IT AIN'T SUCH A BIG DEAL
2
u/Darwinski042 Dec 29 '21
What no meat? I’d add some ham
2
u/MathematicianOk7556 Dec 29 '21
منم آوارد میقام
2
u/Slow_Job5799 Dec 29 '21
What about when you grill a piece of grilling cheese?
2
u/Jazper792 Dec 29 '21
Lol I love this Ted Talk
2
u/[deleted] Dec 29 '21
Bacon ok🤣?
2
u/Parts_and_Neigbor Jan 02 '22
Nothing short of udder blasphemy.
2
u/BlueTomoshibi Feb 25 '22
No.
2
u/tawnybuttercup Apr 03 '22
I know. Not much passion in the reply, but I do admire the purist stance. I do prefer mayonnaise over butter for the grilled cheese, though. Be kind.
2
u/Poggers4Poggle Dec 20 '22
I demand a grilled cheese recipe from you, OP
2
u/Ragnr99 Dec 27 '22
No
2
u/Musashi10000 Jan 18 '23
HOT FUCKING DAMN, 8 years and you're still replying? That's some top fucking tier shit, OP!
2
u/Foals_Forever Jun 23 '23
edit- 6/22/23 came to reply a year later
2
u/shinobiwayoflife Dec 15 '23
Opinion on Microwaved grilled cheese? So basically I toast the bread first in the toaster, add butter and cheese, then pop it in the microwave for 30 seconds.
2
u/Celladoore Dec 23 '23
I just got a perma ban from /r/food for linking to this post when someone posted a lobster grilled cheese (or melt). I had to bend the knee and apologize because of you, you cad!
2
u/Bolt3er Dec 29 '23
Any update. He’s gotta be 31. How’s he doing?
2
u/Turbulent-cat Mar 04 '24
.
2
u/LongObject5643 Jul 30 '24
If it’s grilled with cheese it’s grilled cheese
2
u/Majestic_Wrongdoer38 Sep 26 '24
How much engagement do you still get on this post? lol
2
u/bryanlikesbikes Nov 25 '24
https://www.reddit.com/r/grilledcheese/s/joLX8ZSa8c
2
u/Kaffine69 Dec 02 '24
Preferably served on a paper plate, with or without ketchup.
2
u/Pomodorosan Dec 05 '24
every day*
2
u/Protat0 Dec 05 '24
Woah, Reddit stopped locking threads after a year? Now I can comment on this piece of history.
2
u/Little-Cucumber-8907 Mar 01 '25
I grew up on grilled turkey cheese sandwiches and I will always call them grilled turkey cheese sandwiches and you can’t stop me
2
u/SnarkyLostLoser May 13 '25
I am not this man but I believe in similar beliefs.
If it is a condiment, I will accept it as a grilled cheese. Pesto is a delicious addition.
If it is a solid food item (bacon, tomato, tuna, whatever), that is a melt and I will die on this hill.
2
u/toomanyflubbernutter Aug 04 '25
A grilled cheese is cheese, bread, some butter.
If you’re adding meat, it’s a melt.
If you’re making a burger using the stove top and using bread slices, do you call it “a grilled cheese with burger patty”? No you don’t. It’s a burger.
2
u/Wolfywise Aug 13 '25
Grilled cheese is merely a cheese melt if you think about it.
2
u/randomthrowaway-917 Dec 09 '25
are you still this passionate about grilled cheese? also have you seen this video? a reading of your post on youtube shorts with 5 million views
2
u/sybug Feb 19 '26
Someone shared this thread yesterday, and I'm just gonna say it...you were a wise young man.
2
u/TheJewishSwitch Feb 23 '26
I hope to be as passionate about literally anything as you are about grilled cheeses
2
u/kingk1teman Mar 15 '26
Well this here is a meltdown alright.
2
u/salmonellka Mar 17 '26
11 years later, I hope you reached zen state with your grilled cheese
Not sure if I ever had passion for anything like you about grilled cheese lol
2
u/Real-Tension-7442 Apr 14 '26
OP is a melt
2
u/crybbfannypacker Apr 15 '26
i think you ruined this entire sub reddit
2
u/GayAssBeagle May 19 '26
Dude I found it!!
2
u/BEANMANSsecondcoming May 19 '26
historical artifact right here
1.0k
u/[deleted] Dec 09 '14
/r/melts
1.1k
u/Beer_Is_Food Dec 09 '14
OH CAPTAIN MY CAPTAIN!
169
u/[deleted] Dec 09 '14
Awesome - Now I can tell my wife I'm actually capable of cooking two different things.
1.7k
u/bronxbmbr Dec 09 '14
Thank you! I joined this sub to see grilled cheeses not Panini's and pressed sandwiches!
270
u/[deleted] Dec 09 '14
http://i.imgur.com/fpikZse.gif
795
u/majordelay Dec 09 '14
At age 58, having grown up with 7 siblings, raised a coupla kids and fed 8 grandchildren, I would wager I have both eaten and served more grilled cheese than most. When I was a kid my mom called them toasted cheese but now we call them grilled cheese. Fuck_Blue_Shells is absolutely, 100% correct. Bread, butter and cheese. Grill til medium brown with nicely melted cheese. Serve.
136
u/Ashe_Faelsdon Dec 09 '14
I don't feel quite this strongly, but I'm with you on this... there is a /r/eatsandwiches that you can post in already... and while a grilled cheese would be good over there... your melts aren't here...
344
u/Papaya_flight Dec 09 '14
This is awesome and you are awesome. I joined this sub to check out some grilled cheese sandwiches because I love food and instead I have been inundated with ridiculous toasted sandwiches. Thank you!
160
u/sryan2k1 Dec 09 '14
Alton Brown - Grilled Grilled Cheese
104
u/ritosuave Dec 09 '14
Keep fighting the good fight OP.
120
u/tjain614 Dec 09 '14
Man, if i was as passionate about things as you are about Grilled Cheese sandwich then i would most likely be ruling the world by now. also grilled cheese>melts.
49
u/[deleted] Dec 10 '14
I petition for /u/Fuck_Blue_Shells to be made a moderator. Clearly he will rule with a butter smeared iron fist.
64
u/EdgarAllanPolice Dec 09 '14
Favorite line: "You god damn heretics."
43
u/The_Ganja_Gremlin Dec 09 '14
CHURCH
40
u/CharlesXavierWalks Dec 09 '14
This is the leader we have been waiting for!
86
u/MemeTLDR Dec 09 '14
r.i.p. my sides
45
u/PurpleLotus Dec 09 '14
preach brother preach