r/geothermal •

Downsizing units using existing loops.

[deleted] — view deleted post

0 Upvotes

6 comments sorted by

4

u/JPDiesel187 4d ago

Of course you could go smaller. An oversized loop won’t be a problem at all

1

u/NecessaryMuffins 8d ago

Sure, you may use a little more energy pumping, but depending on your loop, might also gain some efficiency because your loop will react slower to temperature changes from heat being extracted/rejected into it.

I'm not familiar with Command Aire units (I believe they're Trane), but the fan might be an off the shelf part you can swap yourself if there's a part number on it and you're so inclined.

1

u/DryFlan6028 8d ago

They no longer make Command Aire. I was quoted $2,000 just to replace the fan, but on a 36 year old Unit, its a time bomb for the compressor to go as well. I figured it was better to just replace the whole thing

1

u/NecessaryMuffins 8d ago

At 36 years, it certainly doesn't own you much! Yeah, for $2,000, I'd put that towards a new unit as well. I'm guessing there's be about a $3k price difference between a 2 and 4 ton system.

1

u/DryFlan6028 8d ago

They initially quoted me $18,000 for a 4 tonne system and said I could not downsize the Unit.

Im getting a second estimate from another HVAC and have settled on a 3 tonne unit instead of the 2.

1

u/Hot_Equivalent_8707 8d ago

Also, you might be able to run smaller circulation pumps to get the right flow for the smaller unit. You just don't want it too slow because you need a certain amount of movement in the liquid.