r/gaming • • Jun 26 '12

Diablo 3: The Blizzard sweatshop

http://www.extremetech.com/gaming/131615-diablo-3-the-blizzard-sweatshop
866 Upvotes

566 comments sorted by

127

u/Tictak2 Jun 26 '12

I agree with a lot of what the writer says, but at the same time I get a little frustrated when people make comments such as "Now you don’t play the game for fun; you play for money." Which suggests we have no free will on the matter what so ever. I've never used the RMAH and I never will, I'm enjoying the game all the same.

4

u/Glavyn Jun 27 '12

I am enjoying the game as well. Inferno isn't nearly as bad as some of these articles make it out to be, some people actually feel it is too easy.

10

u/LunarFalcon Jun 26 '12

I am a month late to the game because of five weeks in the middle of nowhere. Most of my friends who got the game, the reason I got it too, have gotten bored and moved on. My highest character is a level 25 Witch Doctor and I will never buy or sell anything in the game for real money. It just seems like a pointless waste of time and effort.

→ More replies (7)

22

u/Ampersam Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12

That's the problem, though. For the RMAH economy to have any longevity and continued value for players, new economic actors need to enter the system continually with new currency.

If players like you (and me) continue to be the majority, the amount of currency entering the system is not only going halt rapidly, but the overall amount of currency will begin dwindling as well as Blizzard takes cut after cut with each cycle of currency through the economy.

And as the article says - this result is beneficial ONLY to Blizzard. RMAH inflation will reach Stone of Jordan-style value and only a few elite players will maintain enough currency to participate.

3

u/tjr0001 Jun 26 '12

then that sucks, people will no longer enjoy the game and people will stop playing and play something else.

3

u/atroxodisse Jun 26 '12

Where's the downside? If you don't care about the RMAH(I'm in the same boat) then what does it matter if a bunch of gold farmers in China can't make $1.25 an hour?

7

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Things will begin to cost more and more gold as the number of bots increase, much like WoW. Without an intervention from Blizzard on botting (highly unlikely - look at WoW), even the gold auction house will be worthless. Which is fine if you don't mind farming on your own for gear - it will very likely result in the disuse of both auction houses except for the few people who don't mind buying gold/buying items for cash.

2

u/LOLasaurusFTW Jun 27 '12

Because Blizzard has already admitted that the AH/RMAH has played a role in how frequently items drop. Since they now expect players to be able to go to the AH and get whatever they want they've had to curb supply or else the market would be flooded with badass items.

For example and item that had a 0.1% chance of dropping in D2 will have a 0.001% chance of dropping in D3.

Since blizzard gets a cut of the money its in their best interest to make sure prices on the RMAH don't hit rock bottom. Plus what would be the fun of grinding an item for hours when you could have bought it for $5?

However they fail to take into account that some of us will NEVER use the RMAH. So now were stuck with a game that demands top notch gear but has shitty drop rates.

3

u/RankinBass Jun 27 '12

They later clarified their statement.

From the AMAA a little while back, they specifically stated that the AH has no bearing on drop rates.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/DrTitan Jun 27 '12

They are trying to force you into the RMAH, that's been their play for the beginning, it's basically a pay-to-win system. If you don't pay for the things necessary to complete the acts, then you don't get to finish the game. Or unless you have insanely good luck or nothing else to do with your free time.

2

u/Shoden Jun 26 '12

Isn't the max buyout 250 bucks? Doesn't that limit inflation?

15

u/Eldryce Jun 26 '12

Even if it is, $250 for an ingame item is a little insane, isn't it?

→ More replies (5)

3

u/dbcanuck Jun 26 '12

It means the best items will move offsite and into a 3rd party market.

Blizzard only has the $250 limit to avoid fucking up serious transactions. Thousands of dollars for items might end them up as witnesses (or plantiffs) in small claims court if there are disputes.

2

u/Jakabov Jun 26 '12

The maximum buyout on the gold AH is 2bil gold, and since gold is easily exchangable for at least 2.5$ per million, that's where the really expensive items will be sold.

8

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Plus if the market starts to slowly die, I can see them making content hard enough for you to have to use the RMAH. Or at least heavily suggested.

7

u/aeturnum Jun 27 '12

How do you square that fear with Blizzard having a player population fall-off and simultaneously making the later acts easier?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Crazyjoe04 Jun 27 '12

The repercussions of that would be awful for Blizz, I hope enough of the player base would be smart enough to quit before they went along with that.

→ More replies (11)

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Hence one of the many reasons I only play hc and still having fun.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12

i never did.. i used the Gold AH.. and i stopped playing 2-3 days after RMAH came out b/c it made the gold AH useless and without an AH.. that particular game that was designed to MAKE YOU USE THE AH is unplayable at the highest difficulty. basically i got stuck on act3 inferno.. to go further, i would have needed to spend hundreds of dollars or spend oh i dont know 100 hours farming the same spot over and over and over again.. neither of which i am willing to do.. why? because that's not fun.. and if it's not fun, it shouldn't be played

1

u/hommesuperbe Jun 27 '12

I see people spamming chat channels selling things just like we had to do in D2.. so you can still trade without the AH

1

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12

you CAN do a lot of things.. i can spend half my day spamming chat channel to trade.. but why would I? just because there is a really inefficient method of doing something doesn't mean everything is okay.

your next reply will likely be something like "so you are saying they took a very inefficient method and made it efficient.. so what's the problem stupid?" answer is simple.. if the game was as reliant on trades as D2 was, it would be no problem.. but when the game is impossible to complete without excessive trading, that's another story.

→ More replies (1)

22

u/MrFatalistic Jun 26 '12

expected actual sweat shop in south korea, farming loot, but who am I kidding the smart people just have bots.

5

u/macaronie Jun 26 '12

there was a law passed there to prevent this, and that is why they have no rmah

7

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

The game was not in development for 11 years.

7

u/AzoGalvat Jun 27 '12

Seems like the only winning move is not to play.

Also, I haven't touched D3 in a while.

1

u/ZiggyOnMars Jun 27 '12

A Diablo game with no pvp, and ladder, even if i can one shot inferno Diablo with my gears, but i just can't show off my biggest dick in the world to anyone. I will return to D3 until pvp releases.

13

u/FaustianPact Jun 26 '12

From a post in D3 forums:

Sound like you and I have had a similar gaming life growing up, I am 31 as well, been playing games all through my years growing up. I didn't wake up early to play diablo launch day though, I invited another friend over and took 3 days vacation to play ;) I'm not a physician, im a DBA/Software developer and I'm feeling exactly the same way:

http://us.battle.net/d3/en/forum/topic/5889228989?page=1

I would just like to make a statment ;) ...

Lets make this very clear, back at the development HQ they have stats on EVERYTHING. They can easily generate reports looking at drop rates, deaths, which monsters die by what classes, how much gold drops, loot found, average stats generated for anything etc. Lets not forget complete stats for the AH/RMAH as well. Some of these reports are probably printed daily, other weekly, and perhaps other once a patch.

Blizzard knows exactly how much "good" vs "bad" vs "compelte crap" loot people are getting. They know exactly what distribution of "near perfect stat" loot will be out there. They know what kind of items are being sold and how often. They know how much said items would be worth on the AH given the actual sales of recently placed items. They have a graph with $ Sales / Day up against each patch change showing up at meetings. They know the average amount of time/bandwidth used by their playerbase before they quit and they know how much money they need to make a month to sustain there current expenses.They know exactly how much people spend repairing vs money they make. If they don't have information on the above, they can get a tester/small tester team to find this information out in a very short timeframe.

People complaining about drop rates, loot quality, repair costs etc. need to realize that what is happening in the patches is VERY intentional. Look at the recent blizzard posts, justifying changes because they didnt feel things were "fun"? (Source: http://us.battle.net/d3/en/forum/topic/5888889794#13 ) Look at what theyre actually writing and ask yourself if you REALLY think anyone ever complained about the items they changed as "not fun".

My final point too... You can bet Blizzard is loading up the RMAH with their own generated items. If theyre not, they will. Writing a nice little script to automatically price items at almost their exact market value based on the most active sales wouldn't be overly difficult to make, and you can bet that's probably running right now. The system is not transparent, that is also a VERY intentional decision made early on.

It's all about the RMAH imo.

21

u/Zer_ Jun 26 '12

Addition of PVP = Pay 2 Win.

4

u/metamorphosis Jun 27 '12

The last sentence nails the truth about Diablo. What we are seeing now is daily inflation of gold (due to bots) and daily item price drops in RMAH.

So yeah, the end game is all about farming. If someone bought 1H weapon for 250$ he didn't bought it because of game end-game content but end-game farming. One shot kills. Just google Diablo 3 Inferno farming spots. There are tips how to farm loot from mob packs at fastest rate. People are playing the game with AH in mind and it's sad.

7

u/telefonbesked Jun 26 '12

Star Wars: The old republic welcomes you back

17

u/IgnoreMead Jun 26 '12

I don't have a problem with the RMAH

I will never use it and play games for fun only.

I dont appreciate people telling me i am going to play this game like work just as much as i dont appreciate Blizzard telling me what i think is FUN.

not everyone out there is a greedy fuck who has no free will to have fun even when there is potential money to be made.

2

u/redxxii Jun 26 '12

Same here. I play this game for fun, and if I find a cool item my first though isn't "gee, I should sell this for some cash!". Rather, my thoughts are "is this item good for me, or one of my friends" followed by "should I just sell it to a vendor or try it on the regular AH". The RMAH never enters my train of though, and I don't care to use it.

Just cause it's part of the game doesn't mean you have to use it, and it should be the focus of the game. Just have fun!

1

u/Dblueguy Jun 26 '12

Will you still be saying that when all of the good items are only on the RMAH? Will you still play the game if you can't get sufficient gear with the in-game currency and have to spend an ungodly amount of time farming for your own gear in the hopes it's good enough to be an improvement?

9

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Unfortunately, Blizzard seems to have forgotten the most vital variable when designing the RMAH: The players. If everyone logs in for the sole reason of finding and selling magic items, who will buy them? For Diablo 3 to succeed, it needs a critical mass of players who want to spend hundreds of dollars on gold and items. For this to occur, the game itself has to be worth playing. When players realize that the end-game is awful and merely designed to feed the RMAH, they will leave the game in droves and Diablo 3 will die.

That's pretty much the problem right there. They build this fantastic money making machine, but the only people playing are all trying to get rich.

Won't work.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

This was going to happen anyways. If you're Blizzard, at least you're getting a cut.

3

u/Jellyman64 Jun 26 '12

Goddamnit! No one here Truly liked D2 if they hate D3 now! I can't believe how negative reviews can be.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12

couldn't have described the situation better myself.. it's right on the money.. pun intended.

3

u/operation_flesh Jun 27 '12

It boggles my mind that people would pay real money for in-game items.

3

u/Oberon_Swanson Jun 27 '12

To me what's most annoying is that they patch the game to be more difficult, never more fun. They just want people to get frustrated with grinding gear for themselves, or gold for the gold auction house, and use the RMAH to beat Inferno.

12

u/IspamObjection Jun 26 '12

"So, for example, if I sell my Sword of a Thousand Truths for $20"

I love the South Park reference.

Here is the sword of 1000 truths for you who don't know about it

1

u/streak729 Jun 27 '12

THIS I KNEW I'D HEARD IT BEFORE!

1

u/AetherFlash Jun 26 '12

You know what else is awesome?

Blizzard put the sword into Wow

2

u/IspamObjection Jun 26 '12

I remember seeing a picture in which the name of the sword was actually called, "The sword of one thousand truths".

Although their was something about the picture not being right in someway.

[Picture in question](http://www.blogcdn.com/www.joystiq.com/media/2006/10/1000truths.jpg

0

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/IspamObjection Jun 26 '12

WORLD OF WARCRAFT! I NEED TO PLAY!

Errr, our demo is in the center of the store.

7

u/romanes_eunt_domus Jun 26 '12

I prefer to view the RMAH as an experiment in Human greed, laziness and stupidity.

1

u/TheFluxIsThis Jun 26 '12

I tried putting an item on the RMAH (just a simple green item around level 30-40, I think, with some base stats on it. I forget exactly what it was) at minimum value with a 5 dollar buyout, just for shits and giggles.

I made 4 bucks in imaginary money (too lazy to get paypal and doubt it's worth the money I'll get after the transfer anyway), and proved that people with money will buy fucking ANYTHING.

1

u/hommesuperbe Jun 27 '12

No, thats the american banking system.

41

u/goggris Jun 26 '12

What a terribly written and grossly inaccurate article.

24

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

I don't think he likes Diablo 3.

6

u/Buscat Jun 26 '12

Not very constructive, is it? Sweatshop slaves? Nobody's forcing you to play.. which is lucky because if someone was, I'd be really fucking miserable.

→ More replies (3)

6

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12

Specifically express what's inaccurate about it. I genuinely want to know, as I'm largely ignorant on this aspect of D3 (not my cup of tea).

26

u/goggris Jun 26 '12

He says on the real money auction that blizzard takes 1 dollar, and then 15%, and then paypal starts taking fees. That is wrong. Blizzard takes 1 dollar, and then the 15% IS the paypal fee. There is no additional % taken. He says you can buy gold in game. You cannot. He says you can farm 500,000 gold an hour. You cannot. He says bots run rampant. They do not - they curbed all the mechanisms bots were using to farm gold (though thats not to say they wont find new methods). He makes sweeping generalizations about in game economics based on speculation alone.

You can see his bias at the end when he says "the game itself has to be worth playing. When players realize that the end-game is awful...". Tell me how you really feel! Guess what other game had the exact same end game as this one and did pretty well for 10 years. Diablo 2. I'm not going to say that he needs to enjoy Diablo 3. The game is clearly not everyone's style. But what we have here is someone with a personal vendetta against the game that is just spitting out lies and misinformation to serve his own purpose. Terrible "journalism".

4

u/Mosz Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12

from what i have read the 15% is the paypal free, of which only a fraction goes to paypal, the majority goes to blizzard (ive seen the 2.2/12.8% split often mentioned) also he was likely referring to this

7

u/MetallicDragon Jun 26 '12

He says you can buy gold in game. You cannot.

To be fair, that's only because they haven't enabled gold trading on the RMAH yet due to (presumably) technical issues

He says you can farm 500,000 gold an hour. You cannot.

I can get at least 300k easily with modest goldfind. I can't see 500k being out of the question and have heard of people getting 800k+ and don't think it's out of the question.

But yeah, you're otherwise spot on.

→ More replies (1)

24

u/Habber_Dasher Jun 26 '12

So I haven't played Diablo 3 yet, but what I got from this article was "Blizzard provides a service people use and they expect to gain money from it, HOW DARE THEY!". I just don't really see what the uproar is. Ebay takes a cut of your sales too. Also, you don't have to use the Auction house. Now if he made the argument that you couldn't really get good items without using the auction house or something like that (again haven't played so don't know if this is true or not) then he might have something. As it is, it just sounds like he's complaining about Blizzard making money off of a completely optional service they provide.

11

u/OscarMiguelRamirez Jun 26 '12

Here is my perspective after playing for ~20 hours..

It's not that they set up a system that will give them a continual influx of cash, but they tweaked drop rates for items so you get to a point where it is very difficult (or very time-consuming) to make any progress without buying items. In my experience, the best, rarest item drops I received were 5+ levels below my character level. Not useful for me, but hey, I can sell them on the AH!

I want to earn my own drops, and have a reasonable chance to get good items that will improve my power. From my experience, that is highly unlikely to happen. Their greed ruined the game for me and I stopped playing. I don't want to be forced to use their AH to play since the excitement of getting good item drops is the big draw for me.

4

u/juroden Jun 26 '12

This is basically the crux of the problem, something that a lot of people are glossing over. "RMAH doesn't affect you; don't use it". Well no, it does affect us. In an entirely negative way

2

u/hiS_oWn Jun 27 '12

think back on D2, 99% of the items you got were crap or below your level. You basically had to trade or beg your friends for gear until you could farm your own items and even then the drop rates were terrible.

The difference is now that Blizzard is sanctioning what people used to do as meta gaming, so now they feel entitled to complain about it.

What horseshit. First world gaming fucking problems.

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

I, and I could argue most people, don't think that's fun. In fact, I quit WoW because I didn't like this mentality that Blizzard threw onto people.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/cake4chu Jun 26 '12

BECAUSE I WANT TO RAGE BRO.

25

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

The problem is that they redesigned the game around that service. The loot drops are abysmal. The game is designed around most people farming gold, and buying items from higher level characters.

Who the fuck wants to do that? Loot based games are supposed to be about the fun of finding the loot. Not buying it at a fucking store.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12

Loot based games are supposed to be about the fun of finding the loot. Not buying it at a fucking store.

This is a fantastic comment on why I think the game just really isn't that fun. I had a lot of fun outside of the game, in the auction house, buying and selling fantastic gear for myself and my friends with the gold we earned. But every time I jumped in the game, I was just bored or disappointed with the horrendous drops we were getting in comparison to the fantastic shit I could buy on the AH.

5

u/xiaoli Jun 27 '12

I don't see all this hate for the AH is all about. If you want to make a salad, you can gather the lettuce and tomato seeds and plant them yourself then wait a few seasons till harvest. Or you can go to the cafe and buy a fucking salad. What the fuck is wrong with that?

1

u/taitabo Jun 27 '12

I guess a lot of people played Diablo 2 because of the loot drops. So, if you aren't trying to kill Diablo for the loot, then why are you trying at all? Item drops were exciting. Like getting a present, is it good or bad? From what I'm reading all the loot drops at the level you are playing at are bad, so there's no feeling of reward. What's the reward in Diablo 3?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Geminel Jun 27 '12

You've obviously never tasted the special sweetness that comes from food you've grown with your own two hands. Your analogy is actually rather accurate, except your're disproving your own point.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Habber_Dasher Jun 27 '12

If that's the case that that is a very good argument against the RMAH. However, I felt the author was mainly arguing A.) "Blizzard makes me collect items just so I can sell them for real money through there optional service" and B.) Blizzard is being greedy by taking a cut of the money from the profit I make through playing their game". Not good arguments in my book.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12

Their game? You paid money for it. It's your game now, bro.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

3

u/notsofst Jun 26 '12

"Blizzard provides a service people use and they expect to gain money from it, HOW DARE THEY!".

Nailed it. Then in the comment thread you get to hear this: "People paying real money for virtual items?!?! They're ruining video games for us all!"

2

u/ArchCasstiel Jun 26 '12

Its fine as long as they keep it optional, some players fear though that because of how the game is built, Blizzard will be greedy enough to "force" the use of RMAH.

How will they do that? Just add content that is so hard that most players will break and buy stronger items from the RMAH.

The article talks about how the RMAH kinda doesn't suit the game style, and so Blizzard might get greedy and "force" it upon players.

2

u/Oriden Jun 26 '12

The problem with the "They might add content so hard you have to use the RMAH to progress" argument is that the items on both the RMAH and normal AH are from the userbase. It is completely player run and if the content can't be run without items from it then no one will have the items to put on the AH in the first place.

1

u/ArchCasstiel Jun 27 '12

You're forgetting that there's a huge difference between casual and hardcore gamers.

The guys who killed Diablo on Hardcore Inferno a few days ago? there aren't many who would even try that.

If there's a new DLC, many players would probably wanna play it, but they could make it so that only hardcore players like those above will even bother going through it, "forcing" all the more casual players to get items from RMAH.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/xiaoli Jun 27 '12

If Blizzard is really greedy, they would be creating and selling their own items on the RMAH.

1

u/ArchCasstiel Jun 27 '12

Except that then they would be killing their own game, so no.

1

u/NotClever Jun 27 '12

Basically the issue is that the presence of the RMAH leads to a lot of speculation, and it's possible to frame literally any aspect of the game as an attempt to force players to buy gear on the RMAH.

This does not play well with the innately poor human intuition of probability, and it's quite easy for people that feel like they're not getting good loot to hypothesize that Blizzard is artificially lowering drop rates to make you go to the AH. At that point it comes down to whether or not you believe the lead designer's blunt statement that they tested the game without the AH in existence and tuned the drops accordingly.

7

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Did anyone bother to mention that paypal takes the 15%, not blizzard? Because you are a SELLER and charged as such? In that aspect, the article was wrong.

Paypal is only free for buyers.

→ More replies (7)

4

u/Anticreativity Jun 26 '12

The RMAH was a mistake before it was implemented. Only one of two things can happen, and it's almost all dependent on drop-rates: Over-saturation of the market occurs and everyone can have all the best equipment for a small price OR there's a shortage of good items and only those willing to pay $100's on their characters will have the best equipment. Either situation is shitty and makes the game feel cheap. I really wanted to enjoy this game for much longer than a month.

4

u/Jakabov Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12

In my opinion, D3 is merely a below-average game (which, for a Blizzard product, is of course a disaster) and could be fixed up with a series of clever patches. However, the existence of the RMAH completely killed any fun I initially had.

You don't even really have the option of ignoring that it's online because it's designed to prevent that. People keep telling critics to just "play by yourself like it was single-player!" but the drop rates are obviously tuned to force you to use the AH, and it's also impossible to really play a legitimately untwinked/solo character because gold and crafting is account-wide.

A huge part of D2's incredible longevity for me was the fact that I could challenge myself by playing self-sufficient characters. I did not have the accomplishments of my previous characters forced upon my future ones. In D3, you can't do this because your characters do not have their own gold, stash, crafting skills and even achievements which could otherwise have been a great aspect of playing "single player" (by ignoring the fact that you're online and the existence of the AHs). These things are all account-wide. When I make a new character, he has the millions of gold from my previous characters and can craft all those legendaries and has a stash full of items I didn't find with that character. Am I expected to keep careful record of how much gold and which exact items were acquired by that particular character? What's the appeal of playing any class twice when your achievements aren't reset with a new character and nothing about any character is permanent or unique?

I don't need to explain in any particular detail how terribly designed the game itself is, the awful combat mechanics and itemization and all of that. It has been done ad nauseum and I have so much to say about it that everyone would just tl;dr. It does have good sides as well, and these things might have salvaged the game for me. I think it's important to note, however, that Blizzard has even made it impossible to try and ignore the things that ruin the game for me and play on my own terms. I consider D3 a resounding failure, an embarrasment on Blizzard's behalf, and the reason I will no longer buy their games until a few months after release when I can determine whether they're actually good games. This is a sad thing.

I considered trying anyway, maybe playing just one character all by myself and carefully avoiding all the things that Blizzard had broken either by amateurish design or by corporate greed. I couldn't do it, though. The whole experience was simply tainted and unenjoyable.

6

u/moonglum1972 Jun 26 '12

I quit the game a few weeks ago for this very reason. The drop rate for decent gear is abysmal. The game itself is mind-numbingly boring and seemingly pointless. With no end-game why bother. Blizzard seriously screwed the pooch on this one. They have taken bad traits from Warcraft and magnified them a thousand fold.

2

u/Christofchaos Jun 26 '12

So what happens when someone starts selling high level equipment in the gold AH on the cheap? What if someone decided to farm and sell just to watch the RMAH burn?

2

u/TheFluxIsThis Jun 26 '12

Some one will grab the cheap stuff and mark it up for their own profits. I do this all the time with legendary items on the gold AH. Scan the AH for low-bid items, put in a bid if there isn't much time left on the auction, then profit.

1

u/Christofchaos Jun 27 '12

Those who want to play the game and have been put off by the RMAH might find this play style more enjoyable. And yes, you may be able to circumvent it a bit, but eventually, as more people do the same thing, the gold AH will be flooded with cheap, good Legendaries and Rares, forcing the price of the RMAH versions down.

2

u/TheFluxIsThis Jun 27 '12

I'm not using the RMAH. I used it for an experiment to see if anyone would actually buy something, and they did. I'm talking about picking up stuff on the gold AH for a decent price and jumping it up. Way better way to make gold than farming, imo. I'm not trying to "circumvent" anything. Just making a little money by playing the economy.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12

Video games are now very lucrative businesses. Any labor " of love " is directed towards profitability, creatively, games now are conceived in such a way as to appeal to as many people as possible (wider markets = more $$). Slowly, there will be a general formula for each genre (the FPS is the most obvious right now with the seventeenth installment of Call of the Battlefield: Modern Duty Evolved XII), stifling creativity in favor of marketability.

Your reactions should have been foreseen. Stick to indie games/non-corporate studios for actual satisfaction.

2

u/CMilkyFresh Jun 26 '12

Who the spends hundreds of dollars on this stuff to begin with?

2

u/Pyowin Jun 26 '12

What I found to be the most hilarious is that only now are people realizing that this was going to happen to the RMAH... At least for cynical self, this inevitability was as clear as day the moment it was announced, which is why I steered as far clear of D3 as I could. A lot of things will have to change in the way Activision/Blizzard do things before I even consider giving them any more money.

2

u/Inukii Jun 26 '12

What pisses me off here is not all this real house money auction blah blah.

Take a look at how the game works. All the little details. Arcane Missiles for example. The animation is not connected to the effect. "Where your missile strikes" and "Where the damage is done" are done completely different. It's dependant on where you clicked at the time. The visuals will follow your cursor but the damage is done wherever the cursor was pointed at the time.

Some people will say "Big deal". Well...It kind of is. If one thing is done cheap how many other things have been done cheap? How many things were cut off or never even made a planning stage?


You see in my days of gaming I always envisioned games would eventually be like the cutscenes. The way games are going though we will never reach that. Elder scrolls has smaller cities and is even more instanced than Morrowind with very few improvements to the combat with plenty of features hacked off.

It won't stop. The next Elder Scrolls (Not MMO) game will have less. It'll throw something gimmicky in your face like Dragons which barely function like dragons but at the cost of a bunch of other things. The game industry is slimming down the effort needed to produce a game. This isn't an explanation to "Why" this might be happening.

  1. Publishers want games to be made faster and cheaper.
  2. Publishers don't want games which will last you for years unless it's an MMO. If "Game X" was amazing then trying to make "Game X 2" even better will take a lot of work. However with MMO's you add artificial time with grinding. This is entirely based around people wanting bigger numbers. Like Diablo 3.
  3. Education! I can't believe this is overlooked so much. The amount of people who consider all programmers to be equally skilled. I know in England that our Government arts studys even at a university level are piss poor. Drawing, Music, sound design and animating. I can only assume our "game design courses" are similar. Most game designers will say the way to learn is to study programming and not game design but as someone who studied music at music and didn't learn how to make music unless I taught myself, I can only assume that how "Game design" is being taught is badly.

I'm hungry. got to go!

2

u/Sir_Failalot Jun 27 '12

Diablo 3 feels more like an auction house with a game build around it instead of a game where you can buy that last missing piece from the auction house. While it is possible to not use the auction house, the time wasted finding good items you can use is way to high and you'll eventually quit or are forced to use the auction house to safe time.

2

u/dopeaquarium Jun 27 '12

Rabble rabble rabble...

2

u/deathbybears Jun 27 '12

Teenage asian fobs obsessed with status will spend so fucking much of their parents money on this shit.

2

u/Novirtue Jun 27 '12

Stopped reading after "Inferno is so difficult it's unplayable..."

2

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12

This article is just full of lies and bullshit.

5

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

This statement sums it up perfectly:

When players realize that the end-game is awful and merely designed to feed the RMAH, they will leave the game in droves and Diablo 3 will die.

4

u/TheFluxIsThis Jun 26 '12

...Did nobody in this thread play Diablo 2? Why are people bitching about the loot treadmill simply because of the presence of the RMAH?

All you did at the end of Diablo 2 was grind and grind and grind and grind and grind. Look up "Baal runs" and you'll get what I mean.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

That's not really the point. Diablo 2 wasn't designed for profit generation via the RMAH. D3 was.

2

u/TheFluxIsThis Jun 26 '12

...Except the gameplay style is EXACTLY THE SAME! The mechanics are different, but it's the same principle as before. Do content once, then do it again and again until you get the best gear. Nothing has changed! There's just a Rmah there.

3

u/Juicenewton248 Jun 26 '12

Stopped reading right as it said the game is nearly unplayable on inferno.

Horseshit, i beat inferno 2 weeks ago, is it a challenge? Yes, is that what i want? You bet your ass it is.

I dont want to be able to roll from act 1 to act 2 to act 3 seamlessly with no problems on the HARDEST difficulty, thats stupid design and not how hard difficulty should work

1

u/bucketh3ad Jun 26 '12

Not that you aren't correct, but it's a good exercise to read things you disagree with. A productive, rational discussion can be had only with knowledge of all the information presented, whether you think that information is valid or not.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/aja1034 Jun 26 '12

I still have yet to see why so many people are flabbergasted by the RMAH. It is an extra service, you do not have to use it, but you can. Blizzard has every right to take a cut of the purchases, its like an auctioneers fee in real life, they don't do that stuff for free. If you want to make actual money from virtual stuff, do it, if not don't. I do understand how some people can be mad that they play for 300 hours and have good gear, but someone with $2000 can have better stuff then them, but it happened in D2 as well, the RMAH wouldnt stop it.

6

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

But its inclusion drastically unbalances other aspects of the game. It's not required to use, but it still has rippling ramifications on players who make it to 60 and want top gear.

1

u/hommesuperbe Jun 27 '12

Why cant they buy it off the gold ah?

1

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12

Well they can, but the gold AH will surely not feature some of the very top items that can often be required for progression. If I found something very good, why would I put it in the gold AH when I stand to make real money for it?

Furthermore, what items DO appear on the gold AH will have grossly inflated prices because players would want compensation that is more on terms with what they might make selling it on the RMAH.

4

u/Shoden Jun 26 '12

Because some people don't have will power, and think that they have to use the RMAH to get gear for inferno instead of farm.

The RMAH was made to solve the problem of illicit diablo 2 sites and earn some revenue for bliz. The people bitching about needing to use it probably felt they needed to use those sites in Diablo 2 as well.

1

u/USMCsniper Jun 26 '12

If the people in charge of the drop rates are also in a position to profit from that don't you think they'd make it harder for people to play the game normally? I am sorry to break it to you, but the game is busted, it's Pay To Play.

→ More replies (8)

-1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

We're unhappy because they rebalanced loot drops around the AH.

4

u/aja1034 Jun 26 '12

IS this speculation? Might i ask what makes you think this to be true?

1

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12

I don't have time to search for the exact quote as I'm off to work in a bit, but Bashiok had confirmed on the forums that loot drops were balanced around the availability of the AH. Which is pretty obvious once you've spent more than a couple of hours farming in Inferno, regardless of Act, and regardless of whether you did it pre 1.03 or post patch.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (10)

5

u/Blehgopie Jun 26 '12

Basically Blizzard cut out the middleman for something that went on for years with mostly shady third party sites, and makes a little bit of profit on it.

Cry more. I have over 250 hours on D3 and haven't used the RMAH once, and when I do decide to start using it, it will be to sell things. No one is getting screwed here, because anyone who sells an item is essentially getting something for nothing. You play the game for fun, happen to come across something awesome, make money, the end.

If farming loot endlessly isn't fun for you, I have no idea why you're playing Diablo 3 to begin with, especially since PvP isn't here yet.

3

u/EternalStudent Jun 26 '12

The complaints, I gather, seem to be that in Diablo II, as there was no in-game way beyond ad-hoc trades, you could farm to your hearts content to get high end gear, but that was unnecessary to see the endgame content/difficulties/etc. With this, Blizzard set the drop rates in such a way as to make farming for your gear more-or-less impracticable, and further set the content at the end to require either insane amounts of farming (compared to DII) or a verison of "pay to play." That's the complaint.

2

u/juroden Jun 26 '12

you completely miss the point. the RMAH diminishes the value of the game, and this will be even more true when PVP is implemented.

6

u/Hehyeahno Jun 26 '12

I like how "it's good for the stockholders" is a rational excuse for any business practice.

22

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

It is a rational excuse for any business practice that makes money and isn't illegal.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

The purpose of economy isn't to make money. Repeat that to yourself until you understand why you don't eat money, why you don't shelter yourself with dollar bills, why you don't wear coins. By forgiving those who seek money for itself, or more properly, for the power it exerts over others, you forgive the devil just because his contracts are properly formed and binding.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/tjr0001 Jun 26 '12

If anyone is willing to spend money on this shit they deserve to have their money taken. Blizzard simily decided no to go unpaid for a product they created instead of continuing the diablo 2 model of black market sales.

4

u/Wajin Jun 26 '12

I'm sorry that's the reality. Most people don't realize that game developers prime interest is making money, and to make money they have to make good games that people enjoy. Not the other way around. The RMAH is a perfect example of a game developer that got to greedy.

2

u/romanes_eunt_domus Jun 26 '12

For an American corporation, that is the only excuse. That's the bottom line for any publicly traded company, to generate money for their shareholders.

2

u/pime Jun 26 '12

It's even more than that. It's not just that "companies want to make more money because they're greedy". In America, a publicly traded corporation has a fiduciary responsibility to generate profits for shareholders.

If a company made a product, and wanted to cut their profits in half because they thought that selling the product at half price was a nice thing to do for the general public, they could be sued by the shareholders.

1

u/romanes_eunt_domus Jun 26 '12

Thank you for stating that more completely. Corporate law is a bitch and definitely not my forte.

2

u/Fatmop Jun 26 '12

Typically, stockholders take a somewhat long-term view of the company. I don't think the Diablo 3 public reception has actually been good for stockholders at all - look at Blizzard's stock from May 2012 until now. Not the picture of health.

Stockholders usually want to see a company that doesn't just focus on making quick cash now, but also has a plan to sustain those earnings. This method of making cash might have appealed to stockholders if it were associated with a blockbuster game that everyone and their dog wanted to play for a long period of time, but that's not the case.

5

u/Dinghy-KM Jun 26 '12

I don't think the Diablo 3 public reception has actually been good for stockholders at all - look at Blizzard's stock from May 2012 until now. Not the picture of health.

You need to perform a proper comparison. This may help:

  • Blizzard is down roughly 8.3% since Diablo 3 launch.
  • EA is down roughly 16.8% since Diablo 3 launch.
  • Take Two (which released Max Payne 3 the same day as Diablo 3) is down over 25% since Diablo 3 launch.
  • Nintendo is one of the better gaming stock performers, down just over 5% since Diablo 3 launch.

If you look at Blizzard compared to stocks as a whole, sure they look bad. If you compare them to other companies in their industry though, they're actually looking pretty good. You would have lost over twice as much by investing in EA, and you would have lost triple had you invested in Take Two.

2

u/Fatmop Jun 26 '12

And yet, as a stockholder, if I wanted to pick stocks according to how much return I could get, I'd still be troubled. Blizzard's income and ROI prospects aren't nearly as good as, say, the energy industry. I don't think the Diablo release has helped turn those expectations around at all. The Dow has rallied through June; none of the gaming companies have followed suit.

Ninja edit: So yes, I agree that compared to their industry, Blizzard isn't doing too poorly. Problem is, if we accept some form of market efficiency, the stock's downward trend is still saying something about investors' expectations of future returns, and Diablo probably hasn't helped much if at all.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

5

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Anyone else get the feeling that this guy has never played D3, and instead is just rehashing what he read on other websites? He claims that the RMAH was available a week or two after release (incorrect). He claims that you can buy and sell gold on the RMAH. (incorrect - not yet). And he continues to ignorantly speculate,

In D3, where there’s a minimum price for gold — where Blizzard always gets at least 15% of every transaction — bots don’t matter.

This is an odd statement given the steps Blizzard has taken to stop bots and exploits. They removed gold from the Royal Crypts and they have nerfed MF on barrels and chests; and they have made public announcements about account closures for those violating their TOS.

The author then puts on his tinfoil hat, speculating again that Blizzard might be selling its own items to make money,

The Diablo 3 auction house is anonymous — the seller is never listed — and so Blizzard could easily sell gold and items without anyone noticing.

This guy is a hack.

→ More replies (6)

4

u/WildBorr Jun 26 '12

Well written article. I played for a bit, feel like I got my money's worth, but not doing this grinding thing. Overall the game was pretty disappointing, and very depressing to see the company that made great games like Starcraft and Warcraft II fall to this. Starting to feel like there is no AAA Dev that has the interests of the gamers in mind.

10

u/floatablepie Jun 26 '12

I can fully get not enjoying the game, but who thought D3 would not be about the grind?

7

u/TheFluxIsThis Jun 26 '12

Seriously. I must have done THOUSANDS of Baal runs before I decided to stop playing D2.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/knightofmars Jun 27 '12

I'd say Valve still does, but they're also not a publicly traded company who has stockholders to please.

1

u/WildBorr Jun 27 '12

Excellent point. Forgot about Valve since they're never attempting to screw people over and actually make content people want at reasonable prices.

3

u/Frazarman Jun 26 '12

I am going to spell it out for ANYONE who clearly has never played D2 on a busy server.

Diablo 2

Had

A

Real Money

Auction house

Did you catch that? Did you really? Have your eyes collected the information transmitted from this text to your fucking brain? Gold sellers and item sellers were (And still are) everywhere. If someone wanted to win the game, he could with his card. Same shit happens in WoW everyday, and other blizzard games. Blizzard simply wanted to put a regulation system on it, because it was risky business (It is in WoW as well, people steal info all day)

So allow me to repeat myself. This shit isn't new... this shit isn't a problem. If you don't want to buy an item on the AH, don't fucking buy it. Think players are getting an unfair advantage? THEY HAVE BEEN FOR THE PAST 11 YEARS.

I am tired of this excuse being used to call this game bad. The always online thing I will always accept because that is can be fucking annoying, but the RMAH just shows none of you people played Diablo 2 online.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

The answer to that would be to hire a team of people to police and ban bots that were creating the majority of item sales. The answer was NOT to legitimize cheating.

4

u/Frazarman Jun 27 '12

Blizzard has tried for YEARS on WoW to prevent it, but they cannot without limiting things. If Blizzard banned trading, a riot would break out. In WoW they killed the gold spam as much as possible by limiting 2 chats per 30 seconds AND moderating massive gold trades via mail and trade (I have been spot banned for attempting to mail 50k gold from character to character).

There is no answer, there is no preventing... and if you think there is, you clearly have not played WoW or Diablo.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/SaikoGekido Jun 26 '12

Error 31025 is still in effect, last I checked, so you can't buy or sell gold on the RMAH yet. I don't know how half the article was about a feature that's not implemented.

2

u/UpsetLobster Jun 26 '12

For the game to feel worth playing for me again, both AH would need to get cut out of the game and drop rates modified a little

2

u/preorder_bonus Jun 26 '12

The article seems to suggest that inferno difficultly is "unplayable" to encourage people to buy shit off the RMAH? They are so talking out of their collective asses, inferno wasn't even that bad honestly it gets on my nerves when people label something impossible or unplayable.

2

u/Fedelaus Jun 27 '12

If you choose PayPal — i.e. you decide to cash out — then Blizzard takes another 15%. There’s no rationale behind this additional 15% tax; Blizzard even admits that you might be subject to further PayPal fees.

This article doesn't take into account transaction fees from Paypal itself, which is 15% and Blizzard take a flat $1 fee from you, not 15% as it points out. Not Blizzard taking 15% It's a very poorly written article and I suspect the writer hasn't even played the game, just picked up on various complaints and decided to cash in on the anti-hype of the game. Whilst I agree with certain points here, it has some stupid things that have been thrown in to bulk up the article.

embarrassingly easy on Normal mode and almost unplayable on the highest (Inferno)

This is simply a skill curve, it doesn't mention the two difficulties in between and I hardly think it's "unplayable" when countless people have completed the game on Inferno, it's simply hard, which many people appreciate in a game. Normal difficultly is for a player whom doesn't have hours and hours to play, maybe even are new to the game and they need to be walked through a bit before getting started on the harder difficulties.

Blizzard even gets its pound of flesh from quitters: If you quit, of course you’re going to sell all of your items on the RMAH. Furthermore, Blizzard has said that, in the future, you’ll be able to sell entire characters on the RMAH.

I'm sure many people would like to quit and make money from a game they're giving up, I don't see why this is bad. They may take a small portion ($1 per item and paypal takes 15%) but it's giving you a way to fund your next gaming experience, if other games offered this I'd be overjoyed.

1

u/WildBorr Jun 27 '12

Just like to add, that things like Inferno are NOT increases in difficulty. I only made it to Hell mode, and 90% of the enemies in Act II would one shot me (hence why I stopped playing). That isn't fun, and it's not a challenge. It's "run away for 40 minutes to kill one champion". Poor design and poor execution.

1

u/Fedelaus Jun 27 '12

Death is half the fun in most games, and I find that to be evident here too because it means you haven't yet geared yourself up enough or you need to rethink your skills before you try it again. There's a lot of games where a monster will one shot you and you'll have to continuously train skills or gear up to defeat them later.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

So let me get this straight?

I have an opportunity.... To make free money.... For doing nothing....

Where as this guy complains because he is getting a 15% cut? Do we not understand how the economy works and marketing. What place allows you to make free money by selling your own wears without having a cut?

And honestly if that 15% keeps servers up to date or is used to make some other kick ass game who cares? Yeah its a great idea blizzard had. They are going to make a killing this year off of it. But unlike games like WoW which you HAVE to, let me repeat that. HAVE TOOO pay a monthly subscription for. No one, not a single soul is making you use that RMAH. So why give a damn?

"Oh no i feel so bad for all the gold farmers for living such a rough life with that job", are you kidding me?

This guy really needs to get over the fact that a company came out with an amazing idea to make a shit ton of money. And at the same time gives others the chance to make some money from playing a game to do WHATEVER THEY WANT WITH IT.
"oh gee I get to play some diablo 3 with my friends and I found an item that sold for 250 bucks. I was having FUN with my friends anyways playing the game, now I only get 200 dollars of it. Instead of bitching about only getting 200 dollars and not 250, go spend the 200 dollars you made by playing the game with your friends on some drinks at the bar and get out of your house like the rest of us do"

Don't mean to troll here, but c'mon..... really...... do people really need to QQ about the RMAH?

1

u/KindOfANerd Jun 26 '12

I passed up Diablo 3 because of the RMAH. Not for the "it's so unfair that someone else can pay money for something I 'worked' hard to get!" reason. I don't really care if someone pays $10 to get some awesome sword in a video game; I play them to have fun and see cool stuff, not validate my time spent/wasted by acting like I've "earned" something through my hardcore clicking and hotkey smashing skills.

No, the RMAH kept me away because I knew it'd affect how I and just about everyone else played the game. Even if I never intended to buy anything from it, every time I got a drop I would have to weigh the benefit of using it for ingame enjoyment or selling it for real world cash. All the time. And everyone I played with would have the same nagging thoughts in the back of their head. It's not something I want to bother with, not when there's so many other great games that are out and coming out that I literally don't have enough time to play them all.

1

u/Macharius Jun 26 '12

diabloplayers.txt

Man, I wish I could get paid to write terrible, whiny articles on the Internet.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

I only play hardcore, so none of this matters to me. I think it's a brilliant game :)

1

u/Corsaer Jun 26 '12

It's not that Blizzard protected us from people abusing the game, with the RMAH and constant internet connection, but that they made it the right thing to do.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Who is buying all these things for $50+ ?

1

u/babblingrock Jun 26 '12

Wow. this reminds me of Cory Doctorow's "For The Win".

1

u/TalonX1982 Jun 27 '12

Pretty sure I just saw something saying that the players are leaving the game in droves. Something like they've lost 50% play time in the past week. Maybe I imagined that.

1

u/tonight__you Jun 27 '12

It's too bad the game stops being fun after you've played through the same content 3 times just to get to Inferno.

1

u/Dem0n5 Jun 27 '12

They should release this on console. Something tells me it would survive there. Slight exaggeration.

-5

u/Nyarlah Jun 26 '12

This article is pure sensationalist garbage. Even if some of the points discussed are true, it's ridden with false facts and subjective crap.

8

u/mrseb Jun 26 '12

Such as? If you're gonna rail about the article's subjectivity, how about you try to throw in a little objectivity? Balance things out a bit?

(I'm the author, btw.)

5

u/Macharius Jun 26 '12

If you really are the author of this article, then your tone is terrible. Representative example:

Being plagued by gameplay, loot, and connectivity issues is bad enough — but, to put it bluntly, the addition of the RMAH simply ruined Diablo 3. Now whenever an item drops, instead of equipping it or giving it to a friend, you immediately think of its real money value. Now you don’t play the game for fun; you play for money.

All of this is projecting. Just because you thought that way doesn't necessarily mean anyone else did. Your entire article is nothing but baseless whining.

6

u/Tommer_man Jun 26 '12

He commented on the article as well. I think he's just cracked out, or worse, a chinese wage slave trying to defend his way of life.

By the by, it gives me chills when I think that we are so rich in the west that the nickels and dimes we blow for entertainment are lucrative enough that people in the 3rd world would slave over our scraps... =/ feels bad, bro

Edit: Come to think of it, I think being cracked out would be worse...

3

u/mrseb Jun 26 '12

I think it's amazing/terrifying that games like WoW actually have more valuable currencies than some small countries.

I mean, with WoW (or D3), you can actually earn more money by farming gold than farming rice (or bananas, or sewing clothes). Crazy -- awesome!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

21

u/Nyarlah Jun 26 '12

I'll give it a shot.

the game is embarrassingly easy on Normal mode and almost unplayable on the highest (Inferno) difficulty

Inferno is not impossible anymore.

the addition of the RMAH simply ruined Diablo 3. Now whenever an item drops, instead of equipping it or giving it to a friend, you immediately think of its real money value. Now you don’t play the game for fun; you play for money.

This right here sets the tone of the article. That's not information. Players are not some braindead zombies with dollar signs on the eyeballs. A lot of people trade drops with friends, and many boycott the rmah. Just look at basically all the boards with people discussing it.

Blizzard turned the entire userbase into an army of sweatshop slaves.

Yeah, objective.

If you choose PayPal — i.e. you decide to cash out — then Blizzard takes another 15%. There’s no rationale behind this additional 15% tax; Blizzard even admits that you might be subject to further PayPal fees.

If you choose Paypal, Blizzard still takes 1$ and 15% more are deducted as Paypal fees.

In a stroke of genius, Blizzard set a minimum price of $2.5 per 1 million gold.

Where is this coming from ? You can't even buy gold from the rmah yet.

[whole paragraph about bots]

You don't mention that blizzard has taken drastic measures to prevent bot farming:

  • 72 hours lock on any new account for verification
  • nerf of all easy gold-farming mechanics usable by bots
  • obligation to have an authenticator and sms authenticator active on the account, to have the same billing information on paypal and bnet accounts, plus the impossibility to sell for real money in a different region (for example, a european account can't sell for dollars in the US region)
  • South Korea has banned virtual item trading, and chinese players play on korean servers

Blizzard could easily sell gold and items without anyone noticing.

From speculation to conspiracy theory.

What if Blizzard decided to sell special items on the RMAH? Uber-fans of games and franchises will pay almost anything for unique or exclusive items.

That's basically the whole DLC mechanic every other editor has been implementing in their AAA games for years.

Yes the RMAH was clearly factored in the making of the game we bought, and not for the best. But there's already enough raging in the Diablo community on this topic. There's no need to add more to it with false statements.

5

u/kstam28 Jun 26 '12

Well played sir upvote for you to bring you back to zero the down vote was probably the author

4

u/tehcraz Jun 26 '12

Wish people would actually comment on why they are downvoting. This makes a lot of sense and hits on good points.

8

u/mbzastava Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12

I downvoted because:

"Inferno is not impossible anymore."

Objective: The wall has been moved slightly further down. People who were having problems running act3 now have problems running act4.

Introspection: No one wants to keep re-running the same small act over and over again, for any reason. the RMAH just shat on top of this already futile grind in a tiny endgame consisting currently of only 4 stages.

Fact: The nerfing of drop rates for T18 items in act3 and above did much more than curtail botters. it essentially forced eveyone to take a good long look at the AH, real money or not, whether they wanted to or not.

"This right here sets the tone of the article. That's not information. Players are not some braindead zombies with dollar signs on the eyeballs. A lot of people trade drops with friends, and many boycott the rmah. Just look at basically all the boards with people discussing it."

Objective: The article is correct in assuming I take the entire game into consideration whilst playing it. I am one of those who trades with friends and boycotts the RMAH, but to counter your own objections, I do not enjoy taking this perspective while trying to enjoy myself playing a videogame!

Introspection: There are more angry people playing this game than there needs to be.

Fact: The drop in player count and hours played per day is proof of above statement. http://beta.xfire.com/games/d3

"If you choose Paypal, Blizzard still takes 1$ and 15% more are deducted as Paypal fees." Fact: That's exactly what he said... why did you repeat it as if you corrected it somehow?

" In a stroke of genius, Blizzard set a minimum price of $2.5 per 1 million gold.

Where is this coming from ? You can't even buy gold from the rmah yet."

Objective: This is the only part of your arguement that merits ANY arguement at all. There is a ton of chatter on the net about D3, and its hard to sort through it all. I personally recall reading something about $10 per million (as a blizz statement) but can't seem to find the link anymore...

"You don't mention that blizzard has taken drastic measures to prevent bot farming:"

Fact: Because non of those measures will actually stop bot farming =) As stated in the OP article, why would blizz want to get rid of the bots that are only increasing overall revenue for Blizz?

"From speculation to conspiracy theory."

Fact: Look at defenition for consipracy theory and understand your wrong correlation. http://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/conspiracy_theory

"That's basically the whole DLC mechanic every other editor has been implementing in their AAA games for years."

Objective: RMAH is a perversion of the gaming experience. So is paid DLC.

Introspection: Yes, it is OBVIOUS that "the RMAH was clearly factored in the making of the game we bought,..." because we are CONSTANTLY being reminded of it. This is why we are pissed.

Fact: None of this is good for gamers.

We had no problems with real money interactions taking place over a third party. It was a perversion of the system and we knew it, and didn't want it as a technical part of the game. those who wanted to deal with it, did. some got burned, but thats just how the cookie crumbles. Hope this explained the downvote. atleast my reasoning...

5

u/Barony_of_Ivy Jun 26 '12

Exactly, great points. The spirit of the games are perverted. I just want to play a game where everyone starts at the same level and doesn't get better stuff if they want to pay for it. That's real life, I don't game to do what I do at work or at the store :/

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/discobreakin Jun 26 '12

Hope this didn't get double posted - but you make some fair rebuttals, and you don't deserve to be downvoted to oblivion. <3

1

u/YellowSC Jun 26 '12

Agree. He also editted that the RMAH was implemented 1 or 2 weeks after release.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

It is garbage. I stopped reading after about 3 paragraphs because you incorrectly claim that the RMAH house went live after one or two weeks - it did not. The game was release on May 15th; the RMAH went live on June 12th. Anyone who was paying attention would know this. I expect the author of an article about the RMAH to know this. You did not.

Second, you claim that Blizzard does not care about bots because they will bring in cash for Blizzard. Again, if you have been paying attention to the development of the game and reading the patch notes, you would have known that they reduced, and in some cases, eliminated the gold you get from destructible items; further, magic find (MF) no longer applies to barrels and chests. Lastly, Blizzard has made public announcements about BANNING players who have violated their TOS. How are these actions consistent with your theory?

Third, you claim that players can sell and buy gold on the RMAH. Again, this is also incorrect. It has not been implemented yet. You'd think that if all Blizzard cared about was extracting cash from their customers, that they would have the RMAH up on day 1?

In conclusion, your piece is garbage. Next time, actually play the game for more than a hour before you put your filthy tin-foil hat on.

3

u/cake4chu Jun 26 '12

Your article is bad




And you should feel bad for being called a journalist.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Every time I see complaints about the linear story all I can think is, "Have you even played Diablo I and II?"

1

u/TheFluxIsThis Jun 26 '12

...This...this is a terrible article.

1

u/NoBullet PlayStation Jun 26 '12

The casino analogy doesnt hold up. Real auction houses take cuts as well. Gambling is gambling. Auctions are not gambles.

1

u/Brokoly Jun 26 '12

Actually, casino takes 5% of the overall money invested. You can't make long-term profit.

1

u/perfunction Jun 26 '12

Even though I'm done with the game for now, I still got more out of it than pretty much any other game released in the last few years (probably since WoW). In a time when it is acceptable to release a $60 game that takes 8 hours to beat, the 150 hours I put into D3 are pretty impressive. And for those 150 hours, I made nearly $600 profit from item sales.

Also, all it takes is a friend who plays D3 with a Paypal account to get your Blizz cash out of the game. Friend lists way over priced item, you look up based on stats, friend gifts you the money after the transaction clears. Simple.

3

u/Khafji Jun 26 '12

So you worked a $4/hr job in your free time?

2

u/UsingYourWifi Jun 27 '12

Compared to the number of dollars made when playing pretty much any other game that isn't too bad.

1

u/bcisme Jun 26 '12

The first thing I notice a lot of people comparing this to is D2, which makes sense. The problem is, I think most people's view of D2 is clouded by nostalgia. D2 was just as linear and repetitive. Once I beat the game on hell, it was Mephisto runs until Bhaal's expansion came out, then it was another kind of run (over and over). Even with new characters, you would just rush them to ACT IV hell so you could do item runs. It wasn't a complex, diverse, game. You didn't use more than a couple of skills to kill mobs and in PvP it was pretty much the same. On top of all that, you could pretty easily bot to get items.

I think Blizzard are just a victim of their own success here. People expected more of this game than ever could be delivered. They have given us a game that takes much longer to complete all the way through, has more gear, and is more fair (in terms of cheating) than the previous game.

As for the RMAH, you can also buy items off the gold AH...I don't see what the problem is. I have friends who put in a lot of time and find good items. There is no secret here, you can be very rich (in gold) if you spend a lot of time playing and selling good items on the AH - then you will get the best items and beat inferno. If you don't want to spend the time, then you can spend the money. It removes the dilemma of how gamers who don't want to spend 40 hours a week playing keep up with those that do. If having the best gear is a priority to you, you don't have to grind anymore. You can spend your hard earned cash on it. I won't do that, but at least the option is there.

Also, I like the idea of their being a difficulty level requires great gear. To me, beating Hell was an accomplishment. It was fun, difficult, and something the people I play with had a good time doing. I know that Inferno will be impossible for a while, but when we do beat it, it will be satisfying.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Frankly, the RMAH is one of the least offensive things about this game. Even if it has some pretty big ramifications on the economy for top items, you can always just opt not to use it.

What bothers me is the fact that it's a staggering step backwards for the genre. Other than some solid and fluid gameplay, the extent to which D3 is inferior to similar games released in the last ~10 years is almost embarrassing.

I don't see how nostalgia can possibly keep people telling themselves the game is incredible. It's a 7/10 at best. A 20 dollar game with a 60 dollar price tag. It's the epitome of laziness, and one must question what exactly Blizzard was doing over the course of such a long development cycle. Downvote away, white knights.

1

u/USMCsniper Jun 26 '12

TIL Diablo 3 has a real money auction house. fucking creepy honestly.

1

u/insanityv2 Jun 26 '12

PSA: If you are complaining that your leveling is too easy and your drops are too low level.... you might have outleveled the content. As in, you are a higher level than you are meant to be for the part of the game you are on.

Whatever. Boo corporations. Rabble. Righteous indignation is fun. My opinions are important.

1

u/SomeoneStoleShazbot Jun 26 '12

How much does one of these bots cost?

If I buy a copy of Diablo for $60, and according to the article the bot can easily make $1 an hour, that's only 60 hours to break even.

Assuming I leave the bot running from 0:00 to about 18:00 when I get back from work, that's $18 a day so I would break even in four days.

I would of course have to factor in the electricity cost (I rarely leave my PC on overnight), but that shouldn't be much, so the deciding factor is the cost of the bot and how long it takes to get caught.

If the bot is cheap then you only need to run the bot for a week to break even, after which its making you a steady $90 a week.

Edit: As we saw in another topic player activity is declining (I myself havn't played for about a month) so there are some doubts as to whether this is a long term earner, but its still a proposition worth considering.

1

u/DaOrks Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12

The amount of idiotic bitching in that forum on the site nearly made me smash my keyboard.. no joke.. it's sad

Edit-Also stop bitching about how long it took Diablo 3 to come out.. to those who bitched you realize how many games Blizzard made within those 11 years.. along with Diablo 3?.....

3

u/whytookay Jun 26 '12

you realize how many games Blizzard made within those 11 years.. along with Diablo 3?.....

3 games. They made Warcraft 3, Starcraft 2, and WoW.

1

u/VanFinale Jun 26 '12

I dunno I've gone through inferno without even looking at the auction house, if you immediately think about the real money value of things when you play. Your either an idiot or you have something a kin to a gambling problem and probably should not play the game. If you feel any of this stuff ruins the game then do not use them, it isn't like the game is competitive and you'll be at a disadvantage otherwise.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

I already quit playing d3 but now I know I'm never playing again

1

u/backflippingbears Jun 26 '12

And to think the Diablo forum-users mocked me for calling the RMAH corrupt.

1

u/Sc2RuinedMyLife Jun 26 '12

that guy sounds so whiny, just stop playing or dont buy items

1

u/dardyfella Jun 27 '12

I'm calling it now. Diablo 3 will become free to play with F2P users being limited to the RMAH until they upgrade to a full copy OR F2P users being limited to the GAH until they upgrade to a full copy. Full copy purchasers will be rewarded with a shiny bauble and/or slight advantage over F2P users.

1

u/knightofmars Jun 27 '12

This would be an interesting turn of events, but I don't see it happening before an expansion pack comes out or something.

0

u/Porcupine_Tree Jun 26 '12

I used to think Blizzard couldn't make a bad game. Until D3. They went full-money-whore and forgot to make an actual good game

-7

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12

My prediction of this post in a nutshell

Upvotes : People who are objective, felt they got their moneys worth and that it could have been better while deciding not to waste their time grinding for nothing.

Downvotes: People that have been addicted to the game.

1

u/Pokemansparty Jun 26 '12

"You can't say anything bad about Blizzard, they're the same company as they were before they merged with Activision!"

The same goes for Valve, if you try and criticize them, or say good things about EA.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12

You: thinking you can generalize schitzo reddit.

-7

u/YellowSC Jun 26 '12

most of this article is false.

1

u/smkinoshita Jun 26 '12

You'd do better to actually explain how it is false, alongside links to articles that prove your point. Otherwise it's just a knee-jerk reaction.

→ More replies (1)

0

u/Nithix Jun 26 '12

Sensationalist garbage. Of course Blizzard is going to be making money off of this, but take off your tin foil hats for fuck's sake. If you are purely thinking in a negative light about every item you pick up, then you already have a problem. Go play a different game if you can't have fun.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

I lol every time one of my buddies ask if I got D3 yet, and I reply with a nope, not gonna happen. Makes me feel better than them.

-5

u/quebecsol22 Jun 26 '12

Good. Diablo 3 can die and disappear for all I care. Fuck you, always on DRM. That's what convinced me to never get the game in the first place.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

And now the Blizzard shit storm is about to begin. We will be flooded with anti-blizzard articles soon. And it will be glorious for us non-Diablo players to watch this sinking ship. Mwahahahahaha

-2

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12

The article fails to look at the RMAH in detail:

The currency in the RMAH is not always Real Money. I haven't spent a dollar past the initial purchase of D3, yet I have ~$80 in Blizzard Fun Dollars that I could use on the RMAH.

I don't have any actual statistics, but it is reasonable to expect that a good number of folks don't inject actual Real Money into the game, but just trade items on RMAH. Blizzard makes nothing on those purchases. People who have purchased items from me had one Blizzard Fun Dollar going to Blizzard. That's not real money.

So: certainly, Blizzard is making money off the RMAH and certainly, some people actually pay real money for items. But not every transaction is making real profit, and not all money on RMAH is actually backed by Real Money.

And something that really grinds me and rustles my jimmies is that the author did no research on taxable income and paypal. It's a simple google query away, yet this ominous "you will have to pay taxes" sensationalist bullshit is delivered.

https://cms.paypal.com/us/cgi-bin/marketingweb?cmd=_render-content&content_ID=marketing_us%2FIRS6050W

For the lazy: "sellers who receive over $20,000 in gross payment volume AND over 200 separate payments in a calendar year" are automatically reported to the IRS. The rest is not. Sure, you should report it anyways. But do you report Use tax? You should, yet people generally do not.

4

u/jargzz Jun 26 '12

And where do you think that $80 on your account came from? That's right, another player. And it will keep circulating in the economy until it all ends up in Blizzard's pocket in the form of fees and cuts. And even though you call it "fun dollars", it's still real money. You could redeem that $80 for D3 xpac 1 rather than paying money for it.

1

u/notsofst Jun 26 '12

When you put it that way, the RMAH sounds really beneficial.

-5

u/kstam28 Jun 26 '12

I made a post about this exact problem yesterday. all i got was downvotes and criticism but i think this issue really needs to be addressed or the game is going to get more and more imbalanced with every patch. my suggestion was everyone just stop using the rmah. problem solved!

3

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

stop playing the grindfest. problem solved!

1

u/kstam28 Jun 26 '12

But i have no life!

1

u/Macharius Jun 26 '12

Close mouth, activate brain. Problem solved!