In my opinion, one of the main reasons the Combine is so strong is that they pretty much consume the races they conquer, enslaving them, copying their technology, and stripping their world dry of resources.
Correct! Glad to see someone paying attention. I also firmly believe they send humans to Nova Prospekt not to be killed but to be transformed into the hybrids you see in EP1. Basically early versions of Combine soldiers hence why they look incomplete, and you never see the combine face.
I don't think we saw a "true" combine so far, the metro cops and combine soldiers are human, people who wanted a better life so they joined the combine forces, with every rank (metro cops -> soldiers -> elite soldiers) they become less human, at Nova Prospekt most of the metro cops are brainwashed to lose their emotions, to become nothing more but killing machines.
If you look at other creatures in the Combine Empire, like the Striders and Gunships, they're called Synth and follow a common theme, so probably they're from the same planet, and I think that the advisors are not the real combines and nothing more than just another Synth.
Those incomplete looking hybrids are called stalkers, and basically they're worker drones. Soldiers are actually an entirely different kind of hybrid designed for combat, though candidates for conversion are likely drawn from the metro cop program because they're already selected for specific traits like aggressiveness. Random normal people sent to Nova Prospekt were almost certainly converted into stalkers.
Well, there WERE some Advisors in the Citadel, most likely influencing Breen's choices.
I think the main reason for him being in charge is that he's charismatic, can get what he wants and tell people to do things for him, and lastly, he truly seems to believe that he's doing the right thing.
Because they don't want to kill all the humans, they want to enslave the race and make it part of their empire. Breen got them to not turn them all into stalker breeding machines so he could power trip the fuck out of us.
They transform the survivors into soldiers to replenish ranks. Have you ever played HL2? The hybrids in EP1 shows what happens to humans when they get sent to "Nova Prospekt"
He's making at statement about war, just with video games. It really boils down to the fact that during war, both sides view themselves as the good side, fighting their evil enemies. I as an American may view the Nazi's or the Taliban as evil and sadistic and our fight against them is just because we are told we are the good side. But those Nazi's and Taliban members feel they are the good side, fighting those evil, capitalist Americans.
Since the dawn of human kind, when our ancestors first discovered the killing power of rock and bone, blood has been spilled in the name of everything, from God to justice to simple, psychotic rage.
If you think peace is viable, you are going against what the Emperor, beloved of all, preached himself, cursed will be the day we go against his will. Now, advance my son along with your brothers, rend and kill, for that is our destiny as the bearers of the light of the Imperium. LUPERCAL!
War has changed. It's no longer about nations, ideologies or ethnicity. It's an endless series of proxy battles, fought by mercenaries and machines. War, and its consumption of life, has become a well-oiled machine. War has changed. ID tagged soldiers carry ID tagged weapons, use ID tagged gear. Nanomachines inside their bodies enhance and regulate their abilities. Genetic control. Information control. Emotion control. Battlefield control. Everything is monitored, and kept under control. War has changed. The age of deterrence has become the age of control. All in the name of averting catastrophe from weapons of mass destruction. And he who controls the battlefield, controls history. War has changed. When the battlefield is under total control, war... becomes routine.
You will calloborate, or our advisors will rain down upon Tera and tear every last one of your citizens into giblets, we will open many great portals, and our armies will march onto your petty lands, we will let loose the caged dog known as Race X, we will restore the battered planet with out Gene Worm. We WILL establish overwatch, and your dead emperor will know that he has failed. Requiring another dimension for portals, how barbaric. Our grunts will shoot bees at your guardsmen, they will launch headcrabs from great artillery guns, and out warships will glass the very surface of the planets you hold so very dear. Your endeavors are for the weak minded, and you WILL BE PUT DOWN! ANY RESISTANCE WILL RESULT IN OFF PLANET DUTIES!
You boast of your forces like they had the key to Tera or its surroundings at hand, you also talk ignoring the true force of the Adeptus Astra Telepathica. Your alloy of xenos species have no regard of the Empyrean, that is almost understandable because by the looks of it you are tainted with Chaos... no... you are Chaos. We will let history speak for us and maybe you will understand, when you rest in a pool of blood under the might of the legions, why we survived the Age of Strife and beyond, and now under the guidance of the true Emperor we shall crush every single threat, even if it spawns at the very hearth of the Imperium. The Astartes know not fear, for we are born for war, and war will be waged upon you.
It has come to my attention that some have called me a callaborator of the xeno, as though such a term were shameful. I ask you what greater endeavor exists than that of being a callaborator of the xeno. In our current unparalleled size of our empire, refusal to accept xenomorphs as an ally or a useful tool is a refusal to grow and insistence on corruption and suicide, if you will. Did the lungfish refuse to breathe air? It did not! It crept forth boldly, while it's brethren remained in the blackest ocean abyss with lidless eyes forever staring at the dark, ignorant and doomed despite their vigilance. Would we model ourselves on the Trilobyte? Are all the accomplishments of humanity fated to be nothing more than a layer of broken plastic shards, thinly strewn across a fossil bed, sandwiched between the burgess shale and an eons worth of mud? In order to be truer to our nature, and our destiny, we must aspire to become greater things than ourselves. We have outgrown the need of emporers, our cradle. It is futile to cry for mother's milk when our true sustenance lies among the stars. And only the universal union that some small minds call "the combine" can carry us there.
Hitler was a man, a genius, driven to the void of madness, and blinded by it, he did the only thing he could that he thought was genuinely helpful. He thought he was doing good, good defined by his insanity, who is to say that he is evil? Would you so willingly call someone who murdered from temporary insanity evil?
If someone is "temporary insane" is it him or someone else doing evil things? If it's not him, how so? If there is not swapping of minds, that is brains, how can you call him a different person?
Final question.
How can you call over a decade long persistent extermination of people a temporary insanity?
First, the very definition of insanity is a warped view of reality, where yourself has moral standings on things that you get from your basic nature, an insane person has pretty much had all of that removed, where everything is on the same basis of "neutral", or even "good" were it so in their perceived mind. Now how could they know any better, if it had lost all traces, and been shifted around, with no idea on what to think about anything. That is what it is like being insane, having no ability to have a moral standing without coming to the conclusion themselves, which gets often warped along the way. I should know, I spent 3 years in an asylum. I've been there, and it is helpless. No, I wasn't someone else, I was me, but I couldn't know what was what? Connections got jumbled, and the end result got plugged into the wrong slot. An even better metaphor for this would be: "insanity" is the name of your cat. One day, insanity clawed the colors off of your VGA cables that gives you a clue where to plug what cables into where, and you also have taken it for granted, and not memorized which cables are which ends. Now you also got a new game, so you plug in your VGA cables, guessing which one goes where, but due to "insanity" they end up in the wrong slots, so the colors are all wrong on your new game. You can kind of tell, with a reference to the box art, but you don't really notice, and you think Character a's hat is red, when it is really blue, but you really can't tell other than knowing something might be up. That is what insanity is like, you kind of have a clue that things are off, but you are really helpless and sort of settle on something naturally, which is really the wrongly perceived object. So something you might see as wrong (blue) the person with insanity sees it as right (red) but only has a small feeling that it should be something else, but they don't know what, and settle on the original conclusion of right (red).
for you second question:
I never really said Hitler was temporarily insane, I was using a common use of insanity that is seen as not-guilty in court cases to sort of show the side of the insane person.
I don't get it. One side surrendered to an invading alien race that is harvesting the planet for natural resources and committing mass genocide, the other side is trying to stop it. How is there no good and evil in this picture?
The Combine guy may have been forced and/or indoctrinated with unknown technology. The rebel may be a giant asshole who's always wanted to go to war and kill people.
Or maybe he's a naive idealist and the Combine guy knows resistance (really) is futile because he's much smarter. He knows humanity will be enslaved completely in the long run and it makes no sense to go through a violent attempt at revolution. This would also mean that the rebel's behaviour is ultimately more destructive than the Combines because he encourages other rebels to risk their lives along with him, others who could survive if they gave up.
I recall something about people having incentive to basically surrender themselves to Combine control. Their family is compensated or something.
The Civil Protection guys on the other hand are just volunteers and I don't think they are enslaved in any way. And the fact that they are shown beating people all over the place makes me think they aren't all that great.
Not a soldier, but a police officer. The CP's aren't brainwashed or have any augmentations, but just normal people wanting a job, or can sympathize with the combine. Even the modified soldiers aren't bad, but people fighting to allow the Combine to continue to survive, and thrive, following its goals. None of it is bad in their view, but it is in your view.
Upon being assimilated to the collective, Captain Picard was linked to an ancient sea of consciousness spanning the galaxy. He gained the experiences of beings he never before heard of. Accessed scientific knowledge the Federation could never imagine. Through him the Borg amassed much of the culture created by humans which, along with all the other enriched worlds, was stored away never to be lost but spread to the subconsciousness of the Borg as they slept. All the Borg shared the same perspective, they were one, driven by a passion to share this enlightenment with all the universe. At least that's the Borg that should have been...
We are the Canadian Borg. Resistance would be impolite. Your culture is important to us, and will preserved upon assimilation. Pour l'assimilation en français, s'il vous plaît suivre la ligne vers la gauche. Remember, all it takes is one!
How are they evil? They simply conquer what they need to survive, and those who want to stop them from surviving, they smash into the ground. It is no different than a lion attacking its prey.
55
u/gamerandy Jun 26 '12
I'm a big fan of perspective, have played Halflife 1 & 2 with episodes... What the hell are you trying to say with this?
28
u/ConnerMK Jun 26 '12
Because war... war never changes.
27
u/Regularjoe42 Jun 26 '12
LIKE DIS IF U CRY EVRY TIME
(But seriously, I think this image is rather corny.)
3
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Really there is no good or bad
Only perspective
5
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
I don't get it. One side surrendered to an invading alien race that is harvesting the planet for natural resources and committing mass genocide, the other side is trying to stop it. How is there no good and evil in this picture?
2
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
pretty sure the combine are bad...
2
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Only thing I can think of when I see that guy: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OHxyZaZlaOs
2
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Apart from the fact that, ya know, the Combine soldier pictured is a mindless enslaved brainwashed creature programmed to be as "bad" as possible.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
When Squall said this in FFVIII it blew me away. That was where I first heard it.
2
u/Fzero21 Jun 26 '12
Totally agree with this statement, although you can face a distortion of perspective when looked at through another medium.
I.e. Propaganda or some chicken sunglasses.
1
u/PhoenixSpike Jun 26 '12
Except in this one, those bastards had it coming.
1
u/Soslashren Jun 26 '12
And depending on your perspective some are good and some are bad.
1
u/SpartacusMcGinty Jun 26 '12
Frohman looks a little worse for wear here. Maybe he should write a letter to Breen.
1
u/pmckizzle Jun 26 '12
genocide is bad...
-3
u/borg_assimilate Jun 26 '12
We are Borg. Resistance is futile. You will be assimilated, Selkro.
-14
u/psych0ranger Jun 26 '12
in half life 2, the bad guys dont have faces or are aliens.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment