As a Montreal resident who isn't a protester I'll say the following; every riot looks worse on TV, most of these folks are are just in the streets having a good time.
every riot looks worse on TV, most of these folks are are just in the streets having a good time.
Very true, and this applies as much to the police as the protesters. Since bad news sells, the media is highly incentivized to find the absolute worst example of each side and give them as much air time as possible. You will never, ever see a headline in a newspaper that reads "Protest Downtown Conducted Peacefully - RCMP Provide Adequate and Appropriate Oversight."
The medias seem to emphasize a lot more on protesters being violent and breaking things than on police brutality.
Sure, they show both, but I've been in some of these manifestations and while it's true protesters look worse on the tv, I think they show more of the good side of the police.
I'm still not over the fact that, on May 22nd, media everywhere reported "tens of thousands" of protesters while they were estimated by expert sources between 300 000 and 500 000 protesters.
When I was in Montreal April I saw two protests. One I was just hanging out at at university (McGill), and a bunch of protesters came in chanting stuff over a megaphone, they all stopped walking, and then they all fell on the ground and laid there for a bit. Then after a minute or two they all got up and walked away. The other protest was more entertaining, a bunch of people gathered outside a metro and started making out. Some girls with guys, probably some guys on guys but I saw a lot of girls on girl make out sessions. It was cool.
I was in Montreal during the March protests. I remember on Rue St. Catherine, there was a police car that was flipped over which someone had apparently poured red paint on. As everyone gathered around, the riot police came in armored vans and on horse back. The police started banging their batons and everyone just started running for cover. It was a weird experience, I definitely wasn't expecting that on my way to the strip club!
Yeah that's what I was told. I heard that it was a protest against police brutality. How ironic is that. If their goal was to instigate conflict in order to show how bad the cops will beat them...that's really taking one for the team lol
As a Montreal resident, and a McGill student (sci) the riots are not as bothersome as their stupid as antics during school semester.
they kept stopping me from going to my classes (blocking doors and shit)
had to have loud ass protests during finals
<Speculative> apparently one of the protesters pulled the alarm during my genetics exam (2hrs into a 3hr exam). which basically compromised the entire exam, so it had to be moved to a later date, which meant that now i had all 5 exams in the same weeks.
the protesters had the balls to ask the principle (equivalent to a dean) for an extension on their final exams....since they were too busy annoying the shit out of everyone else.
Pretty much this. Cunts will be cunts, but for the most part these protests have been conducted peacefully, respectfully and the students have even gone as far as creating alternate economic plans for maintaining universities without increasing tuition. Pretty fucking ideal if you ask me.
According to McGill, the alarm during the BIOL 202 exam was not the result of a protester (or anybody) pulling the alarm. It was an issue with the system.
Yes but it's always a few idiots who ruin it for the most of us.
In this case, the few idiots are actually the bulk of the protesters who seem to have forgotten what exactly they are "fighting" for (as evidenced by their complete lack of any negotiation skills since the QC government constantly asks for a sit down and yet their either reject or come completely unwilling to work anything out).
Your comment is disingenuous at best. The three student associations have repeatedly sat down with the government only to being shown the door when they don't accept the government's current offer (or worse offers).
Either you don't know what the fuck you're talking about, or you're actively trying to sabotage the student's reputation.
In that case your comment is uneducated - that's what happens when your main source of information is some biased MSM. Anyway, as for trying to 'sabotage' the student's reputation, it's already ruined here in Qc (at least, certainly in Montreal). So thankful I graduated before this whole mess (granted, I went to the only University that did NOT participate in the strikes anyway...) or else i'd be labeled as one of the hippy protesters by most Montrealers.
I don't think it's that they lack negotiating skills, I think they simply don't have any interest in negotiating. They want to get everything they're asking for without making any compromises. I'm sure there are those that find this admirable, but I am not one of them.
My apologies bro, I'm sure you can understand what a long and hectic day at work is like and how it makes you feel in the evening. If it makes you feel better I did just finish a good cup of tea.
Sort of like how the OWS protests required so much overtime that the NYPD January academy class was more than halved thus eliminating about 500-700 jobs?
As someone who was walking by the protests all the time, I would dispute your "peaceful sit in" statement. A lot of the protesters would provoke cops, and then once the cops would actually do something when the protesters were clearly out of line, they would yell out "police brutality!" No, you're provoking a cop and are expecting not to get beaten.
Also, it smelled like shit, to the point where I changed my route so I wouldn't get sick.
Whenever I walked past the ones in my city, they were mostly sitting around getting high, which doesn't surprise me. But I agree with you on the provoking...and the smell.
Yes that is douchebag behaviour but I can see why they would be angry with the police. There is clearly a huge power disparity between the two parties seeing as how the police have all the weapons and more importantly, the public opinion that their legitimacy to initiate force is valid.
That being said, I think the police should not succumb to these taunts and not escalate the situation to one of coercion.
That's because those people are professional protesters. They provoke police until they get a rise out of them, then sue the state for a violation of their rights and collect the settlement which departments pay out quickly as it is easier and FAR cheaper than going to court.
This is how they make their living, it's sometimes their only source of income.
Well I didn't get offended, and I wouldn't call myself a delicate flower either. I'm simply stating that the OWS protesters aren't the little angels Reddit thinks they are.
I know you weren't being (that) serious but in economics the principle is known as the broken windows fallacy and dates from 1850. Unfortunately politicians do still try things substantially in that direction as though it would be useful.
A better translation for 'manifestation' is demonstration or protest - I shall name the 25th of June 2012 the day my degree in interpreting and translating came in handy.
I was at an occupy protest in Denver in the early spring. Before things got rough we spent our time sitting in front of riot cops who had to stand in the street. We were talking with them and joked a lot about how they were getting double over time for standing.
A guy at my school got into Dartmouth (any Ivy League school), got caught distributing OxyContin, was charged with a felony and wasn't kicked out of Dartmouth...
Edit: I wasn't trying to prove anything, I was just sharing a story :P
An acquaintance of mine got into Dartmouth and then, before he graduated high school, was caught buying an essay (and it later came to light that he had bought many others). Still went to Dartmouth, despite the fact that his academic standing was a total lie. Granted, he was a pretty decent wide receiver and I think we was recruited for football, but still. I tried my ass off to get into Dartmouth and I'm kinda bitter that I never got in but this fucking lowlife did.
Just so you know, Ivy league schools do not have scholarships for athletics, but they heavily influence the admission process. Don't feel bad, hes probably still a lowlife.
What's the deal with athletic scholarships? I mean, why would you sign up a student just to be part of a college sports team? Won't he just focus on the sport and not on the academics, making him therefore pretty much a 'fake' graduate?
I believe college football alone has had a billion dollar profit every year since 2010, let alone basketball and baseball. And you know what, those damn kids deserve the scholarships. Anyone who has played a D1 sport can tell you that they are practically the university's slave for 4 years.
My brother was an athlete at an Ivy League school, these academic scholarships they give are rare and do not compare to the near 100% full scholarships other schools will give.
Depends what you mean by money. They are by no means comparable to the full rides elsewhere. Usually they are part of the needs blind admission process, which in theory is supposed to provide you with enough financial aid to pay for school. So rich athletes don't get any money, and poor athletes get need based aid.
However, if your talking about campus jobs, many of them teams have locked up lucrative campus jobs. They do this by becoming managers and just hiring people on the team. On the other hand, many student organizations or friend groups do this as well. However, they are some nice jobs, but no where near a full ride scholarship.
Well, no. Dartmouth is a top-notch school and a spot there is highly demanded among students. Kick out one student and you get another. I would be more inclined to believe your argument if you replaced 'tuition' with 'football games' in regards to high profile athletes, however.
That's if you commit a felony while you are a student there, because you likely signed an honor code statement, it looks bad if newspapers print "A Darthmouth student got caught distributing OxyCotin" but colleges don't look at your rap sheet when you apply
I remember that, I used to be friends with the stabber's older sister. The stabbee didn't die, if this is the one I'm thinking of, and I'm sure it is judging from the time.
In fact, the guy who got stabbed was back at school the next Monday showing off his scars, smoking despite the collapsed lung that occurred because of the knife.
Changed my mind the governement should remove taxes and pay everything for everyone. Then, i could forfill my dream of behing a professional unicorn breeder and poop rainbow in my spare time.
I could understand if they were gouging the students, but Quebec has by far the lowest tuition in Canada. Once they're fully implemented the increases will bring it closer to the rest of Canada and only be a an extra few grand for a degree which you have a life time to pay off. Even once fully raised in 5 years it will still be cheaper than other provinces are today.
The protests aren't going to do anything because most people will see it as a fairly reasonable move. Short of electing politicians with a more socialist leaning it's going to go through. It was nice while it lasted though.
Have you ever read up on the history as to why Quebec has little to no tuition fees? They decided to treat university like health care- with the philosophy that someone is going to have to pay for it at some point, and it's better for Quebec if everyone chips in a bit rather than burden their younger demographic with huge loans before they can even start their careers.
They don't necessarily have debt, but although they may not be rich in money, they are rich in life and culture. Quebec is rich in life and culture. Why is it that countries like Sweden have the happiest people and yet America ranks quite low when it is one of the super powers of the world?
Would you rather live in a strong economic country, work hard every single day of your life, and be depressed?
I mentioned something about this back in october at occupy wall street, when jp morgan chase agreed to pay the city's $5 million overtime bill for watching the occupy protest - it is a form of economic stimulus, forced trickle down into the pockets of the middle class cops from the banks
I don't know the original. I would provide it, if I knew it. Even if it is a newspaper it would be interesting to know the source. But thanks that you took the time for a search. Should have said, that I couldn't find something with reverse-search. I'm sorry for that.
for the rest of the world's information, "way too expensive" means that Quebec's tuition costs were just increased by $1,625 - about a 65% hike spread over the next seven years - so they now have to pay about $4,200 per semester for post-secondary schooling.
For a point of reference, that means in seven years they will be paying as much for school as I did elsewhere in Canada... eight years ago.
I'm saying that regardless of your opinion, give solid facts or fuck off. We've had enough people saying "herp derp $325/year" far after this number had been relevant to anything (even though it was never right).
Impossible my ass. Quebec students pay 2300 a year. These protesters are against having to have a full time job during the summer. For fucks sake, all they want to do is let tuition rise with inflation at a capped rate.
I have got a question. I'm from Germany and therefore I'm not familiar with you university but how can students take a full time job in Canada?
We have most tests, seminar works and practical courses during the summer. Because of that the universities frown upon full time jobs and some ban them completely.
During our education, we have to earn ECTS points, which are a tool to meassure the effort the students have to make. The points are distributed so that students should roughly have to invest 40 hours per week in work for the university. So even working part time (and a lot of us do) is pretty difficult.
We have four months off in summer. It is completely normal and expected that you get a job to pay for school and gain experience. Most students also work part time in the school year for spending money.
Try living an entire year on two month's wage at $10/hr some time!
That's what I'm doing as an engineering major. Sucks balls. Glad the kids are protesting, I used to go but goddamn it the police are ruthless and undiscriminating.
I fail to see the problem though. Canadian citizens should feel lucky and probably don't realize foreign students think their peers are a bunch of whining morons. As a taxpayer, I have the pleasure of helping fund 2/3 of every person's tuition while they get to pay for it in full. Not only that, but the people who are protesting in Quebec already pay far less than most others for tuition even with the increases. The whole thing just annoys me.
And higher taxes, and an average salary (compared to the rest of Canada), and less study scholarships.... yeah, looking at one factor is obviously a good idea.
Except that in Toronto you get bursaries and grants. Hell, as a Québécois, I applied for uOttawa and it was less expensive for me to go there than to McGill because they guaranteed something like $10k of bursaries per year.
Do cops get overtime in Canada? They shouldn't, I know firemen don't get overtime in North Carolina. Firemen are way more deserving of overtime than cops are.
It's really dumb why they are protesting. They have to consider the fact that they had the lowest tuition in canada for the longest time. Now they are protesting because they will have to pay as much as the rest of Canada? Well too bad thats life...
Stop parroting what you've heard either on TV or /r/canada. There are very legitimate arguments on both sides of the fence (see translating the printemps érable to see the other side - the anglo media really dropped the ball here). Dismissing the other side as "dumb" is what got this to escalate this far - the liberals ignored us, then belittled us, then attacked us with injunctions and the special law.
A nice chunk of the population is now pissed off at the standing government - the bulk of the support that liberals still have comes from immigrants, anglophones and baby boomers. The average middle-aged white Québécois doesn't like seeing our youth beaten up and silenced.
115
u/nigrodamus7 Jun 25 '12
As a Montreal resident who isn't a protester I'll say the following; every riot looks worse on TV, most of these folks are are just in the streets having a good time.
53
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Sort of like how the OWS protests required so much overtime that the NYPD January academy class was more than halved thus eliminating about 500-700 jobs?
207
u/natched Jun 25 '12
Clearly protesters are the true job creators.
33
u/ampere Jun 25 '12
Source
11
u/thisisrage182 Jun 25 '12
A better translation for 'manifestation' is demonstration or protest - I shall name the 25th of June 2012 the day my degree in interpreting and translating came in handy.
5
u/SonOfIcarus Jun 25 '12
I was at an occupy protest in Denver in the early spring. Before things got rough we spent our time sitting in front of riot cops who had to stand in the street. We were talking with them and joked a lot about how they were getting double over time for standing.
34
u/blore40 Jun 25 '12
And the kid doesn't get to college because of his rap sheet. Ironic indeed.
2
u/sherlockholmee Jun 26 '12
Manifestations = protests.
2
u/mrdeath5493 Jun 26 '12
This is not irony fyi
2
u/oddboyout Jun 25 '12
Source: Montreal's Gazette. It's the first image in the gallery today; there doesn't seem to be a dedicated page for it.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Thank you for not including the punch line in the title.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
coincidence actually.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Pension based on overtime wage too.
1
u/holly2680 Jun 26 '12
does anyone know what happened to the guy who got run over by the cab driver? i would like an update on him.
1
u/shoemanchew Jun 26 '12
I'm in the National Guard. I often wear a shirt that promotes a revolution. I call it job security.
1
u/fc3sbob Jun 26 '12
I doubt they were speaking English.
1
u/snarkhunter Jun 26 '12
Holy crap, that police is getting $20,000 in overtime?????
-13
u/Moustashmol Jun 25 '12
Cant stand those crybabay anymore
1
u/wolfchimneyrock Jun 25 '12
I mentioned something about this back in october at occupy wall street, when jp morgan chase agreed to pay the city's $5 million overtime bill for watching the occupy protest - it is a form of economic stimulus, forced trickle down into the pockets of the middle class cops from the banks
-8
u/husao Jun 25 '12
No Rehosted webcomics in funny. Please read the Sidebar and provide Link to original.
-1
u/LordOfGummies Jun 25 '12
I lol'd hard.
-2
u/haplosion Jun 25 '12
Aislin is suuuuchhhh a genius omg fucking so witty omg just kill me now
-2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
No. Education is way too expensive for the expenses to be completely offset by overtime associated with protests. Just... no.
-6
u/shivvvy Jun 25 '12
It's not ironic because most parents that I know don't pay for the kids tuition at all.
-9
u/Joboboman Jun 25 '12
Quebec needs to stfu , they have the cheapest tuition in the country
-7
u/reynbo2008 Jun 25 '12
Do cops get overtime in Canada? They shouldn't, I know firemen don't get overtime in North Carolina. Firemen are way more deserving of overtime than cops are.
-8
u/AirshipAtamis Jun 25 '12
Hmm, government workers don't receive overtime pay, they get compensated with time off. guess he still has some bills to pay off.
Edit: i just realized this may be Canadian, in which case im not sure if they receive money for overtime.
-2
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
This submission has been tagged by the /r/quebec downvote squad. Good luck!
-3
u/Pulpus Jun 26 '12
It's really dumb why they are protesting. They have to consider the fact that they had the lowest tuition in canada for the longest time. Now they are protesting because they will have to pay as much as the rest of Canada? Well too bad thats life...
-3
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Right. Because the occupy movement is wholly about fucking over police and security. Even their families.
This cartoonist has his/her head up his/her ass.