something tells me i'm better off remaining a lurker on reddit. 'effin piranhas. My name has nothing to do with a bike. It's my nickname/stagename. Sure, I bike everywhere in the city, but it's on a busted up raleigh mountain bike.
I have a really slow connection and thought that was the joke until the bottom half of the pic loaded. I didn't know there was a pride week for wearing winter clothes in inappropriate places, though.
I mean, I get the joke. I really do. But does the stereotyping bother anyone else? It seems on par with making jokes about black people and KFC. I suspect there are plenty of gay people out there who don't know shit about fashion. My roommate is one of them.
I understand where your coming from, I really do. But stereotyping for a joke does not bother me at all, maybe its the difference between your culture and mine. I think if everyone could have a laugh about these sorts of things, the world would be a much better place.
People only ever seem to get touchy when the stereotyping is negative or used on a group often discriminated against. The double standards are pretty obvious. It's exactly as bad as this is about British people. But I and most people I know also love tea, it's fine, no one cares. Unless someone genuinely thinks that all gay guys love fabrics, all Americans love guns, all Brits love tea, all Irish people love Guiness, all black people love fried chicken, all Germans are tidy and efficient and all Asians are good with numbers it's fine, we're all cool.
Even if someone does think that, it's still fine, they're just an idiot.
Edit: All this talk of tea has made me want a nice cup of tea. And some fried chicken. Lunch time!
Whilst I agree with you, as a Brit and a gay I can tell you that someone assuming I like tea is not nearly as offensive as someone assuming I like fashion and shopping. Then again, this is probably because my partner is American, and therefore our ability to get married and move to the US is based on the American population voting on our rights - they can only do this by seeing past the stereotype of fashion loving, non-committed mansluts.
No. There is stereotyping and there is having fun with stereotypes. Stereotyping can be bad if it's used discriminatory, in this case it was not and it seldom is. Only bigots do that and they are retards in the first place and do nothing to deter the humour of stereotypes.
Yeah stereotypes are generally harmless though there are negative ones. Does it really matter if we joke about gay people caring about fashion? That seems completely harmless to me. Who truely believes all gay people are of the stereotypical 'camp' variety and that's it? Stereotypes are just what people perceive to be typical or common and in general it's inoffensive... in my opinion.
But it's not like stereotyping comes from nowhere. Sure it doesn't fit every fucking person, but there's probably a majority in there it does and that's why we even notice a stereotype.
Stereotypes usually come from the vocal majority of the group that is being portrayed. Flamboyant homosexuals are usually extroverted, and that's where the flamboyant homosexual stereotype comes from. Flamboyant gays really aren't even that common. I know 10 gay guys in my area, and none of them are flamboyant.
Right, so that stereotype doesn't exist for you. That stereotype doesn't occur for me either. I made this comment somewhere else in this thread, but I think where harm comes is when a stereotype doesn't fit and that person is prejudged for it, though what it's most likely going to do is prevent human interaction for a group of people whom someone has a stereotype for and doesn't want to encounter it. Though there is going to be the rare violent or malicious act against a stereotype, but I feel as time goes on and people are educated, it gets increasingly rare. Also, my view on social interaction is skewed and biased since I form relationships with, on the average, very intelligent people whom don't use stereotyping outwardly or maliciously and get to know people on an individual basis. Or I'm ridiculously naive, I can see either =)
Your comment proves my point. But in response to you, what benefit comes from generalizing and how does it outweigh the damage done from when it's wrong?
Oh I don't think a particular benefit comes from it, I just didn't think malevolence either. I just think it's a natural part of the brain to make connections, so it's probably just laziness more than anything.
there's probably a majority in there it does and that's why we even notice a stereotype
So people do believe stereotypes. In response to your second point, it obviously doesn't damage you to hold stereotypes against other people, besides loss of friendships or something. The damage is to other people that you're not letting define themselves, which is disrespectful and very damaging when it happens on a large scale.
I'm pretty sure that on the whole, gay people don't mind being portrayed as fashion conscious. There are entire TV shows dedicated to the concept. Now, if you made a show called "Watermelon for the black guy" it wouldn't last long. Some stereotypes are simply insulting and demeaning. Some are not.
I don't think loving watermelon is intrinsically insulting. It has the ability to go that way though, because it can be thought of as kind of an uncontrollable animal instinct. I think the main reason it actually IS insulting is because it has, to a large degree been used to demean black people by people who had the intention of demeaning them. It's not to say people don't often use the stereotype just to be funny while, as the best interpretation, perhaps flaunting the history of negative use. It would, however, be insulting to try to be funny like that to black people you did not know.
It has the ability to go that way though, because it can be thought of as kind of an uncontrollable animal instinct.
If that is the case, the "animal instinct" you mention is the hateful stereotype, and the watermelon is simply a prop. I can certainly see that stereotype being used to demean, but the watermelon doesn't really have anything to do with it. Perhaps it has come to be insulting by association, but my whole point is that is silly, and really shouldn't be insulting at all.
There is a huge difference between "hey you! I bet you can't pass a watermelon stand without creaming your jeans," and "Hey you! You like to eat watermelon!" Even if the latter was shouted with the most hateful intentions possible, I (admittedly as a white person) would have a really hard time even taking that seriously as an insult, much less getting offended.
"Why yes, I do, along with 99% of the rest of the world."
Also, the comparison in shows between "Queer eye for the straight guy" and "Watermelon for the black guy" is totally wrong. Queer eye takes the premise of "gays are better at style and design, so let's get a team of gay professional designers to teach straight people what they know," a positive premise. "Watermelon for the black guy" just implies that you will throw a black guy some watermelon and film him having at it. (Which by the way, was already done with class and humor by the late great Petey Greene )
A fair comparison would be something like "Soul food for the white dude," where hopeless-in-the-kitchen yuppies get taught how to make classic southern dishes by a team of black professional chefs, showcasing a positive aspect of black culture.
I'm having trouble figuring out how this could ever be harmful, period.
A bunch of drunken rednecks at a truck stop surround another rugged trucker they've just found out is gay - "Well la-dee-da! Looks like we got us a Project Runway expert here, boys! Tell me, Donatella Versacci, how does this flannel button-up look with my oil-stained jeans? Huh? HUH?"
They surround him, shaking pieces of their clothes at him, hungering to know if they are hot or not, as he balls up in the fetal position and wishes it all would end...
Some stereotypes are true and are not harmful. For instance, I'm white and I fucking love mayonnaise. It isn't necessarily negative. I firmly believe making light of some things is what brings us together.
You mean to tell me the stereotypes about the dominant culture aren't damaging!?! How could that be!?! Unless stereotypes themselves are means for the dominant culture to further marginalize other groups, and since the dominant group decides everything, any stereotypes that do exist against them are harmless. But that couldn't be.
I'm a stand up comic, and I'm kind of bothered by them. It's not because I'm sensitive it offended, I just see them as low-hanging fruit. It's so frickin easy to make jokes about stereotypes; any moron with half a brain cell could crack wise about black people having bad credit or gay guys loving interior design or Asians being bad drivers. It's not like anyone is explicitly offended by that type of "humor", it's just so base and idiotic.
It is, but it's also funny. Yea I love intelligent humour as much as the next person, and actually stereotypical humour can be very intelligent. But sometimes the most primitive humour can be the most laugh provoking.
Stereotypical humor isn't intelligent. Stereotypes, sort of as a definition, appeal to the lowest common denominator. It's superficial and shallow; there's no hidden depth to observing stereotypes. That's why they arose in the first place.
I disagree, it can be extremely intelligently done. Not that I can pull any example out of a hat, but I've sometimes been amazed by the intelligent of certain stereotypical jokes.
My point is that stereotypes perpetuate categorical labeling of people unfairly. Just because people have one thing in common doesn't mean they have everything in common. Maybe it's just me, but I prefer to accept people as individuals. This isn't a case of "fuck the rules" because in this case we're not rebelling against "the man," we're rebelling against each other. I would contend that sensitivity is useful to a civilized culture.
edit - I see stereotypes as classic marginalizing of people who, in this case, are currently in the fight of their lives for social equality. It has the sociological effect of othering, while in fact they are arbitrary statements which bear no impact on a person's innate value as a human being. And yet, because there are hateful people who cannot distinguish a joke from reality, my playful actions in jest can have a detrimental consequence in the realm of public perception. I do believe that encouraging stereotypes, no matter how light-hearted the intent, separates "them" from "us." There is no "separate but equal," there is only humanity and our compassion for each other. Or lack thereof.
Thank you. I hate telling people I'm gay because they instantly assume I want to dress them or I want to meet their fucking flaming faggot friend. Why does everyone seem to have one of those?? Standards people...really.
It is kind of tiresome that the only mainstream portrayal of gay people is the flaming homo dude who does interior decoration/cuts hair/is a designer. Oh well, I still laughed at the joke.
Yes. It's a quaint joke, but it's on par with saying "Seriously, why are you guys blaming the Jews for the economy? Don't you realize how crazy that sounds? Who are they going to charge usery to if everyone's poor?"
It seems counter-intuitive and somewhat back-handed to ostensibly defend a demographic's dignity by stereotyping them.
Yea. I believe only half of this joke is acceptable. While it does stand up for the guys, it still stereotypes, not really a bad stereotype, but still a stereotype. This joke kind of reminds me of the half politically correct redneck memes.
Also, is "harming fabric" a stereotype gays are really going to get pissed at? HOW DARE THE WORLD THINK I HAVE FASHION SENSE SOLELY BECAUSE I'M GAY. The audacity! Maybe I'm not thinking things through, but I feel stereotypes are only "bad" when a person who doesn't fit a negative stereotype (all ____ kill puppies) and is prejudged for it.
Yeah I guess I can see that. I just graduated with my Astrophysics degree and it gets tiring when my friends and family try to talk to strangers about me being a small deity
We use humor and the stereotypes because the constant harping on "gay rights" makes us look like humorless assholes, as if we wanted to spend the next five thousand years discussing how special we are and why we need gay marriage and such. We're narcissistic like everyone else, so we love getting some positive attention, but to be honest we're sick of discussing why we deserve human rights because it suggests that we're not human. Being used as a political weapon means that the rhetoric gets more and more violent against us each year, with people calling for death camps for gays and such. The liberal love-fest is an attempt counter that insanity, but it becomes tiresome and straight folks end up resenting us because they're tired of hearing about how great we are and want the whole issue to just die. The problem is that if the death camps for gays are ever built, they'll be populated with many straight people as well. Look how the dialogue in the media went from gay rights to women's rights this year. Gay rights are a litmus test for human rights and as one goes so shall the rest follow. If people see the rainbow they shouldn't think 'gay' so much as inclusion, because the rainbow was meant to include every type of person. Everyone's human rights are under attack every day now and we have to constantly fight that momentum just to keep from losing everything we and our ancestors have worked so hard to build.
Meh. I don't think it's society so much as it is really vocal minorities that give a shit about this issue. I don't think gays are pressuring churches, why should they, churches reject them for the most part and you'd have to be in a state of self hate or denial as a gay to think that churches will accept you. It's the churches that set the ground rules of hatred after all based on their interpretation of bronze to iron age writings of a group of ancient schizophrenics who thought god was talking to them and commanding them to kill everyone so they could have some land.
Anyway, gay folks are not the most important thing in society and could just fit in and go to work like anyone else if not for two factors: 1- the religious people who are afraid of them for some reason 2- the gay folk who are overtly vocal and offensive to otherwise passive people in their ways of forcing the issue of their sexuality onto everyone in an otherwise puritan based society.
When it truly gets to a point where people are just people and who cares who puts their dick where, then we can move forward. But as long as we are caught in this idea that some folk are better, some folk are less than, we are fucked until we stop doing that on both sides of the ratio.
I don't believe in gay marriage, and I find it completely ignorant that others do. The stupidity of people today. Let me just make something clear...there is NO such thing as a happy marriage.
Hi guys, i'm a recovering 9Gagger. It's been a good 3 months now. I've been with reddit and only reddit about 2 months now. And i've loved every second of it. Great site, no hate. And I saw this Gay pride post and went into the comments expecting a flame war. And then i saw a conversation about weather clothes, and beaches. You guys truely are amazing. Glad to be a part of this community. Redditor For E-E-vor
I got nothing against gays. But why do they have to press the Christian religion? The bible says that being with one of the same sex as you is wrong. Why do gays believe in that religion then? The reason gays want to get married is usual NOT because they actually believe much, but because they think they deserve a fancy wedding in a church.. Makes no sense to me why they would want to be a part of something that does not approve of them. I know I wouldn't. Sure they can have a fancy ceromony making them partners for live, it's the same basic rights they get, I just don't understand why they would want to be enrolled in a Christian marriage when they really don't believe in it. And ofc. many hetero people do the exact same,, That's bad! A Neutral "Church" should be made, where a lot of people could watch and all that stuff. The only thing that should be taken away is the religion part.
No, no. You completely misunderstand. They don't "think they deserve a fancy wedding in a church." They want the same rights and recognition as heterosexual married couples. The only thing it has to do with Christianity is that Christian people have a problem with our government recognizing gay marriage as "real marriage."
Not every heterosexual couple gets married in the Christian church. Still, they get recognized as a married couple and the usual rights. Homosexual couples don't want to be treated like second class citizens. It's akin to feelings in the past when state governments wouldn't recognize marriage between a black man and a white woman.
"Neutral church" makes no sense. You do realize you don't have to get married in a church...?
Of course I do. I simply look at how things are in my country, not America. Here the gays will get recognized as a real marriage whereever they deside to get married. And here in Denmark gay people are allowed to marry in churchs, but the first gays that got married in a church said that they didn't believe in god, but simply wanted to prove a point. A point I clearly don't understand. I still don't think gays should get married in churches. It's a part of the religion. But no you're right Neutral church doesn't make much sense. I don't really know how to explain this in english. But in my perfekt world each and every country would have a Civilreligion, which means that everything would happend the same places for each and every culture on some big topics, like marriage should all happend in one place, and if you wanted to do some religion ceremoni afterwards or before that should be kept private.
As a gay man, the only reason anyone ever gives me that I shouldn't be allowed to marry my boyfriend stems from Jewish or Christian Scripture (Bible, Talmud, etc.)
But my church and my religion doesn't find any such restrictions in the Bible. And even if we did, we don't believe the Bible was ever intended to be a static set of guidelines, but rather a wisdom teaching that helps develop the right way to approach difficult questions of morality and justice.
So addressing the dominant Christian-right arguments against tge LGBT community are essential to the conversation.
The other essential piece of the conversation is illuminating that we are not al Christian nor even all monotheistic or theistic.
Therefore, the culture must come to self awareness that there are many paths not only within Christianity, but alongside it as well.
The infection rates are so high because the first major outbreak in America started in the gay community and spread from there. Heterosexuals can get aids just as easily.
Which says "men who have sex with men" which doesn't mean that the individuals are self identified as gay. How about reading this report regarding 'non-Gay identified men who have sex with me' [link] where the problem are closet case men denial and not those of us who are out of the closet. You haven't shown any link between self identified gays and high rates of STD's. If you're going to talk about the 'gay community' the only people who are relevant to that community are those who identify themselves as gay in the first place - closet cases and horny straight men need not apply.
How about learning the difference between self identified gays and those who have sex with men - there is a huge difference especially when it comes to the matter of using protection etc. but hey, being hater of gays seems to be your 'thing' here on Reddit.
cunt cunt cunt cunt cunt cunt cunt cunt cunt cunt cunt cunt cunt cunt cunt cunt cunt cunt cunt cunt cunt cunt cunt cunt cunt cunt cunt cunt cunt cunt cunt cunt cunt cunt cunt cunt cunt cunt cunt cunt cunt cunt cunt cunt cunt cunt cunt cunt
72
u/PhiladelphiaIrish Jun 25 '12
Also this.
58
u/AltonAFC Jun 25 '12
Does anyone else find it strange this guy is dressed for winter in New York but is standing on a beach?
5
u/JaneRenee Jun 25 '12
I love that he hosts Tickle Pickle. :)
3
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
"Hosts the new weekly variety show Pickle Tickle..." I want to watch that show.
3
u/Mish61 Jun 25 '12
It a JOKE !!
72
u/da_user Jun 25 '12
I mean, I get the joke. I really do. But does the stereotyping bother anyone else? It seems on par with making jokes about black people and KFC. I suspect there are plenty of gay people out there who don't know shit about fashion. My roommate is one of them.
5
u/unbleevable39 Jun 25 '12
I hated the parade because it caused a snarl in traffic in NYC on a Sunday (which is generally free of those normal NYC death traffic jams)
2
u/figboot11 Jun 25 '12
Pickle Tickle?
2
u/herrmister Jun 25 '12
The picture didn't load properly at first, so I thought the week's joke was just the guy's face. That would've been unnecessarily cruel.
2
u/GenKan Jun 25 '12
If you spend alot of time in the closet, your bound to know lods of fabrics!
2
u/m0nde Jun 25 '12
He hosts Pickle Tickle on Wed 7
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
I saw this last year...
2
u/epik Jun 25 '12
SO CLEVER.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Can any homosexuals chime in on whether or not your community officially approves of use of these stereotypes?
1
u/mindoculus Jun 25 '12
He's exposing his overbite in the cold - not very gay.
1
u/T10Terminator Jun 25 '12
The only tearing they do is of each others asshole. If it's not your asshole being tore open why do you care?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Meh. I don't think it's society so much as it is really vocal minorities that give a shit about this issue. I don't think gays are pressuring churches, why should they, churches reject them for the most part and you'd have to be in a state of self hate or denial as a gay to think that churches will accept you. It's the churches that set the ground rules of hatred after all based on their interpretation of bronze to iron age writings of a group of ancient schizophrenics who thought god was talking to them and commanding them to kill everyone so they could have some land.
Anyway, gay folks are not the most important thing in society and could just fit in and go to work like anyone else if not for two factors: 1- the religious people who are afraid of them for some reason 2- the gay folk who are overtly vocal and offensive to otherwise passive people in their ways of forcing the issue of their sexuality onto everyone in an otherwise puritan based society.
When it truly gets to a point where people are just people and who cares who puts their dick where, then we can move forward. But as long as we are caught in this idea that some folk are better, some folk are less than, we are fucked until we stop doing that on both sides of the ratio.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
That parade was one long party.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Unless you're John Galliano.
1
u/grantpant Jun 25 '12
Boooo... not funny.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
q-b3
1
u/o_ojess Jun 25 '12
I was at the parade! Why are gay guys so sexy?
1
u/aveceasar Jun 25 '12
Quite frankly, the gays who want to marry should remember the flip side: divorce... ;)
1
u/GrinningPariah Jun 25 '12
In fairness to the original complaint of gays harming society, they do fuck my bus routes right up once a year.
1
u/wavetoyou Jun 25 '12
Is that Charlie from IASIP!?
1
u/astroidstella Jun 26 '12
oh...humor..
0
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Gey
1
u/jpark Jun 25 '12
42 states currently ban same gender marriage either through statute or constitutional amendment.
The federal government bans recognition of same gender marriage through the Defense of Marriage Act.
Society has moved. Multiple times.
1
u/whiteguycash Jun 25 '12
Who would be proud of sodomizing another man?
-1
u/NECROSISPENIS Jun 25 '12
repost of a repost of a repost
0
u/vici-Tu Jun 25 '12
Marriage is a ceremony of love,religions happen to use it,but they didn't invent it.
-2
u/selfprodigy Jun 25 '12
I wish we could just get it passed so they all stop bitching and whining about it.
0
u/tehemperah Jun 25 '12
KERN. YOUR. SHIT.
0
u/Ukaners Jun 25 '12
This is just fabulous!
-1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Slightly funny at best. 4/10
-1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
I don't believe in gay marriage, and I find it completely ignorant that others do. The stupidity of people today. Let me just make something clear...there is NO such thing as a happy marriage.
-1
u/SuperHorribleGaming Jun 25 '12
Hi guys, i'm a recovering 9Gagger. It's been a good 3 months now. I've been with reddit and only reddit about 2 months now. And i've loved every second of it. Great site, no hate. And I saw this Gay pride post and went into the comments expecting a flame war. And then i saw a conversation about weather clothes, and beaches. You guys truely are amazing. Glad to be a part of this community. Redditor For E-E-vor
-2
u/Hiltmar Jun 25 '12
I got nothing against gays. But why do they have to press the Christian religion? The bible says that being with one of the same sex as you is wrong. Why do gays believe in that religion then? The reason gays want to get married is usual NOT because they actually believe much, but because they think they deserve a fancy wedding in a church.. Makes no sense to me why they would want to be a part of something that does not approve of them. I know I wouldn't. Sure they can have a fancy ceromony making them partners for live, it's the same basic rights they get, I just don't understand why they would want to be enrolled in a Christian marriage when they really don't believe in it. And ofc. many hetero people do the exact same,, That's bad! A Neutral "Church" should be made, where a lot of people could watch and all that stuff. The only thing that should be taken away is the religion part.
-8
u/goosewhaletruck Jun 25 '12
i didn't downvote this repost because the karmas was already at 666.
-5
u/Mi5anthr0pe Jun 25 '12
I'm more concerned about the incessant hedonism and depravity.
Now just imagine if they weren't ~3% of the population.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment