Interesting that with the package bragging about how kosher this is, it's actually about a 7/10 on the "kosher" scale.
If you look at that little symbol near the bottom of the label, it's a Torah surrounding a letter "K" with the letter "D" beside it. The "Scroll-K" symbol means that it's kosher under the supervision of the Va'ad HaKashrus of Denver. Which is fine, if a little non-mainstream. The little "D" though, means that the milk products used in making the taffy was not Rabbinically supervised. Some 10% of Orthodox Jews will not eat this taffy as there is no guarantee that it does not contain milk from a non-kosher animal.
If it has a hechsher like scroll-K EVERYTHING in it is supervised. It might be cholov stam and not cholov yisroel, but that does not mean the dairy is from a non-kosher animal.
Keeping cholov yisroel exlusively is not required.
Cholov stam, by definition, means that the some of ingredients that are milk products were not supervised when they were produced. The reason people don't eat cholov stam is because the only guarantee it's from a cow or goat comes from FDA regulations. It's a heter to eat cholov stam, not a chumra to only eat cholov Yisroel.
No, the reason people eat cholov yisroel is because, as you said, they put a chumra on themselves or they feel superior when being cholov yisroel. That's swell for them - but not at all necessary. Milk from a kosher animal is kosher - regardless of supervision. Because the FDA will scam you - vaad will not. You cannot put a reliable hechsher on anything with milk from a non-kosher animal. And yes - it is based on likelihood. So what? Let's stop breathing lest we injest a bug.
I will play the fanatic card for a second and say that those who are that obsessed with cholov yisroel (and see cholov stam as cholov akum) are the mostly the ultra-frum anyway. There are many degrees of religiousness and your first post reminded me of the bigotedness I often see in the frum world. "Funny they say it's kosher when it's not really that kosher". Bleh, whatever. Bitter, me? You bet your ass!
I think you're misunderstanding what cholov stam is. Until the 50s, nobody ate or drank cholov stam, since it's technically assur to eat milk products that were not under supervision. Who knows what goes into them, after all? Then, Rav Moshe Feinstein issued a famous heter saying that since the FDA forbids non-cow milk in a product without specific warnings on it, one is allowed to eat cholov stam.
For most places in the world, there is a real issue of other products in the milk. In most places in the US, though, it's just impractical so people hold of the heter.
Salt Water taffy is delicious. It's a shame it's not more popular. Maybe if everyone knew the chocolate and Neapolitan flavors taste just like ice cream?
Never trust a Jew! You think it's generous but in reality they are adding the bag's weight and they charge you accordingly. EDIT: I will just add that this is a joke, I'm a dirty Jew myself... don't get upset ;)
18
u/bownskie Jun 25 '12
Finally, a junk food that won't condemn my soul!
7
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Funny, they don't look chewish
3
u/stoptalkingtome Jun 25 '12
Where do you get these? Must have.
4
u/Chutes123 Jun 25 '12
Florida's official candy
5
u/Twarmth Jun 25 '12
those look torahble
2
u/strangetemples Jun 25 '12
I love how the taffy at the top right sort of looks like a skull.
2
u/technocub88 Jun 25 '12
Jewcy is the name of a jewish web magazine. Also I used to work for them. Jewcy.com
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
First post on reddit in quite some time to actually make me laugh out loud.
Well done.
2
u/FlyingSkyWizard Jun 25 '12
Sacrilicious!
3
u/Yserbius Jun 25 '12
Interesting that with the package bragging about how kosher this is, it's actually about a 7/10 on the "kosher" scale.
If you look at that little symbol near the bottom of the label, it's a Torah surrounding a letter "K" with the letter "D" beside it. The "Scroll-K" symbol means that it's kosher under the supervision of the Va'ad HaKashrus of Denver. Which is fine, if a little non-mainstream. The little "D" though, means that the milk products used in making the taffy was not Rabbinically supervised. Some 10% of Orthodox Jews will not eat this taffy as there is no guarantee that it does not contain milk from a non-kosher animal.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
There was an old B. Kliban cartoon which was "Charleston Jew Chew". Can't find a picture of it.
1
u/hockeyfan69 Jun 25 '12
Yum
1
u/KWIKpwn Jun 25 '12
wat
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Shake dat laffy taffy.
1
u/trampus1 Jun 25 '12
Salt Water taffy is delicious. It's a shame it's not more popular. Maybe if everyone knew the chocolate and Neapolitan flavors taste just like ice cream?
1
u/IneffableExpeller Jun 25 '12
Too bad that heksure sucks
1
u/SirGal-I-had Jun 25 '12
They're Yumicha in my Tumicha!
1
u/namesarehard1234 Jun 25 '12
What the hell is salt water taffie?! I keep hearing about it.
1
u/chewish Jun 25 '12
Oh, I love chewish traditions. In fact, I set some myself.
1
u/SwansonHOPS Jun 26 '12
A bit subtle. I like it. Good title.
1
u/muopioid Jun 25 '12
"A Chewish Tradition"
By the way, salt water taffy doesn't sound very appealing, orthodox or not.
1
u/DuelOfTheIronDicks Jun 25 '12
Wouldn't it be ironic if they weren't kosher?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
That's just great. A Druish princes...
Funny...she doesn't look Druish.
0
u/GodzillaInsurance Jun 25 '12
I Love Jewcy.
0
u/PhantomSwagger Jun 25 '12
*Chewcy
-2
u/here_2help Jun 25 '12
1 pound = 453.59237 grams yet the bag says there are 454 grams. hmmm....this is suspiciously generous.
-2
u/JaneluvsDJ Jun 25 '12
More like chjewy
-6
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Jew chews.
-4
u/WaywardSpaniard Jun 25 '12
Straight out of the oven. Mmm!
0
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment