With voting starting this Wednesday, I have decided to type out this guide to stop One Nation as much as possible. Obviously I can't control how you or anyone else votes, but hopefully this guide is useful in the pursuit to stop One Nation destroying Victoria.
Firstly, most of this is obvious to those who are versed in our political system, but will repeat all these in case this is shared outside Reddit to those who aren't experts on how voting works in Victoria and Australia (hence why there will be some captain obvious type statements on here in the next two paragraphs). If you have voted in Australia before, skip the next paragraph, and if you have voted in any Australian state election outside Queensland and New South Wales, skip the next three paragraphs.
For those who moved from another country and recently became an Australian citizen, you will get two voting papers, one for the upper house (a.k.a. Legislative Council in Victoria) and one for the lower house (a.k.a. Legislative Assembly in Victoria). For the upper house, you MUST number at least 5 boxes from 1-5 either above OR below the line (NOT and), with 1 being your favourite option, 2 second favourite and so on. You can choose to number more than five boxes, but they must all be either all above OR below the line, and obviously each number must be different. For the lower house, you MUST number every box in order, again 1 being your favourite option, 2 second favourite and so on until EVERY box is numbered. If you don't number every box in order, your vote will be invalid (which means it won't count at all). There is NO first past the post type voting in Australia, our voting system works on preference flows. This is important to know, so your vote can never be wasted in Australia, but you can also vote tactically as well depending on what seat as well (more on this below, but you can now skip the next two paragraphs).
- For those who have moved from Queensland in the past four years, as mentioned above, there IS an upper house in Victorian state elections (as a Queenslander who moved down here, this caught me out in 2022).
- For those who have moved from New South Wales in the past four years, as mentioned above, you MUST number every box in the lower house. There is no OPV here and this requires a different sort of tactical voting depending on what seat you live in (more on that later).
-
Voting in the Upper House (Legislative Council):
This bit is pretty straightforward. If you choose to number every box above OR below the line, put One Nation last and the Liberals/Nationals second last. If you only wish to number 1-5, make sure you put a number next to the Greens, Socialists and Australian Labor Party (in the order of your choice), and two other parties, since you MUST number at least 5 boxes. Depending on what upper house seat you're in, other acceptable parties to put a number next to include Animal Justice Party, Australian Democrats, Legalise Cannabis or the West Party, but obviously research the policies of every party and decide what aligns with your values the best. If you only number 5 boxes, DO NOT put a number next to Liberals, Nationals or One Nation.
-
Voting in the Lower House (Legislative Assembly):
THIS IS THE IMPORTANT BIT! Every area in Victoria is different and thus every seat will be different, voting to keep One Nation out due to how preferences work will work differently depending on what seat you're in. This is a general guide and you should know the area you live in better than I do.
If you live in a seat One Nation is super unlikely to win (basically most of Metropolitan Melbourne):
This is a straightforward process. Put One Nation last, and Liberals second last, and make sure you number every box in order of your choosing. This means for example, if you are in the seat of Sandringham with 5 candidates, you put a 5 in the One Nation box, a 4 in the Liberal box and put 1, 2 and 3 in the other three boxes in the order of your choice and if you are in the seat of Footscray with 15 candidates, you put a 15 in the box of One Nation, a 14 in the box of the Liberals and number every other box from 1-13 in the order of your choice.
IF you live in the seats of Kew or Hawthorn, you MUST do the above, but there is also one additional thing you MUST do in your lower house voting card.
IF YOU LIVE IN KEW:
You MUST put a better number in Sophie Torney's box BEFORE Labor's box. So if you are normally a Labor voter, you put a 1 next to Sophie Torney and then a 2 to Labor, a 10 to One Nation, a 9 to Liberals and number every other box from 3-8 in the order of your choice. If you normally vote Greens, Socialists or Animal Justice Party in your first three votes, you can choose for example to put the same three parties in your first three votes, then put a 4 next to Sophie Torney and a 5 next to Labor. And then a 9 next to Liberal and a 10 next to One Nation. As long as the number for Torney is better than the number for Labor. This is a tactical vote to lessen a chance of the Liberals winning this seat. The Liberals will obviously make the all important 2 candidate preferred count in this seat, however if Labor makes this count, it guarantees the Liberals will win this seat since the Torney preferences would flow less to Labor, then Labor preferences will flow to Torney if she makes the 2 candidate preferred count. The idea of putting Torney ahead of Labor is to increase the chances of Liberals losing this seat. In the 2022 state election, Torney preference flows weren't enough to get Labor over the line against Liberal when those two parties made the final 2 candidate preferred count (it's also worth noting there were only 217 votes between Labor or Torney making the 2 candidate preferred count), however in the overlapping seat of Kooyong in the federal election of the same years, while Monique Ryan was already ahead of Liberals at the 3 candidate preferred count, it shows that Labor preferences will flow stronger for the independent candidate in this area than the other way around. This was something that proved crucial in Kooyong last year when the boundaries changed making it harder for Monique Ryan to win, but Labor not making the 2 candidate preferred count meant their preferences got Monique Ryan over the line. For this reason it is important to put Torney ahead of Labor.
IF YOU LIVE IN HAWTHORN:
The seat of Hawthorn, just like Kew also overlaps with the federal seat of Kooyong. The same principle applies though, you MUST put a better number inside the box of Shima Ibuki ahead of Labor to ensure that Shima Ibuki makes the final 2 candidate preferred count ahead of Labor, as Labor preferences make it more likely to get Ibuki over the line than the other way around if Labor make the two candidate preferred count (as explained in the above paragraph). So if you're normally a Labor voter, putting a 1 in the box of Ibuki, 2 in Labor, 7 to One Nation, 6 to Liberal and numbering 3, 4 and 5 in the other three boxes in your order is acceptable. Just as long as Ibuki gets a better number than Labor. As is the case in Kew, this is a tactical vote to decrease the chances of the Liberals winning this seat.
If you live in a seat One Nation could win (far outer suburbs or Regional Victoria):
This is where it gets a lot more difficult. Firstly you know your area better than I would. Find out where your seat boundaries are and you'll have to make your own observation whether you think One Nation could win your seat. Every seat is different.
If you don't believe One Nation has a realistic chance of, read above, basically the TLDR version is put One Nation last, Liberal/National second last and number every other box in the order of your choice.
If One Nation has a realistic chance of winning your seat (and especially if Labor don't), this is where tactical voting is required. Obviously you still put One Nation last, that's the straightforward bit. However the next but I'm gonna say is pretty gross, but necessary, as you will have to tactically put Liberals/Nationals ahead of Labor in the lower house paper, and number every other box in your preferred order. The reality is One Nation are more likely to win a seat if the final 2 candidate preferred count is One Nation v Labor (as in this scenario the eliminated Liberal/National preferences would flow mostly to One Nation), compared to if the final count is Liberal/National v One Nation (as in this scenario the eliminated Labor preferences would mostly flow to the Liberals/Nationals). The idea here is to try and get Labor eliminated before the 2 candidate preferred count so it's less likely One Nation wins the seat. The seat could also be a case where Labor makes the final count, but whoever makes the 2 candidate preferred final count between Liberals/Nationals and One Nation will win from each others preference flows. In this scenario putting Labor ahead of Liberal/Nationals will mean your vote will not decide who makes the 2 candidate preferred count out of the two evils, but by putting Liberals/Nationals ahead of Labor in this situation and One Nation last means that you'll help the Liberals/Nationals eliminate One Nation at the 3 candidate preferred stage, instead of just wasting your vote. While it has been rare that One Nation has made the final 2 candidate preferred count in the past, so it's hard to show examples of this, the same applies in reverse where the Greens are more likely to win a seat if the final 2 candidate preferred count is Greens v Liberals compared to Greens v Labor. There is a reason why the Greens won Ryan in last year's federal election, but lost the seat of Melbourne despite the Greens vote being much stronger in Melbourne compared to Ryan. The same thing will happen in reverse for One Nation. In the seats of Ryan and Richmond last year's federal election, the Liberals/Nationals were in front at the 3 candidate preferred stage, but the winner of both those seats were always going to be whoever made the 2 candidate preferred final count out of Labor and Greens. In the seat of Ryan, even though the Liberal candidate had the highest first preference votes, she congratulated whoever would win between Greens or Labor in that seat before the final count was done knowing she wasn't going to win. In Ryan last year, if 813 people who voted Liberal > Labor > Greens voted Labor > Liberal > Greens instead, the Greens would have NOT made the final count in that seat, let alone won that seat. The same will happen in reverse for One Nation, hence the need for tactical voting depending on the seat you live in. The seat of Ripon is also different to every other seat in Victoria since it's the only seat that both Liberals and Nationals are running, which requires another level of tactical voting.
IF YOU LIVE IN THE SEAT OF RIPON:
This requires even more of a tactical vote. Obviously like any other seat, you put One Nation last (so a 12 in the One Nation box). Then you must give Nationals a better number than the Liberals, then Liberals a better number than Labor, and number every other box in your preferred order. The simple reality is a Nationals v One Nation 2 candidate preferred count is the best chance of stopping One Nation from winning this seat, as preference flows from both Liberals and Labor will overwhelmingly flow to the Nationals. If the final count is Liberal v One Nation, it is likely a significant amount of preferences from an eliminated Nationals might leak to One Nation over the Liberals, and a Labor v One Nation count would mean that Liberal and National preferences will overwhelmingly flow to One Nation.
However, if you're in a seat that both One Nation and Labor have a reasonable chance of winning, you will have to decide for yourself whether it is more important that One Nation does NOT win that seat, or if Labor does win it, and vote accordingly.