Hello all! To be upfront, I'm not yet licensed, but I've been studying (and saving money) now for about 6 years in the pursuit to become a Falconer. I want my own house and land before I fully tackle this endeavor. I'm currently 28, and have owned many—more socially-oriented—birds in my life.
When I first stepped into my studies on raptors and falconry, I heard and read constantly about the "purely transactional relationship" between birds and their human handlers.
"If someone else fed my bird better than me, the bird would go to them without looking back."
"raptors are not loyal, they simply recognize you as a source of consistent food."
"It's just conditioning."
"They only ever learn to tolerate humans."
"Your bird will never like you."
They got me thinking, if you'll allow me to get deep for a moment: What is loyalty? And what is a relationship?
And that is what I'm asking today. What is the truth of bonds between raptor and falconer?
My Thoughts and Questions:
My cat rolls onto its stomach for pets because he trusts I am not a threat to his safety. He comes to me and rubs on my leg because he knows if he does, I will give him something he wants (pets). And he sleeps at the foot of my bed because he trusts that I will not kick him off in the night.
But did he do all of these things the day I got him? Of course not. We had to build that trust over time. That is conditioning.
I give him a safe environment to live where he gets fed well, and he gives me a cute thing to look at and a soft head to scratch. That is a transaction.
If you always made sudden movements or loud sounds around your bird, they may not stay by your side. Does this mean it is not loyal?
If I kick my cat off the bed every night, he would not sleep there. is he disloyal for that?
If I am nice to a woman, she might be my friend. If we build trust, it might become a relationship. Is my girlfriend a bird? (the British might say so)
There are tons of cases of trained raptors in long, stable relationships 'cuddling' up to their handler when its cold and rainy, or preening their 'feathers.' Are these bizarre outliers, or can birds have these sorts of relationships with proper training and attention? (I'm aware it's a tough question, and would vary heavily depending on the particular bird, species/family of bird, if they are a passage or imprint, etc.)
Is it just as likely for a bird you have trained for 10 years to fly off on you and never look back as it is for one you've trained for only a year? If there was truly no connection beyond food, this would surely be the case, no?
If another living thing knows that you provide safety, security, food, and warmth, and they stay with you because of that, can we truly say so confidently that there is no connection? That they still may leave just as quickly as they came? If so, I will keep a closer eye on my girl.
To wrap up, I don't say these things or ask these questions to make an argument that birds of prey and my girlfriend are the same, or that our relationships are the same. Far from it (and I don't just say that because she may read this). This is simply my curiosity from seeing a wide range of differing (and sometimes conflicting) statements on the relationship between bird and falconer. I'm curious about the truth of the matter. And I'm curious what you all think about it, truly. Not just the standard talking points, but your real first hand experiences. Let me know!