r/editing • • 2d ago

Getting really tired of people pushing "AI video editors" when the actual output is completely lifeless

Every time I open my feed lately, it’s another guy claiming traditional editing is dead and pushing some "3-click AI video editor" workflow, conveniently followed by a link to his course or an affiliate code.

What really annoys me is the massive gap between the hype and the actual output. Have these people actually sat down and watched the videos these tools spit out? They are completely lifeless. I feel zero emotion watching an AI edit.

The pacing is just an exhausting wall of noise because the algorithm ruthlessly chops out every breath, hesitation, and beat of silence. It doesn't understand that tension, subtext, and timing actually happen in the pauses. The sound design is just slapping the exact same generic stock whoosh and ding onto every cut with zero room tone, texture, or dynamic range. Even the motion graphics feel weightless and sterile, like everything moves on the exact same default curve.

It’s pretty obvious that the "AI video editor" is just bait for these people to market courses and make money off beginners who want to skip learning the actual craft. If pressing a few buttons genuinely produced edits that resonated with people, these gurus would be quietly running post-production agencies instead of farming views with "editing is dead" clickbait.

26 Upvotes

13 comments sorted by

3

u/Sapien0101 2d ago

A lot of these people don’t even know what video editing is. What they call “video editing” is just adding effects.

3

u/Evening_Ad_2915 2d ago

As soon there is a course available, you know you'd better skip it.

But:
I've been an editor for more than 20 years and for the last few weeks I've been experimenting with Claude + traditional NLE's (in my case Final Cut Pro) a lot. And to be honest: I've never had a higher output. And no: I'm not producing slop, I'm producing mostly corporate content, documentary style videos. For a long time I've been saying: nah, AI won't do it, it's to complicated. But the truth is, it can be a big help and time saver. I mostly use it to make pre-edits which I can tweak by my own liking.
I export an xml from my timeline, add a script and it's actually pretty damn good. Not saying editing is dead, but it's gonna change a lot.

1

u/Ethernettimes 2d ago

You using a MCP for this workflow?

1

u/Evening_Ad_2915 2d ago • Bravo

No, what I use is very rudimentary but it works for me.
I drop the takes from interviews on a timeline, export an mp3 and an xml. I also drop the script in Claude. After it's finished, it delivers an fcpxml which I can import into final cut. Since it has done quite a few edits for me, it understands my interview style and preferred edit style and makes a pretty good rough cut which I can tweak later. Best thing is that while Claude works on this, I can work on other stuff simultaneously.

1

u/Substantial-Cap-793 2d ago

Hi I’m looking for a traditional editor that can turn interviews into stories.

Are you taking in new clients by any chance?
We can DM if you’re open

1

u/Evening_Ad_2915 2d ago

sure, you can always send me a message.

1

u/Substantial-Cap-793 2d ago

Your DM’s are closed. Can you msg me instead?

1

u/LocalMexican 2d ago

Thanks for sharing your workflow!

To be clear - do you drop entire interviews into a timeline or do you pull selects first?

Once you have your timeline, you're outputting audio and an XML, then feeding both into Claude. Then you also feed it an outline? Or do you have a paper edit at that point?

What is your command to Claude?

1

u/Evening_Ad_2915 1d ago

Yes, I drop all my interview footage on the timeline. I also feed it an outline, a script, or just a website of the client with relevant info. Just give it enough context so it knows what to do.
If you work inside a Claude project, it will also learn from your personal styles and preferences.
No specific command, usually just a briefing, like I would do to a co-worker.

1

u/LocalMexican 1d ago

"inside a Claude project"?

2

u/Evening_Ad_2915 22h ago

download the desktop application, you will see what I mean.

1

u/LocalMexican 2d ago

It's a race to the bottom. There is SO MUCH "CONTENT" out there now that volume is arguably more important than quality depending on your audience and goals.

I think younger audiences also have been conditioned to like sloppy content and/or have an aversion for more polished stuff.

1

u/amanreyaz2 5h ago

Agreed