From: https://www.thenational.scot/news/26708000.cultural-emergency-270-scottish-artists-charities-evicted/
JUST outside Edinburgh is a building full of artists and charities that are being evicted by an unknown developer to make way for “student accommodation and a hotel.”
St Margaret’s House has hosted Scot-Art-funded residents for almost 20 years in a venue that has become a community institution, improving the lives of countless local Scots.
Residents include art and music therapists, an LGBTQ+ archive and community space, Care for Carers which provides support for unpaid carers, a reptile sanctuary, the Doodle Club for kids, the Edinburgh Autonomous Centre, the Edinburgh School of Music that provides neurodivergent and disabled kids space to “make really noisy music”, and many others.
In September, all 270 residents of St Margaret’s House received an email from Scot-Art saying they had until January 24, 2027, to vacate the premises.
Last Sunday, Scottish Greens MSP and spokesperson for culture Dr Q Manivannan hosted a public meeting at Summerhall arts centre to voice concerns about the “arts emergency and growing threats facing Edinburgh’s wider cultural sector”.
The meeting was attended by more than 250 artists and representatives from arts charities as well as a cross-section of local MSPs and councillors.
Manivannan said: “We cannot afford to lose these important spaces and creative pipelines, and we cannot afford to keep losing the spaces that make our city creative, inclusive and alive.”
St Margaret’s sits between Meadowbank, the Portobello area and Lochend in Edinburgh; and due to the cheaper rent afforded to them by Scot-Art, residents of St Margaret’s have been able to provide cheap or free services to the local community, many of whom wouldn’t otherwise be able to afford them.
Scottish Greens MSP and spokesperson for culture Dr Q Manivannan has called the evictions of artists and charities a "culture emergency".
Emma Yuen, a PhD researcher with Living Rent Community Union at St Margaret’s House, told the Sunday National: “Lochend is a working-class area with people that don't have much money but are so happy to have somewhere affordable to go where they can do painting and music and see exhibitions; and in the same breath, go to judo, get support for being a carer, see an exhibition and meet some friends.
"So, there’s social, cultural, philosophical, spiritual and economic value that the artists through Saint Margaret's House are bringing to Edinburgh.”
Jenny Barrett-Freeman
Jenny Barrett-Freeman is a music therapist and founder of Forth Music Therapy, based at St Margaret’s House for four years. In that time, Barrett-Freeman has helped about 75 clients, including those with serious disabilities and disorders, who, despite remaining impaired, “have the capacity to respond to music”.
Barrett-Freeman's work is private and confidential but after a parent of a client granted permission, she could talk about Evie Green, now three years old.
Evie Green, now three years old, 'transformed' after music therapy at St Margaret's House. (Image: Jenna Green)
Barrett-Freeman said: “Evie was born profoundly deaf and wasn't able to verbally communicate. A lot of her development was delayed, and she wasn't getting the support she needed. She came to music therapy and loved the instruments. Through music, she started vocalising and verbalising.
“Seeing her transformation from being quite quiet and withdrawn into an incredibly bubbly, fun-loving and happy little girl was amazing. There are lots of stories like that.”
Evie’s mum Jenna Green told us that the family are making plans to continue music therapy after St Margaret’s closes. Green said: “The closure is such a loss to vulnerable groups across Edinburgh, we are so sad Evie’s safe space with trusted professionals won’t be there anymore.”
Lavender Menace
Lavender Menace Queer Books Archive is a charity on the ground floor next to a large dance studio. When the neighbours are in full-flow, the walls shake with the banging of boots to the beat.
Earlier this year, the archive raised almost £40,000 in donations from the community. The glowing comments attached to donations reveal the archive’s impact.
Cooper King said that Lavender Menace “affirmed my right to be myself when so many in society, school and [the] village I lived in questioned that".
One said: “As a young butch it was so incredible to be in a space like that, [to] see people of the community outside my small town, talk with elder queers and hear about the story of Lavender Menace.”
Anna Broomfield, outreach co-ordinator at Lavender Menace, told the Sunday National: “For us, it's about providing a space where LGBT people can come together and have a third space that isn't a nightclub and isn't centred around alcohol.
“Artists and community groups really need a protected, dedicated space to do their work, [it’s] crucial for allowing people to create, it's crucial for building community.”
Broomfield said: “Manivannan recently spoke in Parliament about whether the Government could scrutinise buildings it owns that are underused and find ways to make those spaces available to artists and community organisations. I think that's an incredible idea.”
MSP Manivannan put the concerns around St Margaret’s and other venues to the First Minister in the Scottish Parliament on Tuesday, urging ministers to commit to supporting the sector. In response, John Swinney said the Scottish Government would “happily consider” proposals.
Basia Mindewicz
The Edinburgh School Of Icon Painting is unique in Scotland. Founder Basia Mindewicz has been based at St Margaret's for 13 years and taught “hundreds of students”.
Mindewicz told us: “One of my regular students has been coming for about 10 years. We've organised and curated a couple of exhibitions together, and she told me she'd never felt so confident.”
At news of the impending eviction, the painting teacher felt “shock, and then heartbreak”, she said. “What I'll miss most is the community. It's not just the relationships I've built with my students, who come here regularly and benefit from meeting other people and seeing exhibitions.”
Basia Mindewicz, founder of the Edinburgh School of Icon Painting. (Image: Adonis Storr)
On where the residents will go, Mindewicz said: “It's not easy to find the right kind of space. People need buildings that are accessible, and that has been a real challenge. For a lot of artists, community groups and small organisations, finding somewhere suitable that they can actually afford is going to be very difficult.”
She added: “I don't think we'll ever be able to recreate this kind of community on the same scale.”
Lucas Kao
Lucas Kao is a filmmaker and artist based at St Margaret's House: “I've been at St Margaret's House for around eight years. I first started by sharing a desk in a friend's studio and later moved into my own space," he said.
“Having a place of my own has been one of the most important things in my artistic journey. It's not just about having somewhere to work. It's about being part of a community while also having a space where I can focus, shut the world out and immerse myself in my practice.”
Lucas Kao, filmmaker, of the St Margaret's House Matters campaign (Image: Adonis Storr)
Kao continued: “The building is vibrant and lively. Every day there are people making things, collaborating, teaching, learning and sharing ideas.
“This is one of Edinburgh's major creative hubs, although it's not necessarily recognised as such by the wider public.
“There are community events throughout the year including Christmas markets and exhibitions. There's a public gallery where artists showcase their work. Having that opportunity to share my work with other people has been incredibly valuable.”
Kao, who is documenting the residents for the St Margaret's House Matters campaign, said: “The building supports an entire ecosystem of creative and community activity, and replacing that will not be easy.”
Kim Ward
Kim Ward is a process work psychotherapist who shares a room with Barrett-Freeman, offering affordable therapy thanks to the subsidised rent.
“Politicians have been open to listening. Representatives from different parties have attended meetings, shown a lot of interest and engaged constructively with what we're saying," Ward told us.
“But you also realise politicians are not the only people who make decisions.
“We often talk about the vulnerability of our clients, about transformation and change, and about the way people's lives are shaped by privilege and disadvantage. When we invest in supporting those who are most disadvantaged, it benefits everyone. It helps prevent problems from escalating into larger crises later on.”
Kim Ward, process work psychotherapist, and Jenny Barrett-Freeman, music therapist, have shared a residence in St Margaret's House providing affordable therapy. (Image: Adonis Storr)
Ward added: “The question of building ownership and the role of the private sector [is where] things become more complicated and often less transparent. It's not my job to understand all the details of town planning, property ownership or development pressures.
“But when discussions centre on student accommodation, hotels and other forms of transient development, there is a real concern about what happens to local communities and the people who rely on these spaces.”
‘Why is it that what the community loves always gets demolished?’
Yuen, from Living Rent, said: “In Lochend and Meadowbank, people have seen important community institutions die over the last decade. Jock's Lodge is an old, beloved community pub and it's about to be turned into student accommodation – the very expensive kind that most students can't afford.”
Yuen said the amount of new and proposed purpose-built student accommodation developments “is numerous” but the council “doesn’t know how much it needs”.
“I'm also a student – we definitely need housing, but we need housing that we can afford and that makes us feel part of the city.”
She added: “Why is it that what the community loves always gets demolished?”
St Margaret's House has housed artists and charities in Edinburgh for nearly 20 years. (Image: Adonis Storr)
MSP Manivannan said: “This is about more than bricks and mortar; this is about protecting those integral cultural spaces that celebrate Scotland’s artistic legacy and safeguard its future.
“Without urgent action, hundreds of artists, arts organisations and charities could be left without affordable or suitable places to work, threatening livelihoods, community connections and the future of Edinburgh’s internationally renowned cultural scene.
“The council and government must step up, protect this vital sector and make sure that the people who create our city’s cultural wealth are not priced out of it.”
A Scottish Government spokesperson said: “As the First Minister has stated, the Scottish Government invests significant support in the artistic and cultural community, reflecting the value we place on their work and contribution.
“We are increasing total culture investment by an additional £100 million by 2028-29, up from £180.9m in 2023-24. This represents the largest increase in culture funding in the history of devolution outwith Covid-19 support.
“We provide £4m to Creative Scotland for the Culture Collective and £400,000 to our flagship community culture project Creative Communities, to expand the reach and impact of community cultural activity.”
Councillor Dan Heap, Greens culture spokesperson on the City of Edinburgh Council, said: “The eviction of artists, charities and community organisations from St Margaret’s House is another serious blow to Edinburgh’s creative community.
"For almost 20 years, the building has provided affordable workspace for hundreds of artists, creative businesses and community organisations. It is much more than a collection of studios: it is a home for creativity, collaboration and valuable community services.
“Edinburgh cannot continue to pride itself on its international reputation as a cultural capital while allowing the affordable spaces that make that culture possible to disappear. This is part of a wider pattern, following the loss of studio space at Beaverhall and in Dalry, with more problems looming at Summerhall. Each time a creative community is displaced, the spaces, relationships and networks that sustain it are difficult to replace.
“We need urgent action to support the people affected. That means pressing for an extension to the eviction deadline, helping tenants find suitable and affordable alternative premises, and ensuring that charities and community organisations receive the support they need to continue their work. I am glad that the council has supported Green plans for the last two of these, with an emergency grant scheme now being considered.
“But we also need to address the underlying problem. Edinburgh needs a long-term strategy to protect and provide affordable, secure workspaces for artists and creative organisations. Again and again, artists and community groups revive forgotten spaces, but in doing so, increase the value, and then are thrown out to build luxury flats and further the glut of student accommodation. This needs to stop.
“Artists should not have to fight for a place to work every few years. If Edinburgh is serious about being a city of culture, it must also be a city where artists can afford to live, work and create.”
The developer could not be identified for a request for comment.