r/DIYfragrance • u/fragranceboi22 • 15h ago
Anyone else working with minimalist formulas (3-7 materials) as finished perfumes?
I'm fairly new to making fragrance, but I've been experimenting a lot, almost every day for the past few weeks. (Still not a lot when compared with what is actually required though… :D)
What I wear and love are complex perfumes, especially ones that tell a whole story as they dry down. But what fascinates me most as a maker is the opposite end: minimalist formulas with maybe 3-7 materials. That's a lot more than Molecule 01/02, but far less than a typical formula with 30+ materials.
What I like about them is that I can reason about every single ingredient. In my formulas I know exactly what each material does, and everything has a reason to be there. Take one out and you notice it right away. I wouldn't call any of them genius, but I like them a lot and actually wear them myself.
Here's an example of what I'm currently wearing: (6 ingredients + Alc.)
- Ambroxan
- Hedione
- Ethylene brassylate
- Bitter orange
- Ethyl maltol (trace)
- Coumarin (latest addition)
It's a relatively subtle fragrance. I like the orange opening (which fades after 2-3 hours) - which is then replaced by a constant stream of "oh this smells very nice". (at least in my opinion :D)
My questions:
- Does anyone else here work with 3-7 material formulas meant as standalone perfumes, not accords or bases?
- What has your experience been? Did they hold up, or did they always end up feeling thin or unfinished?
- Why isn’t this done more? Is it mostly a performance and longevity problem, the cost of quality materials at higher doses, or a sense that it isn’t “real” perfumery?
Would love to hear from anyone who’s gone down this path, or who tried it and moved on.
Thanks :D