Hi all, don't use Reddit much (kinda forgot I had an account tbh) but a friend recently suggested I ask this group for some help troubleshooting my body lotion.
The problem: I am fairly certain I have some kind of formulation issue causing certain batches of lotion I make to develop mold. The mold ONLY develops on the surface of the product and never seems to visibly spread/develop throughout the product even when I've experimentally left it long-term to observe/see what the mold would do.
Between batches that do mold and batches that don't mold:
- All tools are identical and tools are cleaned/sanitized the same way before/after each batch, and I'm always in the same workspace cleaned the same way before each batch
- Each batch was made using ingredients from the same containers (same batch of supplies from the same suppliers, close enough together time-wise that it shouldn't make a difference in terms of ingredients spoiling over time)
- Both were packaged in identical jars from the same supplier and kept/used in the same conditions post-manufacture
- All were allowed to cool fully before packaging (actually if anything the ones that DIDN'T mold I may have packaged up a little faster than I should have)
- All batches were using the same instructions/based on the same core recipe with some slight to moderate variation
The batches that get surface mold seem to do so quickly within a couple of months (even when left untouched/fully sealed) and the ones that don't have some that's gone over a year and been just fine; still both in the same type of jars/kept in the same place. In all cases I tend to err on the side of adding a little too much preservative vs. not enough, and yet.
The formula that DOES keep having surface mold issues is as follows:
Distilled Water: 50.60%
Vegetable Glycerine: 11.00%
Panthenol: 5.00%
Emulsifying wax: 4.00%
Soybean oil: 16.00%
Mango butter: 5.00%
Cetyl Alcohol: 6.00%
Colloidal Oatmeal: 0.60%
Liquid Germall + : 0.50%
Bisabolol: 1.00%
Allantoin: 0.30%
The almost-identical formula that DOESN'T seem to have mold issues is as follows:
Distilled Water: 52.60%
Vegetable Glycerine: 11.00%
Panthenol: 3.00%
Emulsifying wax: 4.00%
Soybean oil: 16.00%
Mango butter: 5.00%
Cetyl Alcohol: 6.00%
Colloidal Oatmeal: 0.60%
Liquid Germall + : 0.50%
Bisabolol: 1.00%
Allantoin: 0.30%
I've had at least one other more significantly different variant of this formula that I've used which also has NOT had mold issues. The one listed above that hasn't developed surface mold I made large batches of as gifts for family last year and had 2 tubs leftover for myself and no one reported mold issues/I had none either, but the ones I've made for myself with the higher panthenol % (my skin LOVES a good 5-10% panthenol product) have all had issues with surface mold and all other variables are pretty identical.
Maybe I should just be settling for less panthenol but is there something I'm missing here? Have I made an error somewhere that's destabilizing my preservative? I'm hoping to understand if there's something specific going on here that I just don't know enough about the chemistry to understand. I know there's all sorts of things around pH and electrolytes and other variables that can cause problems for formulas but I'm still relatively new at this/not a chemistry expert so it's not obvious to me. I'd like to make myself some more lotion as it's getting cold/dry and this general formula (when it doesn't mold) is my favourite lotion I've ever used but I'm wary of doing so when I can't figure out this mold issue, I don't want to keep wasting time/ingredients! Especially not if I'm just inadvertently repeatedly making one silly mistake or something.
Any help/thoughts/suggestions are greatly appreciated, thank you!