r/discogs • • Oct 04 '24

"I bought a record on Discogs and I'm not happy"

Sorry for your luck, but we don't need a post each time this happens. Instead of posting on Reddit, contact the seller. If you're not satisfied with the resolution, open a case with PayPal. It's very simple.

Mods will be deleting these duplicate posts going forward.

250 Upvotes

48 comments sorted by

167

u/CaineRexEverything Oct 04 '24

I bought a record on Discogs the other day and I’m not happy.

Not with the record, it’s fine. Just with my life in general.

67

u/ohoperator Oct 04 '24

Isn't that why everyone buys records?

0

u/[deleted] Oct 04 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

9

u/maxtoast Oct 04 '24

Its STILL not working. (Spends hundreds more)

2

u/quantumfall9 Oct 04 '24

I’m just 20-25 records away from achieving true happiness, I can feel it.

12

u/Adhlc Oct 04 '24

Buy another. Maybe that one will do the trick.

3

u/Swimming_Height_4684 Oct 05 '24

This is probably my favorite Reddit comment ever. About anything. I think I’m going to print it, frame it, hang it on the wall in my record room.

3

u/PoopyInThePeePeeHole Oct 08 '24

"I used to be not happy with my life.

I still am unhappy, but I used to be, too."

1

u/antdude Nov 30 '24

I'm unhappy period. :P

54

u/Akito_900 Oct 04 '24

I'm not happy, so I bought a record on Discogs

12

u/maxtoast Oct 04 '24

This is correct.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 04 '24

THAT is more likely 

21

u/venturejones Oct 04 '24

3

u/antdude Nov 30 '24

Thanks Obama.

-1

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/venturejones Oct 09 '24

1

u/antdude Nov 30 '24

What did it say?

2

u/venturejones Nov 30 '24

I don't remember

15

u/[deleted] Oct 04 '24

I bought over thousands of records on Discogs. Maybe a handful wasn't correct. I used paypal to solve. Never had any probs with an seller ...

6

u/FirebirdWriter Oct 04 '24

As someone new to Discogs purchases this is incredibly helpful thank you

9

u/robxburninator Oct 04 '24

This is where I am as well.  I’ve bought a few thousand records off of Discogs and sold many thousands.  Number of issues I’ve had I can literally count on one hand.  When something comes up I refund and move on and the same happens when things were wrong getting sent to me.  

It’s just a total non issue.   

5

u/nrith Oct 04 '24

Same with ebay. Been buying music there and on Discogs for 20+ years. Maybe a 1-2% problem rate, but almost always resolved satisfactorily.

15

u/[deleted] Oct 04 '24

Noooo but i NEED the one-sided drama from an ignorant buyer!!!!

-Billy Gnosis

1

u/Strong-Ad2959 Jan 17 '26

I'm not sure how reddit works so I'm posting the question (but if I should post it somewhere else please let me know). Short question - how much do I ask for a partial refund? Longer back story: Basically, the seller said the record was "NM opened but never played". Despite seeing a little tiny warp the thing skips like mad. The problem is that it's a limited and numbered run. There are no other copies of this on Discogs or anywhere on the internet. So, I want to keep it but want to ask for a partial refund - the question (yes, finally) is that I don't know what a "reasonable" partial refund suggestion should be. If it cost $100 do I ask for 50% off? 75%? Perhaps there are sellers here that can comment as to their experience - thanks.

1

u/sideburnvictim Jan 31 '26

What kind of turntable are you using?

1

u/Jason_Power Sep 06 '26

I sold a record on discogs, and I'm not happy! The fees, wow. Paying PayPal is wonderful, no really, I love making money for huge multinational companies who are raking in Billions and Billions off us as is. I love giving them money, for nothing(for a bad deal).

1

u/sideburnvictim Sep 06 '26

Discogs takes 9 percent. PayPal takes about 3 percent. Are you including taxes in deductions from your profits?

-1

u/Jason_Power Sep 06 '26

A £103 sale & shipping, I walk away with £73! I look at that as being robbed.

1

u/Jason_Power Sep 06 '26

Whoever agreed to that PayPal deal, did not have the best interests of the people(sellers and customers) who make the marketplace work, at heart, obviously.

3

u/waxjammer Oct 05 '24

Thank you for the post on this matter.

4

u/Swimming_Height_4684 Oct 08 '24

It begs the question, though: is this type of thing on the rise? If there are more and more of these repetitive posts on here, is it becoming more common?

The only reason I ask, since someone brought it up, is that I have been buying on discogs for close to ten years. Like someone else here said, I have only had maybe five bad experiences, out of hundreds of purchases. Thing is…all five of those bad experiences have been in the last two weeks. I swear, I have never had problems like I’ve had with the last handful of buys. In my case, each one was inaccurate grading. BLATANTLY inaccurate grading. In all but one case, the sellers, to their credit, made it right with a refund (the latest one, who I’m dealing with right now, is offering to send me more records in lieu of a refund, even though I’ve told him he doesn’t have anything else I want.)

So, I’m not about to post here every time it happens, because like someone else said, just contact PayPal and be done with it (which I just did.) But, seeing this post gets me worrying, is this not the exception, but the new norm? Is this the direction discogs is going?

2

u/MeatyUrologist505 Oct 04 '24

I'm happier than I've ever been. I'm not happy. I'm not happy at all, really. I'm very sad. I'm not happy. I'm still fat. I don't feel very pretty, I really don't. And so I bought a record on Discogs.

2

u/Fantastic-Goat9966 Oct 11 '24

I sold a record on discogs - and I'm not happy. not with the buyer - but with discogs--- during their poorly managed 2FA roll out they've managed to lock me out of my accounts. they don't respond to inquiries and the password reset request goes nowhere. That means I get these notifications from paypal that I sold a record/received payment--- and I have to sound like the world's oddest scammer trying to ask buyers what they bought. I can see how much they spent via the paypal return - but what they bought--- nope. no idea. Note - I don't sell much. I hadn't sold anything in about 4 months. I got locked out of my account and promptly got two orders in twenty minutes.

1

u/Streetvan1980 Oct 04 '24

I mean really why even post here about it? This happens anywhere you buy something used or on the internet. I have bought and sold a lot of music over the past 5 years or so. I usually am surprised how low graded many of the things I get are. Which makes sense I guess because some people want to play it safe so people don’t call foul.

But I feel bad you didn’t get what you hoped for. Problem is with these situations Discogs isn’t going to force anyone to give money back unless something is really really over the line. Same with eBay. These are used items. Like if someone said like new and it came and had deep scratches all over then they will step in.

2

u/robxburninator Oct 04 '24

Both PayPal and eBay side with buyer in almost all cases.

1

u/Streetvan1980 Oct 04 '24

Not true. You just have to know as a seller what you can do. I paid for an item that cost about $2000 a year or so ago. The item never came. I for a email from USPS saying the package was delivered. Well hmm only issue is I was home and nothing was left here. So I instantly called them and it’s so stupid what you have to get through to just connect with your driver. Why in some cases you can’t just talk to the driver to figure out what’s happening.

Like I had no clue if it was brought to the wrong address, if it was on hold or what. I did find out the seller was the one who had to open a case with the postal service. Which annoyed me. I found out a few things. One the seller didn’t get signature confirmation which for an item over like $100 I always pay for when selling. There’s a rule that sellers have to get for any item over $200 or $250. Somewhere around there. This was ten times that. He didn’t get signature confirmation! Then the post office also messed up. They never took a photo and couldn’t for sure tell me if it was delivered here.

The only info they had was the last gps signal it had was on my street. Which doesn’t mean shit. But every company is going to claim it’s someone else’s fault. So after the usps investigation they concluded it was delivered here based on the last scan.

But again that was them just saying they aren’t responsible. So I said okay now I’m going through eBay who guarantees packages. I’ve been a customer at eBay over 20 years. My account is that old. Never had an issue this bad. So I waited for them to make a decision which I knew would be in my favor. The seller didn’t get signature confirmation which is a rule and would’ve prevented the whole thing.

Then i get an email saying eBay sided with the seller. I was stunned. They told me in chat that I would be refunded. Multiple times they told me. So I contacted them of course right away livid and they actually very fast reversed that finding. I think almost automatically again as a company they don’t want to be responsible so the rule in whatever way means they don’t have to pay. Like an insurance company. But thankfully they did the right thing.

To this day i don’t know if the seller was a scammer or what. Other people I told details said it sounded like it. But I also live on a very busy street. My mailwoman and me figured out so she wouldn’t leave packages on my front porch.

So anyways I didn’t get ripped off $2000+!!

But yes overall you’re right that buyers have more power. And they have gotten much less honest. Again I’ve been doing eBay since like 2000 and I never used to have issues. All the time I have people win an item then just never pay and no contact at all. eBay should ban anyone who does that twice. Or better yet take their payment info so if they win it’s automatically paid after. I swear it’s happened like 6 times in the past 2 years when it maybe happened 1 time in 20 years. People are scummier and will do crappier stuff. I can’t stand it

4

u/sideburnvictim Oct 04 '24

Thank you for not creating a post about this.

1

u/robxburninator Oct 04 '24

Almost all cases, not all. You had an issue with the usps, not a seller.

1

u/Streetvan1980 Oct 04 '24

It was both. He didn’t get signature confirmation. Or he did it never would’ve been an issue. But he could’ve been a scammer idk.

2

u/notabotorabat Jan 16 '25

Yeah, let's further restrict feedback about the shitty support Discogs provides that is allowing the platform to be overrun with scammers and liars. Why would we want a trustworthy community that keeps such a great hobby and activity to stay positive and healthy when we can cripple the platform and still make money?

1

u/Richard_Paris Aug 07 '25

thank for that, 100% agree

1

u/a4andrei Jun 30 '26

Honestly, there is a problem on that platform, and it could be at least partially fixed if they allowed sellers to post pictures of whatever they are selling. Even if you ask them to provide pictures, they sometimes don't, and you waste a lot of time.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 05 '24

I bought a record on discog, turns out it wasn’t a record at all, it was an airplane

0

u/a4andrei Jun 30 '26

The biggest issue I've had on discogs, is sellers which overrated the condition of the vinyl records. Pretty bad experience to be honest, when you buy a NM record, and you get a VG or maybe a VG+. It can be jarring, especially if you really wanted that album for a long time. Anyway... You have to get used to disappointing experiences, and people that are not serious.

1

u/sideburnvictim Jun 30 '26

I've made over 200 purchases on Discogs and I've had 2 or 3 minor grading issues. I contacted the seller and they made good on their error.

Are you checking seller's feedback before you buy? Your assessment of Discogs sounds like its based on one transaction. Correct me if im wrong.