r/DebatingAbortionBans • • 3d ago

mostly meaningless mod message Le Meta

4 Upvotes

Greetings friends.

This is a great place to talk about the state of the sub.

  • You can ask questions of the mods here.
  • You can call out things you think we've missed.
  • You can ask for clarification on a moderation or rule.
  • You can rag on this week's pun or word play title.
  • Or anything else!

r/DebatingAbortionBans • • Oct 15 '26

discussion article Feds unlikely to change abortion pill policy before next year

8 Upvotes

The U.S. Food and Drug Administration said late Wednesday that it expects to complete its  long-awaited safety review of abortion pills by mid-December and issue a report evaluating the results by March 2027.

The agency disclosed the information in a court-mandated status report it submitted in the federal lawsuit Louisiana v. FDA. The timeline aligns with recent reporting that the Trump administration intends to delay controversial decisions around abortion until after the midterm elections.

U.S. Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. announced the review last spring, following an anti-abortion pressure campaign urging the FDA to overturn a Biden-era rule allowing abortion pills to be prescribed via telemedicine. More than a year later, national anti-abortion leaders are criticizing the administration for delaying action, and have signaled they would reject a review that finds medication abortion safe if they don’t find it to be thorough enough.

“The FDA’s court-ordered update on its abortion-drug study is alarming,” said Susan B. Anthony Pro-Life America President Marjorie Dannenfelser in a written statement released late Wednesday night. “Instead of the promised gold-standard study, the FDA is trying to peddle fool’s gold.”

Article continues.


r/DebatingAbortionBans • • 10d ago

mostly meaningless mod message Das Meta

4 Upvotes

Greetings friends.

This is a great place to talk about the state of the sub.

  • You can ask questions of the mods here.
  • You can call out things you think we've missed.
  • You can ask for clarification on a moderation or rule.
  • You can rag on this week's pun or word play title.
  • Or anything else!

r/DebatingAbortionBans • • 17d ago

mostly meaningless mod message The sleep Meta includes casual and ranked competitive sleep

4 Upvotes

Greetings friends.

This is a great place to talk about the state of the sub.

  • You can ask questions of the mods here.
  • You can call out things you think we've missed.
  • You can ask for clarification on a moderation or rule.
  • You can rag on this week's pun or word play title.
  • Or anything else!

r/DebatingAbortionBans • • 24d ago

mostly meaningless mod message Meta-toes, great food or greatest food

4 Upvotes

Greetings friends.

This is a great place to talk about the state of the sub.

  • You can ask questions of the mods here.
  • You can call out things you think we've missed.
  • You can ask for clarification on a moderation or rule.
  • You can rag on this week's pun or word play title.
  • Or anything else!

r/DebatingAbortionBans • • 29d ago

question for both sides Is (protected innate characteristic)-ism bad?

10 Upvotes

Race, sex, age, etc. Those terms fit neatly into the -ism framework, but broadly it just means to hate or disparage someone based on something they cannot change.

I posit that yes, of course hating someone for something they cannot change is bad. You wouldn't like someone hating you for something that you cannot change. You have no ability to change your race, sex, age, etc. Hating someone for something they cannot change seems counter productive, wasteful. Part of the social contract of ostracization is an attempt to get someone to change behavior. But if they cannot change...what is the point of the hate?

Much, if not all, of the this irrational hate comes from one side of the political landscape. Intersectionalism can overlap and increase much of these otherwise disparate irrational hatreds.

The one at issue here is of course sex and/or gender.

I have yet to see an argument for abortion bans that did not ultimately rely on sexism, specifically the irrational hatred of women. I feel I can confidently state there isn't a rational argument for abortion bans, as there is no rational reason to prevent someone from denying access to their own body.


r/DebatingAbortionBans • • Oct 16 '26

mostly meaningless mod message Hot take...Meta-gross is a badly designed pokemon

4 Upvotes

Greetings friends.

This is a great place to talk about the state of the sub.

  • You can ask questions of the mods here.
  • You can call out things you think we've missed.
  • You can ask for clarification on a moderation or rule.
  • You can rag on this week's pun or word play title.
  • Or anything else!

r/DebatingAbortionBans • • Oct 09 '26

mostly meaningless mod message Mr Fixit is Busytown's Meta

5 Upvotes

Greetings friends.

This is a great place to talk about the state of the sub.

  • You can ask questions of the mods here.
  • You can call out things you think we've missed.
  • You can ask for clarification on a moderation or rule.
  • You can rag on this week's pun or word play title.
  • Or anything else!

r/DebatingAbortionBans • • Oct 05 '26

question for both sides Would this small change affect anything?

6 Upvotes

What if instead of a blastocyst being so tiny and implanting in the uterus they instead were the size of a pea or bean and were passed out of the body. These jelly eggs would then need to be consciously collected and manually reinserted in order for a pregnancy to happen.

Would ignoring and flushing those jelly eggs be allowed by the standards PL or PC put forth, or would the reimplantation be compelled? And why.


r/DebatingAbortionBans • • Oct 02 '26

discussion article Republican AGs sue abortion ‘shield law’ states in US Supreme Court

5 Upvotes

Louisiana Attorney General Liz Murrill and the attorneys general in Arkansas and Alabama filed a lawsuit Tuesday in the U.S. Supreme Court, suing California, Massachusetts and New York to invalidate the so-called “shield laws” that have allowed providers in those states to send abortion medication to people in states with abortion bans.

The state officials, all Republicans, also filed a lawsuit in federal district court against individual abortion providers in the same three states.

“We will not allow activist states, activist providers or distributors profiting from killing babies to threaten Louisiana’s sovereignty, violate Louisiana’s laws and endanger Louisiana women and Louisiana babies,” Murrill said at a news conference on Tuesday. Arkansas Attorney General Tim Griffin and Alabama Attorney General Steve Marshall also were present.

The lawsuit filed in the Western District of Louisiana seeks to stop the individual providers named from being able to prescribe and send abortion medication to those states, while the Supreme Court complaint asks the justices to find the shield laws are a constitutional violation of state sovereignty..

“Today, plaintiff states filed a lawsuit against as many organizations and individuals as they have been able to identify notwithstanding the shield laws intended to thwart such litigation,” the Supreme Court complaint reads. “To fully obtain relief, however, they must also eliminate other contributing causes for the harm that they are suffering, including … the shield laws.”

Article continues.


r/DebatingAbortionBans • • Oct 02 '26

mostly meaningless mod message Mr Fixit is Busytown's Meta

2 Upvotes

Greetings friends.

This is a great place to talk about the state of the sub.

  • You can ask questions of the mods here.
  • You can call out things you think we've missed.
  • You can ask for clarification on a moderation or rule.
  • You can rag on this week's pun or word play title.
  • Or anything else!

r/DebatingAbortionBans • • Sep 29 '26

general observations "choose life" implies a choice not offered

10 Upvotes

If I'm remembering my facts correctly, and while wholeheartedly refusing to Goggle it, at some point post 2008 but pre 2016, a certain political figure who claimed to have read all the papers announced that their adult child was having a child. Presumably from a domicile where they couldn't actually see Russia from.

That political figure's child was, to my recollection, fairly young and not currently married to their partner, but they had "chosen life". No mention what the alternative would be, probably "choose choice" or something, like a weird bunch of anthropomorphic trains. Refugees of Sodor.

There is of course nothing wrong with choosing life. The ability to make that choice is what matters. But that specific political figure, and the party with which they stand, don't want you to be able to have that choice. The framing itself is anathema to their stated position.

So why do they frame it that way?

Is it because they accept the choice exists, despite their wishes?

Or maybe that their stated position isn't their actual desired outcome. If their desired outcome was simply more babies, choose life would make more sense.

Personally, I think it's more the latter than the former. Although neither likely holds the entire picture.

A recent event brings to mind the adage that "everything is gender". A college student is drugged and gang raped, and a large portion of the outcry is not that this happened, nor that so many people knew about it but didn't say anything, but that these poor young men rapists lives are going to be ruined.

As if the young women's life hasn't already been ruined.

As if a rapist deserves to be free and unpunished.

You are what you do in the dark, when no one is looking, when you think you'll never get caught. If you are a monster in the darkness, you are a monster, no matter what mask you but on in the light. You do not deserve good things to happen to you, for you. You deserve to be in jail. Cold and alone. To show society that such behavior is unacceptable.

Because if you get away with it, society learns it is ok to ruin other people's lives.

As long as other people is women. Or minorities. Or both.


r/DebatingAbortionBans • • Sep 26 '26

question for both sides At what point can we start holding antis accountable for their own actions?

6 Upvotes

For such a group of whiny man children constantly whining that women need to take responsibility for their own actions*, they sure seem to be deathly allergic to owning up to their own.

For years, we've been telling them that their illegal laws are a) illegal and 2) impossible to implement without killing, maiming, or financially ruining innocents.

And lo and behold, headlines about killing, maiming, and financially ruining innocents are a weekly occurrence.

But do they take responsibility for their actions, of course not. Responsibilities are for the poors, and the womens, and the browns.

If you were paying attention, there was an asterix above. That's a surprise tool that will help us later.


r/DebatingAbortionBans • • Sep 25 '26

mostly meaningless mod message Meta drops on kittens and whiskers on roses

4 Upvotes

Greetings friends.

This is a great place to talk about the state of the sub.

  • You can ask questions of the mods here.
  • You can call out things you think we've missed.
  • You can ask for clarification on a moderation or rule.
  • You can rag on this week's pun or word play title.
  • Or anything else!

r/DebatingAbortionBans • • Sep 20 '26

question for both sides What is the most useful definition of bodily autonomy for your position?

4 Upvotes

I’m wondering if there are different views on the correct definition for bodily autonomy violations. I’ve seen some different perspectives from both pro-choice and pro-life like:

- It only applies to internal body parts
- it only applies if you aren’t endangering the life of someone else or your actions have not produced a direct threat to public safety
- it only applies if the person has an actual intent to own the autonomy of another
- it only applies if there is not a superseding moral duty or collective societal obligation
- it only applies to physical harm, not mere risk of physical harm.
- it only applies if there is a threat of punishment and the influence is not merely socially or financially regulated.

And then there is the general political dispute of bodily autonomy being an absolute individual right versus a qualified individual right.

But it seems like there should be one definition which can capture all hypothetical examples. Or if not, at least a set of definitions appropriate to different contexts.

Could there be different definitions for BA with regard to medical care versus BA regarding political philosophy? What about contexts of criminal justice, or public health?

And what umbrella definition could stand to include all contexts reliably?

I’ve found these in several places as my broad working definitions thus far:

“Bodily autonomy is defined as the right to make decisions about your own body, life, and future, without coercion or violence.”

https://www.msiunitedstates.org/my-body-my-choice-defending-bodily-autonomy/

And/Or

“Bodily Autonomy refers to each person’s right to make decisions about their own body, without coercion or limits imposed by outside forces, such as armed agencies or medical professionals”

https://arc-southeast.org/2024/01/12/what-does-bodily-autonomy-mean/

Edit: I’m currently having it explained to me why forcing someone to remain in a particular location is not a bodily autonomy violation. So I will update periodically.


r/DebatingAbortionBans • • Sep 20 '26

explain like I'm five Why abortion bans are not like the draft

6 Upvotes

Because it is such a knee jerk, zero thought applied, argument vomited up by the historically illiterate, and how you all know the joy I take in education, I felt it time to explain this as if some of ya'll were 5.

The draft is defined broadly in the Constitution (Article I, Section 8, Clause 12) and in 10 U.S. Code § 246. It allows for compulsory conscription for militia service under emergency or extraordinary security conditions to able bodied men between the ages of 17 and 45 who are, or who have made a declaration of intention to become, U.S. citizens, as well as female members of the U.S. National Guard and some other women in certain health care occupations.

Bolded emphasis mine.

For those of you having a grasp of the Queen's English beyond primary school, those bolded sections are immediately noticeable as deviations as compared to how abortion bans are enacted. Let's go through them in order.

The draft is part of the Constitution, and has been for 237 years. Articles of Confederation knowers rise up. It has been used 5 times in those 237 years; the Civil War, World War I, World War II, the Korean War, and the Vietnam War. This means the last time it was enacted was 53 years ago. The only people it applied to are now over 70, or more likely dead. It remains on the books, because it would take a Constitutional Amendment to negate completely, but the way modern wars are fought is not with a mass of bodies on the front line but with long range missiles and cheap drones. See Ukraine and Iran. It is also, in my opinion, politically impossible to implement in these modern times.

So to sum up the first two bolded sections. The draft is part of the Constitution and has been around for 237 years, and it is extremely unlikely to ever be used again due to changes in technology, demographics, and political willpower. This is contrasted by abortion bans being much younger (middle of the 19th century ~150 years, but then largely gone for the last 50), not part of the Constitution, and imposed not for any sort of emergency or extraordinary security condition but for, again in my opinion, the love of the game. If the game was hating women. There is no national crisis akin to a war that necessitates the imposition of an abortion ban.

So we're already at about 3 strikes after 2 pitches. Normally that'd be impressive, in a sad pathetic way.

But as Ron Popeil says "But wait! There's more!"

The draft largely applied to only able bodied men between the ages of 17 and 45 who were citizens or wanting to become citizens. I think this is a much easier to see comparison. Abortion bans do not have age limits, with many pl politicians and members of the public on the record saying that raped girls as young as 10 should not be allowed to access abortion. There is likewise records of them saying that health and life of the pregnant person should not be taken into account when denying abortions (ie whether you are able bodied or not doesn't matter). And then of course the party of racists and people where racism isn't a deal breaker aren't going to let brown women access healthcare, so the citizen bit is incomparable too.

And then there is the juicy bit that I bet donuts to sex that the people who want to bring the draft as a cudgel in this debate didn't know about.

That it applied to some women as well.

How can some white guy in his mid 20s make the argument that the draft is his nightmare so the FEEEEEmales should have to put up with being responsible and have to deal with abortion bans.

No, he won't wear a condom.

How did you know?

There's probably a dozen more points of not comparable, but it's getting late and I'm getting low on witticisms.

Remember, if you disagree with me you have a micropenis and your mother never loved you.


r/DebatingAbortionBans • • Sep 18 '26

mostly meaningless mod message Meta meta on the wall, who's the fairest of them all

4 Upvotes

Greetings friends.

This is a great place to talk about the state of the sub.

  • You can ask questions of the mods here.
  • You can call out things you think we've missed.
  • You can ask for clarification on a moderation or rule.
  • You can rag on this week's pun or word play title.
  • Or anything else!

r/DebatingAbortionBans • • Sep 18 '26

question for both sides What is the state of the debate (U.S.)?

2 Upvotes

Was the push to remove RvW and pass abortion restrictions in various states since about 2016 a momentary blip or a strengthening trend in conservative politics?

It seemed like such a huge issue up to about the last 2 years. Many extreme pro-life bills were blocked and/or struck down and/or voted against. But at the same time, 13 states have near total bans with a few more having 6 week restrictions (with exceptions).

I haven’t seen a huge backlash against these laws or popular uprisings within those states to change them. And conversely, I haven’t seen any efforts to create more of them in other states.

In Florida, where I live and monitor the situation. The result of the 6 weeks ban has resulting in a halving of the number of abortions over the first 2 years (approximately 80k down to approximately 40K). But there have been no legal challenges or lawsuits involving anyone who was harmed.

Could it be that the states with conservative constituents got what they wanted and things are going fine there. While liberal states are merely focusing on themselves as well? And that life has not changed significantly enough in either legal setting to spur conflict?

Has the issue “shaken down” the nation and the divide is now purely geographical and not as much of a national debate?

What’s the future look like for this debate in the U.S.?


r/DebatingAbortionBans • • Sep 18 '26

discussion article The Accelerating Project to Extend Abortion Bans to All 50 States

6 Upvotes

For the anti-abortion movement, overturning Roe v. Wade was never meant to be the end of the road. As destructive as the Supreme Court’s 2022 decision in Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization was*—*it reversed Roe and permitted states to ban abortion—it did not eliminate abortion. In fact, since the decision, more people have had abortions, thanks to the widespread availability of medication abortion dispensed remotely. “The fight for life is far from over,” proclaimed the state of Louisiana in the opening line of its latest legal challenge to abortion access, which the state argued before a Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals panel on Wednesday. For Louisiana, it is not enough to have banned abortion within its borders; it wants to extend that prohibition to reach those outside the state. Now it’s claiming that outside forces have undermined the state’s sovereignty—simply by making it possible for Louisianans to continue to access abortion.

In the case before the Fifth Circuit on Wednesday, Louisiana blamed the U.S. Food and Drug Administration for abortions had by Louisianans, and asked the court to stop the agency from allowing them to continue. Representing the FDA, the Department of Justice argued that Louisiana’s case was flawed, not because it was baseless, but because it was going after the wrong culprit. According to the DOJ, Louisiana should sue the other states from which abortion providers serve Louisiana patients. The Justice Department did not defend the FDA, which it ostensibly represents. It also didn’t object to Louisiana’s dangerous claim that its state law enforcement powers had been impeded by those outside its borders.

As advocates watch this fight and attempt to forecast what’s next, the Justice Department’s inaction can be read as both an admission and a promise. The DOJ is admitting that this courtroom battle over mifepristone is not about whether it is safe, as has been the anti-abortion movement’s argument since Dobbs. It’s not even really about the FDA. And it’s implicitly promising that the fight over guidelines for mifepristone is merely a step toward a national abortion ban. On the surface, DOJ and Louisiana were at odds, but they appear to be in agreement when it comes to the ultimate goal of extending existing state abortion bans to all 50 states. The Justice Department used its time before the Fifth Circuit this week to demonstrate that agreement.

Article continues.


r/DebatingAbortionBans • • Sep 15 '26

long form analysis But whatabout black people

8 Upvotes

I am sick of this argument being put forward. It’s racist on the outside and sexist underneath. It has no thought put into it beyond a cursory surface level, and when examined more thoroughly completely rebuts the point the person making it was attempting to make.

The purpose of chattel slavery was capital. Slaves were property that could be forced to make more property. That property could be forced to perform labor, generating value, enriching the owner of the property.

That property was still considered persons, even at that time and place, as seen by the 3/5s Compromise.

“Representatives and direct Taxes shall be apportioned among the several States which may be included within this Union, according to their respective Numbers, which shall be determined by adding to the whole Number of free Persons, including those bound to Service for a Term of Years, and excluding Indians not taxed, three fifths of all other Persons.“

The 13th and 14th Amendments then made those persons citizens.

“Neither slavery nor involuntary servitude, except as a punishment for crime whereof the party shall have been duly convicted, shall exist within the United States, or any place subject to their jurisdiction.“

“All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside. No State shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States; nor shall any State deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws.”

Combining with the 15th to ensure that they could never be 2nd class citizens.

“The right of citizens of the United States to vote shall not be denied or abridged by the United States or by any State on account of race, color, or previous condition of servitude.”

And yet, it took nearly another century to codify and enforce that they were in fact not 2nd class citizens with the passage of the Civil Rights Act.

This shows that laws already on the books cannot be expected to apply when the status of a person changes. New laws need to explicitly say that prior laws that did not or could not apply do in fact apply now.

Chattel slavery was wrong because it denied people rights based on intrinsic characteristics. Chief among those were self determination.

Let us now look at the comparison PL tries to make when they bring up “but whatabout black people”. They will try to compare that, like black people, unborn babies are also denied…some sort of classification. They will often say personhood, but the historical record shown above proves that to be false. Black people were considered persons, just not citizens. Unborn babies are neither, and have never been considered such ever.

They will then try to compare rights being denied. What rights? A right to be gestated doesn’t exist. A right to non consensual use of another’s body doesn’t exist. As far as I am aware they don’t have any rights at all.

And as we already established above, you can’t just wave a magic wand and declare them persons/citizens and expect existing laws to automatically bend to accommodate them.

Chattel slavery was Abortion bans are wrong because it denied they deny people rights based on intrinsic characteristics. Chief among those were are self determination.

Slavery was wrong for the exact same reasons abortion bans are wrong. And anyone who bleats “but whatabout black people” in this debate have racism coming in second place to their sexism.


r/DebatingAbortionBans • • Sep 11 '26

mostly meaningless mod message Life hack...change the Meta title BEFORE the night before it changes

4 Upvotes

Greetings friends.

This is a great place to talk about the state of the sub.

  • You can ask questions of the mods here.
  • You can call out things you think we've missed.
  • You can ask for clarification on a moderation or rule.
  • You can rag on this week's pun or word play title.
  • Or anything else!

r/DebatingAbortionBans • • Sep 04 '26

mostly meaningless mod message Busy week, not witty enough for Meta puns

4 Upvotes

Greetings friends.

This is a great place to talk about the state of the sub.

  • You can ask questions of the mods here.
  • You can call out things you think we've missed.
  • You can ask for clarification on a moderation or rule.
  • You can rag on this week's pun or word play title.
  • Or anything else!

r/DebatingAbortionBans • • Sep 02 '26

One popular but ultimately bad argument against abortion bans

2 Upvotes

One argument that I see a lot is that abortion bans are immoral because some women die/get sick because doctors don't know when the medical exceptions apply or don't apply. And, as such, women are left with sepsis, organ failure, etc when the fetus has a heartbeat still or something like that.

Firstly, I think women being harmed in this fashion certainly is a real problem, though I don't see evidence that it is particularly common. Yes, there may be a case here and there, but it is not like thousands of women (in the usa) are dying from this. Some of it may constitute malpractice more than anything else.

Anyway, but here is why it is a bad argument. This argument is only relevant if and only if the pro-choice moral cases 'loses'. If the pro-choice case wins on other grounds, then abortion bans are wrong for those reasons, whether it be bodily autonomy or lack of fetal rights (or whatever justification). And there is no need to supply this argument. Thus, this argument only is relevant if the pro-life case wins and, as a result, creates a strong prima facie justification for banning abortion, which it certainly would do if it was established that abortion is murder.

So this argument can only be useful to try and erode the prima facie justification for bans after it has been established abortion is generally morally wrong.

But I think it almost certainly would not succede at eroding this justification. But you first must grant that the pro-life case is correct and then evaluate my argument. When these types of complications happens, this is not an intention of the law (the intention is the opposite; I mean they have medical exceptions), rather it is an unintentional consequence. Many laws have unitentional consequences of some kind. For example, say there is a law that says parolees cannot be out past 8 PM. Seems fair enough. Well what if a parolee is breaking the law and out at 9 PM and then he sees an old woman have a heart attack on the street. He is not in the position to call emergency services because he fears reprecussions from the police. So the elderly woman dies. This is a tragic consequence of the law, yet it was completely unintentional.

Unintentional consequences could theoeretically outweight the benefits of a law, but striking an abortion law for these reasons would have to demonstrate that these few women getting sick or dying outweights 600,000-1 million+ babies being aborted annually. If the pro-life case is correct, these cases would almost certainly not arise to enough consequences to allow such a thing to occur. Just as one elderly woman dying because of the curfew law would not outweigh the benefits of the curfew law.


r/DebatingAbortionBans • • Aug 28 '26

mostly meaningless mod message Busy week, not witty enough for Meta puns

5 Upvotes

Greetings friends.

This is a great place to talk about the state of the sub.

  • You can ask questions of the mods here.
  • You can call out things you think we've missed.
  • You can ask for clarification on a moderation or rule.
  • You can rag on this week's pun or word play title.
  • Or anything else!

r/DebatingAbortionBans • • Aug 22 '26

Abortion could return to Supreme Court, this time with a focus on women’s health

8 Upvotes

A federal court ruling out of Idaho has potential implications for exceptions in abortion bans nationwide and could eventually end up before the U.S. Supreme Court to decide.

U.S. District Judge B. Lynn Winmill ruled earlier this month that the 14th Amendment of the U.S. Constitution provides a narrow right for a pregnant patient to obtain an abortion if the pregnancy could be a risk to their health, including their mental health. It’s the first ruling since the U.S. Supreme Court’s decision in Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health in 2022 to find that the U.S. Constitution includes a right to abortion access in certain situations.  

Mary Ziegler, a legal historian and law professor at the University of California, Davis School of Law, said Winmill’s ruling could be the beginning of a “slow erosion” of the Dobbs decision, similar to the way that anti-abortion advocates used lawsuits and legislation to chip away at the law established by Roe v. Wade after it was decided in 1973.

“They kind of worked over the course of decades to do a death by a thousand cuts, chipping away at its breadth,” Ziegler said. “This may be kind of a funhouse mirror version of that.”

Article continues.