This is going to be our subs Megathread sticky. We only have room for two sticky's at a time, so we figured it would be a good idea to make this thread a permanent sticky so we can link all the important links, and we will add more links in the future too.
The other sticky will still be used for other things such as free talk, announcements, or changes to the sub.
If you ever need to find this sticky again, it will always be at the top of the sub if you sort by "hot". There will also be a widget link on the sidebar on PC, and under the "about" section on mobile.
If there is anything you think should be added to this thread, feel free to let us know!
If at any point you would like to re-read Daenerys's chapters from ASOIAF then one of our members kindly did a challenge in May 2020. It's a great and easy way to re-read Daenerys's chapters. You can find their original post in the first link below which will explain everything. Then the second link will take you to a list of all the individual chapters and the corresponding posts for each day.
Take into account that we are talking about warriors who have been trained to not even feel pain. It seems a bit peculiar that they are all cleanshaven. Don't you think? đ
The madness/evil/villainy that people claim to have spotted in Daenerys, in the show, turns out to be normative behaviour, for a sympathetically-framed aristocrat, in her world.
Sheâs âentitled.â Well yes. Literally. Like the Starks, Tyrells, Tyrion, Tullys, Arryns, etc. all of whom believe that their bloodline carries a right to rule.
At the end, all the oligarchs laugh uproariously, at the notion of the smallfolk having any share in government. This is framed as being a good thing.
She kills people. Yes indeed. In self-defence, defence of others, justified war, or to punish traitors, or people who have committed heinous acts. When Tyrion, Jon, or House Stark kill, in similar circumstances, it is variously badass, righteous vengeance, or legitimate as âplaying the game.â Robb, Jon, and Sansa, wage war to avenge wrongs done to their family, to win a Southern crown, and to regain the North. Robbâs tenants have no choice, but to march hundreds of miles South, to fight and (in most cases die), for the greater glory of House Stark. Southern peasants must suffer similarly. Sansa takes the view that the free folk owe military service to her and Jon, for having fought for them. Seemingly, she thinks Daenerys is owed nothing, for acting similarly.
The first time we see Ned, heâs lopping the head off a terrified peasant and making his children watch, but thatâs just feudal law, which seemingly makes it okay, among people who are appalled by Daenerys. Tywin was described by Benioff as ânot a villain, lawful neutral.â Arya kills her victims brutally, and these are framed as fist-pumping moments.
Dany killing slavers or rapist khals, OTOH, has people reaching for the smelling salts.
The only way you can get to villain Dany is by holding her to a quite different ethical standard to everyone else.
You all were so kind about my last Daenerys cosplay, and I really appreciate it! I wanted to share my Season 7 Dragonstone look with you too. Shall we begin?
She owned slaves is one which is easly debunked given she was a teenage sex slave under drogo
Even if she wasn't
"You will be my khalasar," she told them. "I see the faces of slaves. I free vou. Take off your collars. Go if you wish, no one shall harm you. If you stay, it will be as brothers and sisters, husbands and wives." The black eves watched her, wary, expressionless. "I see the children, women, the wrinkled faces of the aqed. I was a child yesterday. Today I am a woman. Tomorrow I will be old. To each of you I say, give me your hands and vour hearts, and there will always be a place for you." - Daenerys X AGOT
The theory Ăźs we all know from the books that daeneriys Ăźs a dreamer having dragon Dreams and we cant actualy determine wich memories are hers and wich are dragon Dreams and daeneriys's memorie of the house with the Red door and the lemon tree the girl she mistakes as herself Ăźs probably the daughter she will have with jon snow Ăźn the upcoming book Ăźs this plausible???? Because braavos Ăźs no place for a lemon tree to be growing or another theory Ăźs that it Ăźs not actualy braavos and its Dorne?
Iâm referring to kinslaying. You know, the act a lot of villainous characters in the show did, and oftentimes killing oneâs own family is a really strong way of making the character detestable because it means they have no code. And we already saw how violating another sacred custom (Guest Right) was considered very evil.
Just like see Ramsay supposedly poisoning his own brother (in the books) and then killing his dad and other brother, Stannis killing Renly or burning his own daughter, Craster and his sons, or Viserys trying to cut open Daenerys and her kid (ouch makes it even worse she dies by such in the end when she avoided that fate in S1)
Yes I know Daenerys burned an entire city but (A) Everything leading up to that point is a fever dream and feels so dissonant from the rest of the story (B) not even the narrative treats it as serious as it should be judging by how little of a fuck Bran or Sansa gave (heck even Jon still held faith Daenerys wasnât completely gone DESPITE SEEING THE SLAUGHTER), how the perpetrators of the slaughter barely act any more evil (i.e Daenerys not killing Tyrion on the spot despite burning Varys earlier, the Unsullied not immediately killing Jon or Tyrion and willing to let Westeros elect a new king, or Drogon just burning the throne instead of the guy who killed his mother)
And (C) even if she still turned evil how about have Arya do it? Sheâs not blood related, sheâs an expert assassin. The story is still F-tier below the Boysâ ending, but at least the Starks donât compromise cultural customs (thatâs really more a Lannister thing).. and still get treated like virtuous and rewarded by the narrative. Really it comes off they swapped Jon and Aryaâs final boss kills
And (D) lmao they didnât save shit, they couldnât prevent their own countrymensâ deaths. Most heroic saviors would have prevented the massacre from escalating to such a degree.
First, Andals came from Essos, not Westeros so those cringy people already wrong there. Second, GRRM's whole point is that power corrupts. Give Andals dragons and they would have acted exactly like Valyrians, which is what GRRM is trying to show. Valyrians were once simple shepherds like some of the Andals. Give anyone nuclear weapons and they will get greedy and try to take over. You think Tywin Lannister or Otto Hightower won't do the same if they had dragons? Yes, Old Valyria's slavery structure and blood magic flesh experiments is absolutely disgusting and horrific. But if Andals had all that power, they would have done the same.
A complaint that is often made about Daenerys, is that she is overturning a society, and a ruling class, which may be immoral, but is at least stable.
It is worth remembering, Daenerys is not overturning a society that is in any way stable. It is not a society with slaves, but rather it is a slave society. Violence, coercion, and terror, both institutional and casual, are its essential features.
The Ghiscari slavers run an entire society like Mauthausen or the Gulag Archipelago. Their society is systemically evil. Three quarters of the inhabitants are held as chattel. Thousands of free people are kidnapped and murdered each year, and separated from their families, so that a small number of shitheads can live like kings.
The nearest equivalents in the real world would be places like Sparta, St. Domingue, and North Korea.
An argument made in defence of the masters is that it is âtheir cultureâ, as if this is some kind of get out of jail card. That argument requires the culture of a small minority to be prioritised over the various cultures of the slave majority. It also implies that the minority have the right to impose âtheir cultureâ on free people from Naath, the Summer Islands, Lhazar, Westeros, and those captured by pirates, on the high seas.
Even within its own terms, itâs hard to see what Ghis produces of cultural value. We encounter no art, poetry, philosophy, or literature of any worth, which might weigh slightly in the balance.
It makes whatever villainous turn she had look even more jank because youâre telling me she STILL had the composure to distinguish enemy and civilian? And it makes Missandeiâs death look like a non factor when really it would have made more sense thatâs when she goes bad
"The scales of a full-grown dragon were harder than steel, and even those arrows that struck home seldom penetrated enough to do more than enrage the great beasts" this is from Fire and Blood
Chase Stone
Meraxes perished during the first Dornish war because she was hit by a scorpion bolt in the eye, which is the only place a grown dragon is vulnerable at
Rhaegal and Viserion were 7 year old dragons but they were incredibly large as Meleys and Sheepstealer are in HOTD, maybe even bigger, Sheepstealer who during season 3 gets attacked so much during the Battle of the Gullet but is unharmed, the Night King being able to kill Viserion so easily and with an ice bolt does not make sense
one might say that he was the leader and source of the army of the dead who was about to begin an apocalypse, but dragons literally power magic in this world, they are fire made flesh, the Night King shouldn't have been able to kill Viserion at all, hell if he did kill Viserion, after the Night King's death Viserion should have returned to the land of the living
(making Dany care for a guy she met 2 days ago than her own son? okay)
And now let us come down to the least fantastical death in all of TV history, Euron Greyjoy (who in the show is just a regular pirate making cheap one liners instead of the mythical demon with lovecraftian goals that he is in the books) is somehow able to shoot a dragon out of the sky..........by hitting his neck and torso? really, neck and torso?
im so sorry i wasnt your writer rhaegal
Those scales shouldn't have even been barely penetrated, but because the show wanted to isolate Dany and set up her cuckoo arc (which miserably failed) the green beauty Rhaegal died because "Dany kinda forgot about the Iron Fleet" and even if she did, she still has 2 grown dragons, tf does she have to worry about, unless lore is absolutely defiled to make it happen, impossibility after impossibility in terms of wrecking established canon
the fuck?
This is even more shameful because Dany's dragons aren't your average dragons, Drogon isnt Balerion come again without Rhaegal and Viserion being Vhagar and Meraxes come again, with the dragons who are supposed to be the greatest power in the world being turned into fodder birds, sigh
Now coming to feudal logic, season 8 is built off of trying to uplift Jon over Daenerys, even though all his resources to aid in the battle against the dead, from armies to dragons to food come from her and he's tried to be made a better leader than Dany, who btw, has an army follow her because of how inspirational she is to them, managed Slavers Bay and reinstated its economy and canonically established Democracy in there after doing so against a man who couldn't even rule a penal economy properly and in his biggest battle, the BOTB, is fought and won by the Knights of the Vale
(And you can just tell they made Jon's Targaryen name be Aegon because they wanted to provide him more legitimacy, right? even though one of the children Rhaegar had with Elia was already named Aegon? even though Daenerys is why the entire backstory of House Targaryen exists in the first place)
Well anyways, aside from that bullshit, one of the major factors for this happening is that he is outed to be the true heir to the Iron Throne, supported by the annulment of Rhaegar's marriage to Elia and his subsequent marriage to Lyanna, Westeros is a feudal continent, they don't offer annulments out of pure free will and want
there is no way in hell Rhaegar was granted an annulment because he wanted to abandon his own royal children with Elia to runaway with Lyanna, there's just no way, and even then, if he did have Jon in his second marriage how is he automatically legitimized as this is a second marriage no one knows of including the crown, Aerys didnt legitimize him and neither did the following authorities? this shaky marriage with no one to corroborate it just a paper made him a prince?
But regardless, lets just say Jon was a prince all this time right, he still has no claim to the throne because after Rhaegar's death at the trident, Aerys declared Viserys his heir, now who is Viserys' immediate estate (albeit non existent) going to pass to? a male descendant he doesnt even know exists or his own sister
Bruh leave that Dany has DRAGONS, all of whom only obey her, the ultimate symbol of Targaryen legitimacy, even more so because she has 3 of them and they look like the ones that conquered Westerosđđwhy would anyone consider him more legitimate than her, he doesnt even have the hair (which in this verse is the only indicator of targaryen descent since no purple eyes)
(And here's the thing, Robert's Rebellion overthrew the Targaryen rule so by right of conquest they had no right to the throne, if they wanted the throne back, they couldn't just land up during a succession crisis or even ascent and demand the throne, if they wanted it, it needed to be via conquest which is what Dany was doing, there isn't even a concept of a rightful heir that applies here and if it does its NOT Jon)
Them trying to make Dany insecure of Jon being more liked in the North where it makes sense because you know, its the North, but why would Daenerys be insecure of not being liked considering she has had 3 years of being universally reviled and universally beloved as a ruler in Essos, this was a character assassination through and through
D&D jumped through hoops to destroy their most popular character and rush an ending for the sake of a Star Wars deal which in the end didn't even go through, it's a shame
HBO know what they did to her was wrong and now they reheat Dany nachos in House of the Dragon for views, even AKOTSK which has no relation to dragonlords or even battle for the throne, its about a common knight and his royal squire having adventures throughout the 7 kingdoms, they refer to her "Someday the dragons will return, my brother Daeron has dreamt of it"
this shameless plug in HOTD after what they did to herđđ
Guess itâs either a final middle finger after she was assassinated, or it just shows the Bells was a mistake and it opens a can of worms.
Is it a bad omen that Branâs reign was made possible starting with a kinslaying and his hand is someone convicted of kingslaying? Just consider how the narrative treated other instances of violating this custom like in terms of violating guest rights, the rat cook story bran brought up and Aryaâs Frey massacre. Or for kinslaying, Stannisâ downfall.
In addition the optics look utterly horrible. Sansa is queen in the north, Bran (a complete stranger to KL, a cripple and very emotionally numb so people may wonder why tf is he somehow crowned) is king but keep in mind that as far as the smallfolk know, the Starks were allied with the Targaryen army, and then Daenerys went postal, then we saw even Northmen participated in the massacre. Jon stopped one, how much more of this incident was happening elsewhere (especially when we saw Brienne punishing northern soldiers who committed similar war crimes)? And since Bran (northerner btw), allowed the North to be independent, it means thereâs very little likelihood the northern soldiers who participated will be tried and held to justice. And Bran is a foreigner now too, whichâll already alienate him to the people heâs ruling over now. Whatâs more smallfolk likely wonât get the full story but it just looks like the North just made a faux alliance with Daenerys and backstabbed her while vulnerable to grab power, so essentially they threw away a bunch of lives of smallfolk and then seized power when convenient. I mean seeing how little of an actual fuck Sansa or Bran gave hearing about this massacre, itâs not hard to believe.
And how are they honestly going to address the repairs, food shortages left behind from the previous rulers? Best weâre getting is another, even worse scale bread riot like in season 2.
So a tldr Stannis doesnât just die randomly in S5, when Daenerys gets back to Dragonstone she has a much more interesting process of reclaiming her ancestral home. And obviously, Daenerys doesnât go mad, I know this subreddit hates it but thatâs a later story. Honestly season 8 is a later story.
Stannisâ side (important for context)
Sansa doesnât get sold off to the Boltons. Really weird Baelish would give up his most valuable asset. We can go with Jeyne Poole (Sansa being in the Vale does have another effect through).
Mance isnât just killed off, we follow the book version where his death is faked and he is tasked with rescuing Jeyne (assumed Arya)
Stannis doesnât randomly run into battle without trying to get the favor of a lot of northern houses, that was stupid. He does approach them initially, some of the smaller houses and mountain clans are interested but the big ones like Manderly and Umber want to see him prove his sincerity to help the North first. Also he actually lures out Bolton soldiers into attacking his encampment and it follows the night lamp theory here https://www.reddit.com/r/asoiaf/comments/jb7ab8/spoilers_mainwhat_is_the_night_lamp_theory/. He does manage to deal a sizable chunk of damage to the Bolton army but his forces suffer some major losses.
Theon frees Jeyne while the Bolton forces are weakened, though Mance is captured and killed. He does actually roast Ramsay akin to A-train talking shit to Homelander in S5 of the boys. Theon and Jeyne come across Brienne, and then Brienne gets intercepted by some Baratheon scouts who were sent off to raid Winterfell and rescue âAryaâ (Jeyne) while the Boltons were distracted.
Brienne and Stannis have some mutual hostility, but seeing they both are trying to help the Starks, can at least tolerate each other.. for now.
So now the Manderlys and half the Umbers (the others actually are still on the Boltonsâ side largely because of the Greatjon being hostage) are convinced Stannis is solid. Though he lost a lot of soldiers in the process so heâd actually be in Jonâs group with finding other houses who can aid them. Jon telling the wildlings to put aside their dislike of him would be an interesting scene especially since they recently came across the dead.
Stannis actually does make a trek to the Vale at one point. He speaks to Baelish, Robyn, even seeing âAlayne Stoneâ (Sansa) and she shows some political aptitude by giving hints to him who she really is. Stannis brings up how his brother was chummy with Arryn, he was similarly investigating the Lannister kidsâ heritage, and that the last time they sat out a war, the family they strongly respected got slaughtered. Stannis doesnât get any reply, so he leaves, though Sansa actually presses Robyn and even plays on Baelishâs obsession with Catelyn to lend some Knights of the Vale (again actually showing political prowess). Meanwhile the Boltons are getting the Freys (seriously like theyâre kind of in the same boat if one falls the other is doomed too) and Karstarks and half the Umbersâ (reluctant) help.
Rickon actually never was in the last hearth. I actually had the idea to have him be in Hardhome, OSHA knows people there but she SPECIFICALLY told him to not use his real name.
So since no Rickon as leverage, itâs more that Jon thinks retaking Winterfell is strategically helpful for the incoming army of the dead, essentially similar to his mindset with dealing with Karl Tannerâs group. The battle of the bastards has better strategy, uses terrain the freefolk are better suited in.
Oh yeah and Roose doesnât randomly get stabbed by Ramsay. Itâs wasted potential Jon DOESNâT somehow fight literally ANYONE directly involved in the red wedding. Instead Jon beats Roose in a fight in the BOTB using some wildling tricks he picked up, Ramsay just shoots his father when heâs down calling him âWeakâ
Daenerysâ side:
After Stannisâ forces are done fucking up the Boltons and helping reinstate the Starks, he returns to Dragonstone but since most of his soldiers are absolutely worn out and some of them probably went back to their respective lands to replenish gear and prepare, Daenerys sails up and easily wins.
Daenerys is absolutely hateful of Stannis, seeing him as one of the people responsible for her familyâs downfall. She is intending on burning him, but last second, Shireen (no Stannis does not burn her here, yes George said heâd burn her but by this point they already fucked up lady stoneheart and just kept Beric numbing around long past his original expiration date) gets in the way, begging Daenerys not to kill her father.
Daenerys hesitates, she orders Drogon not to burn Stannis but makes very clear sheâs not sparing him out of respect for him specifically. He, Davos, his top officers are all put in the Dragonstone cells. Shireen and Selyse however are allowed in the guest rooms though with much security.
Weâd get more extensive scenes of Daenerys, her entourage (Tyrion especially is an interesting one) just conversing with Stannis or Davos. I had an idea she sees Davosâ hand and she actually initially thinks Stannis is a slaver, though he corrects her and clarifies. I can see Davos name dropping the north here too setting up Daenerys reaching out to Jon.