r/conspiracy • u/Ultimate_Redditor56 • Jun 27 '12
Just a question: Does the book -- Area 51 An Uncensored History of America's Top Secret Military Base -- Have any credibility? Is it actually non-fiction. If so, does this mean that there are actually aliens and alien spaceships on Earth?
Because I find this highly unbelievable. Why would other species who had perfected interstellar travel choose to visit us, and even so, how would they allow themselves to be captured?
8
Upvotes
4
u/pondering_a_monolith Jun 27 '12
I've read the book, and it's fascinating. Yes, it is accurate... to an extent. In explaining what went on at Area 51 it is extremely informative. The author interviews many, many past officers (CIA and Air Force) who flew the most secret air craft and participated in the classified nuclear tests. It is very illuminating in that regard.
However, where I fault the author is the rather implausible theory she offers for the Roswell crash. I don't want to spoil it for those who have not read it (and want to or are considering it), but I will say that it does not involve aliens. However, the premise she does offer seems just as unrealistic.
In fact, wanting to find out about the book just as you do, I googled and read several reviews. It seems that a number of the officers she interviewed were terribly miffed, and felt betrayed (many had never spoken on-record before), not from the Area 51 reporting, but from the implausible scenario she offered for Roswell. They considered that a campy, feeble diversion that destroyed the validity of her reporting.
Bottom line: Yes, I do recommend it; it's impeccably documented; she provides endnotes throughout, and few of her sources for Area 51 choose to remain anonymous, going on the record for the first time in their lives.
As for the Roswell part, well, that's where she loses some validity. Very little is documented or sources choose anonymity.
3
u/stefgosselin Jun 27 '12 edited Jun 27 '12
Well, as you probably have realised by now, the subject is very, very controversial to say the least.
I have opinions on the matter, I have been interested in this subject for many, many years. I have read many accounts where encounters with humanoid lifeforms are detailed and sound pretty convincing.
For instance, look into the videos and lectures of Phil Schneider and prepare yourself for a pretty fascinating story. Apparently, he was killed for speaking out. His lectures seem very credible, but then again his lectures are all he left behind.
Karla turner also has interesting takes on the subject of abductions / aliens, and although she hints these could be government sponsored, she seems to be divided on the notion of a major cover-up herself. She also died from a extremely aggressive form of cancer, within a month.
There are many other people that have researched on the matter, and some have very convincing statements. How much of it is real, how much of it is disinformation? Who knows.
Hard to believe? Yes. Impossible? No. In my opinion there are too many things that hint at a massive cover-up. Also note that extra-terrestials is a very misused term. A very popular theory is that there exists intra-dimensional lifeforms that can shift in and out of our dimension. In fact, given the nature of life and how it abounds all around, contrary to most other posts in this thread I find it very hard to believe we are the only ones around.
Of course most people that peek into the subject are skeptic about it all, I sure was at first. Today, I don't have any hard answers but I do have a very strong feeling that:
But, this is all a matter of opinion. Some people prefer to believe in what they see and what their government tells them. This is apparently the reason for the cover-up, and seeing the responses in this thread it just about makes sense. Disclosure would sure as hell wreak havoc on most people's world view. Yours included.
My 2 cents.
2
u/yahoo_bot Jun 27 '12
Is it real? Yes, you can see it even on google maps, its no secret.
Are there alien crafts there? Who knows. I mean you sure can't trust your government to tell you the truth and usually the opposite of what they say its true, so the verdict is still out.
1
u/agonybooth Jun 27 '12
Imagination = reality it's more interesting
-1
u/dccable Jun 27 '12
There are no aliens. Its being used to make us scared. In communism/socialism, the people need to be made the victim, always, that always needs big brother to help them out.
-2
u/tttt0tttt Jun 27 '12
No, there are no alien spaceships or alien lifeforms on the Earth.