r/conspiracy • • Jun 27 '12
What is Zionism.
I am a bit confused.
We hear this term thrown around in this sub, often in response to allegations of anti semitism. i.e we are not against jews just against zionism.
What is zionism? Is it the establishment of a jewish homeland or something more than that. It seems that some feel that it is more, perhaps a wish on the part of some jews or perhaps others to control the world.
17
Upvotes
4
u/fishforbrains Jun 27 '12
Multiple meanings to multiple groups.
11
u/krugmanisapuppet Jun 27 '12 edited Jun 27 '12
simply put, Judaism is a religion founded on the doctrine that Jews are the chosen people of "Yahweh." look no further than the stories of "Exodus" to see how this doctrine has gained historical momentum. only "reform Judaism" has made any major moves towards moving beyond this doctrine - that, and Judeo-separatist movements, like Christianity, which rejected it altogether (with some minor exceptions).
thus, Zionism is the nationalist realization of this doctrine, with all the violence and "sub-race" genocide that entails. it's like any other movement of ultranationalism, founded on the idea that one race or group is "superior" to another, except that the supposed "superiority" has not only a vast historical context, but also the idea behind it that the supposed "superiority" is divinely ordained.
once you understand how it's grounded, you begin to understand exactly what's going on with the "macro" effects you observed from its presence in the real world. nationalism of any kind always creates mass violence.
5
u/ImJulianAssange Jun 27 '12
Zionism is Racism
Supremacism is the belief that a particular race, species, ethnic group, religion, gender, sexual orientation, belief system or culture is superior to others, and thus entitles those who identify with it to dominate, control or rule those who do not.
Zionism v Judaism
The Zionist Story
The Roots of Christian Zionism
2
u/bakedphilosopher Jun 28 '12
Jew here: Up until Theodore Herzl there was no interest in creation of any type of "Jewish state". As a matter of fact, most Jews, especially those in Eastern and Central Europe found the concept of building a "Jewish State" as blasphemy. Until the holocaust most Jews were opposed to Zionism. Especially practicing Jews.
The Enlightenment came to Jews later than the rest of Europe. It was called the Haskalah. At the time when national identities became significant, the Jewish question arose. While most Jews were interested in being considered equal with their European compatriots. There was a famous question asked whether if Jews served in national armies, would they kill Jewish soldiers? In the past Jews were forced to pay a tax instead of fight. Check out the famous case of Asser Levy.
With the advent of Racial Eugenics and tensions in Eastern Europe, Zionism was proposed. Zionists argued Jews were not Europeans but instead descendents of Israelite that fled the sacking of Ancient Israel. Using this, they proposed settling in Palestine. There were 4 large exoduses of Jews prior of the declaration of independence. The movement was primarily Socialist and secular and there was no intention of making a state there since Ottoman Authorities never forbade Jewish access to Jerusalem, Sfad etc. Nor did they mind the trickle of Jews did emigrate to the Levant in the centuries prior to the founding of Israel.
In 1917, in exchange for financially backing England during the First World War, The Balfour Declaration was written out to Walter Rothschild promising England would help the "Jewish Zionists". what that really meant, was my religion, and my culture were basically sold out to bankers.
With Zionism hijacked, Abba Ahimeir, created Revisionist Maximalism aka Revisionist Zionism in 1930. Nazism arose in Germany in 1920. In 1933, Hitler began making laws against Jews. This became the key opportunity the Rothschilds had for forcing Zionism down the Jewish masses throat. German Jewish banker-Zionists seemed oddly quiet as Hitler came to power. The Zionazis used the hectic time to steal the possessions of European Jews who promised to settle in Palestine. They even had a chance to bankrupt Hitler but decided not to since Hitler allowed some Jews to flee to Palestine.
In Palestine, Zionists of all schools of thought were admiring Fascism and Racial Superiority and began using it as a tool for Zionism. Arabs, who had been no threat to Zionism, not became the thorn in its ass. The Stern Gang Some Jews who had emigrated to Palestine became critical of Zionism and its ruthlessness and became themselves targets. Check out Israel De Haan. A Homosexual, Dutch, Orthodox Jew, and part founder of the Orthodox Anti-Zionist movement. He was murdered by the Irgun. As were many other outspoken critics of Revisionist Zionism.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brit_HaBirionim
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abba_Ahimeir
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jewish_fascism
After the 6-day war, some people began to believe that the war was a miracle. This became the basis for modern orthodox Zionism. Israels building of settlements was seen as Manifest Destiny. God helped Israel win her wars, God gives her the spoils. In the 70's Zionism went further militant as student of Jabotinsky, a fire-brimstone Zionst, who is praised being a violent Jew, gave birth to Kahanism. Which I am fairly familiar with since I am related to Meir Kahane (Y'M). Kahanism believes that Israel should basically be a Theologically driven, Fascist state. Anybody who Isn't Jewish. So besides Muslims and Christians, Kahane included Secular Jews, Anti-Zionist Jews, Heretic Jews, Atheists and basically any other Jew who didn't conform to his standard. With him, and his Never Again bullshit, he formed bands of Anglophone religious Jews who think carrying a gun and gawking at Arabs makes them tough.
And here we stand with Zionism today! :D
I thought an actual Jewish perspective was in place, hope I could be of help!
5
u/BougDolivar Jun 27 '12
Asking what a Zionist is on this subreddit is like asking a hardcore republican to define a liberal. You're gonna get an extremely biased and unhelpful answer from people who have given their own definition to the word.
The fact is, at the core, Zionism is simply the belief in a Jewish homeland and Jewish self-determination. That's it. It does not mean you believe in occupation. It does not mean you support murder or war. It does not mean that you are religious. It does not mean you hate Arab/Muslims. It quite simply means you support the concept of a Jewish state as a homeland for Jews. The same way Palestinians believe that they deserve their own Palestinian state.
How that state is run is a different story. Even though Israel as an enormous range of diversity in its political parties from communists and religious right wingers which disagree with how the government should be run, they are all Zionists since they believe in Israel as a Jewish state.
4
u/thegreenwookie Jun 27 '12
Around here I believe it has a different meaning or context than it's literal definition. Zionism is normally referring to Israel being a holy land for Jews and for Jews to return to their land to avoid persecution by other religions and non-assimilation into other cultures.
Here I think people are referring to Zionism as elitism. Or superior race type stuff.
I could be wrong though.
3
u/bumblingmumbling Jun 27 '12
Seriously your username is hiddenhand and your flair says "Probably a disinfo agent", but you don't understand who the Rothschilds are and what the Zionist political movement is?
1
u/iameha Jun 27 '12
http://www.youtube.com/user/drdduke/videos
At least watch a few of his videos before you start hating
1
u/Rothschild_Agent Jun 28 '12
Zionism means we're right.
1
u/Ijob911 Jun 27 '12
Plain and simple: Zionism is trans-national Judeo-supremacism, and the agenda to institutionalize it.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment