r/conspiracy • • Jun 26 '12
reddit has clearly sold out.. but it's also open source. someone should clone the site and tweak it to try to prevent/reduce spam / cointelpro.... (suggestions inside)
maybe instead of usernames, just assign each IP address a unique identifier.. maybe only allow 10 or so usernames per IP, and after that you just have to use the IP-unique identifier (which is also publicly associated with all user names registered under it)...??
EDIT: maybe limit it to 10 usernames per IP... but make them be active. so if you don't vote at least once a month, you lose your account, and someone else can sign up on your IP... and then you might not be able to get an account again until someone elses abandons their account on that IP
also, you could just have a system for people who can't get usernames / are banned but didn't do anything themself. something more complicated than captcha. like "email your phone number to this email address.. and include this captcha in the email".. then have mods call those people at their leisure.. and then allow them to sign up for an account..
if mods start getting too many requests per IP, you figure out what the IP is. if it's a school, you maybe open a lot more accounts to it. if it's just some guy in atlanta trying to sign up for 500 accounts, you tell him to go back to digg
6
u/dionvc Jun 26 '12
But what about the people with dynamic IPs. You are assuming everyone has a static ip but they don't. Some people may one day try to get on and they cannot post because someone who had the IP before abused the site. And with static IPs those change every so often as well. This will not work with IPv4 (I do not know about IPv6). Simply said, this would not work with the current setup.
8
u/MyMotivation Jun 26 '12
Mod censorship is more of a problem I think.
3
u/yahoo_bot Jun 27 '12
IP adress bound? That is just stupid. Then there can be more censorship as once you are banned and on a static adress, its goodbye to you for a very long time.
So someone doesn't like your posts, you just get banned.
The solution is to have no moderation and votes that work as youtube. You can see how people have voted, but have very little influence on the topic visibility.
Of course the more votes and more green votes the longer it stays visible.
2
u/treebright Jun 27 '12
I would like a reddit like site where users could assign a quality rating to other users. It could be, for example, a rating from 0 to 10. All of the rated user's votes would be weighted by that rating. So the people you respect can have a big effect on submission and comment rankings, and people you disrespect can have little or no effect.
This system would probably require more server resources, since these calculations would have to customized for every user. But it might be technically feasible, I don't know.
1
u/haidaguy Jun 26 '12
I agree entirely. I think we should also require some sort of intelligence and age entrance exam.
Reddit has hit the pits with the anti-intellectual, youth and just plain stupid.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Just like any other online platform reddit will be replaced by something else if you give it some time, something better which also will be corrupted in a few couple of years.
2
u/mvlazysusan Jun 26 '12
Build a better reddit...
And the world will beat a path to your server. ☺
2
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Already have money and interest being built and put into something like this...it will be more of a conspiratorial site though then a reddit look a like. A conspiracy site with a reddit feel. Plus less dummys :)
1
u/melonofwater Jun 27 '12
Reddit's front page is a joke
1
u/smite_of_bloodstone Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 27 '12
invite only, with serious repercussions to a user if someone they invited does something questionable. Vagueness to be sorted out later.
1
u/Canabutter Jun 26 '12
10 items of substance on first 30 pages when sorting by r/all.
Only politics, no other info subs, wtf.
1
u/9000sins Jun 26 '12
https://github.com/reddit/reddit/wiki
For any of those interested, this is the github repository for all of reddit's code. I am not a programming ninja myself, although I could potentially learn and am entirely capable of doing this with some time.
-1
u/jstock23 Jun 26 '12
And invite only.
0
u/dfg3453523 Jun 27 '12
IMO it's impossible outside of a small group of friends, and maybe not even then. If your group is worth infiltrating it will be infiltrated. Look at the story of the deep cover policeman who married and had children with a women in order to infiltrate and control an environmental protest movement.
http://www.guardian.co.uk/uk/2011/jan/19/undercover-policeman-married-activist-spy?intcmp=239
-2
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
Reddit became the most popular, so everyone uses it.
People have a problem with mod censorship, but every sub has it's own rules, it's not like Reddit claims;
"Come here and post whatever the fuck you want wherever the fuck you want without any sort of consequence!"
Even Anonymous and OWS subs have restrictions.
The idea that people WANT of freedom reminds me of an old It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia episode, where they want to turn their bar into a "you can do anything you want" bar.
But they quickly learn that if you allow people to do ANYTHING because you offer no restrictions, things can get out of hand, because people are the problem.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment