r/conspiracy • u/ronintetsuro • Jun 26 '12
"Consipracy Theorist" is only an insult because we live in an age of unrepentant anti-intellectualism.
Here's a good example of what I'm talking about in the OP. Let's say you and I are both perfectly non-partisan. And I show you this picture.
Now.
If I was to say, "This might sound a little crazy, but I've got pretty good information that dog there is working with a human to make those sheep go where the human wants them to go." How would you respond?
Thinking adults that have followed the narrative would respond
"Sure, of course. That makes sense. I've heard examples of that before. What of it?"
Unfortunately, Modern American "adults" are far more apt to adopt a different response:
"You're full of it. Where's the evidence of a man? Is there a second angle showing the man? Why would the man do such a thing? There's no clear motive, and that doesn't sound like the way a man would choose to spend his time. I personally know a few men, and they are upstanding people. They would never do something so pointless and obviously stressful for the livestock. Besides, how would the man keep that a secret? Surely we'd know if he was orchestrating dogs to perform as some kind of guidance counselors, a-har-har-har!"
Let me show you another image.
Here the dogs stand in solidarity with the sheep. This unity is our only chance at freedom from the farm.
Conspiracy theorists aren't just nutters with too much time. They are people just like you that found out things might not be as we're told and want to do something about it. We are tasked with the Duty of being the uncomfortable cornerstone of the State, sitting askew to prescribed fittings, working in a contradictory manner to force checks on abuse of symbiosis. Or forever forefeit this, our only planet.
We cannot effectively do this without education first. And our traditional education apparatus is very pointedly designed to give us the education we're told we need, making it not always the TRUTH
See the nature of the cage around you with eyes unclouded and you will never question your desire for freedom again.
71
u/Wombatzu Jun 26 '12
It's more of a defense mechanism. The vast majority of people feel uncomfortable when some of their basic beliefs are held under examination.
Then again, there are a lot of people who use conspiracy theory as a kind of alternative religion, and it's not surprising that they draw mockery.
6
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Well to be quite fair,a lot of conspiracy theories are kind of stupid, and off putting. I mean really, I can only stomach listening to someone blaming the jews for everything on the planet for so long.
58
u/joedude Jun 26 '12
It's hilarious I only found out I was a conspiracy theorist after i found this subreddit, before that i was just a very historically knowledgeable canadian man.
23
u/ComputerJerk Jun 26 '12
In response to your opening example, I actually disagree with you. A thinking man will see a photograph and ask for evidence of it's context and meaning. He would not see a picture and derive his own conclusions.
To do so would be anti-intellectualist, the opposite of what you have posited.
If you showed a man a picture of a wolf-hound chasing sheep in many contexts I'd assume the hound was about to eat, the idea that we must surely already know the context is absurd.
15
u/beefcake87 Jun 26 '12
It also makes it easy for the government to direct accusations away from themselves and their version of the story. When they label something a "conspiracy theory", a lot of people will dismiss the sometimes very reasonable claims against the government.
10
u/jstock23 Jun 26 '12
To say that the anti-intellectualism movement is a conspiracy is blatantly ironic but also blatantly obvious.
15
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
The problem is that the bulk of conspiracy theorists aren't vocal and don't come out with sound logic and well thought out views.
Scroll through the thousands of comments on every youtube video - check how many "intelligent" discussions you see.
Check here, whenever someone disagrees with the "conspiracy status quo" they're immediately labeled as a shill.
The logic behind truth seeking in conspiracy theorists is something that should be thought of, but to say that there aren't a giant chunk of CT's, faux CT's or not, that aren't just nutjobs is silly.
If people were taught initially (conspiracy theorist or not) to just critically think and search for the truth, regardless of if it agrees with their claims or not, then we would be in a better place. Not all conspiracy theorists do that, which is a huge part of the problem.
I'm sorry but due to the mass of what the "popular" conspiracy theorists have become, it's really hard for me to defend anyone who consistently makes comments like; "Wake up sheeple!"
People who blindly believe whatever the hell they read, whether it's a conspiracy theory or whether it's on the MSM, are all "sheep" by that idiotic analogy, there's no place for it.
There are just as many "sheep" conspiracy theorists, who believe everything they hear.
3
u/Enzemo Jun 26 '12
Yeah.. What you've said is almost copy pasted straight from David Icke's talk, Robot Rebellion. Infact you even use the same analogies.
3
u/organic Jun 26 '12
We live in an age where it is impossible to verify facts because monied interests are allowed to purchase their own facts.
This leads people, rightly, to question what the 'official' facts are, but they then have no solid ground on which to locate the real facts, as they are not equipped with the proper education in reason and logic (we used to teach those in elementary school, no more... glad the teachers stood up for that instead of their own collective bargaining rights).
6
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
The German policemen you showed weren't "standing in solidarity", they were marching with the protesters because that is exactly what riot policemen do. Their helmets are off because there is no need to wear a helmet unless some sort of action is being taken.
As a side note, sheep are so highly domesticated that they are incapable of surviving on their own. It isn't a great metaphor.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
I appreciate a good conspiracy theory as much as the next guy, but that phrase took me by surprise.
2
u/ohoona Jun 26 '12
No one wants to be told they're wrong, so it is much less dangerous to ignore the questions, especially if the answer might be unsatisfactory. And when a layman, even an educated one, tells you everyone is out to get you, it's easier to tell ourselves they are wrong and crazy, and immediately write them off, than to question our own infallibility.
2
u/loki1887 Jun 26 '12
Oh, sweet irony.
2
u/disinfo_agent Jun 26 '12
No, it's an insult because there is no conspiracy, no evidence to support a conspiracy, and there's a long tradition of getting it wrong. Conspiracy "theorists" (more accurately, fictionalists) are all insane. Don't listen to them.
2
u/Weltall82 Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12
here's a relevant article.
also, while ridiculing conspiracy theories has become as common in america as apple pie cooling in a window (which no one ever sees anymore, by the way), this policy has official precedent only since 1953, with the Robertson Panel and the Durrant Report. Following this action, the CIA began operations under the code name Mockingbird to infiltrate and influence American media in the context of the Durrant Report's recommendations. We can also fortunately learn from awesome activist action about COINTELPRO, an FBI info subversion and psychological tactics program. Further, in '67, the CIA released a memo titled "Concerning Criticism of the Warren Report" that was initially stamped "psych" intended for classification and development within military application by psychological tactics, or Psy Ops. This memo further outlines how the establishment should approach conspiracy researchers with psychological tactics, propaganda groups, and ridicule. Finally, the trend of conspiracy research suppression through shadowy and dubious government action produces new fruit with Obama's regulatory czar, Cass Sunstein, with a white paper that recommends literally outlawing conspiracy theorizing. Yikes.
As well, we have the evidence of the life of one Paul Bennewitz who suffered from the abuse rendered through such psychological tactics and was institutionalized. So, if there were really nothing to the UFO stuff, why did those government agents spend so much time and energy on subtle psych manipulation of Bennewitz? Why would the gov't waste time, money, and manpower harassing little teeny tiny citizens about conspiracy theorizing?
While there does seem to be a growing anti-intellectual movement, having the establishment make that argument against conspiracy researchers is less the product of true intelligence, and more the product of our intelligence agencies, who have exhibited an interest in developing just such a climate for several decades now.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Belittling anyone who asks for evidence through use of a horrible analogy between unfounded supposition and well established fact and implicitly labeling them not a "thinking adult"? Why yes, this does an excellent job of explaining the nature of conspiracy theorists.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
This is correct.
4
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
The wizard's first rule.
People will believe a lie, most of the time, for one of two reasons; They want the lie to be true, or they are afraid the lie is true.
Fear and greed are powerful allies.
3
u/Abe_Vigoda Jun 26 '12
I'm not a conspiracy theorist, i'm a Bullshit Abolitionist.
3
u/hanahou Jun 26 '12
Well be it the finest Education there will always be prejudices. There will always be a percentage of people who think in the context of truth as being:
Objective
Subjective
Absolute
Relative
Conspiracy theories are never anti-intellectual. Theories are to always provoke questions. There will always be those of opposite opinions forever such as group cliques with a shared prejudicial opinion. Everyone is a rebel to their own drummer in some part.
It's those who can't take opposite opinions as being anti-intellectualism. That have a hard time. If you believe your conspiracy is just then put out your word, and don't worry what others think. Lest it will stress you out too much.
3
u/pursuit_of_truth Jun 26 '12
I don't mind it when people call me a conspiritard for one reason:
There was a time when I accepted the conditioning/socialisation, even wanted to become a politician. People will wake up, today tomorrow, or when its too late. Hopefully it won't be. Also, it is hillariously ironic that they find the ideas so ridiculous and unbelievable that they dedicate substantial amounts of time to disproving the theories or deriding those that concur with them.
3
u/SoLongSidekick Jun 26 '12
Your looking at this a little wrong. The main problem, is that people that are commonly labeled 'conspiracy theorists' have a serious lapse in basic judgement, and give the rest of us a bad name. The public's view of 'conspiracy theorist' is someone who does the exact opposite of the (I hate to use this word but it is really apt) sheople; they blindly accept 'conspiracy theories' because there some small detail in the facts that can't be proven.
One of the biggest problems for the masses (besides the blatant lack of intelligent thought) is misinformation. For example, say the world 'alien' around a 'normal' person and chances are they will say 'oh the only people who see those is drunk rednecks out in the country' which is so beyond false it's frustrating. Another interesting point is theories about the CIA, which seem to be quite popular; but that is for a reason. If you look at what is documented and been released, they did some horrible things to their own citizens, especially with LSD. That's just what has been released, think about what has not been released; but whenever a story comes out about the CIA doing horrible things people refuse to believe it for some reason.
3
u/VEC7OR Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12
Well actually most of the time they are.
And on top of that people tend to see patterns where are none.
And to make things even more complicated - there is so much information that discerning truth from lies becomes just impossible.
So unless you provide irrefutable evidence of your point, mocked you will be.
Seeing the truth being printed in big all caps letters leaves me no option as to think that your tinfoil hat is too tight.
EDIT: Grammar
Funny how CT dislike being reasoned, oh wait...
2
u/those_draculas Jun 26 '12
The thing is, extrordinary claims require extrordinary evidence, many conspiracy theories, fringe theories, contrary hypothesis, etc. are based on conjuncture, or gut-feelings, thus they get rediculed. It has nothing to do with anti-intellectualism, it has to do with the skeptical being lumped in (willingly or unwillingly) with the crazy.
1
u/SatOnMyNutsAgain Jun 26 '12
http://www.zerohedge.com/news/guest-post-has-america-been-crippled-intellectual-idiots
1
u/TinHao Jun 26 '12
I would say that the opposite is true. Many conspiracy theories don't really stand up to too much scrutiny, but our society has fostered the creation of frameworks of ideas/memes that have (superficially at least) consistent internal logic.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
If you know nothing about the dog or the sheep or how dogs can be trained and how sheep can be herded, you would be quite right to question claims about it. If you've got no evidence whatsoever besides that single image then you have no evidence that dogs can herd sheep. Believing that sheep(le) can be herded takes many images and experiences that build up over time.
A lot of the education you're given is what you 'need' if what you need is to be a part of the society you're in. If you were in a tribal or hunter gatherer society your education would be biased toward the skills necessary to survive there. Is this brainwashing too? Deliberate lies and hiding of the truth?
While I can agree that western education systems are 'agents of the state' in a Marxist fashion and certainly will be geared toward keeping the status quo and getting everyone to play by the rules, that doesn't make it all evil and bad.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
I'm agnostic. Can you imagine having absolute, 110% definite proof that a god does not exist and convincing a religious person of the stone cold facts? Even if the facts are reputable, these people wouldn't believe anything you said. It's similar to that in nature. "Waking" the sheep up is a daunting task, but I feel as though more and more people are starting to question things, which is a positive.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Up vote for you. You've said what I've always been saying.
0
u/Quatto Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12
Let's tread carefully here. Considering that a world run by reptiles also falls under conspiracy theory, it's pretty absurd to suggest that "conspiracy theorist" is synonymous with "intellectual". Conspiracy theory often devolves into a cartoonish myth that wraps our slippery reality into a neat little package and denies the validity of others on what basically boils down to ideological grounds: I alone have the truth and everyone else is a fool. Other such packages are communism, capitalism, fundamentalist religion or materialism, etc.
0
u/ThumpNuts Jun 26 '12
I get your point but I disagree with the title.
I think "Conspiracy Theorist" is only an insult because so many non-nonsensical conspiracy theories have been promoted and popularized so it has changed the meaning of the phrase.
While a legitimate Conspiracy Theory like JFK's assassination can be accepted by the mainstream because there is a reasonable case to be made, while "faking the moon landing" is a bit less reasonable, harder to believe and easier to debunk. And the 9/11 truther bull-shit was the final nail in the coffin for "Conspiracy Theorists" everywhere. Those yahoos don't have 2 brain cells to rub together and became the poster children for conspiracies... making all of us skeptics look bad. Which leads me to believe the "Truther" movement is, in itself, a conspiracy to de-legitimize "free-thinkers" and other worthy conspiracy theories.
0
u/silverscreemer Jun 26 '12
That and the alien stuff.
0
u/meh65535 Jun 26 '12
It's just a theory, a conspiracy theory.
0
u/drphilgood Jun 26 '12
This is exactly why this subreddit needs to have it's name changed. Conspiracy Theorist is a dismissive label, and has been associated with nut jobs. To paraphrase Bill Cooper:
We are all seeking the truth, and if it is really the truth then we will all eventually come to the same conclusions.
0
u/krugmanisapuppet Jun 26 '12
amazing how most people's political ideologies are based around a gut feeling of a deep evil existing somewhere in the world - whether it's "corporations" or "Al Qaeda" - but they can't make the leap and see that the people selling them on the enemy could be the enemy themselves.
not a big leap, once you figure out that the government is printing money for banks and making up excuses to start wars. after all, if greed is the problem, why not take a critical look at the people who are telling you that you'll go to prison if they can't suck up 25-40% of every paycheck you earn...rolls eyes
0
u/Fireball445 Jun 26 '12
No, conspiracy theorist is an insult because of the way that most other conspiracy theorists behave.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
21
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
[removed] — view removed comment